Utah's dubious destiny in nuclear power development
Union Electric Callaway Nuclear Power Plant in Missouri. (Photo by)
In February, 2025, in remarks delivered to the Nuclear Industry Council's showcase in Salt Lake City, Utah Gov. Spencer Cox outlined Utah's future as a national leader in nuclear power development: 'We believe that Utah is uniquely positioned to lead the nuclear renaissance in the U.S.'
At a conference in Park City in October 2024, Utah Senate President Stuart J. Adams went Cox one better and said, 'We want to establish Utah as an expert here for energy innovation . . . we want to be the world leader. And to do that, nuclear is going to be a big part of it.' Another Utah politician eyeing the moon while jumping on a pogo stick, Utah Congressional Rep. John Curtis (now Utah Senator) said at the same Park City venue, 'We want to be a big part of this. We're ready for nuclear facilities here in our state.' Unclear about referencing the state or the nation, he also said, 'We're not talking about dozens of nuclear facilities. We're talking about hundreds of nuclear facilities.'
Utahns have heard this before — big promises, big plans, out-of-this-world expectations, and fizzling results. A parade of top Utah leaders have long excelled in making thrilling predictions about the state.
For example, a Utah attorney in 1976 promised to sweep corrupting long-term power out of Utah's future. Orrin Hatch criticized then-incumbent Senator Frank Moss' 18-year tenure in the Senate, saying, 'What do you call a Senator who's served in office for 18 years? You call him home.' Hatch argued Moss had lost touch with his constituents after so long a time gulping down the muddy waters of the Potomac River.
Orrin Hatch won the election that year and promptly lost touch with his constituents for the next 42 years as he became the longest running elected U.S. Senator up to that time, serving seven six-year terms in office. His treacherous contribution to the political landscape helped to lay the basis of the Senate's current House of Lords-style lifetime service model, devoted primarily to serving the interests of an autocratic occupant of the White House rather than the people of this country.
Utah Gov. Mike Leavitt made promises and predictions during his 11 years in office about education that neither he nor the Legislature could bring to pass: reducing class sizes, raising up students in poor areas of the state, and improving educational achievement by handing out special grants to 'Centennial' schools. He and the state could not manage to improve the state's ranking of dead last in per student spending among the 50 states. Furthermore, Scholastic Aptitude Test (SAT) scores under Leavitt slid backward for 5th and 8th graders.
The aforementioned Utah Senate President Stuart Adams glibly promised the people of Utah that Utah would lead the nation out of the pandemic. However, Utah, with all its anti-vax religious libertarians leading the way, arguably led Utah and the nation back into another round of pandemic illness and death.
Now, along comes Gov. Spencer Cox in the prime of his fame and power in 2025. It seems to have slipped the governor's mind that Utah was the recipient of drifting nuclear mushroom clouds during the atom bomb testing beginning in 1945 at the Nevada Test Site. This tidy little underperformed piece of history produced an American Chernobyl with cascading cancer deaths from generation to generation as a result of the 'downwinder' effect on southern Utahns.
Cox also seems not to have taken to heart another nuclear warning story that comes to us from Utah's west desert. That part of the state is a holding place for some of the US military's deadliest materials. One article cites, 'Everything from compacted urban trash to nuclear reactor waste seems to end up there among the tumbleweeds, alkaline salt flats, and jackalopes. Even the Deseret News once called it 'a place to store and burn and bury our country's toxic trash.'' The Dugway Proving Ground located there became one of the centers of the nation's chemical and biological weapons testing and a dumping ground for nuclear waste. Dugway ran into trouble in 1968 when testing a new nerve agent that accidentally killed 6,000 sheep grazing in the desert.
In another slap to the face of Utah's megalomaniacal ambitions is that Utah is not even mentioned in the short list of states who are leading the way in developing nuclear energy, a list which includes only Virginia, Michigan, and Wyoming.
It is hard to know from what source Utah politicians are taking their delirious political prompts. It certainly is not necessary in an authentic democracy to always be first and best in everything.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indianapolis Star
30 minutes ago
- Indianapolis Star
Mike Braun is failing Indiana, yet wants to be president
Mike Braun hated being a U.S. senator and left after one failed term. Now, he's not quite six months into a failing term as Indiana governor, and he's already looking for his next job. Politico's Adam Wren reports Braun is discussing a run for president in 2028, the strongest signal yet that he is as delusional as he is inept. Here's Braun's record as governor so far: He over-promised a massive property tax cut and couldn't deliver. It won't get better from here. The economy is worsening, which means Braun is likely to oversee an era of increasingly draconian budget cuts, rising unemployment and accelerated decline in rural areas. That is not the stuff of presidential campaigns. Put aside Braun's botched first legislative session. Presidents need to be good at politics. Braun is bad at politics. Braun didn't have the political acumen to stop Micah Beckwith's lieutenant governor nomination last year, but he thinks he can navigate a presidential primary? Does he know that other people will be running? Briggs: Jim Banks would let Trump commit any crime you can imagine Braun's fiasco at last year's Indiana Republican Party convention saddled him with a lieutenant governor who overshadows him at every turn and is openly opposing him. Remember, President Trump actually endorsed Braun's preferred running mate, state Rep. Julie McGuire, and it didn't matter. Beckwith won anyway because Indiana's populist right views Beckwith as authentic and Braun and his team as MAGA cosplayers. Beckwith's outsized presence has forced Braun into errors, such as making the ill-advised property tax promise and then doubling down on it at a Beckwith-headlined rally where Braun was the third wheel. Braun lacks principles and objectives, so he operates as a copycat politician. But he doesn't actually understand why figures such as Trump or Beckwith are successful, so he offers awkward imitations and looks pathetic. Yes, Braun has won big elections. He ran an exceptional campaign for U.S. Senate in 2018 and then lucked his way through an overcrowded and underwhelming GOP primary field for governor last year before winning in November. Despite all that winning, he doesn't have a single substantive achievement to serve as a foundation for a presidential run. He doesn't even have a lame culture war win. Braun is a sad man in a blue shirt who can't appreciate any of his business or electoral success because he's always looking for the next big, powerful job to give his life meaning. There is no national demand for someone like this to run for president. Braun is not going to be president. What's worse, Braun also won't be much of a governor. Who do you know who excels at a job they don't want? Braun is bored with being governor, just like he got bored early in his Senate term. We're stuck for three and a half years with someone who pursued the governor's office for a dopamine rush and now would prefer to be elsewhere. Briggs: Diego Morales is rubbing our faces in his corruption. Impeach him now. Braun checking out on Indiana was entirely predictable. Why did he want to be a senator? Why did he want to be governor? Why does he want to be president? I'm genuinely asking. As far as I can tell, Braun has no theory of government external to his own ambitions. He runs for office for the sake of running for office. Unlike when Braun was a non-factor in the Senate, Hoosiers will notice him checking out now. Braun is not even a sure thing to win a second term as governor, should he decide to run, much less a top-tier contender for the presidency. The only thing ahead for Braun, 71, is retirement. He can either come up with something productive to do and try to leave a lasting impact on Indiana, or keep doing TV hits and signing inconsequential executive orders to look busy. Either way, his presidential ambition is a fantasy. The most pitiful thing about Braun is he'll be the last person to figure that out.
Business of Fashion
an hour ago
- Business of Fashion
French Senate Backs Law to Curb Ultra Fast-Fashion
France's Senate approved a revised version of a law regulating fast fashion on Tuesday, which if implemented would ban advertising by fast-growing Chinese e-commerce platforms like Shein and Temu. Senators in the upper house of parliament voted almost unanimously for a modified version of a bill passed by France's lower house last year, which aims to reduce the environmental impact of the textile industry. Critics say the low-priced garments produced by fast-fashion chains drive excessive consumption and waste, exacerbating the textile sector's impact on the environment. An amended version of the bill distinguishes between 'ultra' fast fashion and 'classic' fast fashion, however, imposing less onerous restrictions on European fast-fashion players like Zara and Kiabi, but drawing criticism from environmental groups. The 'clarifications (made by the Senate) make it possible to target players who ignore environmental, social, and economic realities, notably Shein and Temu, without penalising the European ready-to-wear sector,' said Jean-Francois Longeot, chair of the Senate's Committee on Regional Planning and Sustainable Development. 'Shein is not a fast fashion company,' said the Chinese firm in a statement in response to the vote, adding that its model was 'part of the solution, not the problem'. Faced with competition from very low-priced products, several French brands are experiencing significant difficulties, such as Jennyfer, which went into liquidation at the end of April, and NafNaf, which has been in receivership since May. The law would also introduce penalties for both fast and ultra fast-fashion companies if they don't meet certain environmental criteria, reaching at least 10 euros per item of clothing by 2030, or up to 50 percent of the product's price excluding tax. The government needs to notify the European Commission of the vote, and will then need to set up a joint committee to reach a compromise between the Senate and lower house versions of the law before it is implemented. By Florence Loeve; Editors: Dominique Patton and Mark Potter Learn more: Tariffs Won't Kill Fast Fashion, But They Might Kill Sustainable Fashion Some have hailed America's escalating trade war as a means to finally curb overconsumption of cheap goods. Instead, the economic hardship its likely to bring on will eviscerate efforts to transform the industry for the better, writes Kenneth P. Pucker.
Politico
an hour ago
- Politico
The GOP's latest megabill casualties
Presented by IN TODAY'S EDITION:— House GOP to ax some megabill proposals— Mfume now pro-seniority amid Oversight race— MAHA spat between GOP senators, RFK Jr. House Republicans will vote to make difficult changes to the GOP megabill today in an attempt to keep the bill on track in the Senate. The House Rules Committee teed up a provision Tuesday night that would scrub the House-passed bill of problems the Senate parliamentarian flagged as threats to the measure's filibuster-skirting power, our Jennifer Scholtes, Meredith Lee Hill and Katherine Tully-McManus report. The proposals getting axed include: — Cracking down on the fraud-plagued employee retention tax credit created during the pandemic. House Republicans were relying on this for $6.3 billion in savings to offset spending in the bill. — $2 billion for Pentagon military intelligence programs and $500 million to develop missiles. Losing this particularly irked many House GOP lawmakers. — Allowing mining in a protected wilderness area in the Midwest. The contentious provision would have reversed then-President Joe Biden's move to protect the Boundary Waters area. — Part of the policy ending increased food aid for households that also qualify for heating and cooling assistance. Senate Appropriations Chair Susan Collins previously complained about this. — Extending a policy requiring federal agencies to procure a certain amount of biofuels or bio-based products. By cutting these items, the bill retains its ability to pass the Senate with a simple majority, rather than 60 votes. While Senate Republicans are still mulling their own tweaks to the bill, and could seek to restore some of the measures now on the chopping block, these changes need to be fixed now before the Senate votes on it. More policies could get slashed. In the coming weeks, expect Senate Republicans to start getting their first 'Byrd bath' rulings from the parliamentarian on additional GOP proposals under challenge from Democrats. To help avoid a tough whip effort today, House GOP leaders are embedding the fixes in the procedural measure they're using to set up debate on the $9.4 billion rescissions package — legislation that even the most conservative Republicans support. That won't be the case when the bill comes back from the Senate in a few weeks, as leaders hope. GOOD WEDNESDAY MORNING. We hope to see you all at the Congressional Baseball Game tonight! Follow our live coverage at the Inside Congress blog at and email your Inside Congress scribes at mmccarthy@ lkashinsky@ bleonard@ and crazor@ THE SKED The House is in session and voting on the rule for the rescissions package that includes special language to amend the reconciliation package at 4:15 p.m. — Democratic Leaders Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer will have a news conference on the GOP megabill at 10 a.m. — Appropriations will have a full committee markup of the fiscal 2026 Agriculture-FDA bill at 10 a.m. — Agriculture will hear testimony from Secretary Brooke Rollins at 10 a.m. — Ways and Means will hear testimony from Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent at 10 a.m. — The Republican Study Committee will have its weekly lunch at 12:30 p.m. The Senate is in session and voting on ending debate on Billy Long's nomination to be IRS commissioner at noon, on proceeding with landmark cryptocurrency legislation at 2 p.m. and on discharging resolutions that block the sale of certain arms to Saudi Arabia and United Arab Emirates around 4 p.m. — Environment and Public Works will have a hearing on Sean McMaster's nomination to be administrator of the Federal Highway Administration at 10 a.m. — Commerce will have a hearing on Bryan Bedford's nomination for FAA administrator at 10 a.m. — Energy and Natural Resources will have a hearing on the president's fiscal 2026 budget request for the Interior Department at 10 a.m. — Appropriations will have subcommittee hearings on the president's fiscal 2026 budget request for the Defense Department with testimony from Secretary Pete Hegseth at 10 a.m., for the Forest Service with testimony from Chief Tom Schultz at 10:30 a.m., for HUD with testimony from Secretary Scott Turner at 3:30 p.m. and for Treasury with testimony from Bessent at 4 p.m. — Republicans will have a conference meeting at 2:30 p.m. — The Congressional Baseball Game will start at 7:05 p.m. at Nationals Park. The rest of the week: The House will take up the rescissions package and the HALT Fentanyl Act. The Senate will work through Trump's nominations and landmark cryptocurrency legislation. THE LEADERSHIP SUITE FIRST IN INSIDE CONGRESS: MFUME EMBRACES SENIORITY — Kweisi Mfume fled the House three decades ago over frustrations with Democrats' seniority system. Now Mfume, 76, is banking on the age-old practice as he vies for the party's top slot on House Oversight, our Nicholas Wu, Hailey Fuchs and Ben Jacobs report this morning. Mfume's using an old-school sales pitch, too. Rather than provide a detailed agenda for taking on Trump and congressional Republicans, Mfume said he'll aim to build 'consensus' among panel Democrats on the best path forward. He wants to 'moderate' disagreements rather than brawl across the aisle. It's a sharp contrast to a Democratic base that's itching for more aggressive and younger leadership. Some complicating factors for Mfume: He's the oldest in a four-person field that includes two candidates in their forties. Rep. Stephen Lynch, 70, has more seniority on the panel. Rep. Robert Garcia won the Congressional Hispanic Caucus' endorsement. Mfume is unlikely to win official support from the Congressional Black Caucus because another member, Rep. Jasmine Crockett, is also in the race. And Mfume's 2004 departure from the NAACP was marred by sexual harassment allegations, though Mfume denies wrongdoing. Senior Republicans skipping Trump's military bash Top Republicans including Senate Majority Leader John Thune, Senate Majority Whip John Barrasso, House Majority Leader Steve Scalise and the chairs of the House and Senate Armed Services committees won't be attending the president's multimillion-dollar military parade Saturday, Lisa, Calen and Mia report. In fact, among 50 Republicans we surveyed this week, only seven said they were staying in town to attend the Army's 250th birthday celebration (which is also Trump's 79th) — Reps. Marjorie Taylor Greene, Byron Donalds, Elise Stefanik, Cory Mills, Rich McCormick, John McGuire and Lisa McClain. The White House is shrugging off the absences; an official granted anonymity to discuss planning for the event said senior military leaders and at least 15 Cabinet secretaries are slated to attend. And GOP lawmakers broadly said they support the spectacle that could cost upwards of $40 million, though a few are balking at the price tag. Thune says Trump's tax promises are here to stay Thune said Tuesday that Trump's campaign-trail tax pledges will be included in the Senate's version of the megabill, even as some Republicans mull scaling back key provisions to help expand business tax incentives, our Jordain Carney reports. 'The president, as you know, campaigned hard on no tax on tips, no tax on overtime, social security, interest on car loans,' Thune told reporters. 'They were addressed in the House version of the bill and I expect they will be in the Senate, as well.' Thune also said he'll likely return to the White House for another megabill meeting with Trump before week's end. Meanwhile, as negotiations continue over the Senate's megabill changes, SALT Republicans are seeking a meeting with Thune over the state-and-local-tax deduction, which could happen as soon as today. House Freedom Caucus members Chip Roy and Scott Perry crossed the Capitol Tuesday to meet with fellow deficit hawks Sens. Mike Lee, Rick Scott and Ron Johnson, Jordain scooped. Scalise skeptical of Texas redistricting push Count Scalise among the Republicans unnerved by the White House's push for Texas lawmakers to redraw the state's 38 U.S. House districts. Scalise on Tuesday cautioned that the effort — pitched as a measure to preserve the GOP majority in the midterms — shouldn't inadvertently put incumbents at risk. 'You have to balance a lot of things,' he told reporters. Members of the Texas GOP House delegation didn't show much enthusiasm for the idea in their closed-door meeting Monday night, a person familiar with the discussions told Nicholas. They'll huddle with White House officials Thursday to discuss the redistricting plan further. Johnson backs Trump's military force in LA Speaker Mike Johnson is standing behind Trump's decision to dispatch both the National Guard and the Marines to Los Angeles amid clashes between protestors and law enforcement over ICE. He said there's a 'clear distinction' between condemning violent protesters in California and Trump pardoning rioters who stormed the Capitol on Jan. 6, though he declined to elaborate. Meanwhile, Collins broke with GOP leadership Tuesday over the issue. 'I would draw a distinction between the use of the National Guard and the use of the Marines,' Collins told reporters. 'Active duty forces are generally not to be involved in domestic law-enforcement operations.' POLICY RUNDOWN SCOOP: MAHA MEETING MELTDOWN — Key farm-state GOP senators had a tense meeting with HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and other Trump administration officials Tuesday over the Make America Healthy Again report, which criticized pesticide use, four people tell our Grace Yarrow. Senators in the meeting included Agriculture Chair John Boozman, Appropriations Agriculture Subcommittee Chair John Hoeven, Chuck Grassley, Cindy Hyde-Smith and Roger Marshall, along with Kennedy adviser Calley Means. The three other people familiar with Tuesday's discussion described the tone as 'heated.' At one point, Kennedy pounded on the table, one individual said. 'If this was to try to calm people down, they failed miserably,' the person told Grace. SIMPSON BUCKS THE WHITE HOUSE — Rep. Mike Simpson, a senior appropriator, is pushing back on White House budget chief Russ Vought's enthusiasm for so-called 'pocket rescissions,' which would allow the Trump administration to make permanent cuts to federal spending without congressional approval, our Katherine Tully-McManus and Meredith report. 'I think it's a bad idea,' Simpson told reporters Tuesday. 'It undermines Congress' authority.' A pocket rescission refers to when the White House moves to claw back money already approved by Congress with fewer than 45 days left in the fiscal year, then withholds that funding through Sept. 30 in an attempt to cancel it permanently. SENATE GOP SNAPS BACK — Senate Republicans are finalizing a scaled-down plan to shift some federal food aid costs to states as a way to pay for their megabill, five people with direct knowledge of the negotiations told Meredith and Grace. The move to downsize the House-passed plan comes after intense pushback from Republican senators, including some of Trump's closest supporters. They're concerned that red states in particular would be hit with billions of dollars in new costs to administer the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, which helps feed more than 40 million low-income Americans. The reworked Senate plan under consideration would force states with the highest payment error rates to pay 15 percent of SNAP benefits — a lower rate than the House's 25 percent proposal. It also would scale down the costs for states with lower error rates, allowing some of them to avoid footing any of the cost-share for benefits. REPUBLICANS BACK OFF MEDICARE CHANGES — Senate Republicans are bursting their own Medicare bubble after some lawmakers floated making changes to the program to help pay for their megabill, Jordain and Robert King report. Sen. Kevin Cramer, among the first lawmakers to raise the possibility of including Medicare changes in the party-line package, conceded in an interview the concept lacked political momentum: 'There aren't many of us courageous enough to talk about it.' Best of POLITICO Pro and E&E: CAMPAIGN STOP NORTON'S FLIP-FLOP — Eleanor Holmes Norton, D.C.'s nonvoting House delegate, said Tuesday she would seek reelection, only for her spokesperson to say hours later that the aging representative is 'in conversations' about retirement, Nicholas reports. Norton, who turns 88 this week, has faced increasing concern about her capacity to continue serving in Congress, particularly as D.C. faces a Congress-induced budget shortfall. SHERRILL ADVANCES IN N.J. GOV RACE — Rep. Mikie Sherrill clinched the Democratic nomination for New Jersey governor Tuesday night. The state's electorate leans blue, but the race between Sherrill and Trump-backed Republican Jack Ciattarelli is expected to be competitive. If Sherrill wins in November, there will be a special election to succeed her. Expect a crowded Democratic field there; her district favors Democrats, our Madison Fernandez writes in. Sherrill's the latest House Democrat elected in the party's 2018 wave to seek higher office. TUNNEL TALK DEMS HOPE TO AVOID ANOTHER SHELLACKING — Democrats are looking to break a four-game skid against Republicans in the Congressional Baseball Game tonight after getting blown out last year. It's been ugly: Republicans have outscored Democrats 70-29 in the past four games, including a 20-run victory last year. The game is played at Nationals Park and benefits charities, including the Boys and Girls Clubs of Greater Washington. Names to watch: Rep. Greg Steube has been the GOP's ace pitcher and won the MVP last year for Republicans. Sen. Eric Schmitt and Reps. August Pfluger, Morgan Luttrel and Brad Finstad are all dangerous hitters. For the Democrats, Reps. Chris Deluzio, Peter Aguilar and Jimmy Panetta are among their heavy hitters. They've struggled to find a replacement on the mound for Cedric Richmond, who left the Hill for the Biden administration in 2021, but Aguilar and Deluzio have stepped in to help pitch in recent years. The forecast: Elections analyst Nathaniel Rakich crunched the numbers and says the game is 'likely Republican.' THE BEST OF THE REST New Jersey Rep. LaMonica McIver indicted following ICE protest, from our Ry Rivard Freedom Caucus chair leads in earmarks, Jack Fitzpatrick and Ken Tran at Bloomberg Government Lawmakers Traded Stocks Heavily as Trump Rolled Out 'Liberation Day' Tariffs, from Katy Stech Ferek, Jack Gillum, James Benedict and Gunjan Banerji at The Wall Street Journal 'Super Cagey': Inside Rep. Mark Green's Mysterious Resignation From Congress, from Reese Gorman at NOTUS CAPITOL HILL INFLUENCE TELEHEALTH TAKEOVER — The American Telemedicine Association's lobbying arm is blanketing more than 40 Capitol Hill offices today in a bid to extend expanded pandemic-era access to virtual health care. Popular and broadly bipartisan telehealth flexibilities that started during the pandemic expire at the end of September. 'We are most definitely not standing by during the budget reconciliation process — there's just too much at stake,' ATA Action executive director Kyle Zebley said in a statement. ALSO FLYING IN — Several trade groups are on the Hill this week to discuss the Trump administration's tariffs, including the National Retail Federation and the American Seed Trade Association, POLITICO Influence reports. Meanwhile CEOs with AdvaMed will meet with lawmakers today to try and win support for a new medtech Medicare coverage bill. JOB BOARD Cally Barry is now senior adviser and comms director for Rep. Ralph Norman. She most recently was comms director for Rep. Morgan Luttrell. Marybeth Nassif is joining Jones Walker as a director in the government relations practice group. She previously was a professional staff member for the House Appropriations Committee. HAPPY BIRTHDAY Former Rep. Mike Conaway … CMS Administrator Mehmet Oz … Kim Oates of the House Radio/TV Gallery … J Street's Jeremy Ben-Ami … Cesar Gonzalez of Rep. Mario Diaz-Balart's office … Tad Devine of Devine Mulvey Longabaugh … Lorissa Bounds … Kristen Thomaselli ... Mary Kate Cunningham … CNN's Morgan Rimmer … Sofia Jones of the House Agriculture Committee … Jonathan Martinez of Haleon … Tamar Epps of the National Head Start Association … Amy Barrera of Thune's office … TJ Adams-Falconer TRIVIA TUESDAY'S ANSWER: Paul Hagner correctly answered that Richard Nixon was the first president to visit all 50 states while in office. TODAY'S QUESTION, from Paul: William Henry Harrison had the shortest tenure as president. Who had the second shortest tenure? The first person to correctly guess gets a mention in the next edition of Inside Congress. Send your answers to insidecongress@ CORRECTION: Yesterday's newsletter misstated the time of a House Democratic leaders press conference and misspelled Sang Yi's name — our apologies.
