logo
Italy's top court rules single people can adopt children from abroad

Italy's top court rules single people can adopt children from abroad

Local Italy21-03-2025

"The exclusion of single people from the international adoption of minors is unconstitutional," the court said in a press release summing up the ruling.
The legal case revolved around a 2019 request by a single woman in Florence to legally adopt a child.
Though the original request was denied by a Tuscan court under a 1983 law, the case was forwarded to Italy's Constitutional Court, which was asked to determine whether the woman's rights were being violated.
The Rome court found that the law "disproportionately restricted" the rights of aspiring parents who sought to adopt a child in need of a home.
The court said that the desire to become a parent "falls within the freedom of self-determination of the person and must be taken into account, together with the multiple and primary interests of the minor".
Single people are "suitable to ensure a stable and harmonious environment for a child," it said.
It added that, as is the case with married couples, it is up to a judge "to ascertain in concrete terms the emotional suitability of the aspiring parent and his or her ability to educate, instruct and maintain the child".
That "may also take into account the family network of reference of the aspiring parent".
Alessandro Zan, from the centre-left Democratic Party (PD), described the ruling as "a historic turning point".
"Meloni and her government must recognise once and for all that what matters is love, not marital status," he said.
Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni won the 2022 general election on a campaign stressing the importance traditional family values.
"Let's go further now. This right must also be extended to couples of the same sex. Enough discrimination. Enough prejudice," Zan said.
Experts said the ruling may now be used by single people seeking legal recourse to adopt children within Italy too.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Italian writer first to die under Tuscany's assisted suicide law
Italian writer first to die under Tuscany's assisted suicide law

Local Italy

timea day ago

  • Local Italy

Italian writer first to die under Tuscany's assisted suicide law

Pieroni, who suffered from Parkinson's disease, died at his home on Saturday, May 17th, the pro-euthanasia Luca Coscioni Association said on Wednesday. Pieroni's death came over three months after a landmark right-to-die bill was passed by Tuscany's authorities. The Italian Constitutional Court ruled in September 2019 that assisted suicide was allowed for patients 'kept alive by life-support treatments and suffering from an irreversible condition" as long as the condition caused 'physical and psychological suffering' considered 'intolerable". At the time, the court urged parliament to pass a law to provide a clear legal framework setting out the circumstances in which assisted suicide was possible. But the invitation went unheeded, with multiple consecutive governments sidestepping the issue. This means that patients looking to resort to assisted suicide in Italy often wait years before being granted permission by national health authorities. In February, Tuscany became the first of Italy's 20 regions to set out its own right-to-die rules, streamlining and speeding up the request process. Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni's government is strongly opposed to euthanasia and is currently challenging Tuscany's bill in court. But any court decision on the matter will come too late to affect Pieroni's choice. Born in 1961, the writer had been suffering from Parkinson's disease since 2008 and was forced to use a feeding tube for 21 hours a day, the Luca Coscioni Association said in a statement. Pieroni 'self-administered" a lethal drug in the presence of doctors and his family, it added. The Luca Coscioni Association has called on other regions in the Catholic-majority country to follow Tuscany's lead. "Too many people continue to suffer or emigrate to die with dignity," the association said. "We invite all regions to act to guarantee freedom and respect for people's wishes." Since the 2019 Constitutional Court ruling, eight people have committed medically assisted suicide in Italy. The first was Federico Carboni, 44, from the central Marche region, in June 2022.

Italy's opposition warns of 'democratic crisis' after low referendum turnout
Italy's opposition warns of 'democratic crisis' after low referendum turnout

Local Italy

time2 days ago

  • Local Italy

Italy's opposition warns of 'democratic crisis' after low referendum turnout

The citizenship referendum, along with four others relating to workers' rights held over June 8th and 9th, drew just over 30 percent of the electorate – far lower than the threshold of more than 50 percent required for their results to be valid. Maurizio Landini, leader of Italian trade union CGIL which had promoted the referendums, slammed the low turnout as a sign of a "clear democratic crisis" in Italy. But the result was celebrated as a victory by Italy's hard-right coalition government, which strongly opposed the proposed reforms and had publicly called on its supporters to boycott the vote. "YOU LOST" Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni's Brothers of Italy party posted to Facebook shortly after the results were announced on Monday afternoon, with the letters superimposed over a picture of opposition party leaders who had supported the reforms. Meloni announced last week that she would go to her polling station but not vote in any of the referendums, saying that abstention was 'a right for everyone'. "I don't agree with the subjects of the referendums and, as has always been the case in the nation's history, when you don't agree, abstention is also an option," she said. Of 77 referendums held over the past 50 years, only 39 met the voter threshold, and only four of those were held in the past 30 years. It's unclear how much of an impact the government's abstention campaign had on the turnout in this referendum. Riccardo Magi, leader of the centrist +Europa party, which had campaigned for the citizenship reform, said that "organised abstentionism strengthened by spontaneous abstentionism and lack of information" had won the day. Lorenzo Pregliasco, head of political polling agency Youtrend, told Huffpost Italia that the results showed that the referendum is "a tool in crisis". But there were other factors at play, he warned. "The referendum was politicised, particularly in the last few weeks [...]; the campaign wasn't inclusive of voters who weren't necessarily on the left," he said. "This may have pushed out those voters who were less militant and could have made the difference." It's not uncommon for politicians in Italy to tie support for a referendum to support for their own party – a strategy that's been known to backfire. In 2016, former PM Matteo Renzi was forced to step down after he said that a vote for his referendum on constitutional reform was a vote of confidence in his leadership – and lost. "The only real goal of this referendum was to bring down the Meloni government. In the end, however, it was the Italians who brought you down," Brothers of Italy wrote in the caption to their Facebook post. Meanwhile Elly Schlein, leader of the centre-left Democratic Party, did her best to present the result as a win for the opposition. "More voters voted for these referendums than those who put Meloni in government in 2022," she told reporters on Monday evening. "Politics that celebrates abstention only hurts itself." Following Monday's result, calls for a reform of referendum rules came from both ends of the political spectrum. "We may need to change the referendum law, we probably need more signatures, not least because we spent so much money to send millions of ballots to Italians abroad that went unused,' said Deputy PM Antonio Tajani. Under current rules, if a petition to change the law collects 500,000 signatures, the government must hold a public vote – which was the basis for introducing the referendum on citizenship. Others said the solution wasn't to lower the threshold for staging a referendum but to lower or even eliminate the voter threshold (or quorum). 'We'll need to adopt a different approach" given that 'no referendum has reached the quorum in recent years,' Benevento Mayor Clemente Mastella said. New rules should include the 'lowering of the quorum, which now seems almost impossible to reach,' he added.

Is this the end of the road for Italy's citizenship reform?
Is this the end of the road for Italy's citizenship reform?

Local Italy

time2 days ago

  • Local Italy

Is this the end of the road for Italy's citizenship reform?

It was always a long shot. But many of The Local's readers had their fingers crossed that there might be a chance of a Yes vote in the closely-watched referendum this week on whether Italy should cut the wait for those applying for citizenship through residency. Non-EU nationals must live in Italy for 10 years before they can start the application process, and usually have to wait several more years for it to be processed. The waiting time to apply would have been reduced to five years under the referendum proposal, putting Italy in line with other major European countries including Germany and France. But, as expected, voter turnout was too low, which meant that the referendum result was declared invalid. There's a minimum threshold, or quorum, of 50 percent for the vote to count. Turnout was 30.6 percent, slightly lower than polls predicted. This is nothing unusual in an Italian referendum. Participation has been historically low and falling for decades. As the results came in, there were renewed calls for sweeping changes to the country's referendum laws. There have long been calls for lowering the quorum from 50 to 40 percent, or eliminating it altogether. But, without this threshold, how would the vote have gone? Of the votes cast this time, 65 percent were in favour of changing the law on citizenship. While high enough for a positive result, this was lower than the percentage who voted in favour of the other four referendum questions (on workers' rights), which was 87 to 89 percent, reflecting divided public opinion. The leftwing opposition parties who backed the referendum said that it had sparked public debate on an issue that no one had been talking about. They could, in theory, put similar proposals to parliament in future. However, they'd be unlikely to get far while the ruling coalition government enjoys a majority in both houses. The government is strongly opposed to easing citizenship rules in any way. Senior ministers made it clear ahead of the vote that they didn't want the quorum to be reached, urging voters to 'stay home' or 'go to the beach'. The failure of the referendum was widely reported as a victory for Meloni, who had appeared at a polling station on Sunday to announce to reporters that she would not be voting. Her government's stance shouldn't surprise anyone. In March it abruptly forced through changes to the law on eligibility for Italian citizenship by descent, applying a two-generational limit. Last year, it quashed proposals to extend citizenship to young people who complete their education in Italy. As long as Meloni's government remains in power, any changes that would make the lives of foreign nationals in Italy easier seem a remote possibility. The proposal to cut the waiting period from 10 years to five originally came from Italiani senza cittadinanza (Italians Without Citizenship), a grassroots movement highlighting obstacles faced by would-be applicants. They say they'll continue to campaign on the issue. For those who plan to apply for citizenship via residency in the next few years, the wait continues.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store