Class action on birth alerts gets green light against Ontario, but faces hurdles
A class-action lawsuit that hopes to help pregnant mothers who were red-flagged and had their newborns taken away by child welfare agencies has been certified to proceed against the Ontario government — but it's only a partial win for the plaintiffs.
Part of the lawsuit — to hold 49 children's aid societies (CAS) across the province accountable for those "birth alerts" — failed to get the green light from an Ontario Superior Court judge.
It's taken three years for the proposed class action to reach this certification ruling — a step necessary before a group lawsuit can proceed to trial. Now, a lawyer representing the plaintiffs says appealing the court's decision could delay justice for parents a bit longer.
Birth alerts are notifications that child welfare agencies issued to hospitals about pregnant people they deemed "high-risk." In turn, health-care providers were required to alert welfare authorities when the subject came to seek medical care or deliver their baby.
The alerts led to newborns being taken from their parents for days, months or even years. Critics have called them unconstitutional and illegal.
The Ontario government issued a directive in 2020 to end the practice, following several other provinces and territories, saying the alerts disproportionately affected Indigenous and racialized mothers.
I'm not fighting this alone. - Neecha Dupuis, Ottawa mom
Co-plaintiff G.G., whose identity is protected under a publication ban, said she's seeking "due justice" for Indigenous women like her who've been traumatized by birth alerts.
She learned in 2016 that Native Child and Family Services Toronto issued a birth alert while she was pregnant with her third child, and said she felt pressured to undergo invasive testing and mental health assessment. Workers later amended the birth alert after finding no grounds to apprehend her newborn, her claim states.
"I want there to be justice and accountability," G.G. told CBC News. "Indigenous mothers and families have the severe impacts of birth alerts that continue to this day."
Neecha Dupuis, who was the subject of a birth alert at an Ottawa hospital, sat in the virtual courtroom in April as the certification hearing took place.
"It widened my view as to how far and how deep CAS has harmed all these people," said Dupuis, who's Anishinaabe. "It's so emotional, it really is, because … I'm not fighting this alone."
Appeal to follow 'strong' ruling: lawyer
This week, co-counsel for the plaintiffs Tina Yang said her team is planning to appeal the judge's decision to not certify the action against the children's aid societies.
"It's a strong ruling with regard to Ontario ... [but] obviously, disappointment with regard to the denial of certification against the children's aid societies," said Yang, with Goldblatt Partners LLP, in reaction to the decision.
Yang said the class action in Ontario is the first among similar claims in B.C., Saskatchewan and Manitoba to reach certification.
"It's such an important cause to be litigated," said Yang. "It's not just compensation. It's about recognition of what happened, vindication of those rights ... and that hopefully ... there's a commitment to making sure that something like this never happens again."
The Ontario Ministry of Children, Community and Social Services forwarded CBC's request to the attorney general, which said in an email it would be inappropriate to comment within the appeal period.
The lawyers representing the 49 children's aids societies also declined, citing the same reason.
The appeal period ends Friday. Should there be appeals from any parties, the matter will then go through the Ontario Court of Appeal before the class action could move forward, explained Yang.
CASs did not act 'in unison': motion
"Birth alerts were illegal and discriminatory," the statement of claim states, especially as they targeted unborn children.
The plaintiffs' lawyers had pointed out that child protection agencies "have no jurisdiction to act in protection of, or, by extension, to require warnings in respect of, the unborn," according to the certification motion, citing a 1997 Supreme Court decision.
The claim alleges the provincial government was negligent and breached sections of the Charter of Right and Freedoms, and argues "for years the Ministry failed to end what was within its knowledge a wrongful and harmful practice."
However the judge found the claims against the 49 children's aid societies — conspiracy, negligence, intrusion, misfeasance in public office and breach of the same charter rights — failed to pass the test for class actions in the province.
"The relationship between the 49 CAS Defendants is non-hierarchical. They are separate, distinct, and equivalent entities," the judge wrote.
For instance, the owner of a Toyota with bad transmission can't sue Honda, even if Honda's transmissions are just as bad, the motion explains.
"Since the CAS Defendants are independent actors, they cannot be liable in unison regardless of whether Birth Alerts were wrongful or rightful."
Yang wants to stress that the denial "was not a rejection of the validity" of most of the plaintiffs' claims, "but rather a reflection of the technical class-action rules."
"We still believe strongly in this case," she said.
Yang added her team is exploring options suggested by the judge, such as bringing a class-action against individual children's aid societies, though that would mean finding dozens of additional plaintiffs.
G.G. said she's proud the legal team is pursuing the appeal.
"This class-action lawsuit places responsibilities on each and every one of the children's aid societies of the unconstitutional and racist behaviour of opening files on Indigenous pregnant persons," she said.
"And that's wrong, and that's not what truth and reconciliation looks like."
Ottawa mom hopeful
Since sharing her story with CBC in 2022, Dupuis obtained hospital records through a freedom of information request that show child protection workers sent alerts to The Ottawa Hospital where she gave birth to her son in July 2011.
"This [social worker] received three voicemail messages over the weekend concerning CAS alerts on this patient," read the hospital worker's notes from that July, which were shared with CBC.
That's why Dupuis says she supports the appeal against the children's aid societies, no matter how long it takes.
"They need to be held accountable for what they did to my family," she said. "If we made it halfway, that's better than no way."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
Brothers who gave $50K for palliative care room at nursing home learn tough lesson
Social Sharing The moment brothers Alan and Glenn von Weiler saw the palliative care room at their father's former nursing home — created in his memory — was one for the books, they say. "I think my dad would have been so happy," Glenn said. "My dad believed in giving back to the community. He did that all his life, and now he was able to do it posthumously." But just over a year after they saw the new palliative care room at the Fundy Nursing Home in Blacks Harbour, the brothers have a sour taste in their mouths. They learned from staff at the home that the room has been taken apart. In December 2022, Alan and Glenn's father, Joost, died after living at the home for a while. Shortly before his death, the brothers were so pleased with the care he had received from staff that they decided to make a $50,000 donation to the Fundy Nursing Home. The brothers, who live in Saint John, about 70 kilometres east of the home, spoke with the administrator at the time and ultimately decided on a palliative care room. The money would go into a trust set aside for the room. "It's life-changing for the families, so, you know, they deserve respect — they're not numbers, they're people," Alan said. The largest expenses for the project were the $15,000 in renovations that had to be done and the specialized palliative care bed, which cost about $15,300. Other features of the room included a pull-down, or Murphy bed, kitchenette items, and a heat pump. A shadowbox with their father's photo, a biography, and some of the paintings he did during his life were also added. WATCH | How much do a donor's wishes actually matter? Saint John brothers share cautionary donation story 3 hours ago Duration 3:26 On March 7, 2024, the palliative care room opened, with the von Weiler brothers in attendance. Not only did the room have everything a family could need for loved ones at the end of their lives, they said, but it also had a homey atmosphere that didn't come with regular rooms for residents. But recently, the von Weilers were informed by staff that the room had been disassembled — something the brothers never expected. "The enthusiasm from the staff was phenomenal," Alan said of the palliative care room. "How could I ever think that someone would go in and just take it apart?" The von Weilers wanted to get official confirmation of the dismantling, so they contacted Constance Gilman, the current administrator for the nursing home. In response, they received a letter, which they shared with CBC News. "I would like to apologize to your family about the misinformation that was shared with you, and would like to take the time to explain to you what the home plans to do to ensure that this important service is still in place and that your donation is not forgotten," Gillman wrote. She went on to say that the palliative care bed was being used for a non-palliative care resident because it was more comfortable for that person. "But the problem is, if you have someone coming up that needs a palliative care bed … that bed's not going to be available," Alan said. Because you can't remove a patient from a bed so another one can take the bed. He said the bed, with a special mattress to prevent bed sores, was specifically for palliative residents. Gilman's letter said that to avoid causing discomfort, the home didn't want to transfer a palliative care resident to the new bed. Brothers understand move She also said the palliative care room had been moved to another location with a wider doorway, so resident beds could be rolled into it. The room was now closer to the nursing desk to "minimize the risk" of a resident being "forgotten," she said. The brothers said the former administrator chose a location a little removed from the general traffic area to provide more privacy for families. But even so, Glenn said, he understands that patient health has to come first and moving the room was understandable, if it had the same fixtures as the previous one. Gilman's letter said the kitchenette items would be moved to the new space, but the Murphy bed was broken, so if families wanted to stay overnight, a sleeper chair could be rolled in. The art and the memoriam shadowbox would be put back as well, the letter said. After reading the letter, the von Weilers asked to see the new room. "It was basically an empty room with a recliner in it and a small little kitchenette," Glenn said. "If someone needed a palliative care room that day, it was not available. "I don't think that you should shut something down without opening up the new one." CBC News requested an interview with Gilman but did not receive a response. The von Weilers are still grateful for the care their father received while at the nursing home, but this experience makes them think they would have chosen a different location to donate to, had they known what was going to happen. They wonder if anything would have been different if they'd had a written contract outlining the request. The agreement with the home was a verbal one, aside from a receipt from the home that said, "Donation to memorial fund palliative care room." But legally speaking, there isn't anything that can be done in this situation, according to Toronto business lawyer Jonathan Kleiman. A promise to do something specific with the donated money could be enforceable, he said, but without a proper contract, it's a flippant promise. And even with a proper written agreement, Kleiman said, it's unlikely the contract would have specified a specific length of time that the room had to remain. "I find it very hard to believe that the nursing home meant to offer anything in perpetuity," Kleiman said. "So all the more reason to have something in writing, so you understand what you guys are getting, and there's no misunderstandings." The von Weilers believe this situation will make them more careful with future donations. They'll ask more questions and get things in writing. One of the most upsetting parts of the experience for the von Weilers was how they found out — from a staff member and not management. "I think it's just respect," Glenn said. "If you have people in the community investing in the community, I think that they deserve to know what's going on."
CBC
3 hours ago
- CBC
Alberta babies have been born with measles due to outbreaks, worrying doctors
Social Sharing As the province's measles case count approaches 1,000, health experts are raising the alarm about Alberta babies who are being born already infected with the virus. The provincial government has confirmed cases of congenital measles, which can lead to severe complications, including death, have already occurred as a result of this year's outbreaks. Pregnant Albertans are also testing positive. "Fewer than five cases of congenital measles have been reported in Alberta in 2025. In each case, the mother was not immunized. Information on whether the infants were born prematurely is not available," an official with Primary and Preventative Health Services said in an email. "To date, there have been 20 confirmed cases of measles in pregnant individuals. Fewer than five have been hospitalized due to the infection." The Alberta government does not publish this information publicly. CBC News asked for the data after Ontario reported a premature baby, born infected with measles, died. That province has reported seven cases of congenital measles since mid-October. When CBC News asked for more detailed data, an official said the province limits the release of information when case numbers are very small for privacy reasons. The data was up-to-date as of June 12. No measles deaths have been reported in Alberta since the outbreaks began this year. As of June 14, a total of 85 Albertans had been hospitalized due to the infection, including 14 intensive care unit admissions. By midday Thursday, the province's total measles case count had climbed to 996. Serious complications Pregnant individuals are at higher risk of complications from measles. "We're extremely concerned about the potential for exposures for unimmunized mothers, in particular during pregnancy, given that there is an increased risk for premature birth and complications that are pretty significant for the mother," said Dr. Amber Reichert, an Edmonton-based neonatologist. "There is an extremely high risk to either pregnancy loss or potentially an early birth or potentially the babies becoming infected as well." A recent editorial in the Canadian Medical Association Journal warned of these serious consequences. Premature birth itself comes with risks, including underdeveloped lungs and babies requiring breathing support. In addition, pregnant people can get very sick from a measles infection, often due to pneumonia. "There is a ten-fold higher risk of death when a person who is pregnant gets measles," said Dr. Eliana Castillo, an obstetrician and clinical associate professor in the department of medicine at the University of Calgary. What is congenital measles Congenital measles occurs when the mother passes the infection along in the final two weeks of pregnancy and the baby is born infected, according to Castillo. It can spark severe complications in the infant, including brain inflammation and even death, according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. "Those babies can be very, very sick," said Castillo. Ontario announced earlier this month that a premature baby born with congenital measles had died. The infant's mother was unimmunized. At the time, health officials said measles was a "significant contributing factor" to the premature death but that the baby also had other serious health problems. In addition to a fever and rash, babies with congenital measles can be born with other symptoms, including inflammation of the liver, physicians are warning. "They potentially could also present with pneumonia or potentially have an infection around the brain, which is called encephalitis," said Reichert. If the baby is born early — and has congenital measles — there is a higher risk of serious lung disease due to the immaturity of their lungs, she added. And beyond the immediate health concerns, there are several potential and serious long-term consequences, including a rare but debilitating neurological illness that manifests years later. Subacute sclerosing panencephalitis is a virus that hides in the brain for years. It eventually flares up, triggering brain inflammation and causing children or young adults to lose the ability to move and speak. In nearly all cases patients die. According to Reichert, the risk of this complication is believed to be higher when a baby is born with measles or is infected early in infancy. "It's a devastating consequence because it really isn't treatable," said Reichert. Babies can also experience immune system impacts that leave them more highly susceptible to illness, Castillo said. A major worry Measles is highly contagious and health officials have warned that given low immunization rates in parts of the province, official case counts are the tip of the iceberg and there are likely more cases going unreported. It's a major worry for physicians. "Everyone is concerned this is going to be happening for months at a time," Castillo said, adding that as case counts rise, so too do the chances that more babies will be infected and potentially face life-altering or life-threatening complications. She's concerned that Albertans don't fully understand the risks that go along with pregnancy and measles. "We have not had a concerted public health response, particularly to raise awareness about how serious it can be for babies and pregnant individuals," she said, adding she's glad the province shared the data it did when requested by CBC News. "But again they're not in the public domain. And that makes it very, very hard because we haven't had the concerted effort to raise awareness … and give people the tools to make decisions." CBC News asked the province if it will publish this information moving forward, but did not hear back prior to publication time. Reichert wants Albertans to understand the risks and she's urging everyone to ensure that they and their children are immunized to protect both themselves and others around them who may not be able to be immunized. Mothers who are immunized pass antibodies on to the fetus during pregnancy, offering protection during a baby's first few months of life. Post-exposure therapy The measles vaccine (MMR) is not generally recommended during pregnancy in Canada. Pregnant Albertans who are unimmunized and have been exposed to measles and infants under six months of age are among the high risk groups who may be offered immune globulin, a short-acting antibody medication that can protect against the virus. It must be given within six days of exposure. According to the province, 52 people have received it including 37 infants since the outbreaks began in March. The province did not say how many of the adults were pregnant. Alberta is also offering an early and extra dose of the measles vaccine to babies as young as six months living in the harder hit south, central and north zones.
CTV News
3 hours ago
- CTV News
Ontario's measles outbreak through the eyes of front-line workers
Emergency department charge nurse David Lambie outside the emergency entrance of the Woodstock General Hospital in Woodstock, Ont., Thursday, May 22, 2025. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Nicole Osborne ST. THOMAS — Health-care workers battling measles in southern Ontario say they think about the outbreak from the moment they wake until the moment they sleep. They say treating and tamping down the surge of a disease most have never seen in their lifetime is constant. Some have even been infected by patients who unwittingly spread the highly infectious illness while seeking help for early but general symptoms — fevers and coughs are common before the telltale rash appears days later. Measles has spread to more than 3,000 people in Canada this year. More than 2,000 of those infected are in Ontario. Here's a look at caregivers on the front lines of an outbreak that has particularly struck a region south and east of London. 'The unlucky ones' Carly Simpson considers herself one of the 'unlucky ones.' Five days after developing a sore throat, body aches and fever, the nurse practitioner gazed at her reflection in the bathroom mirror, stunned to see red splotches all over her body. 'Oh my gosh this is measles,' Simpson gasped. She said measles never crossed her mind when she first fell ill mid-March, suspecting a more likely cause was her autoimmune disease, ankylosing spondylitis, which leads to chronic pain and inflammation. After all, the vast majority of cases had been among the unvaccinated and Simpson said she had been inoculated three times — including a booster in 2015 after a test revealed her previous two shots didn't lend full immunity. Simpson said she had been assured at the beginning of the outbreak that three shots would be enough to protect her. She still got sick and was essentially bedridden for days, only mustering enough energy to walk to the bathroom. But she said the rash only lasted a day and never spread to her husband or kids. 'I had a mild case because I've been vaccinated,' said Simpson, among five per cent of the outbreak's cases to involve vaccinated people. She suspected she was infected by a patient who came to her clinic with virus symptoms a couple of weeks earlier. Early symptoms can seem like other illnesses until the rash appears, leaving health-care workers who examine them vulnerable to exposure. 'Is this just a common cold? Is it just some viral infection?' she said of the questions that dog caregivers. Shawn Cowley was unlucky, too. He noticed white spots inside his cheeks in late April, and then a red blotchy rash on his forehead that migrated down his face, and onto his shoulders and arms. 'Fortunately for me, because I was fully vaccinated I didn't get the full brunt of measles,' he said, explaining that the rash otherwise would have covered his whole body. Still, it took about a week for his body to recover from the exhaustion. Cowley is a key player in measles containment as head of emergency management and preparedness at the local health unit, Southwestern Public Health. His case was traced to his son's hockey tournament. He eventually told his colleagues that he contracted measles but noted there is 'a stigma' associated with the illness. Cowley also felt guilty for going to the grocery store and filling up on gas before he was symptomatic, potentially spreading it to others. 'When you find out you do potentially have measles, and the number of people I've exposed, understanding how virulent measles is, that's a really hard thing to deal with personally because you put other people at risk.' 'Slow burn' Dr. Erica Van Daalen calls the outbreak a 'slow burn' but one that has required close collaboration among local hospitals to safely treat and isolate measles patients. The chief of staff at St. Thomas Elgin General Hospital said she might see one to three patients in the emergency department on an average day, and often they are children. As of late May, three infected pregnant women had delivered babies and 15 kids had been admitted. Those include young patients transferred from hospitals in Woodstock and Tillsonburg, which don't have pediatric units. 'It's a lot of one-on-one bedside nursing,' Van Daalen said in an interview earlier this spring. 'When the days are busy, it wears on the nurses.' Less than seven per cent of Ontario's cases have ended up in hospital. But the logistics of safely admitting a measles patient is like expert-level Tetris. Masked patients are ushered through back doors to negative pressure rooms that keep contaminated air from escaping into other areas of the hospital and infecting more people. The room is sealed and has a system that filters and exchanges the air. Exposure risks are avoided as much as possible, even trips to the bathroom, said Sangavi Thangeswaran, a registered nurse and an infection control practitioner at both Alexandra Hospital Ingersoll and Tillsonburg District Memorial Hospital. 'We ask the patient to stay in there. If they need anything like using the washroom, we try to give them commodes or urinals, just to lessen the exposures,' Thangeswaran said. There are five negative pressure rooms at Woodstock Hospital. When they're full, patients are assessed in the ambulance garage, said David Lambie, a charge nurse in Woodstock's emergency department. It is an extra layer of logistics to navigate, said Lambie, whose hospital has cared for 108 measles patients since January, 55 of them kids. Once a patient is well enough for discharge, their negative pressure room is left empty for half-an-hour while contaminated air is expunged. Then it's deep cleaned for the next patient, said Thangeswaran. She said each of her Oxford County hospitals initially had just one negative pressure room in each emergency department but as cases swelled they created three more. As of June 12, her team had cared for 14 measles patients in Ingersoll and 64 in Tillsonburg. 'Inherent challenge' Van Daalen, of the hospital in St. Thomas, said deciding whether to discharge a kid sick with measles sometimes keeps her up at night. 'You hesitate to send them home because you're not quite sure how they're going to land,' she said. 'There are some later-term consequences for kids who have measles. It's a very rare complication, but we'll have to keep our surveillance up.' Dr. Ninh Tran said he felt like he was approaching burnout in late February. Ontario's weekly case count had nearly doubled to 177 over a two-week period ending Feb. 27, with almost half of the overall cases located in his southwestern public health unit. Pressure was high to trace cases, halt community spread and stop infections. Measles was on his mind every moment of the day and night. 'You could sense a bit of tension and anxiety in all this discussion,' Tran recalled in late May. 'It's always like a temporary feeling of doubt, fear, anxiety when we see numbers go up and there's just a lot of things coming right at you,' Tran said of the outbreak's early days. 'And then you have to step back and say, 'OK, it's not going to be helpful if I get stressed because I need to — and other leaders have to — figure out a way to move forward.' The spread of measles has ebbed and flowed, but Tran noted a steady decline of new cases mid-June. 'While it's still early to confirm a persistent pattern, the consistency of the decrease does suggest a potential shift in the trajectory of the outbreak,' said Tran. 'We are cautiously encouraged.' This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 20, 2025. Canadian Press health coverage receives support through a partnership with the Canadian Medical Association. CP is solely responsible for this content. Hannah Alberga, The Canadian Press
