Lawyers got most of £25m to settle legacy cases
The Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) paid out £25m to settle civil cases related to the Troubles in recent years and most of it went to lawyers, the chief constable has told MPs.
Jon Boutcher said lawyers received almost £18m - more than double the amount obtained by victims who brought the claims.
He was giving evidence to the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee.
Mr Boutcher described legacy as "a green field site for lawyers" due to "an attritional approach by all the security agencies around information disclosure".
Mr Boutcher said the PSNI was not properly funded for legacy issues and the costs would pay for the recruitment of hundreds of extra officers.
The PSNI's costs cover not just court cases, but also operating its Legacy Investigations Branch (LIB).
"We are spending just over £20m a year. That would be about 400 police officers," he said.
"But we've been left with this millstone, this anchor, that holds the PSNI back.
"It is a considerable burden on us."
The PSNI is currently dealing with 1,100 civil actions - in 2014 the figure was 150.
The head of its LIB, detective chief superintendent Claire McGuigan, said: "We don't have anywhere near the resources to deal with those, nor the money to settle them.
"We're in a position that is very, very difficult and it doesn't build trust in the community because it looks like we are stalling."
She said the PSNI continues to have "obligations" despite the Legacy Act passing Troubles' cases to a new body, the Independent Commission for Reconciliation and Information Recovery (ICRIR).
The former Police Ombudsman, Nuala O'Loan, also gave evidence to the committee.
She told the committee it was unreasonable to expect the PSNI to use "today's budget to fund yesterday's cases".
"The government really need to be ready to set aside a specific budget for these matters," she said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Police deploy more officers after Ballymena 'mob violence'
A significant number of extra police officers are being deployed into areas of Northern Ireland affected by two days of violent disorder, police have said. During the violence, the worst of which took place in Ballymena, 32 officers were injured and six people arrested. The disorder began on Monday after a peaceful protest over an alleged sexual assault in the County Antrim town. Assistant Chief Constable Ryan Henderson said the violence was "racist thuggery targeted at ethnic minorities and police officers". The constable said all footage of incidents was being reviewed and prosecutions would come. Police Scotland has agreed to a request to send officers, after police in Northern Ireland requested extra support under mutual aid arrangements. The deployment will involve an undisclosed number of public order officers trained to police civil unrest. The PSNI said they have requested 80 officers in Great Britain. "We're taking steps to increase available resources and are surging a significant number of extra officers, vehicles and equipment to those areas where the rioting is taking place," he said. Analysis: How a peaceful protest descended into hate-filled violence "This will have an impact on our communities. This will take away vital resources needed to police other areas. It will have an impact on our ability to serve communities," he added. "It's hugely important that people realise there are consequences for this." The first protest was organised hours after two teenage boys appeared before Coleraine Magistrates' Court. They spoke through an interpreter in Romanian to confirm their names and ages. Their solicitor said they would be denying the charges. ACC Henderson said many people woke up on Wednesday "feeling genuine fear for their lives and their livelihoods". "This violence only serves to undermine the criminal investigation and cause further distress and turmoil to a young victim and her family," he said. "This violence threatens to derail the very pursuit of justice it claims to challenge." Police said there have also been sporadic incidents of disorder in Carrickfergus, north Belfast and Newtownabbey, where one man was arrested. Homes in north Belfast were damaged with windows smashed on Tuesday night and a number of vehicles were set on fire. The PSNI said the incidents are being treated as racially-motivated hate crimes. One man, 29, has been charged with riotous behaviour, disorderly behaviour, attempted criminal damage and resisting police after Monday's violence. The worst of the disorder took place in Ballymena, mainly in the Clonavon Terrace area. Police officers came under sustained attack over a number of hours with multiple petrol bombs, heavy masonry, bricks and fireworks thrown in their direction. ACC Henderson said "the power of social media" is "galvanising" some of the violent behaviour. "We have seen a number of calls over social media for protest activity this evening at various places within Northern Ireland," he said. The constable added that he is "absolutely alert" that "we could see more tonight", but added that "at this stage it's too early to judge". ACC Henderson also said that it is "absolutely of note" that petrol bombs and masonry were thrown at police during Monday and Tuesday night. "There were people who were intent on violence right from the off, so that says to me that there was pre-planning involved from those who wanted to attack us." "A number of other protests, attacks on homes and disorder took place in Belfast Lisburn, Coleraine, Carrickfergus and Newtownabbey," he said. Authorised officers discharged a number of Attenuating Energy Projectiles (AEPs) and a water cannon was also deployed in an attempt to disperse the crowds. Some homes have begun displaying stickers outlining the residents' nationalities. Signs which read "British household" and "Filipino lives here" could be seen on some doors. Businesses and homes were attacked and damaged and a number of vehicles were also set on fire in the area. Some homes in Ballymena began to display stickers outlining the residents' nationalities. Signs which read "British household" and "Filipino lives here" could be seen on some doors. A clean-up operation commenced on Wednesday, with debris and burning items being cleared from the roads. Scorch marks and melted bins could be seen on the streets. Mother-of-two Mika Kolev, who lives and works in Ballymena, said she was now fleeing her home with her family and is considering moving back to Bulgaria after her house was damaged in Tuesday's disorder. "We know what's going to happen so it's not possible to wait and see what's going to happen," she said. "I have to save my children, I have to save them." The family was in the process of moving following Monday night's violence. Mika said she watched her home being attacked on social media by "angry children". "This is my house, I pay rent. I feel like this is my country, this is my city. My daughter was born here. It's very scary." Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer said he "utterly condemns" the violence. First Minister Michelle O'Neill said what was happening in Ballymena was "pure racism, there's no other way to dress it up". Meanwhile, the Deputy First Minister Emma Little-Pengelly said the violence was "serving no purpose whatsoever" and was only damaging communities. The PSNI Chief Constable Jon Boutcher described the disorder as "mindless violence". "These criminal acts not only endanger lives but also risk undermining the ongoing criminal justice process led by the PSNI in support of a victim who deserves truth, justice, and protection."
Yahoo
7 hours ago
- Yahoo
Police condemn "hate-fueled acts and mob rule" in Northern Ireland unrest
London — Hundreds of masked demonstrators attacked officers during a second night of "rioting and disorder" in the Northern Ireland town of Ballymena on Tuesday, injuring 17 officers, according to police. The Northern Ireland police condemned the unrest on Wednesday, saying 32 officers had been injured in total since the disorder — reportedly an explosion of simmering racial tension — was sparked by an alleged sexual assault in the town. "The mindless violence witnessed over the past two nights in Ballymena is deeply concerning and utterly unacceptable," Chief Constable Jon Boutcher said in a statement. "Hate-fueled acts and mob rule do nothing but tear at the fabric of our society. They resolve nothing and serve no one." At least five people were arrested overnight, as four houses were damaged by fire and demonstrators smashed windows of homes and businesses, according to CBS News' partner network BBC News. "Police officers came under sustained attack over a number of hours with multiple petrol bombs, heavy masonry, bricks and fireworks in their direction," the Police Service of Northern Ireland said in a statement. The protests began just hours after two 14-year-old boys appeared in a court Monday over the alleged sexual assault of a teenage girl in the town. BBC News said the boys had communicated through a Romanian interpreter. Ballymena has a large immigrant population, according to AFP news agency. Residents described the violence as "terrifying" and told AFP that "foreigners" were being targeted. A Romanian resident in Ballymena told the Irish Times newspaper on Tuesday that she had put a British flag on her front window to avoid being targeted. Northern Ireland lawmaker Paul Frew told BBC Radio that he feared the violence could turn deadly, saying tension in the town had been rising for a while, and people were "frightened about illegal immigration." There has been no confirmed information about the immigration status of the teenagers who appeared in court on Monday. LAPD chief speaks out about deployment of military forces to anti-ICE protests Can Trump deploy National Guard without governor's approval? Trump's $134 million deployment draws scrutiny
Yahoo
7 hours ago
- Yahoo
Watch: Rioters burn down house live on TikTok
Credit: TikTok Rioters livestreamed themselves burning down a house on TikTok during a second night of racially motivated disorder in Northern Ireland. Violence first erupted in Ballymena, County Antrim on Monday after two 14-year-old boys, thought to be Romanian, were charged with the attempted rape of a young girl. The violence continued on Tuesday night, with rioters attacking police with petrol bombs, masonry and fireworks, as well as targeting properties they believed belonged to foreigners. Video footage obtained by The Telegraph shows a group of balaclava-clad men laughing in front of a house on Queen Street that had been set alight after being broken into. The person filming asks for likes, follows and 'gifts' while livestreaming on TikTok before someone is heard to say they will 'smash a window for a gift'. At one point, the person streaming the incident says 'rack them gifts up, boys' and 'I've got 2.6k views lad'. TikTok gifts can be converted into cash and are a way of allowing users to monetise their video content. In the footage, dozens of masked men are seen standing in front of the burning house as others break down wooden pallets and add them to the fire raging in the doorway. As the fire continues to grow, someone says, 'this doesn't seem real', before rioters kick down the door of the neighbouring house and can be heard shouting for anyone inside to come out. When no one emerges, someone says: 'They're probably P----, that's why they're f---ing away running upstairs'. They then enter the house to search for anyone who might be hiding inside before retreating to the street after apparently finding it empty. Credit: Kevin Scott/Belfast Telegraph Police officers came under 'sustained attack' from multiple petrol bombs, heavy masonry, bricks and fireworks over a number of hours. A water cannon and rubber bullets were used against the rioters to contain the 'serious disorder', which was condemned as 'racist thuggery' by police. A spokesman for the Police Service of Northern Ireland said: 'During the course of the serious disorder in Ballymena, authorised officers discharged a number of Attenuating Energy Projectiles and the water cannon was also deployed in an attempt to disperse the crowds. 'Businesses and homes were attacked and damaged, and a number of vehicles were also set on fire in the area.' In total, 33 officers have been injured in the violence, with some requiring hospital treatment. The force said five people had been arrested on suspicion of riotous behaviour and remain in police custody. One man was also arrested on suspicion of disorderly behaviour on O'Neill Road in Newtownabbey. Speaking in the Commons on Wednesday, Sir Keir Starmer told MPs: 'I utterly condemn the violence that we have seen overnight in Ballymena and in other parts of Northern Ireland.' Jon Boutcher, the Police Service of Northern Ireland Chief Constable, said the 'mindless violence' was deeply concerning and unacceptable. 'These criminal acts not only endanger lives but also risk undermining the ongoing criminal justice process led by the PSNI in support of a victim who deserves truth, justice and protection,' he said. 'Ironically, and frustratingly, this violence threatens to derail the very pursuit of justice it claims to challenge.' The Police Federation for Northern Ireland said its officers were working in conditions that were 'downright dangerous'. Liam Kelly, the chairman, said officers 'cannot continue to be exposed to unnecessary risk or extended frontline duties'. He said attacks on innocent people and police officers are 'reprehensible'. He added: 'There should be no place in this society for violent thugs and racists to blatantly disregard the rule of law, intimidate and terrorise people out of their homes and criminally attack both persons and property. 'I would directly appeal to the right-minded public to condemn these actions and provide PSNI with the information that will assist in identifying the perpetrators so they can rightly be put before the courts.' Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
