logo
‘Failed our son': Brave NSW parents fight after toddler dies

‘Failed our son': Brave NSW parents fight after toddler dies

News.com.au30-04-2025

Following the tragic death of two-year-old Joe Massa, his mother has spoken out, saying the system 'failed our son', prompting calls for reform from both parents and government officials.
At a press conference on Wednesday, NSW Health Minister Ryan Park vowed to overhaul the REACH (Recognise, Engage, Act, Call, Help is on its way) patient escalation system across the state's hospitals, describing the death of Joe as a tragic failure and a catalyst for urgent action.
Joe was taken to Northern Beaches Hospital in September last year after vomiting through the night.
His parents, Elouise and Danny Massa, said he waited more than two hours for a bed and was wrongly classified as a lower priority, despite showing signs of severe dehydration and an elevated heart rate.
The couple said hospital staff refused their repeated requests to administer intravenous fluids. About three hours after arriving at the emergency department, Joe went into cardiac arrest and was transferred to Sydney Children's Hospital in Randwick.
He later died from brain damage.
Police have since launched an investigation into his death.
Joe's parents joined the media conference to discuss NSW Health's Roundtable on the REACH protocol.
'Today, in 2025 I'm standing here because the program failed our son, Joe,' Mrs Massa said.
'We need to make sure that it works, we need to make sure that it is simplified and that it is amplified, and that we do not stop talking about the program to save lives, not one more child, not one more person can be lost.
'We need to ensure that the program is bolstered, and that is exactly what we are doing here today, and I have no doubt, with the support of the Health Minister, the premier and of course, Susan Pearce, that we will get there.'
The REACH program was established in 2013, shortly before the death of six-month-old Kyran Day, who was misdiagnosed at Shoalhaven Hospital on the NSW South Coast, where the program was not implemented correctly.
Kyrans family also attended the conference, including his grandmother, Jane Carritt, who called for greater awareness and access to the escalation system.
'There were so many moments where Kyran could have been saved and there were so many moments where Joe should have been saved,' Ms Carritt said.
'You are entitled to ask for a second opinion, but also, when you're in that situation, you're usually very stressed, it's very hard to think clearly.
'So you need the support of the technology and the information and the clinicians to support the patients and the children and adults who cannot speak for themselves,' she said.
Kyrans father also spoke at the event, becoming emotional as he addressed the media.
'Sometimes the worst things in our life cannot often turn into something that creates a monumental change, and that's why we're here today,' Mr Day said.
'Both Kyran and Joe were only here for a short time, but their legacy is going to live forever, and I think that's something that's really important.'
Mr Park acknowledged that while REACH has the right foundations, its implementation across NSW hospitals has become inconsistent and confusing.
'In big government departments, we can sometimes lose sight of what we're actually trying to do,' Mr Park said.
'What we're trying to do here is to make it as simple as possible for a mum, a dad, a carer, a brother or sister, an advocate, to raise their hand and say, 'I've got some concerns.''
'We are confident that it is being used well in many places, we are not confident that it is being used as well as it could across the system,' he said.
Mr Park emphasised the need for a streamlined, easily accessible system with one clear and centralised contact method.
'What I want … is for this to be synchronised and centralised,' he said.
He confirmed the REACH program would not be scrapped but strengthened, with simplification, visibility and accessibility as key priorities.
'It's not a criticism of those who came before us,' he said.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

My son's death was not in vain: Joe's Law means lives will be saved
My son's death was not in vain: Joe's Law means lives will be saved

Sydney Morning Herald

time3 days ago

  • Sydney Morning Herald

My son's death was not in vain: Joe's Law means lives will be saved

I was often asked, 'How can you be campaigning for change so soon after Joe's death?' or one that close family would ask from a well-meaning place was, 'do you really want to be doing this?'. But my response came from deep grief and fierce love. How could I not be advocating for change? Joe's love and the need for justice and compassion is the driving force behind everything I do – it propels me forward every single day. We commit to standing firm in our belief that access to excellent healthcare is our universal right and should not be subject to substandard treatment at the hands of trillion-dollar private equity firms who only care about the bottom line and not the care of our patients in NSW. Joe lost his life due to a cascade of failures – beginning with the government's 2014 decision to adopt a public-private partnership (PPP) model for healthcare. What followed was a string of inadequate policies, broken processes, poor IT systems, individual failures by staff at the Northern Beaches Hospital and a false sense within the community that it was a safe hospital. The fundamental problem is that running acute and emergency services is not compatible with owning a profit-making business. This is the model at the Northern Beaches Hospital and it is broken. We learnt the Northern Beaches Hospital was controlled by Healthscope, a private company that was acquired in 2019 via a $5.7 billion takeover by Canadian private equity firm Brookfield. During the 2019 acquisition, Brookfield pledged to continue funding Healthscope's investments and growth. 'Brookfield intend to provide support for Healthscope to continue developments of existing sites and pursue growth opportunities.' This clearly has not happened. Loading As an asset manager responsible for critical infrastructure, Brookfield had a duty to invest in Northern Beaches Hospital when it mattered most. We believe Brookfield failed both the northern beaches community and the NSW government. In our view, they should no longer be allowed to operate and trade in Australia across any sector. We hear constantly from people in our community who are avoiding Northern Beaches Hospital in emergencies – too afraid to take their children or loved ones to an emergency department operated by Healthscope. While it isn't perfect, NSW has a public health system that is in many respects the envy of the world. The northern beaches are currently locked out of that standard of care. We will not stop advocating for our most vulnerable – babies, toddlers, the elderly – and every person in NSW who relies on a safe and dependable health system. Health must be the first priority on every political agenda. But I believe that when we make morally right decisions – ones grounded in truth, love, and collective resolve – there is nothing we cannot achieve. Joe's death will not define him. Change - and love - will have the last word. Stay with us, Joe, and guide us into the new tomorrow.

My son's death was not in vain: Joe's Law means lives will be saved
My son's death was not in vain: Joe's Law means lives will be saved

The Age

time3 days ago

  • The Age

My son's death was not in vain: Joe's Law means lives will be saved

I was often asked, 'How can you be campaigning for change so soon after Joe's death?' or one that close family would ask from a well-meaning place was, 'do you really want to be doing this?'. But my response came from deep grief and fierce love. How could I not be advocating for change? Joe's love and the need for justice and compassion is the driving force behind everything I do – it propels me forward every single day. We commit to standing firm in our belief that access to excellent healthcare is our universal right and should not be subject to substandard treatment at the hands of trillion-dollar private equity firms who only care about the bottom line and not the care of our patients in NSW. Joe lost his life due to a cascade of failures – beginning with the government's 2014 decision to adopt a public-private partnership (PPP) model for healthcare. What followed was a string of inadequate policies, broken processes, poor IT systems, individual failures by staff at the Northern Beaches Hospital and a false sense within the community that it was a safe hospital. The fundamental problem is that running acute and emergency services is not compatible with owning a profit-making business. This is the model at the Northern Beaches Hospital and it is broken. We learnt the Northern Beaches Hospital was controlled by Healthscope, a private company that was acquired in 2019 via a $5.7 billion takeover by Canadian private equity firm Brookfield. During the 2019 acquisition, Brookfield pledged to continue funding Healthscope's investments and growth. 'Brookfield intend to provide support for Healthscope to continue developments of existing sites and pursue growth opportunities.' This clearly has not happened. Loading As an asset manager responsible for critical infrastructure, Brookfield had a duty to invest in Northern Beaches Hospital when it mattered most. We believe Brookfield failed both the northern beaches community and the NSW government. In our view, they should no longer be allowed to operate and trade in Australia across any sector. We hear constantly from people in our community who are avoiding Northern Beaches Hospital in emergencies – too afraid to take their children or loved ones to an emergency department operated by Healthscope. While it isn't perfect, NSW has a public health system that is in many respects the envy of the world. The northern beaches are currently locked out of that standard of care. We will not stop advocating for our most vulnerable – babies, toddlers, the elderly – and every person in NSW who relies on a safe and dependable health system. Health must be the first priority on every political agenda. But I believe that when we make morally right decisions – ones grounded in truth, love, and collective resolve – there is nothing we cannot achieve. Joe's death will not define him. Change - and love - will have the last word. Stay with us, Joe, and guide us into the new tomorrow.

Annah was told to take her daughter home from hospital. She died the next day
Annah was told to take her daughter home from hospital. She died the next day

Sydney Morning Herald

time25-05-2025

  • Sydney Morning Herald

Annah was told to take her daughter home from hospital. She died the next day

NSW deputy coroner Joan Baptie will on Monday resume her inquiry into the care Pippa received in the days and hours leading up to her death – and whether her death was preventable. Sepsis occurs when the body's immune response to an infection causes damage to its own organs and tissues. A locum paediatrician involved in the toddler's treatment at Orange Hospital previously told the coroner Pippa would 'almost certainly' have survived if she had received antibiotics 12 to 18 hours earlier. Parents Annah and Brock, who will both give statements in court on Monday, hope the inquest will build momentum for system-wide reforms after a series of high-profile failures in NSW public hospitals. Annah White said recent tragedies, including the deaths of two-year-old Joe Massa and newborn Harper Atkinson at Sydney's Northern Beaches Hospital, showed families continued to be let down by the state's health system, and she could not grieve her daughter until things changed. 'I would prefer to just be grieving my daughter, but I can't grieve her because I know how bad the health system is,' White said. 'Nothing really has changed, and there's way more that needs to be done.' Loading After Joe Massa's death in September, Health Minister Ryan Park vowed to overhaul REACH (Recognise, Engage, Act, Call, Help is on its way) protocols to make it easier for parents and carers to raise concerns about the condition of their loved ones in hospital. White was aware of the REACH program through previous hospital visits with Pippa's twin brother Leo, and she tried to escalate her concerns with emergency staff. 'Nothing was done about it,' White said. 'No one's taking their child to an emergency department for fun or for a holiday, and I just feel like no one's taking parental concerns seriously.' The inquest runs all week. It will hear from nurses who treated Pippa, spokespeople from NSW Health, and medical experts who conducted a review of her treatment. White said she had read the expert's report, and it validated many of her concerns about Pippa's treatment. 'There were moments for different people to intervene. It wasn't one error, it was a chain of failures,' White said. 'It's weird to say that it was good to read that [report], but I knew she should have survived and that's why I asked for this inquest.' The White family and their supporters plan to attend every day of the inquest, wearing Pippa's favourite colour, yellow.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store