Kneecap should be commended rather than condemned
Artists excel in the art of controversy. Art has a duty to challenge societal norms and beliefs. It should make us think and spark public discourse. Occasionally, this lands artists in hot water, as DH Lawrence, Francis Bacon and Sinéad O'Connor all discovered. Now, it is the turn of
Kneecap
.
The Irish-speaking rap group from Belfast attracted widespread condemnation in the UK for their actions at some of their recent gigs. At the end of their show at the Coachella music and arts festival on April 18th, messages appeared on the screens behind the band, including 'Israel is committing genocide against the Palestinian people' and 'F**k Israel; free Palestine'.
Counter-terrorism police in London are now investigating videos of incidents at two gigs in London.
Predictably, Kneecap's support for Palestine and their alleged violent words against Tory politicians have been unanimously denounced by everyone on the political spectrum in Westminster, from Labour's prime minister Keir Starmer to the Conservative Party leader Kemi Badenoch, including the SNP first minister of Scotland John Swinney.
READ MORE
The fallout has been considerable. Several of their gigs have already been cancelled, including three in Germany, and the British government has called on the organisers of Glastonbury to 'think carefully' about allowing a planned appearance by the band to go ahead. They are being punished for their words, which is a reminder of the weight of language, but also the moral responsibility that comes with it.
The three musicians found fame when their semi-fictionalised film Kneecap was released in 2024 to international critical acclaim, winning a British Academy of Film Award in February 2025. Apart from the music, the energy, the comedy and the drama, what the film is essentially about is the power of language to shape our identify. Our language defines who we are. As Canadian philosopher Charles Taylor argues, we define our identity always in dialogue, with our contemporaries but especially with our ancestors.
Language is a strange alchemy, to be used judiciously. Words can be inspiring, heartening, bolstering, and they can also hurt. Ludwig Wittgenstein, the most influential philosopher of language of the 20th century, remarked that words don't just reflect meaning, they get things done. By saying something, we do something. Shouting the words 'shoot!' at the television screen when my team is playing football is harmless, and very different from the same words being uttered by the officer of a firing squad. The question is, are Kneecap fanatic supporters of a cause or executioners?
Yelling 'up Hamas, up Hizbullah' at a live concert is a speech-act. These words are not just expressing a sentiment, they are a rallying call with the aim of encouraging people to act in support of a particular cause. Kneecap are using their words to try to persuade, convince or motivate their listeners in the audience to do something about the enduring brutality and crimes against humanity in Gaza.
While all words have consequences, it would be wise to abstain from making rush comparisons between slogans shouted at a concert, and the infamous 'Rivers of Blood' speech by Enoch Powell from April 1968; or Donald Trump's incendiary speech on January 6th, 2021, to a crowd of people intent to storm the Capitol building in Washington DC: 'We fight like hell. And if you don't fight like hell, you're not going to have a country any more.' Lest we forget, Kneecap are artists in their late 20s and 30s. Trump was, at the time, president of the United States of America.
[
Westminster never forgets its murdered MPs - which is why Kneecap's comments could not be overlooked
Opens in new window
]
However, one cannot help wondering at the ethics, and stupidity, of Kneecap's reported choice of words at a gig in November 2023: 'The only good Tory is a dead Tory. Kill your local MP.' That's inexcusable. Even Taoiseach Micheál Martin has called on Kneecap to 'urgently clarify' these ill-judged comments. Kneecap's subsequent apology to the families of murdered MPs Jo Cox (who was killed in June 2016) and David Amess (who was killed in October 2021) is also a speech-act, of sorts.
For philosopher Hannah Arendt, action is the essence of the human condition. Furthermore, action entails speech and speech entails action. Actions occur when we do something but, equally, action occurs via omissions when we fail to act. Paradoxically, by not doing something, we do something: severe neglect, or negligence, is the result of our failure to act. Consider what the Vatican did (not) do when faced with the evidence of sexual abuse by Catholic priests. Similarly, an omission of words is also an action. To keep silent in the face of gross injustice is to be complicit in the wrongness. We have a moral duty to speak out against human rights violations.
If there is one thing that is even worse than being silent, it's being silenced. By accusing anyone who is questioning the current policies of the Israeli government of anti-Semitism, the Israeli government is silencing all its critics, just as it has silenced foreign journalists covering the conflict in Gaza. Kneecap are also being silenced, but not by Israel.
The fact that politicians in the UK are trying to influence who should be invited to play at festivals is pure and simple censorship. A long list of prominent musicians, including Christy Moore, have signed an open letter calling for 'artistic freedom of expression' and denouncing a 'concerted attempt to censor and de-platform Kneecap'. The day politicians decide what music we should hear is the day democracy dies.
Exchanging words is always better than silence. Doing something about human rights violations is better than doing nothing. Their choice of word may have been crass, misguided, irresponsible and boorish, but at least Kneecap were using their art form to create a space for politics. What is happening in Gaza today is unspeakable, which is precisely why we need to speak about it. Denouncing a genocide is doing something and it's better than being silent. Kneecap are to be commended, not condemned – although I suggest they read Hannah Arendt on politics or Wittgenstein on philosophy of language before their next gig.
Vittorio Bufacchi is Professor of Philosophy at University College Cork. He is the author of Why Cicero Matters (2023)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Post
31 minutes ago
- Irish Post
Johnny McEvoy still singing at 80
JOHNNY McEvoy, from Banagher in Co. Offaly, has a unique place in Irish entertainment. Neither pure showband, folk, nor country, he occupies a space all of his own, somewhere between all three. And, unlike many of his contemporaries and those who followed in his footsteps, he has written much of his own material. In the early days, a lot of this was vaguely seditious: anti-war songs, protest songs—leading to frequent comparisons with Bob Dylan. Over the years, however, his songwriting developed strongly, and he can lay fair claim to having written some genuine classics: Long Before Your Time (a hit in 1976), Rich Man's Garden, You Seldom Come to See Me Anymore, and Michael, a tribute to Michael Collins. Johnny pictured at Killmainham in 1979 (Pics: Johnny McEvoy) But it was with a song of unclear origins (see panel) that Johnny scored his first hit. In 1966, he reached No. 1 in the Irish charts with the definitive version of Mursheen Durkin, instantly turning the song into an essential part of any ballad singer's repertoire. The air to which it is sung is Cailíní Deasa Mhuigheo (Pretty Girls of Mayo), a popular reel dating from the 19th century. The lyrics were added, it is believed, in the early 20th century by our old friend Anon. Whatever its origins, the song clicked with the public. But Mursheen was no overnight success—Johnny had a sackful of Irish ballads over his back. 'From the early sixties I was doing folk clubs and fleadhs. I was brought up on traditional music—I used to spend every summer at my grandmother's in Co. Galway, and I was virtually fed folk music and storytelling intravenously. It's one of the abiding memories of my childhood.' Johnny's Gaiety Show in the 1960s As Johnny reached his twenties, he fell under the influence of the wider contemporary folk scene—Hank Williams, Pete Seeger and Bob Dylan. In Ireland, the ballad scene was underway, and The Dubliners and The Clancys were beginning their steady trek to folk superstardom. It was against this background that Johnny achieved his first hit: 'In 1965 I recorded Today Is the Highway—which didn't do a lot. But the folk boom had begun, and I had a go with Mursheen a year later. It just clicked and sped up the charts. Getting to number one then was about the most exciting thing that had ever happened to me.' Two further massive hits followed—The Boston Burglar in 1967, and Nora in 1968. Johnny McEvoy was on his way—he soon had his own series on Ulster Television, played the Albert Hall and Carnegie Hall, and toured America, Ireland and Europe. 'They were great days, alright,' Johnny nods appreciatively. 'I even did a week at the Gaiety Theatre in Dublin. I was the first singer to try a one-man show—and it was a roaring success.' With this background—hit records, telly shows, appearances at some of the world's greatest concert halls, plus an abundance of natural talent in writing, presenting and performing his material—the obvious question has to be asked: why isn't Johnny McEvoy today an international star of the same order as Christy Moore? Or why doesn't he sell records by the lorryload like Daniel O'Donnell? Johnny pictured in 1982 Johnny, a thoughtful man, has obviously pondered this question many times before: 'Well, paradoxically, it was the demise of the showband that really hit me. Up till then, there was a circuit of venues that could host an act like mine for forty-five minutes or so. But with the end of the showband era, and the closure of a lot of the big ballrooms, that circuit no longer existed. And it was then that I made a big tactical error. Instead of going solo as an out-and-out folk performer, I took the wrong course. 'I formed a country & Irish band and started touring what was left of the old ballrooms. I was never happy in that band—neither the material nor the format really suited me. In a way, I felt I had sold out.' But Johnny seems totally without rancour. 'Yeah, there were a lot of mistakes. At the end of the sixties there was, as they say, a time and a tide—and I didn't catch either of them. But I can't complain. I've had decades doing what I love—and I'm not finished yet; not by a long chalk!' The more lenient hours of the concert circuit mean that Johnny has time to indulge in his hobbies—particularly reading. 'I've always been especially interested in biographies and history—especially the Second World War and the American Civil War.' Evidence of this is obvious in his songwriting. His 1977 hit Leaves in the Wind is a poignant anti-war song. 'I am a committed pacifist, and have been since my twenties. And I've always stayed true to those ideals.' By the 1970s it looked like Johnny would provide much of the soundtrack for the rest of the century. That he didn't emulate the likes of The Dubliners or Christy Moore is probably due to a combination of the vagaries of the entertainment business, the fickleness of Madam Luck, and ill-judged career moves. But Johnny remains indomitable. In 2014, he recorded his first album in over ten years, Basement Sessions 1, and it broke the Top 30 in the album charts. As he said himself, 'Not bad for a folky like me.' The singer pictured in 2020 He followed that up in 2015 with Basement Sessions 2—second in a series of five studio albums to be recorded and released over a five-year period. Into the Cauldron was his third studio album, with the hit recordings of My Father's House and Every Night I Dream of Being a Cowboy. While celebrating 50 years in the business, Johnny became part of Trad Nua's exclusive limited edition The Signature Series, with the first edition of his book My Songs, My Stories, My Life in Music. In April, Johnny celebrated his 80th birthday and a career spanning 60 years. He has a brand-new album entitled Both Sides—a collection of 14 songs and six audio stories, recorded and read by Johnny. These delve into the things that are important to him. 'I may not always have stayed true to my music,' he concludes, 'but I've always stayed true to myself.' Mursheen—a music hall song or folk tradition? MURSHEEN DURKIN could be a product of the Irish folk tradition — or a relic of the 19th-century music hall. Like many popular ballads, its history is somewhat murky. Some scholars trace its roots to the stage: a comic music hall song from the 1880s titled Digging for Lumps of Gold, penned by English songwriter Felix McGlennon, shares a strikingly similar storyline — right down to the Irish emigrant heading west in search of riches. A dispute even arose in 1885 when McGlennon sought damages after the song was performed without permission in a Gravesend music hall, allegedly by Irish comedian Pat Harvey. That version features a character named Corny (or Carney), lending weight to the idea that the stage may have shaped what we now recognise as Muirsheen Durkin. On the other hand, the tune has been collected and preserved within Irish folk tradition. It appeared in Colm Ó Lochlainn's More Irish Street Ballads in the 1960s and is often sung to the air of Cailíní deasa Mhuigheo (The Pretty Girls of Mayo), a traditional Irish reel from the 19th century. This gives the song strong roots in oral transmission and suggests it may have evolved as a folk pastiche of existing melodies and emigration themes. See More: Irish, Johnny McEvoy, Singer
Agriland
an hour ago
- Agriland
Opinion: Irish tillage sector has been left in limbo
Irish tillage farmers have become increasingly frustrated at the lack of strategic vision coming from government regarding the future direction of their industry. And, truth be told, they have more than a valid point. Recent days have seen leading representatives from the Irish Grain Growers' Group (IGGG) expressing their views in terms of what is really going on within tillage at the present time. Their annoyance centres on a number of fundamental realities. Firstly, farmers committed to the growing of crops cannot generate sustainable incomes. And, in turn, this is leading to growers leaving the industry or, at the very least, actively considering their futures in it. But it was all supposed to be so very different. Prior to the last general election, the two main parties in the current government – Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil – each promised an additional €300 million of support for tillage during the lifetime of this Dáil. This works out at some €60 million per year. But, so far, there has been no indication of these monies being made available to growers in any sense. And, of course, prior to all of this, we had the publication of the National Climate Action Plan, within which is a commitment to grow Ireland's tillage sector to 400,000ha by 2030, a mere four years' time. Currently, the industry is just about treading water in terms of its geographic footprint. However, another bad harvest in 2025 could send the sector into a life support scenario. Meanwhile, everyone agrees that the tillage industry has an exceptionally low carbon footprint. And, on that basis alone, its future must be ring-fenced and further encouraged. Irish tillage There are lots of reasons why tillage farmers feel sore about the ways in which they feel politics has failed them. A case in point is the Food Vision Tillage Group. It was set up by the previous government and seen by many as the 'great white horse', empowered to map out a clear future for arable farming in Ireland. However, its report has come and gone with no formal response to its recommendations coming from either the current or previous administrations. And, of course, actions – or lack of them – always speak louder than words. Recent days have seen Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, Martin Heydon chair an international agriculture and climate conference at which he highlighted the need for the development of more sustainable and climate-friendly food production practices into the future. It all strikes me as the perfect prelude for the minister to now issue his strategic vision for the future of tillage in Ireland.
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
Iconic 80s rocker shows support for Irish rappers Kneecap as ‘good friend' shares brew at band's cafe during Dublin trip
PAUL Weller has doubled down on his support for Kneecap by sharing a cuppa with them in the capital. Last month, the Modfather was one of 40 acts who signed an open letter opposing what they claim were efforts to censor the trio due to 3 Paul Weller showed his support for Kneecap at the Bang Bang Cafe in Phibsborough 3 Mo Chara faces a court case on June 18 Credit: Getty Images - Getty 3 Paul Weller was one of 40 acts who signed an open letter in support of the rappers Credit: Handout However, jetting into Dublin this week, the 67-year-old went one step further by sharing a cuppa with the An insider told The Irish Sun: 'Paul was over in 'He's a good friend and Kneecap were able to thank Paul for all his support over a brew.' The Belfast READ MORE IN KNEECAP Set in west Belfast, the The self-titled movie was awarded the Spirit of the Kneecap look set to play one of the biggest dates in their career to 12,500 punters at Their popularity is continuing to grow as member Mo Chara faces an impending Most read in Showbiz In a statement posted on Kneecap were cancelled from the TRNSMT concert lineup in Major TRNSMT act Kneecap in doubt after member charged with TERROR offences Meanwhile, Paul Weller, Primal Scream, and DJ Annie Mac were among the big names to sign an open letter supporting the group last month which denounced the alleged attempts to suppress the band's artistic expression. It urged a stance against political interference in artistic freedom at festivals and gigs, emphasizing the stance that true censorship lies in ignoring global humanitarian crises, such as the situation in BAND BACKLASH Kneecap was criticised after graphics saying 'F*** Israel' were displayed at the Coachella festival in Videos were then unearthed of a band member appearing to shout 'Up The band issued an apology to the families of the murdered MPs Sir David Amess and Jo Cox. The members said their 'message has always been and remains — one of love, inclusion and hope'. They have previously denied supporting Hezbollah or Hamas.
