‘Equitable and fair': BPS leaders weigh significant changes to exam school admissions policy
Related
:
Any change would require a vote by the board and would come about five years after the district completely overhauled admissions to the three schools: Boston Latin School, Boston Latin Academy, and the John D. O'Bryant School of Math and Science. Tuesday's presentation
will lay out a timeline of community engagement throughout the summer followed by a potential superintendent recommendation and committee vote in the fall.
The current policy was intended to make the exam schools more demographically similar to the city's schools as a whole. The three schools had long enrolled larger proportions of white, Asian, and non-low income students than the rest of the district.
Advertisement
'The exam school admissions policies have been largely successful at making the student body at the exam schools more representative of our communities geographically, [in] racial and ethnic diversity and [in] socioeconomic background,' Mayor Michelle Wu said in an interview Tuesday, prior to the meeting.
Advertisement
But the policy has also resulted in large disparities in admission rate based on where students live in the city, she said. Some years, there were 100 percent admission rates in certain neighborhoods and less than 50 percent admission rates in others. The simulations outline potential policies that would preserve the socioeconomic tiers but ensure all students have a chance at an exam school seat, regardless of where they live or go to elementary school, Wu said.
'Every policy within BPS, we have to look at to make sure it's equitable and it's fair,' Superintendent Mary Skipper said. 'We want all students to see themselves in the exam schools.'
The review
of the exam school admissions policy
comes a month after the Trump administration
Related
:
'We're aware of many lawsuits at this point that are happening around selective schools and in process,' Skipper said. 'This was in the courts [and] it came out that the process we've used at the time was considered valid.'
The Supreme Court last year
Under the district's current policy,
Advertisement
Applicants receive a composite score out of 100 based on their grades and entrance exam scores. Students can get 15 bonus points if they live in public housing, are homeless, or are in foster care, or a varying number of points if they attend schools where at least 40 percent of students are low-income. The school-based bonus points vary by tier from two points to 10.
As part of the review, the district found bonus points have not had a significant impact on invitations, Skipper said, as most applicants attend BPS schools that get bonus points. All the simulations prepared for Tuesday's meeting eliminated the bonus points.
Skipper said district staff would analyze versions with the bonus points in the future if the School Committee
requests it, but they found the points make the policy more confusing, create a sense of competition between schools. They also have even created unattainable admissions cutoffs in some cases for students without bonus points.
The idea of scaling the tiers by number of applicants, rather than the number of eligible students, is a frequent demand from some parents. The most affluent tiers have historically had the most applicants, but
since
all tiers get the same number of seats, admission is particularly competitive in those areas.
New data released Tuesday show that distinction has faded somewhat, with application rates falling in Tier 4 (the wealthiest area), and rising in Tier 1 (the least affluent area). Still, the admission rate ranged from 59 percent in Tier 4 to 77 percent in Tier 1, and the minimum scores for Grade 7 admission remained significantly higher in Tier 4.
Advertisement
The latest year's data also showed fewer Black students earning admission than in the prior years. Skipper said district staff are still exploring the data for explanations.
Related
:
Under the simulated policy that equalizes tiers based on applicant numbers, the admission rate would have been about two-thirds in each tier. Two simulations with different versions of a citywide pool of seats each result in the wealthier areas having the highest admission rate, around 70 percent.
On the other hand, district leaders again rejected a different frequent request in Tuesday's presentation. School Committee member Brandon Cardet-Hernandez has repeatedly called on the district to abandon school-based bonus points and instead award bonus points based on individual students' socioeconomic status.
In a memo for the committee, Skipper said individual bonus points are not feasible due to operational challenges and because some low-income students do not participate in programs used to determine eligibility for immigration status reasons.
Wu and Skipper underscored in the interview that while the exam schools are highly-sought after and serve a large and growing proportion of the district's teenagers, they cannot be the only focus.
'The driving goal is for BPS to be the first choice for every family in the city of Boston, and that means making sure we have high quality student experience at seats in every high school,' Wu said.
Christopher Huffaker can be reached at
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
4 hours ago
What is the Strait of Hormuz and why does it matter?
The United States' entry into the Iran-Israel war over the weekend stoked fears of a wider conflict that could spread across the oil-rich Middle East and disrupt the global economy. President Donald Trump announced Monday evening on social media that Israel and Iran had agreed to a "complete and total" ceasefire -- although neither country initially acknowledged the announcement. Before Trump's announcement, investors' concerns centered on the Strait of Hormuz, a narrow waterway and trading route off the Southern coast of Iran that facilitates the transport of about 20% of liquid petroleum consumed worldwide. The Iranian parliament on Sunday approved closure of the Strait of Hormuz, though the final decision will be made by Iran's Supreme National Security Council, Iranian state media reported. While Iran could disrupt the Strait of Hormuz through attacks on oil tankers, it's not clear how it could close the waterway — or if it has the capacity to do so. The Strait of Hormuz remains open. Oil prices initially fell more than 6% on Monday in the immediate aftermath of an Iranian attack on a U.S. military base in Qatar. As of Monday afternoon, there were "no reports of casualties," according to a U.S. official. The sharp drop in oil prices resulted from a perception that the Iranian retaliation may be over, Patrick de Haan, the head of petroleum analysis at GasBuddy, said in a post on X. Closure of the Strait of Hormuz could drive up the price of oil, hiking U.S. prices for gasoline and other goods, while slowing the global economy, experts said. But, they added, the move risks constraining Iran's own oil exports and those of neighboring countries. 'The continued accessibility of the Strait of Hormuz is pivotal to the global economic outlook,' Jim Reid, a research strategist at Deutsche Bank, said in a memo to clients on Monday. What is the Strait of Hormuz? The Strait of Hormuz is a waterway that runs along the Southern coast of Iran and the Northern coast of Oman. The passage marks the only shipping route that stretches from the Persian Gulf to the open ocean, making it a key travel hub for goods originating in oil-rich Gulf countries like Saudi Arabia, Qatar and Iran. At its narrowest point, the Strait of Hormuz is just 21 miles wide. 'We're talking here about a very, very narrow geographic space, and the shipping lanes are even more narrow,' Adam Klein, director of the Robert S. Strauss Center for International Security and Law at the University of Texas at Austin, told ABC News. 'This is a highly vulnerable, highly strategic chokepoint.' Last year, an average of about 20 million barrels per day passed through the Strait of Hormuz, which amounts to roughly 20% of liquid petroleum consumed worldwide, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration, or EIA, a government agency. The vast majority of oil that passes through the strait is bound for Asian markets. Nearly 5 million barrels of oil arrived in China via the Strait of Hormuz each day last year, the EIA said, while about 2 million barrels of such oil ended up in India on a daily basis. By comparison, the U.S. imported just 500,000 barrels of oil each day via the Strait of Hormuz. The U.S. is a net exporter of crude oil, meaning the country produces more oil than it consumes. Since oil prices are set on a global market, U.S. prices move in response to swings in supply and demand. 'The closure of the Strait of Hormuz can cause prices U.S. consumers pay to rise,' Klein said, but he noted other nations could be more vulnerable since they rely more on oil that travels through the Strait of Hormuz. Why does the Strait of Hormuz matter? As a bottleneck for a large share of global oil, the Strait of Hormuz could become the site of a significant disruption of the global economy, some experts told ABC News. Oil prices could surge from a current level of about $74 per barrel up to $120 per barrel if the Israel-Iran conflict damages Iranian oil infrastructure or impedes the passage of some oil tankers in the Strait of Hormuz, Ramanan Krishnamoorti, a professor of petroleum engineering at the University of Houston, told ABC News. That scenario would amount to a more than 60% surge in oil prices, Krishnamoorti added, resulting in a proportionate hike for gas prices. The average price of a gallon of gas would climb from its current level of $3.22 to over $5, since crude oil makes up the key ingredient in auto gasoline. "If we see any throttling back of the Strait of Hormuz, we'll see a massive increase in the price of oil," Krishnamoorti said. That forecast of a potential price spike for oil matched a prediction from asset management firm Lazard, which warned last week of a possible escalation involving "strikes on Gulf energy installations or attempts to temporarily close the Strait of Hormuz." Such a scenario would trigger "price increases upwards of $120 per barrel," Lazard said in a memo to investors. A hike in the price of oil would not only increase the price of gasoline but could also push up prices for a range of other goods, since transport expenses will rise as shippers and truckers pay higher fuel costs. EY, a global accounting firm, outlined a possible Iran War scenario of 'significant escalation' that involves blockage in the Strait of Hormuz and attacks on ships in the Red Sea. Under such circumstances, the U.S. and global economies would likely enter a recession as a result of 'severe supply chain strains and inflationary pressures,' EY said. Still, Iran may opt against closing the strait. The move would impede Iran's own oil exports, which make up a key source of revenue, and it would risk alienating Middle East neighbors, Klein said. 'It would turn countries against Iran that have thus far been on the fence,' Klein said. 'Iran would be hurting those consumers and economies, as well as Israel and the U.S.'
The Hill
5 hours ago
- The Hill
Advocates warn against cuts to science funding
The Big Story A new ad from advocacy group 314 Action, shared first with The Hill, warns that the Trump administration's cuts to science funding will result in countries like China overtaking the U.S. as a scientific superpower. © Getty The ad, titled 'Science is Our Superpower,' targets swing district House GOP incumbents in Iowa, Arizona, Nebraska, and New Jersey. 'We're losing ground to China,' the ad states. 'Turning our backs on science holds us back.' The administration's actions—from eliminating programs and federal departments to slashing grants for scientific research— are leading to an exodus of scientists, and other countries are looking to capitalize. The Trump administration has banned the National Institutes of Health from funding grants that had a connection to 'diversity, equity and inclusion.' It's also capped how much the agency pays for indirect costs and directly targeted federal funding for elite colleges and universities. As a result, other countries offering incentives like tenure and guaranteed funding for the next 20 years to bring American scientists to their labs. The journal Nature reported that more scientists are looking for jobs abroad, with a 20-40 percent increase in job applications in Canada, Europe, China, and other Asian countries, compared to this time last year. Welcome to The Hill's Health Care newsletter, we're Nathaniel Weixel, Joseph Choi and Alejandra O'Connell-Domenech — every week we follow the latest moves on how Washington impacts your health. Did someone forward you this newsletter? Subscribe here. Essential Reads How policy will be impacting the health care sector this week and beyond: HHS promotes insurer pledge to scale back prior authorization Federal health officials on Monday touted pledges they have received from the health insurance industry to streamline and reform the prior authorization process for Medicare Advantage, Medicaid Managed Care and Affordable Care Act Health Insurance Marketplace plans which account for most insured Americans. Health and Human Services (HHS) Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Administrator … Novo Nordisk ends partnership with Hims & Hers over Wegovy copycats Drugmaker Novo Nordisk said it is halting its agreement with telehealth company Hims & Hers after less than two months, citing deceptive marketing and the selling of knock-off versions of its blockbuster weight-loss drug Wegovy. The company in April announced it would be partnering with Hims & Hers as well as other telehealth companies to sell Wegovy at a reduced cost of $499. The telehealth companies sold cheaper … Abortions continued rising in 2024 despite state bans: Report More women were able to access abortion care in 2024 than the previous year despite state bans, reflecting a continued increase in the three years since the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, according to a report issued Monday. The latest report from the #WeCount project of the Society of Family Planning, which supports abortion access, found there were about 1.14 million abortions provided by licensed clinicians … On Our Radar Upcoming news themes and events we're watching: In Other News Branch out with a different read from The Hill: Biden's White House physician to appear before House panel Former President Biden's White House doctor, Kevin O'Connor, is set to appear for a deposition before the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee next month, a committee spokesperson confirmed to The Hill. Around the Nation Local and state headlines on health care: What We're Reading Health news we've flagged from other outlets: What Others are Reading Most read stories on The Hill right now: Supreme Court lifts third country deportation limits; liberals pen scathing dissent The Supreme Court on Monday lifted judge-imposed limits on the Trump administration's deportations to countries where migrants have no ties over a … Read more Former ambassador to Russia: Putin, Xi will celebrate Trump's 'preemptive war' in Iran Former U.S. Ambassador to Russia Michael McFaul offered warnings on Saturday of how U.S. strikes on Iran could influence U.S. adversaries around the … Read more What People Think Opinions related to health submitted to The Hill: Thank you for signing up! Subscribe to more newsletters here
Business Insider
11 hours ago
- Business Insider
Why filling up your tank is likely to cost more pretty soon
Oil prices have proved volatile following the US strikes on Iran's nuclear facilities — and you could soon be paying more to fill up your tank. West Texas Intermediate and global benchmark Brent crude were sharply higher in Asian trading on Monday before losing ground later in the day. That reversal may please President Donald Trump, who posted on Truth Social "Everyone, keep oil prices down." He also called on the Department of Energy to "drill, baby, drill" — even though it does not do so. Fluctuating oil prices could result in more pain for consumers' wallets. Denton Cinquegrana, chief oil analyst at OPIS, thinks that retail gasoline prices will "move higher" in the near term. Despite rising geopolitical tensions, he told Business Insider that oil prices hadn't caught up with levels reached last year. "The probability of prices staying here and not reacting to the next headline is pretty low." He expected US gas prices to approach $3.30 a gallon this week, up from about $3.22 on Monday. The price this time last year was $3.44. Diesel averages $3.68 a gallon, per the AAA, compared with $3.80 a year ago and could also jump, Cinquegrana said: "A spike in diesel prices could hit consumers just as hard as higher gasoline prices as the transport of goods becomes more expensive." Spending power dented Households in the US and Europe spend between 3% and 10% of their incomes on energy, which includes gasoline, heating oil, gas, and electricity, Carsten Brzeski, global head of macro at ING Economics, told BI. "This means that the increase in oil prices has a direct impact on consumers, denting their spending power," he said. "When it comes to gasoline, the impact is very imminent as companies pass higher market prices immediately on to their customers." Brzeski said that energy price rises could hit consumers "like a tsunami." Supply question "For consumers it all boils down to whether we will see a material disruption in oil supplies from the Middle East," said Clayton Seigle, senior fellow in the energy security and climate change program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. "The more the war with Iran escalates, the greater the chances this will occur, and higher crude prices will be passed on in the form of higher fuel prices like gasoline and diesel," he told BI. "However, oil prices have not increased much since the fighting began, because oil traders are sanguine about the risk of disruption." The US produces about 13 million barrels of oil a day and imports a further 3 million a day from Canada, lowering the risk of significant supply shortages. The US also imports oil from countries including Mexico, Saudi Arabia, Iraq, and Brazil. Lower-income pain Ryan Sweet, chief US economist at Oxford Economics, said the US economy had slowed and was vulnerable to further setbacks such as a sudden rise in oil prices. He told BI that lower-income households in the South are especially vulnerable to oil-price shocks because they spend more on gas as they drive more, have less of a "savings cushion" than peers in the North, and fuel makes up a larger share of their household spending. That would leave them with less money to spend on other things. Sweet said "it's a lot" for consumers between limp wage growth, a faltering labor market, tariffs, and now the prospect of higher gas prices.
