Did George Floyd Protesters Miss Their Moment For Change?
Outrage over George Floyd's killing by police catapulted Black Lives Matter into one of the largest protest movements in US history, with angry crowds chanting the slogan at rallies from Los Angeles to Washington.
But five years on, the protesters are gone and an iconic monument outside the White House has been erased, leaving many to wonder if the movement blew its chance for historic change by failing to win over the American public.
"It's very easy to wear the T-shirt, utter the slogan, but then you looked at what they were asking for," Yohuru Williams, who runs the Racial Justice Initiative at the University of St Thomas, told AFP.
Despite widespread revulsion at racism and police brutality in the wake of Floyd's May 2020 death, many turned away when BLM activists broadened their message to calling for the defunding of law enforcement.
National support for the Black Lives Matter movement is now 52 percent, according to Pew Research, down 15 percentage points since June 2020, a month after police officer Derek Chauvin killed Floyd during an arrest in Minneapolis.
Initially, Floyd's death was hailed as a catalyst for a national reckoning similar to the 1960s civil rights movement.
Protests, some turning into riots, spread across the country -- right up to the gates of the White House, where Donald Trump was serving his first term.
Pent-up energy from Covid lockdowns fed the anger, which coalesced around BLM, until then a loose organization founded in 2013 to protest racially motivated violence.
Activists soon widened their focus to systemic racism, with monuments of slave owners removed and some companies investing in diversity initiatives to support ethnic minorities.
Despite the ambition, Williams said that BLM has achieved "very little."
"The moral clarity of 2020 has not translated into enough political courage," Phillip Solomon, a professor of African-American Studies and Psychology at Yale University, told AFP.
The George Floyd Justice in Policing Act, which proposed law enforcement reforms, including nationwide bans on dangerous chokeholds during arrests, has failed to pass US lawmakers.
Solomon said Floyd's killing -- he called it a "lynching" -- opened an opportunity for change that was missed and is now facing a backlash.
The election of Trump to a second term -- despite his racially charged rhetoric and heavy support from far-right figures -- reflects deep-rooted tensions, he said.
"I think this moment is a microcosm of America," Solomon added.
Race inequality has long sparked protests in the United States, where segregation only legally ended in the 1960s after a relentless campaign of marches and civil disobedience.
Floyd's death came in the context of dozens of other high-profile instances of police brutality against Black people -- something that smartphones and social media can now rapidly document and share.
There have been police reforms in some states primarily focused on limiting the amount of force officers can use, as well as local programs to send unarmed responders instead of police to selected callouts.
However, many say these measures are insufficient.
Medaria Arradondo -- serving as the first Black police chief of Minneapolis when Floyd died -- told AFP he was worried about the "grave consequences" of failing to enact more reforms.
"I hope and pray that we as a nation are not sleepwalking our way into the next critical crisis," he said.
Civil rights group the National Urban League this month published a report warning that marginalized communities have been "pushed deeper into survival mode" after Floyd's death.
League president Marc Morial said at a conference that steps to address racial injustices have "been reversed with a vengeance."
Trump's Justice Department has axed all outstanding civil rights investigations from the outgoing Joe Biden administration, ended police accountability agreements, and cracked down on diversity hiring.
Some of Trump's more extreme supporters have gone as far as calling for Chauvin to be pardoned.
But Arradondo said he remains optimistic.
"History has shown we make incremental change," he said, "We're going to have a lot of hard work ahead of us, but I believe we will get there." Protests, such as this one in Minneapolis in June 2020, spread across the United States after George Floyd's death AFP Medaria Arradondo, seen here in April 2021, was police chief of Minneapolis when George Floyd died AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Int'l Business Times
5 hours ago
- Int'l Business Times
G20 President S.Africa Warns Global Turmoil Hurts Poorer Nations
Global fragmentation is fuelling unprecedented turmoil and disproportionately harming poorer nations, South Africa's foreign minister warned Thursday, urging a united G20 response for peace. Ronald Lamola made the remarks to dozens of diplomats from the G20 group of the world's leading economies meeting to prepare for its summit in November under South Africa's presidency. "State rivalries are fuelling fragmentation, with economic decoupling, and proxy conflicts undermining global stability," the foreign minister said, referring to multiple major conflicts and humanitarian crises under way. This was "exacerbating fragility in vulnerable regions while also weakening multilateral institutions that underpin the rules-based international order," he said. South Africa is the first African nation to hold the rotating year-long presidency of the group made up of 19 countries plus the European Union and the African Union that together represent around two-thirds of the world's population and 80 percent of its GDP. Pretoria wants to use its presidency to champion Global South priorities, including boosting climate resilience and tackling poor countries' debt, before handing the baton to the United States next year. Speaking to AFP, Lamola said he was hopeful that the talks at the Sun City resort 185 kilometres (115 miles) northwest of Johannesburg "will persuade and help to encourage the message of peace, good friendly neighbours and the language of de-escalation." Resolutions taken by the bloc are non-binding in nature and the diverse grouping has often failed to reach a consensus. However, many members hold seats on the UN Security Council or are involved in conflict resolution efforts, making the G20 "an important platform" and "very persuasive", Lamola told reporters. Lamola said he was not concerned that the United States -- the bloc's richest member -- did not send a representative to Sun City. "We have received their letter of apology, in which they stated their reasons," he said. "We believe that the G20 can proceed with or without the US, but they are important in terms of participation." Relations between South Africa and the United States plummeted this year over a range of international and domestic policies and US Secretary of State Marco Rubio skipped the G20 foreign ministers' meeting in Cape Town in February. Keen to salvage his summit, South African President Cyril Ramaphosa tried at talks with Donald Trump in May to have the US leader commit to attend the Johannesburg meeting. The Russian representative at the Sun City, Svetlana Lukash, was non-committal about the attendance of President Vladimir Putin, saying only he will take part "in some way". Putin missed the previous G20 summits in India and Brazil, avoiding possible political opprobrium and any risk of criminal detention under an International Criminal Court (ICC) warrant. Lukash said G20 members remained divided over Russia's war in Ukraine but were less fixated on the conflict than they were when it started in 2022. The war has split the G20, with Western countries condemning the invasion and pouring military and financial aid into Ukraine, while Russia has courted support from emerging powers such as Brazil, China and India. "Most of the world closed their eyes on numerous conflicts around the world due to dominance of Western views," she said. But more countries now recognised the "double standards", Lukash said.
Int'l Business Times
7 hours ago
- Int'l Business Times
Argentina To Try 10 In Absentia Over 1994 Bombing Of Jewish Center
Argentina will try in absentia ten Iranian and Lebanese nationals suspected of the 1994 bombing of a Jewish community center in Buenos Aires, which killed 85 people, a ruling seen by AFP on Thursday said. The attack, which caused devastation in Latin America's biggest Jewish community, has never been claimed or solved, but Argentina and Israel have long suspected Lebanon's Shiite Hezbollah group of carrying it out at Iran's request. Judge Daniel Rafecas acknowledged the "exceptional" nature of the decision to send the case to court, over three decades after the bombing and with the suspects all still at large. Trying them in absentia, he said, allowed to "at least try to uncover the truth and reconstruct what happened." On July 18, 1994, a truck laden with explosives was driven into the Argentine Israelite Mutual Association (AMIA) and detonated. The deadliest attack in Argentina's history injured more than 300 people No-one has ever been arrested over the attack. The ten suspects facing trial are former Iranian and Lebanese ministers and diplomats for whom Argentina has issued international arrest warrants. Since 2006 Argentina had sought the arrest of eight Iranians, including then-president Ali Akbar Hashemi Bahramaie Rafsanjani, who died in 2017. Iran has always denied any involvement and refused to arrest and hand over suspects. Thursday's ruling on trying them in absentia is the first of its kind in the South American country. Until March this year, the country's laws did not allow for suspects to be tried unless they were physically present. It comes amid a new push in recent years for justice to be served over the attack, backed by President Javier Milei, a staunch ally of Israel. Rafecas said a trial in absentia was justified given the "material impossibility of securing the presence of the defendants and the nature of the crime against humanity under investigation." In April 2024, an Argentine court blamed Hezbollah for the attack, which it called a "crime against humanity." It found that the attack and another on the Israeli embassy in 1992 that killed 29 people were likely triggered by the Argentine government under then-president Carlos Menem canceling three contracts with Iran for the supply of nuclear equipment and technology. The court did not however manage to produce evidence of Iran's involvement. The Inter-American Court of Human Rights in San Jose, Costa Rica last year found the Argentine state responsible for not preventing, nor properly investigating, the attack. It also blamed the state for efforts to "cover up and obstruct the investigation." Former president Cristina Kirchner has been ordered to stand trial over a memorandum she signed with Iran in 2013 to investigate the bombing. The memorandum, which was later annulled, allowed for suspects to be interrogated in Iran rather than Argentina, leading Kirchner to be accused of conspiring with Tehran in a cover-up. She has denied the allegations.
Int'l Business Times
8 hours ago
- Int'l Business Times
Vehicle Hits Pedestrians Near Primary School In Beijing
A vehicle crashed into pedestrians in an "accident" near a primary school in Beijing on Thursday, with footage shared online showing young people lying seriously injured in the street. Videos geolocated by AFP to an intersection in Miyun district in the northeast of the capital showed a grey SUV wedged against a tree as several motionless people were seen in the road. In one clip a bloodied young person was being given first aid by somebody in white overalls, while in others items of clothing were scattered around. Chinese authorities said the casualties were taken to hospital, but did not give details on numbers or their condition. "On June 26, 2025, at around 1 pm, a traffic accident occurred near the intersection of Yucai Road and Dongmen Street in Miyun district," police said in a statement. No.1 Primary School Miyun Beijing -- where children aged six to 12 go to class -- is located at the traffic junction. A 35-year-old man surnamed Han "collided" with people "due to an improper operation", the statement said, adding those injured were taken to hospital. "The accident is under further investigation," the statement said, without giving the number of injured. An AFP team on Thursday evening saw about 30 onlookers standing behind yellow and black concrete police barriers. A pick-up truck appeared to be being used to remove the remnants of the tree into which the vehicle had crashed. Shortly after arriving, the AFP journalists were told by police to leave the scene. A 19-year-old resident who gave his name as Cheng said he went to the intersection after hearing about the crash from his parents. "When I went down, the victims had already been taken away and the car was gone," he said, adding he saw lots of people and emergency vehicles in the area at about 4 pm. China has seen a string of mass casualty incidents -- from stabbings to car attacks -- challenging its reputation for good public security. Last year a man who ploughed his car into a crowd of mostly school children in central China was handed a suspended death sentence with a two-year reprieve. In November 2024 the attacker named as Huang Wen repeatedly rammed his car into a crowd outside a primary school in Hunan province. When the vehicle malfunctioned and stopped, Huang got out and attacked bystanders with a weapon before being apprehended. Thirty people, including 18 pupils, sustained minor injuries. Some analysts have linked the incidents to growing anger and desperation at the country's slowing economy and a sense that society is becoming more stratified. In November last year, a man killed 35 people and wounded more than 40 when he rammed his car into a crowd in the southern city of Zhuhai, the country's deadliest attack in a decade. And in the same month, eight people were killed and 17 wounded in a knife attack at a vocational school in the eastern Chinese city of Yixing.
