Slippery slope of butter prices
A more than 50% surge in the price of butter is a "frightening" sign the hospitality industry is doing it tough, a Dunedin business owner says.
"Butter, cheese, milk — they're becoming luxuries," Speight's Ale House Dunedin owner Mark Scully said.
According to figures released by Stats NZ yesterday, food prices in May increased 4.4% in the past year, on the back of a 3.7% annual rise in April.
Higher prices for the grocery food group and meat, poultry and fish group contributed the most, rising 5.2% and 5.4% respectively.
Butter, cheese and milk prices were cited as the cause.
The average price of butter last month was $8.42 per 500g, a 51.2% annual increase.
"The cost of a 500g block of butter is nearly twice as expensive as the lower prices seen in early 2024," prices and deflators spokeswoman Nicola Growden said.
Cheese was $13.04 per 1kg block, up 30.1% year-on-year, while milk was $4.57 per 2 litres, up 15.1%.
The average prices of beef steak and beef mince were up 18.6% and 13%, respectively.
Mr Scully, who is also Hospitality New Zealand's Otago branch president, said he was surprised the average price of butter had become so high.
"I knew it was going up, but that is a frightening stat, isn't it?"
The price of butter had seen a "real hype" in the past 12 to 18 months, and protein and dairy costs had been particularly tough for businesses.
Nobody wanted to have to close their business, but it did appear to be a reasonably regular occurrence around the country, Mr Scully said.
"But it's like anything, you just have to be brave and ultimately pass it on to the consumer or else your margins just don't stack up."
Ayrburn general manager Kieran Turnbull said the hospitality precinct had seen a steady rise in food prices across the board since the Covid-19 pandemic, but there had been a "real noticeable increase" in the price of butter this year.
"Everyone needs butter ... butter goes into everything.
"It goes into your scone, it goes into your pastries, it goes into your desserts, it goes into sauces — so it's a cost that flows right through."
While prices were always changing in hospitality, Mr Turnbull believed the costs put on to consumers were being "more acutely felt" than at other times.
"That's probably why it's so tough at the moment for a lot of operators."
The precinct, located between Arrowtown and Lake Hayes, has nine distinct venues.
Having a range of offerings allowed it to absorb costs in one outlet while letting them rise in another, but at the cost of providing so many offerings, Mr Turnbull said.
Supermarkets were also continuing to "artificially set the expectations for the New Zealand consumer of what things cost".
"And that directly affects hospitality."
tim.scott@odt.co.nz
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
an hour ago
- Otago Daily Times
Dunedin Airport lashes out at government
Dunedin Airport has accused the government of double-dipping and questionable law-making in a submission calling on it to abandon a move which raises the cost of bringing back international flights. Under the new legislation, airports that intend to start or restart international services will be required to pay for the establishment costs for border services. The new regulations are expected to come into force shortly, but Dunedin Airport's chief executive Daniel De Bono argued it was tantamount to double-dipping from the government, as the costs of processing international travellers would be funded from the existing border processing levies. In the letter to Parliament's regulation review committee, Mr De Bono said: "We cannot comprehend why a government that is focused on economic growth would make new regulations that are targeted at regional airports and severely inhibit their ability to develop international connectivity." Dunedin Airport had international flights from 1995 until Covid-19 hit the industry in 2020. It resumes international flights this month, with a JetStar connection to the Gold Coast. "As with all international routes at smaller airports, the economics are finely balanced," Mr De Bono's letter said. "When negotiating and agreeing terms, Dunedin Airport and JetStar did not anticipate that the government would take steps to impose significant additional costs on the venue. "The wider effect of cost recovery ... is to create a real constraint on regional tourism and economic growth." Mr De Bono said he did not believe the original intention of the Act was to "unexpectedly be used to impose more levies". This would lead to "serious unfairness and unreasonableness" for airports attempting to re-establish international travel and would have immediate effect on Dunedin Airport, he said. Mr De Bono also provided a legal letter from law firm Russell McVeagh. The legal letter also cast doubts on the government's approach. "Our view is that the proposal to now recover costs under the Airports Act is legally unnecessary," it said. "In pursuing options for recovery under the Airports Act, Cabinet and officials appear to be relying on a mistaken view of the law, leaving their decisions open to legal challenge. "It cannot be correct that there is a presumption in favour of using the Airports Act for new international airports simply because it exists." In response, Biosecurity Minister Andrew Hoggard told the Otago Daily Times customs screening at airports had been cost-recovered for decades. "Cost recovery is for the actual and reasonable cost of providing biosecurity and customs services. "In relation to Dunedin International Airport, the Ministry for Primary Industries [MPI] has worked hard to ensure the establishment costs are fair and reasonable, including reusing existing equipment where possible. "Under the Airports Act, if an airport chooses to start or re-start international air services, the costs incurred by the MPI and New Zealand Customs to establish a traveller processing capacity (establishment costs) and the processing of travellers (operating costs) can be recovered from the airport." Mr Hoggard said cost recovery for establishing or re-establishing international flights was "reasonable" as "the benefits from these flights are received by the airport and those who use the airport".
Scoop
an hour ago
- Scoop
Foodstuffs Keep Inflation Below Average As Meat And Dairy Increase; Tomatoes Rise On Import Ban
Stats NZ records 4.4% annual food price inflation (FPI) in May 2025 Foodstuffs see retail prices rise 3.2% YOY for their comparable FPI basket of products Global prices continue to drive NZ price increases for butter, cheese, beef and lamb Tomato prices up 30% YOY as ongoing ban on Australian imports impacts overall supply The Foodstuffs grocery co-ops say global prices for dairy and meat are continuing to drive food price inflation in New Zealand while prices for another Kiwi favourite – tomatoes – are up now too due to the current ban on tomato imports from Australia. Stats NZ has today reported a food price inflation (FPI) rate of 4.4% in May 2025, year on year, while the Foodstuff co-ops recorded an average 3.2% for their comparable FPI basket of products. The co-ops have been monitoring inflation at their stores since 2022, based on a basket of goods in the same categories Stats NZ monitors. Key drivers of Foodstuffs' average 3.2% retail price increase in May were butter up 55%, cheese up 32%, beef steak up 25%, and lamb leg roasts up 23%. Foodstuffs NZ Managing Director Chris Quin says butter prices have surged worldwide since late-2023 due to constrained supply and rising demand. 'Fortunately, Foodstuffs' scale means we can keep offering competitive prices throughout the country. Right now we're selling butter at a loss because we're committed to keeping essentials like butter as affordable and accessible as possible for customers. 'Meat is where inflation is being felt more keenly, given most of us eat more of it per day than butter. Beef commodity prices are still near record levels, with high demand for New Zealand exports just as we've seen a decline in the national herd. To bolster supply we're even bringing in a bit more Australian beef but only until local supplies improve in spring.' Foodstuffs also saw a slight rise in the produce category, up 1.5% overall in May (YOY), influenced by increases of 30% for fresh tomatoes and 18% for both cucumbers and kiwifruit. 'Tomatoes are up due to seasonal supply and MPI's ban on Australian imports since brown rugose virus was detected there last year. That's to protect our domestic growers but it does mean supply will be lower until there's more sunlight and warmer temperatures here,' Quin says. 'So while Aussie tomatoes are off the shelves, a bit more Aussie beef is coming in – a reminder that New Zealand often relies on imports to supplement local supply and keep prices down or fill gaps entirely, and why it matters to have NZ-owned grocery retailers with the scale to compete for these products on global markets, if needed. 'That's how Foodstuffs have kept delivering value for customers for over a century, and why our scale will remain critical to keeping everyday items affordable.' Foodstuffs' retail prices were again outpaced by supplier costs, up an average 4.8% for products in the co-ops' FPI basket, year on year. Earlier, Infometrics reported a 2.0% rate for the Grocery Supplier Cost Index, across 60,000 goods the co-ops stock including non-foods. Stats NZ measures FPI by tracking the prices of individual items that make up a representative 'basket'. Foodstuffs NZ measures the prices of a basket of products in the same categories Stats monitors, applying the same weighting and methodology to calculate a year-on-year rate.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Where to next, for the Kiwi economy
business food 9:20 am today Food prices have risen at their highest rate in 18 months, and inflation is heading towards the top of the Reserve Bank's 3 per cent target. So what are the implications for the economy and hopes the Government has for growth? Stats NZ's latest food prices index was up 4.4 per cent on the last year with - meat, poultry and fish the biggest risers for the year. Butter, milk and cheese drove grocery prices - the average price for butter was up 51 per cent over the past year, with cheese up 30 per cent. Kiwibank says the outlook for growth is cloudier than ever - its economist Mary Jo Vergara explains.
