Rutherford school board rescinds resolution supporting border closure: 'Damage is already done'
Rutherford school board rescinds resolution supporting border closure: 'Damage is already done' Board reconsiders 2 controversial motions at same meeting
Show Caption
Hide Caption
Rutherford County Schools father speaks against anti DEI policy
Rutherford County Schools father Matt Fee speaks against anti DEI policy
Unanimous board reverses previous 5-1 border resolution vote
Mother: 'This resolution personally affected me'
Mother says absences on rise due to deportation
Vice chairwoman asks to rescind her resolution
Rosales also switches position on DEI
Rutherford County school board members rescinded their resolution urging closure of national borders recently after hearing from upset parents.
Mother Valeria Diaz de Leon shared her concerns about the resolution in person by speaking during the public comment portion of the Feb. 6 meeting
'In this political climate, we all know the implication that has," Diaz de Leon told the seven-member all Republican Rutherford County Board of Education.
'Diversity is a good thing': Split Rutherford school board backs DEI by 1 changed vote
Many of the packed school board audience in a room that can seat 170 people applauded the mother's comments prior to the elected school officials unanimously agreeing to rescind the resolution in question.
The board on Jan. 23 approved the now rescinded resolution in a 5-1 vote a few days after Republican President Donald Trump took his oath of office. Trump soon sought to secure the national borders and deport immigrants who entered the country illegally.
Immigration issue: Rutherford school board votes in support of closing nation's borders due to rising ESL needs
Unanimous board reverses previous 5-1 border resolution vote
Only board member Tammy Sharp opposed the initial resolution in question.
"This is going to send a message to our children − and not a good one," Sharp said after the other present board members approved the now rescinded resolution.
The resolution from vice chairwoman Frances Rosales had support from fellow board members Butch Vaughn, Caleb Tidwell, Katie Darby and chairwoman Claire Maxwell. Board member Stan Vaught was absent.
The resolution also had requested more federal funding for the district to help serve the increase of students needing English as a Second Language instruction.
Republicans capture all seats: Vaught, Vaughn, Tidwell and Maxwell win to join all GOP Rutherford County school board
Mother: 'This resolution personally affected me'
Diaz de Leon said the district should have just asked for more federal funding to hire additional ESL teachers without making a statement about the border.
'This resolution personally affected me and my family because my three sons will be attending RC (Rutherford County) schools as ESL students, and you have just stereotyped all ESL students as coming from the southern border," the mother said.
Diaz de Leon told the board that she was glad to learn prior to the meeting that the school officials were prepared to rescind the resolution.
'With all due respect, the damage is already done,' Diaz de Leon said.
Partisan politics: Democrat fears new GOP majority county school board may mean book banning, teacher firing
Mother says absences on rise due to deportation
Diaz de Leon also suggested that some student absences are correlated with deportation actions.
"Students are afraid that they'll go home to find their parents missing," Diaz de Leon said.
"Parents are afraid to send their kids to school for fear that they may not come home. And our school board decided to respond to this by releasing a statement that completely vilifies our ESL community."
Rather than approving the now rescinded resolution, the board should have reaffirmed its opposition to the state approval of funding vouchers to help parents pay for private schools for their children instead of providing the money to support public schools available to all students, Diaz de Leon suggested.
"We need to believe that you did not write that resolution in good faith but to further divide our community," Diaz de Leon said.
State legislation: Rutherford's 2 state senators tout legislation for school vouchers, farmland preservation
Vice chairwoman asks to rescind her resolution
Rosales, the board vice chairwoman who called for the resolution in question, requested that the board rescind the previous position.
The vice chairwoman provided the following statement to The Daily News Journal prior to the Feb. 6 meeting.
"I advocated for ESL because I am a product of ESL within the public school system," Rosales said.
"The effort got lost in translation as a way to raise awareness about the little to no help the federal government provides to the district, and for that, I was mistaken. Districts have no control over the decisions made by the federal government. All we can do is our best as a district to educate everyone."
The vice chairwoman during the recent meeting mentioned spending her early childhood years in Puerto Rico before moving to the U.S. and being the only Hispanic student at her high school.
First Amendment issue: Rutherford schools removal of 160 more books draws opposition from free speech advocates
Rosales also switches position on DEI
In addition to rescinding the motion, the board also rejected a motion by Tidwell to oppose diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) policies.
Rosales initially supported Tidwell's resolution in a 4-3 vote before she requested another vote to reconsider. She then voted to reject the resolution to oppose DEI with Vaught, Vaughn and Maxwell.
Tidwell's rejected resolution kept the support of Sharp and Darby.
'We are banished': Rutherford schools book banning upsets free speech advocates
Reach reporter Scott Broden with news tips or questions by emailing him at sbroden@dnj.com. To support his work with The Daily News Journal, sign up for a digital subscription.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
13 minutes ago
- CBS News
Activists shut out of Sacramento immigration hearings following ICE detainment
There was pushback outside the federal building in Sacramento on Thursday as members of a local activist group say they were prohibited from attending a scheduled immigration hearing that is typically open to the public. The group, NorCal Resist, said some of their volunteers watched as ICE agents detained an immigrant who was there for an appointment. NorCal Resist volunteers say they often accompany immigrants to appointments to observe, document, and support them through their proceedings. But on Thursday, many activists were left outside as the federal building went on lockdown for several hours after the man was detained, and only those with appointments and employees were allowed in, according to CapRadio. "It's a public government building that we have every right to be in," said Giselle Garcia, a volunteer with NorCal Resist. "This is a gross violation of the law that they're doing here." Some activists stayed there through the afternoon, with one activist describing their interaction first-hand to CBS News Sacramento. "It was alarming. There was an armed man who stood in front of me, and I just have a little poster board sign, and there were agents having their faces covered," the protester, who asked not to be named, said. Shortly after 4 p.m., CBS Sacramento saw a caravan of vehicles leaving the federal building, led by a van and unmarked government vehicles. Around half a dozen ICE agents, mostly in masks, exited a gate at the federal building as the vehicles left. ICE has not confirmed the details of its activity in Sacramento. Democratic Congressman Ami Bera, who represents Sacramento County, said President Trump's immigration policies are "creating a culture of fear in our immigrant communities." "We'll support you if you want to go after criminals, but the folks that are not a threat to our community, let's figure out a better way to address that," Bera told CBS Sacramento. Bera told CBS Sacramento that Democrats and Republicans would need to find common ground "to ease tensions in this country." "We're going to have to listen to one another," Bera said. "I want us to come together as a country, so let's do it." Republican Congressman Kevin Kiley spoke to media members over Zoom on Thursday and said that California and the City of Los Angeles have each passed policies that "have encouraged lawlessness" and "a breakdown of order." "Unfortunately, we had political leaders as well who added fuel to that fire with irresponsible and inflammatory rhetoric," Kiley said.
Yahoo
13 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Republicans respond to Israel's strikes on Iran: ‘Game on'
Republican lawmakers welcomed Israel's overnight attack against Iran and asked the public to pray for the Jewish State, which waged strikes against Tehran's expanding nuclear program and military leadership. 'Game on. Pray for Israel,' Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.), a defense hawk, wrote Thursday night on the social media platform X. Similar messages were posted by other GOP members of Congress since Israel unleashed an attack that, so far, has killed Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps (IRGC) Commander Hossein Salami, along with two other top Iranian generals. Speaker Mike Johnson echoed President Trump's consistent warning that Iran never obtains a nuclear weapon in his response, commending the administration for working 'tirelessly to ensure that outcome.' 'Unfortunately, Iran has refused to agree and even declared yesterday its intent to build a new enrichment facility,' Johnson posted to X on Friday. 'Israel decided it needed to take action to defend itself,' he added. 'They were clearly within their right to do so. Iran will face grave consequences if it responds by unjustifiably targeting U.S. interests.' Sen. Jim Risch, chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, also showed his support for Israel late Thursday, following the strikes. 'We stand with Israel tonight and pray for the safety of its people and the success of this unilateral, defensive action. I am also praying for the brave U.S. service members in the Middle East who keep America safe — Iran would be foolish to attack the United States,' he posted on X. Israel performed at least five rounds of strikes against Iran, hitting dozens of targets, including the Natanz, one of Iran's main enrichment facilities. Israel said the attack was unleashed to help prevent Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said in a video message that the operation, dubbed 'Rising Lion,' would last 'as many days as it takes.' 'We struck at the heart of Iran's nuclear enrichment program. We struck at the heart of Iran's nuclear weaponization program. We targeted Iran's main enrichment facility in Natanz,' the prime minster said in his address, shared to X. 'We targeted Iran's leading nuclear scientists working on the Iranian bomb. We also struck at the heart of Iran's ballistic missile program.' Sen. Jack Reed (D-R.I.), the ranking member on the Senate Armed Services Commitee, said that Israel's 'reckless escalation' threatens to ignite violence in the region and could jeopardize the safety of Americans stationed in the Middle East. 'While tensions between Israel and Iran are real and complex, military aggression of this scale is never the answer,' Reed said late Thursday in a statement. 'I urge both nations to show immediate restraint, and I call on President Trump and our international partners to press for diplomatic de-escalation before this crisis spirals further out of control,' the Democratic senator added. 'President Trump must be crystal clear with the American people and the international community in charting a way forward. The world cannot afford more devastating conflict born of short-sighted violence.' Iran retaliated, launching over 100 drones, some of whom are intercepted by the Israeli military, according to officials. Trump warned Iran Friday morning to accept a nuclear deal with the U.S. or it would face harsh consequences. 'I told them it would be much worse than anything they know, anticipated, or were told, that the United States makes the best and most lethal military equipment anywhere in the World, BY FAR, and that Israel has a lot of it, with much more to come – And they know how to use it,' the president wrote on Truth Social. He added in a subsequent post, 'Now they have, perhaps, a second chance!' Iran, amid the tension, announced Friday that they were pulling out of the next round of nuclear talks that were expected Sunday in Oman. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
13 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Letters to the Editor: We cannot allow a U.S. senator to be handcuffed for asking questions
To the editor: When is enough enough? I am in tears as a senator from my state is manhandled to the ground for asking questions ('California Sen. Alex Padilla forcibly removed, handcuffed during Kristi Noem press conference,' June 12). How could Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem's "security" assault our senator for exercising his constitutional rights? Whether Sen. Alex Padilla was a government representative or not, this is all a part of our rights as citizens, as granted by the 1st Amendment. On top of all the affronts by President Trump's disregard of our laws, this is over the edge to dictatorship. All senators and representatives must stand up to this outrageous disregard of our laws. The Posse Comitatus Act is not a suggestion, nor is the Constitution. It is well past time for Republicans to stand up for our country. Do they really care to go down in history as seditious cowards? I am a 78-year-old Los Angeles native and have never been so angry at the behavior of government officials in my life. I've seen President Nixon lie and the Iran-Contra mess under President Reagan, in addition to many other incidents where officials broke the law. This is much worse. Our rights are on the line. If my mobility were not impaired, I would be protesting with my fellow Angelenos. Stand up for us! Leslie Forester Tillmann, Palm Desert .. To the editor: Noem can shoot defenseless animals, but is unable to answer questions from a United States senator. Is she really capable of ensuring our nation's domestic security? It doesn't look like it. Mary Griswold Gordon, Rancho Palos Verdes This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times.
