Spain prosecutors appeal ‘irrational' Dani Alves rape conviction reversal
Brazilian former footballer Dani Alves leaving with his lawyer Ines Guardiola after picking up his passport, following the top court in Spain's Catalonia region overturning his rape conviction on April 4. PHOTO: REUTERS
– Spanish prosecutors on May 7 said they were appealing at the Supreme Court the 'irrational' reversal of former Brazil and Barcelona star Dani Alves' rape conviction, alleging it 'morally convicted' the accuser by questioning her honesty.
Alves was sentenced to four-and-a-half years in jail in February 2024 after being found guilty of raping a young woman in the VIP bathroom of a Barcelona nightclub on Dec 31, 2022.
However, a Barcelona appeals court overturned the lower court's ruling on March 28, outraging feminist groups and some members of Spain's left-wing government.
It said the trial had inconsistencies and contradictions, and that there was insufficient evidence to prove the guilt of Alves, who had always maintained the sexual relations were consensual.
In a written submission seen by AFP on May 7, the public prosecutor's office criticised a 'thoughtless and irrational assessment' of some of the evidence by the court.
The court's conclusions are 'completely wrong and irrational, even arbitrary', especially regarding the claimed disparity between the victim's account and her behaviour captured on camera, the prosecutors wrote.
'It would appear to recover the medieval assumption of 'the women who agrees to get drunk with a man consents to everything'. That is not the case, she only agrees to get drunk,' they added.
The prosecutors also spoke of the 'cruel' situation for the young woman, 'who is morally convicted and made untrustworthy'.
Alves was jailed from his arrest in January 2023 until March 2024, when he was released pending his appeal after he posted the €1 million (S$1.46 million) bail set by the courts.
The former right-back was a core member of an all-conquering Barcelona team, claiming three Champions League crowns and six La Liga titles with the Catalan giants. His glittering career also saw him win league titles with Juventus and Paris Saint-Germain as well as 126 caps for Brazil. AFP
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
35 minutes ago
- Straits Times
Japan residents with foreign roots raise voices over racial profiling
Mr Syed Zain (middle) who filed a lawsuit against the national and local governments over alleged illegal questioning by police based on racial profiling. PHOTO: REUTERS TOKYO - Residents in Japan with foreign roots have started speaking out about being subjected to racial profiling by police, with some taking the issue to court, but supporters of their efforts warn that progress may be slow given apparent public indifference. Although a survey suggests racial profiling, or questioning by the authorities on the assumption that one is involved in a crime based on race or appearance, has been carried out for years, only recently has the issue been publicly exposed in Japan. 'I am not saying Japanese police should not question citizens, including those with foreign appearance, whatsoever but I want to know the logic behind it,' said Mr Zain Syed, a 27-year-old naturalised Japanese citizen. Born to Pakistani parents, Mr Syed has been stopped by police on the street at least 15 times. Mr Syed said that whenever he had challenged officers on their reasons for stopping him, they insisted he was being treated no differently to anyone else. But convinced that he had been targeted solely based on his ethnicity, he decided to join a lawsuit. The idea behind resorting to legal action is to pressure the government to prevent discriminatory interrogations. Mr Syed, who is self-employed and lives in the suburbs of Nagoya in central Japan, is one of three male plaintiffs in a civil suit filed in January 2024 against the Aichi prefectural police, Tokyo metropolitan police and the state, seeking 3.3 million yen (S$29,300) in damages per person. The response to his Twitter post in 2019 describing police treatment, such as being asked persistently to present a foreign resident's card or passport despite identifying himself as a Japanese, also emboldened him to sue and help others in a similar or worse situation than him. 'I am trying to make Japanese society better by stopping questioning based on prejudice. There are many people like myself with foreign roots who are willing to make contributions to Japan,' said Mr Syed, who came to Japan as an eight-year-old from Pakistan along with his parents and received Japanese nationality at the age of 13. But his acquisition of citizenship is a rare step in Japan, a country whose naturalised citizens accounted for less than 0.01 per cent of the total population in 2024. A recent survey carried out by lawyers in the suit backs the plaintiffs' view that the stopping and questioning of those with foreign appearances often lacks the existence of 'sufficient probable cause' to suspect the person has committed or is about to commit a crime – the requirements set out under the Police Duties Execution Act. The survey, released in February 2025, found that over 71 per cent of foreign nationals in Japan had been questioned by police on the streets in the past five years, a rate around 5.6-fold higher than for Japanese. The questionnaire, the first of its kind comparing police questioning of foreign nationals and Japanese, drew answers from 521 Japanese and 422 foreigners who have lived in Japan for five years or more, excluding those from the Northeast Asian region apparently due to their similar appearances to Japanese. The difference in the frequency of being targeted for street questioning came despite the crime rate between Japanese and foreigners being roughly the same, the lawyers said, citing an analysis using official government data. According to Justice Ministry statistics, out of 182,582 people in Japan investigated by the police in 2020 for suspected Penal Code offenses, 9,529 were foreigners. With the total population in the country, including foreigners, in that year standing at 123.35 million and non-Japanese at 6.34 million, the ratio of people subjected to criminal probes was 0.15 per cent for both Japanese and foreigners in Japan, the analysis showed. In January 2021, advocacy group Japan for Black Lives posted on social media a video which showed a police officer saying 'in our experience many people with dreadlocks carry drugs' when questioning a mixed-race man at a station in Tokyo. The post became viral. The group's founder, Ms Naomi Kawahara, said she could not just stand by to watch her friend being subjected to groundless questioning just because of his appearance. She added the recorded incident is only one among many experienced by her friend and other foreign-born acquaintances. That December, the US Embassy in Japan tweeted a warning to US citizens about foreigners being stopped and searched by Japanese police in suspected racial profiling incidents. The National Police Agency issued an advisory the same month to all prefectural police forces to avoid questioning people in a way that could be perceived as racially motivated. The written advisory read that when choosing who to stop and question, police officers 'should not base their decisions solely on how they look, such as appearance and clothing.' In November 2022, the agency's first-ever internal survey on the issue of racial profiling confirmed six inappropriate cases across four prefectural police forces in 2021, involving officers who stopped people giving reasons such as 'It is rare for a foreigner to drive a car' or 'People with dreadlocks have possessed drugs.' In a move to enhance transparency of police questionings, police officers have started wearing body cameras on a trial basis to record interrogations in public spaces. Mr Maurice Shelton, an African American man from Georgia who wears his hair in dreads and is another plaintiff in the suit, recounted how he had been interrogated by police at least 17 times since first coming to Japan in 2010. 'Just because you look a certain way, does that mean you can be stopped randomly by the police?' the 42-year-old CEO of a personal training gym in Kanagawa Prefecture said. 'Is that something that I should have to deal with because I'm a foreigner, or because I'm a black person, or because I have darker skin, or because I have this hair?' He cited as one of his motivations to join the suit the similar treatment he said he experienced in Georgia and which made him leave his country. 'I've been harassed by the police in America. I've had guns pulled on me by the police,' he said. 'I don't want Japan to be such a place.' Mr Motoki Taniguchi, one of the lawyers representing the three plaintiffs, said in one court hearing, 'Racial profiling is intentional racial discrimination exercised by public authorities and constitutes the most pernicious form of discrimination.' 'It is the responsibility of the court to confirm the illegality of such a practice and to put an end to it,' Mr Taniguchi said. Prospects for change, however, were muddied recently by comments by the justice minister when explaining a step to introduce pre-arrival screening for visa-free travelers from fiscal 2028 and other measures to strengthen the immigration system. 'The government is being strongly urged to take action as public anxiety is growing against foreigners not following rules,' Justice Minister Keisuke Suzuki said last month, in comments that were viewed as potentially encouraging discriminatory attitudes. According to Japan for Black Lives' Ms Kawahara, the recent surge in inbound travelers and the growing discussion of 'overtourism' issues, such as problematic behavior by a small minority of visitors, is likely stirring a public she says is largely ignorant of prejudice issues to accept tight surveillance over people with foreign appearances. 'Some people say casually that the victims claiming they have been discriminated against are just being paranoid or that they don't see a problem in the police stopping foreigners on the street,' she said. 'They say, 'Why not let police stop you if you don't have anything to hide',' Ms Kawahara said. KYODO NEWS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
With shades of Man United, Urawa Reds vow to bring the noise at Club World Cup
Despite having been crowned Asian champions three times, Urawa have only won the domestic J. League once, in 2006. PHOTO: AFP With shades of Man United, Urawa Reds vow to bring the noise at Club World Cup SAITAMA – Their raucous fans are the self-styled bad boys of Japanese football and the team's red shirts, white shorts and black socks bear more than a passing resemblance to Manchester United. But while the fallen English giants won't be at the Club World Cup, Urawa Reds will and are set to be roared on in the United States by more than 5,000 followers. Japan's best-supported club face Inter Milan, River Plate and Monterrey in the opening round when the revamped competition starts on June 14. Urawa is a nondescript suburb about an hour north of Tokyo and the team have been known to draw crowds of over 50,000 to their Saitama Stadium home. Crowd trouble is extremely rare in Japan but Urawa were banned from last season's domestic cup after 'ultra' supporters ripped down barriers and threatened opposition fans. In 2014 they were forced to play a game behind closed doors after fans displayed a racist banner. Supporters say they are misunderstood and are looking forward to hoisting their flags and belting out their songs in front of a global audience. 'People who aren't really interested in football think that we're scary people, but I always tell them that's not true,' Urawa fan Kakeru Inoue said. 'I often bring workmates to games to show them what it's really like.' Urawa began life as Mitsubishi's company team and their official name of Urawa Red Diamonds is a nod to the industrial behemoth's corporate logo. They were originally called Mitsubishi Urawa Football Club, or MUFC, another link to the Premier League side. Despite having been crowned Asian champions three times, Urawa have only won the domestic J. League once, in 2006. But they have appeared at the Club World Cup three times, most recently losing 3-0 to Manchester City in the semi-finals in 2023. Veteran goalkeeper Shusaku Nishikawa says they are proud to be the only Japanese team at the inaugural 32-team Club World Cup. 'The competition will get a lot of attention from around the world and it has a big meaning for us,' he said. 'Who knows whether a Japanese team will play in it again because you need to become Asian champions to earn that right.' The club's achievements have at times been overshadowed by their fans, who hung a banner reading 'Japanese only' over an entrance to the stands before a 2014 game. The incident earned Urawa the dubious distinction of becoming the first Japanese club to be ordered to play a game behind closed doors. One Urawa fan who has attended games since the J. League began said the club were 'all about ultra culture'. 'That's something you can only get in Urawa,' said the supporter, who gave his name only as Nakaji. 'No other club can match us.' Urawa are coached by Poland's Maciej Skorza, who is back for a second spell after leading the club to the Asian Champions League title in 2023. The Club World Cup is being played in the middle of the J. League season, which runs from February to December. Urawa have made a strong start to their domestic campaign and look poised to challenge for the title, having finished 13th last season. Norwegian defender Marius Hoibraten says the Club World Cup is 'a motivation rather than a distraction'. 'Being able to meet the best teams from other countries is a nice experience for us, everyone is buzzing,' said the 30-year-old, one of the few non-Japanese players in Urawa's squad. 'It's a little bit of unknown water. Everyone is really looking forward to it.' AFP Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
Fifa's Club World Cup finally faces the ultimate test
Workers install the natural grass which will serve as the pitch for the FIFA Club World Cub matches. PHOTO: EPA-EFE MIAMI – With an eye-watering US$1 billion (S$1.3 billion) in prize money, some of the biggest stars in the game and clubs competing from across the globe, Fifa's new Club World Cup has all the ingredients to be a huge event. But the 32-team tournament, which will be played across the USA from June 14 to July 13, has faced criticism and scepticism since the moment Fifa president Gianni Infantino began to float the idea. As a completely new arrival in an already crowded football landscape, it remains to be seen whether the competition proves able to carve out a regular place in the calendar. Players representatives, such as global union FIFPRO, have warned of excessive workload on players while others have questioned whether fans will turn out in big enough numbers for the group-stage fixtures. 'Players will have to perform at the end of an 11-month season with little prospect of getting enough rest before the following season starts,' FIFPRO warned when Fifa formally announced the tournament in 2023. Certainly the event adds to an already busy schedule for the world's top players. Inter Milan's Marcus Thuram and Paris Saint-Germain's Desire Doue both played in the Champions League final on May 31 and then switched shirts to represent their country in the Nations League finals in Germany days later. They have since rejoined their clubs for the new Fifa tournament in which both sides are expected to advance to the latter stages. Those games late in the tournament, likely to feature the top European clubs against the best South American sides, should draw big crowds but it remains to be seen how well ticket sales go for the group-stage games with less globally famous clubs from Asia, North America and Africa included. Fixtures such as the June 17 encounter in Orlando between South Korean club Ulsan HD and South Africa's Mamelodi Sundowns will certainly require all the power of American marketing to attract a full house. But Fifa hopes that with broadcasters DAZN offering free streaming of the tournament and the lure of giant club and player brands, fans around the world will be captivated by the new competition. 'We are talking about something never seen before (that will) bring the magic of a national team World Cup to the club level,' Infantino said. 'This tournament will be the beginning of something historic, something that will change our sport for the better and for all future generations who will come to love it as we do.' In an era when players drive interest as much as, if not more than clubs, the involvement of stars such as Lionel Messi, Harry Kane and Kylian Mbappe should ensure social media is buzzing. Twelve of the 32 teams come from Europe including freshly crowned Champions League winners PSG, the continent's most successful club Real Madrid, Premier League giants Manchester City and Chelsea, and German powerhouses Bayern Munich. South America's six teams are made up of four Brazilian clubs, along with Argentina's two biggest clubs River Plate and Boca Juniors. Adding local interest, there are three teams from Major League Soccer – Los Angeles FC, the Seattle Sounders and Messi's Inter Miami, as well as a pair of clubs from Mexico in Pachuca and Monterrey. Four clubs represent Africa, including Egypt's storied Al Ahly who open the tournament against Messi and Miami on June 14, while Asia's quartet includes Saudi club Al-Hilal. American fans regularly snaffle up tickets for the big European teams who come to NFL stadiums to play pre-season friendly games and so the added competitive element should see healthy crowds for the headline performers. Questions over how seriously the clubs would take the new competition became somewhat muted after Fifa announced the huge prize fund. The billion dollars are split between participation fees for all clubs and the rewards for those going deep in the tournament. The winner could leave with as much as US$125 million. Fifa's current plan is for the tournament to be held every four years but it will be interesting to see if that changes after the first test of its appeal. If it is a flop, the critics will likely re-appear and question whether it is needed at all but should it be a roaring success, it is not hard to imagine some at Fifa pushing for it to be held on a more regular basis. AFP Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
