Amazon, Apple seek legal fees as sanction in US consumer lawsuit
HighlightsApple Inc. and Amazon.com Inc. have requested a total of $223,000 in sanctions against the class action law firm Hagens Berman Sobol Shapiro for allegedly prolonging litigation related to iPhone and iPad pricing. U.S. District Judge Kymberly Evanson criticized Hagens Berman for not disclosing that their client, Steven Floyd, wanted to withdraw from the lawsuit, which contributed to unnecessary delays in the legal process. The lawsuit, which claims that Apple and Amazon conspired to artificially inflate product prices, continues with additional plaintiffs after the dismissal of Steven Floyd's claims.
Apple
and
Amazon
have asked for a combined $223,000 in sanctions against a prominent class action law firm, accusing it of dragging out litigation over the price of iPhones and iPads after the initial plaintiff in the case sought to drop out.
U.S. District Judge Kymberly Evanson in Seattle last month said the companies could ask to recover legal fees from Hagens Berman Sobol Shapiro for failing to immediately disclose that its client wanted out of the case.
Hagens Berman "needlessly prolonged this litigation and required considerable judicial resources," Evanson said.
The companies said in their fee request on Friday that their legal teams worked more than 350 hours on motions relating to seeking information about the plaintiff.
Spokespeople for Hagens Berman, Apple and Amazon did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
The lawsuit, which accuses the companies of conspiring to artificially inflate the price of iPhones and iPads sold on Amazon's platform, is continuing after other plaintiffs were added to the case.
Apple and Amazon have denied the antitrust claims.
Apple is represented by attorneys from Weil, Gotshal & Manges and Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe, while Amazon has a team from Sidley Austin, Redgrave and Davis Wright Tremaine.
The tech companies said they would limit their fee request to match hourly rates typically charged in the Western District of Washington. Weil partner Mark Perry, a Washington, D.C., lawyer who co-leads the firm's appellate and strategic counseling practice, said his rate for the purpose of the fee request was $900 an hour. Perry and other defense lawyers in the case did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
Hagens Berman client Steven Floyd told his lawyers in January 2024 that he wanted out of the litigation because he did not want to participate in the discovery process, Evanson said last month.
But the firm did not immediately disclose this to the court, the judge said, and instead created the impression that Floyd "had suddenly fallen out of contact in January 2024, for reasons his counsel did not know and possibly unrelated to the litigation."
Hagens Berman's "characterizations of Floyd's situation over the past fourteen months have not reflected his reality," Evanson said.
The judge on Tuesday formally dismissed Floyd's claims from the lawsuit.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
10 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Before Apple's next big reveal: How iOS 18 redefined updates and user reach
Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads As we approach the next wave of Apple software updates at WWDC, iOS 18 stands out as one of the most transformative updates in recent years not just in features, but in how swiftly users have embraced it. Introduced at WWDC 2024 and released to the public in September, iOS 18 ushered in a new era of personalization, intelligence, and cross-platform connectivity. For the first time, users could fully customize their Home Screen and Control Center, while a redesigned Photos app streamlined media update also brought RCS messaging support, bridging the communication gap between iPhone and Android users. Most notably, iOS 18 marked Apple's official entry into generative AI with Apple Intelligence a privacy-first suite of on-device tools integrated into everyday apps and an enhanced Siri experience. From offline maps and scheduled messages to Game Mode and advanced accessibility features, iOS 18 redefined what users expect from a mobile operating such a feature-rich update, it's no surprise that iOS 18 has seen rapid adoption across Apple's ecosystem. According to Apple, 88% of all iPhones introduced in the last four years are now running iOS 18, with overall adoption across all compatible iPhones at 82%. The uptake has been similarly strong on the iPad front 81% of iPads released in the past four years have updated to iPadOS 18, while 71% of all active iPads are now on the latest version. These numbers highlight not only Apple's consistent update rollout strategy but also the high user trust in its software of the key reasons behind iOS 18's impressive adoption rate is the central role that Software Update plays in the iPhone experience. Unlike many other smartphone platforms, Apple delivers its updates directly to users without carrier delays or third-party intervention ensuring quick, consistent access to the latest features, technologies, and security sets Apple apart is its commitment to longevity: iOS 18 is supported all the way back to the iPhone Xs, allowing a wide range of users to benefit from new features and improvements, regardless of the device's age. Updates are easy to install, with many users opting into automatic overnight updates, and Apple even offers the flexibility to remain on an older iOS version temporarily while still receiving critical security patches. This seamless and inclusive update model not only extends the useful life and resale value of older devices, but also strengthens security across the ecosystem. For developers, this consistency means they can confidently adopt the latest APIs and tools, knowing most users will have access ultimately resulting in better, more feature-rich apps for everyone. It's this deep integration of hardware and software, and Apple's end-to-end control of the experience, that makes broad adoption possible and beneficial.
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
35 minutes ago
- First Post
Looking to diversify from China, Apple gives Tata India iPhone repair business: Report
The market for repairs in India is expected to grow significantly as iPhone sales soar. The latest contract award demonstrates Apple's growing confidence in Tata as it establishes a foothold in a key market read more Apple has engaged Tata Group to manage repairs for iPhones and MacBook devices in the rapidly expanding Indian market. The move signals the Indian conglomerate's increasing role in the Apple's supply chain, Reuters cited two individuals familiar with the matter as saying. Tata takes on key role as Apple looks beyond China With Apple seeking partners beyond China for manufacturing, Tata has swiftly become a key supplier, already assembling iPhones for both local and foreign markets at three facilities in southern India, one of which also produces some iPhone components. In this latest partnership expansion, Tata is taking over the responsibility from an Indian unit of Taiwan's Wistron, ICT Service Management Solutions, and will handle after-sales repairs from its Karnataka iPhone assembly campus, both sources revealed. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD The market for repairs in India is expected to grow significantly as iPhone sales soar. Counterpoint Research estimates that around 11 million iPhones were sold in India last year, giving Apple a 7 per cent market share, up from just 1 per cent in 2020. The latest contract award demonstrates Apple's growing confidence in Tata as it aims to secure more business from the world's most valuable smartphone company. Prabhu Ram, a vice president at Cybermedia Research, noted that Tata's deepening partnership with Apple could lay the groundwork for the US tech giant to sell refurbished devices directly in India, similar to its operations in the United States. The transition of responsibilities from ICT to Tata is currently underway, according to both sources. While Apple's official service centers across India can handle basic repairs, more complex issues will now be shipped to Tata's facility. However, Wistron's ICT will continue to service other clients excluding Apple, one of the sources mentioned. Amid the potential threat of US President Donald Trump's tariffs on China, India is also emerging as a favoured destination for iPhone exports. Apple CEO Tim Cook has stated that the majority of iPhones sold in the United States during the June quarter will be manufactured at factories in India. With inputs from Reuters STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Before Apple's next big reveal: How iOS 18 redefined updates and user reach
As we approach the next wave of Apple software updates at WWDC, iOS 18 stands out as one of the most transformative updates in recent years not just in features, but in how swiftly users have embraced it. Introduced at WWDC 2024 and released to the public in September, iOS 18 ushered in a new era of personalization, intelligence, and cross-platform connectivity. For the first time, users could fully customize their Home Screen and Control Center, while a redesigned Photos app streamlined media update also brought RCS messaging support, bridging the communication gap between iPhone and Android users. Most notably, iOS 18 marked Apple's official entry into generative AI with Apple Intelligence a privacy-first suite of on-device tools integrated into everyday apps and an enhanced Siri experience. From offline maps and scheduled messages to Game Mode and advanced accessibility features, iOS 18 redefined what users expect from a mobile operating such a feature-rich update, it's no surprise that iOS 18 has seen rapid adoption across Apple's ecosystem. According to Apple, 88% of all iPhones introduced in the last four years are now running iOS 18, with overall adoption across all compatible iPhones at 82%. The uptake has been similarly strong on the iPad front 81% of iPads released in the past four years have updated to iPadOS 18, while 71% of all active iPads are now on the latest version. These numbers highlight not only Apple's consistent update rollout strategy but also the high user trust in its software of the key reasons behind iOS 18's impressive adoption rate is the central role that Software Update plays in the iPhone experience. Unlike many other smartphone platforms, Apple delivers its updates directly to users without carrier delays or third-party intervention ensuring quick, consistent access to the latest features, technologies, and security sets Apple apart is its commitment to longevity: iOS 18 is supported all the way back to the iPhone Xs, allowing a wide range of users to benefit from new features and improvements, regardless of the device's age. Updates are easy to install, with many users opting into automatic overnight updates, and Apple even offers the flexibility to remain on an older iOS version temporarily while still receiving critical security patches. This seamless and inclusive update model not only extends the useful life and resale value of older devices, but also strengthens security across the ecosystem. For developers, this consistency means they can confidently adopt the latest APIs and tools, knowing most users will have access ultimately resulting in better, more feature-rich apps for everyone. It's this deep integration of hardware and software, and Apple's end-to-end control of the experience, that makes broad adoption possible and beneficial.
