Spending review could mean cuts in Wales
Some public services are likely to face cuts if the NHS swallows extra funding announced for Wales in Chancellor Rachel Reeves's spending review, experts have said.
There is a warning that "tough choices loom", even though the budget is expected to grow over the next three years.
Labour said it was investing in public services by boosting the Welsh government's budget.
But Plaid Cymru accused Wales' First Minister Eluned Morgan of "asking for very little and getting exactly that".
The Welsh government can raise taxes, but most of what it spends comes in a grant from the Treasury.
Its funding will be £22.4bn a year on average over the next three years as a result of the spending review.
Key points at a glance from the Spending Review
New stations in £445m 10-year Wales rail plan
Reeves boosts NHS and housing as some budgets squeezed
The Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS), an independent think tank, said funding for the day-to-day running of public services would grow about 1.2% above inflation.
"While an increase overall, that will likely require tough choices and indeed real terms cuts for some services," the IFS's David Phillips said.
"Increases in funding for the Welsh NHS could easily absorb most, if not all, of this increase."
He said Welsh Finance Secretary Mark Drakeford will "have to decide carefully which areas to prioritise and which to cut back".
About half the Welsh government's budget is already spent on healthcare.
Waiting times for hospital treatment have risen to record highs in recent years.
On Wednesday, the chancellor announced a real-terms increase of 3% to day-to-day funding for the NHS in England.
That will result in extra funding for Welsh ministers to spend as they wish.
However, Guto Ifan from the Wales Governance Centre warned: "If the Welsh government decided to transfer that money to the health service in Wales, which would still be below the historical growth in health spending, it would mean difficult settlements for everything else in the budget.
"I would imagine that the Welsh government would have to make cuts to services outside health under this settlement."
Reeves' spending review reveals how much funding will be available after next May's Senedd election.
She also announced £445m for new rail projects in Wales, following years of complaints that Wales has not had a fair share of spending.
She backed plans for five new stations in Cardiff, Newport and Monmouthshire, and rail upgrades in north Wales.
First Minister Eluned Morgan said: "Wales will see significant extra investment in rail infrastructure, coal tips safety and Welsh communities will see real benefits that improve lives and create opportunities."
Treasury minister Torsten Bell said there would be "record levels of spending happening in the Welsh government" and said previous Conservative governments "consistently let down Wales" on capital spending which pays for infrastructure.
Opponents said the cash fell short of what Wales needed and criticised a ten-year timeline for the scheme - Labour sources said most of the cash would be spent much sooner.
Plaid Cymru finance spokesperson, Heledd Fychan, said: "Public services, already teetering on the brink in Wales under Labour face further cuts as a consequence of Labour's First Minister asking for very little and getting exactly that."
Welsh Conservative Senedd leader Darren Millar said the amount of rail funding was "shameful".
"Today's rail spending announcement is an insult to the people of Wales," he added.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
‘Trojan horse' treatment given green light for NHS use
Blood cancer patients in England will be among the first in the world to have access to a new 'Trojan horse' treatment, health officials have announced. The targeted therapy can stop myeloma from progressing by nearly three times as long as existing treatments, studies suggest. It is estimated that around 1,500 patients a year with multiple myeloma – an incurable cancer of the bone marrow – will benefit from the treatment. It comes after the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (Nice) approved belantamab mafodotin, also known as Blenrep and made by GlaxoSmithKline, for NHS use. NHS England said that it is the first health system in the world to roll out the treatment. Officials said that the drug can now be offered to patients whose cancer has progressed or not responded to another first-line treatment. The treatment, which is given as an infusion every three weeks along with other cancer drugs, is a type of antibody drug which targets and attaches to cancer cells. It has been dubbed a 'Trojan horse' treatment because it works by being taken into a cancer cell, before releasing a high concentration of a lethal molecule to destroy the cell from inside. 'Myeloma is an aggressive type of blood cancer, but we have seen a steady improvement in the outlook for patients over recent years as we have introduced new targeted therapies,' Professor Peter Johnson, NHS England's national clinical director for cancer, said. 'I am delighted that patients in England will be the first to benefit from this new treatment, which has the potential to keep cancer at bay for years longer, giving people the chance of more precious time with friends and family. 'This treatment could be life-changing for many patients and their families, and that's why it is so important that the NHS continues to secure quick access to the latest, innovative treatments like this, at affordable prices to the taxpayer.' 🚨 Do you know the key symptoms of #myeloma? 🚨 Help us spread the word by sharing this post! Early diagnosis makes all the difference. If something feels off, don't wait – talk to your GP!#BloodCancerAwarenessMonth @MyelomaUK — DKMS UK | We Delete Blood Cancer (@DKMS_uk) September 6, 2024 Helen Knight, director of medicines evaluation at Nice, said: 'We're delighted that people in the UK will become among the first in the world to access belantamab mafodotin for this indication. 'This recommendation demonstrates our commitment to getting the best care to patients fast, while ensuring value for the taxpayer.' Trials have suggested that the treatment, in combination with bortezomib and dexamethasone, delayed progression of the disease by an average of three years, compared to just over a year for patients taking commonly-used drug daratumumab along with the other treatments. Patient Paul Silvester, 60, from Sheffield, was diagnosed with myeloma in July 2023 and received treatment at the Royal Hallamshire Hospital. The first treatment he was given failed to stop his cancer from progressing so he was given belantamab mafodotin through an early access programme. 'I feel like this treatment has brought the party balloons back in the house. It has been amazing – within the first two or three weeks, after the first dose, I was in remission,' he said. 'It gives me quite a lot of confidence in the drugs and it makes me more optimistic about the future. 'I've been feeling well and I'm still quite active – that's what's important in terms of your quality of life. 'One of my daughters is graduating from university in October and it's a goal for me to be there.' Shelagh McKinlay, director of research and advocacy at blood cancer charity Myeloma UK, said: 'It's fantastic to see the UK at the forefront of myeloma treatment. 'We have been working very hard for the last year to get this treatment approved and we know it will transform the lives of thousands of people with myeloma.' Health Minister Karin Smyth said: 'This groundbreaking therapy puts the NHS at the forefront of cancer innovation. 'By harnessing cutting-edge 'trojan horse' technology, we're offering new hope to blood cancer patients across the country.'
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
'This development is welcome news for Welsh jobs and transport'
The United Kingdom Government's spending review included an additional £445 million rail plan for Wales. This plan will encompass the construction of new railway stations at the following locations: Newport West, Somerton, Llanwern, Magor & Undy and Cardiff East. This development is welcome news for Welsh jobs and transport. The railway line and service connecting Ebbw Vale to Newport and Cardiff has been recognised as crucial rail infrastructure for Southeast Wales. This expansion will further enhance this infrastructure, providing more individuals with the opportunity to utilise rail services. In addition to rectifying the inadequacy of HS2 consequential funding, this investment will significantly enhance transport options in Southeast Wales. This is particularly pertinent given the congestion experienced on the M4 and escalating demands on the local transport infrastructure because of much-needed housing. This significant development has the potential to influence employment opportunities and provide increased avenues for skill acquisition. This is imperative for Gwent communities. It was critically important news that the United Kingdom Government announced it was restoring winter fuel allowance payments to more than nine million pensioners across Wales and England. The payment worth £300 will be restored. Anyone with an income of under £35,000 a year will receive it automatically. Those with an income of above the £35,000 threshold will also receive the payment, but it will then be reclaimed from them in tax. The right thing to do. Rachel Reeves has announced that the United Kingdom Government will deliver to Wales £118 million over the next three financial years to keep coal tips safe across Wales. This is a particular issue for post-industrial communities throughout Islwyn. Coal tips remediated (as coal mining ended) face maintenance issues impacted by climate change. The Welsh Government has previously stated £600 million is needed to remediate and remove Wales's coal tips. Currently, Wales has around £221 million allocated to this endeavour, and it is a challenge that will take decades to address. My position though, remains clear. Whilst we aim to remediate and remove historic Welsh coal tips, this can NOT be achieved at the expense of Islwyn communities. I stand with the people of Cwmfelinfach in expressing my strong opposition to the removal of coal at Mynydd Y Grug in Bedwas. No private company should seek to make a financial gain at the detriment of the public usage of the much-loved and valued Sirhowy County Park. Finally, I was delighted to see a famous son of Islwyn recognised. Rugby legend John Dawes, a son of Abercarn, is among 288 people who have been added to the Oxford Dictionary of National Biography. John Dawes died in 2021, but his name will live forever, and his inclusion in this prestige publication acknowledges his impact within the history of the United Kingdom. Rhianon Passmore, Member of the Senedd for Islwyn.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Trump wanted ‘90 deals in 90 days.' Instead, he's finding wins where he can.
President Donald Trump is touting this week's trade agreement with China as the latest triumph of his dealmaking acumen. But his celebratory tone belies an uncomfortable reality: For all his optimistic talk on trade, Trump has made little tangible progress since this spring's tariff spree, so far only securing frameworks of agreements with the U.K. and China and leaving American businesses grappling with continued economic uncertainty. Critics and allies alike say Trump's talk about the China 'deal' signals how eager he is to telegraph progress ahead of the White House's July 8 self-imposed deadline to hash out agreements with trading partners. 'We were promised '90 deals in 90 days.' What we have at this point are 'general frameworks' for the U.K. and China,' said Marc Short, who served as Trump's legislative affairs director and Vice President Mike Pence's chief of staff during the president's first term, referencing Trump trade adviser Peter Navarro's vow. The administration will 'present it as if they're making significant progress and hail these general frameworks as really significant breakthrough deals,' Short added. But 'other countries are seeing that, if I wait this out, he's going to be overly sensitive to bond market yields, or he's going to get himself into trouble, and then he's going to need to get out of it with a deal.' The White House, however, sees the agreement with China as a true win — proof that it went toe-to-toe with its biggest economic adversary and held its own. 'We're in a solid place going forward in these negotiations, because the country that could most push back here, tried to push back and it didn't really go well for them,' said a White House official, granted anonymity to share the administration's thinking. 'We feel good about negotiations. We're increasingly walking into these discussions being able to demonstrate that we do have the cards.' But even Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent acknowledged that it was 'highly likely' that the July deadline could be extended for 18 trading partners he said are negotiating in good faith. Trump downplayed those comments when asked about them Wednesday night, saying that while he 'would' extend the deadline, he didn't think he'd have to. This week's tentative deal with China offers Trump a bit of a boost as he prepares to meet with major world leaders at the G7 summit next week in Canada. Representatives from foreign countries view the upcoming confab as the next best vehicle to nail down something concrete on trade, after White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt told reporters on Wednesday that there will be 'quite a few bilateral meetings.' One Canadian official, granted anonymity to speak candidly, said whether progress is made over the next few weeks with any country, 'depends greatly on U.S. bandwidth to respond on tariffs given all other talks.' 'I'd expect if [an agreement] lands, it's much closer to the U.K. document length than 1500+ pages of USMCA,' the official said, referring to the comprehensive North American trade deal known as the U.S.-Mexico Canada Agreement, which Trump negotiated during his first term. The U.S. announced its first trade 'deal' — which was, in reality, the framework for a more detailed future agreement — with the U.K. in May. But that accord has yet to be enacted, with U.S. levies on U.K. exports, including cars, steel and aluminum, remaining in place and provisions on agriculture and other issues still to be hashed out. And this week, Trump quickly declared mission accomplished on China — subject to final approval from both him and China's leader Xi Jinping — even though top negotiators had reached no more than a handshake agreement to deescalate tensions and advance trade talks, after a meeting in Geneva last month failed to move the ball forward. Meanwhile, the administration has continued to promise that deals with major trading partners, like Japan, South Korea, India and the European Union, are 'close' ahead of a July 8 deadline, after which Trump's sweeping and massive 'Liberation Day' tariffs are set to go back into effect. But talks with those countries have yet to bear fruit, and smaller countries, eager to negotiate, are having a hard time getting the administration to consider tweaks to proposals the U.S. has put forward. Even some Trump allies in regular contact with the White House are struggling to understand the administration's approach on trade. If the White House is truly interested in boosting domestic manufacturing, they say, it would move quickly to negotiate deals. That would allow businesses to move forward with some certainty instead of leaving them in limbo. 'You meet with officials at all these agencies, you even meet with Cabinet secretaries, and they all agree that the intent of the tariffs was never to hinder companies who are expanding, or trying to onshore supply chains here,' said one of those allies, granted anonymity to speak candidly about the trade discussions. 'I have no fucking clue what their strategy is.' A second Trump ally was more optimistic, acknowledging that the deals seem 'elusive' but voicing confidence the administration 'can get them done.' Talks with South Korea, for instance, appear to be ramping up after the country's new president, Lee Jae-myung, spoke with Trump last week and selected on Tuesday a chief trade negotiator, Yeo Han-koo. While negotiations between the two countries have been ongoing, the South Korean government had made clear it was not possible to make a deal until a new president was in place after its June 3 elections. Leaders in India, who were negotiating with the administration on trade even before Trump announced its 'Liberation Day' tariffs, appear optimistic that the pace of negotiations is picking up ahead of the July deadline. India's foreign minister Subrahmanyam Jaishankar told the French paper Le Figaro earlier this week he was 'hopeful' the country would soon reach an agreement with the U.S. And conversations with the EU — which had stalled, nearly triggering a trade war last month — have moved into a negotiating stage, though progress still remains elusive. The EU has expressed a willingness to engage on issues that have long irritated the U.S., like energy, semiconductors, steel and aluminum and autos, but the U.S. has indicated it will only make concessions on tariffs implemented since Trump took office, and that its flat 10 percent 'baseline' tariff on all countries is off the table for negotiations. That's clouded talks, despite a positive readout from U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer after a meeting with E.U. trade czar Maroš Šefčovič in Paris last week. 'The erratic behavior of the Trump administration has to stop if we want to reach a deal,' Italian Member of the European Parliament Brando Benifei said in an interview. Benifei, who chairs the European Parliament's Delegation for relations with the United States, added that the Trump administration's decision to hike tariffs on steel and aluminum in the middle of trade talks 'is damaging the ongoing negotiations, increasing more uncertainty also for the global economy.' Japanese officials, meanwhile, left Washington empty handed last week following a fifth round of trade talks. The country's trade negotiators said that while talks had 'progressed' Japan had yet to find 'common ground' with the U.S. Prospects for a deal are slightly better for Mexico. President Claudia Sheinbaum said it was 'very likely' that she would speak with Trump at the G7 summit, which she will attend as a guest of Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney. The countries are closing in on a narrow deal that could remove the U.S.'s flat 50 percent tariffs on steel, Bloomberg News was first to report. A person close to the White House, granted anonymity to discuss details of the negotiations, told POLITICO that the countries are weighing a quota-based system, and could reveal more details at next week's G7 summit. Those plans, they said, are not final, and the administration is grappling with pressure from its more protectionist factions that have long requested Trump remain focused on reciprocal tariffs in trade talks. Both Mexico and Canada are not impacted by so-called reciprocal tariffs, and received some exemptions for sector-specific duties because of the pre-existing North American trade deal. Other tariffs, such as those on steel and aluminum, remain in full force. Sen. Bernie Moreno (R-Ohio), a staunch Trump ally, argued the pressure to make deals is on foreign governments, not the White House, at this point. 'There's a lot in the hopper. There's pressure on those other countries because quite frankly it's embarrassing to the EU, it's embarrassing to Japan, it's embarrassing to South Korea that we're making a deal with China first,' Moreno said. 'The reality is that those countries just need to step up, acknowledge that we've had a tilted relationship with them for decades and then they need to fix that and come to the table with a legitimate offer to rebalance our trade." Even without substantial deals, some on the right continue to point out how U.S. tariffs have already significantly shifted the economic conversation. Baseline reciprocal tariffs of 10 percent remain in effect globally, with tariffs in China at an even higher level of about 55 percent, on average. 'Some, they want to call it 'caving' or 'giving in' or something like that,' said Mark DiPlacido, policy advisor at American Compass, a think tank that embraces economic populism. 'But they're not comparing it to the baseline of where things were at at the beginning of the year.'
