Henderson left to ‘unravel the mystery' with Constitution Hill
He was all the rage to get his career back on track as the 8-13 favourite, but there were early warning signs for his supporters as he briefly shied away from the starting tapes and then gave the first flight plenty of air and landed steeply.
The eight-year-old did make some ground in the back straight under James Bowen, who was deputising in the saddle for the sidelined Nico de Boinville, but the Seven Barrows superstar had no more to give from the home turn and eventually trailed home a very lacklustre fifth, beaten 27 lengths.
Henderson said: 'It's disappointing, but it's a tough game.
'It was sad he had to be beaten that way because you could live with going down in a battle. He was beaten two out and James looked after him.
'Something has obviously gone wrong because that's not him and our job is to try to unravel the mystery. He's got such a great mind, nothing worries him, but you can't look inside his head.
'He's very uncomplicated, unflustered and his work was good. He was travelling well turning in, but then it was like flicking a switch.'
At the request of the raceday stewards, Constitution Hill was examined by the Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board veterinary officer after the race and was found to be sore and have grazes to his right-hind cannon bone.
The post-race reaction was far more positive from trainer Jeremy Scott, whose stable star Golden Ace proved her shock Champion Hurdle success at Cheltenham was no fluke with a fine effort to finish second to the front-running State Man.
Golden Ace profited from the State Man's final-flight exit at Prestbury and while she was unable to lay a glove on him in the rematch, Scott was understandably proud of her performance in defeat.
He said: 'I'm gutted we weren't good enough to win, but I'm delighted with her.
'She was staying on at the end and today she probably needed a little bit further, ideally.
'I was so impressed with the way she jumped today, she travelled really well, she just didn't have that kick that the winner had, but I think the first three have all run very well and it's quite nice we've got as close to State Man as we have, because I rather felt everyone assumed we'd be beaten a mile.
'If you'd had the Cheltenham hill in front of you, that might have just sapped the stamina of State Man, who knows? I feel slightly more vindicated anyway.
'She might not start next season quite so early, but we'll see how she is in the autumn and take it day by day. I couldn't be happier with her today anyway, without winning.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
4 days ago
- Scottish Sun
‘Spineless' – Meg Nicholls' verdict on Philip Byrnes' infamous fall as dad Charles breaks silence after horse is sold
BYRN AFTER READING 'Spineless' – Meg Nicholls' verdict on Philip Byrnes' infamous fall as dad Charles breaks silence after horse is sold Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) BRAVE Meg Nicholls was praised by punters for giving her no-holds-barred verdict on Philip Byrnes' infamous Wexford fall. The jockey's 'soft' unseat at the last when clear on Redwood Queen has sparked an urgent Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board investigation. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up Statement issued as officials launch probe into jockey's final-flight fall on leading horse who drifted in market The mare, who has since been sold to a new trainer having belonged to Philip's brother Cathal, was a huge drifter in the betting before the off. New footage has emerged of the flashpoint, which saw Philip, whose dad Charles trained the horse, fall to his knees after the horse successfully jumped the last. Nicholls was involved in a discussion with Sun Racing's Matt Chapman and former Grand National-winning rider Mick Fitzgerald last weekend. And Meg, daughter of iconic trainer Paul, didn't hold back when giving her opinion of what happened. Quizzed by Fitzgerald: "So come on then, what are you saying, that he jumped off?" Meg without hesitation hit back: "I think it looks like it. "Watching that it looks as if he is preparing… his knee is out already. He is pushing himself out the left hand side. "It looks as if he is trying to come off." Nicholls' analysis was lauded as 'superb' by ITV viewers - but some disagreed with Fitzgerald. One took exception to his 'spineless' verdict of the incident, while others thought he offered valuable insight into what the jockey was trying to do. Either way, as Chapman wrote in his column, the outcome of the probe will more than likely depend on what can be traced, if anything, to betting patterns around the race. Byrnes senior finally broke his silence on the incident and used the opportunity to hit out at those doubting his son. He said: "It's obvious what happened. "He was trying to get the mare to go in and pop it, because obviously she had the race won, and she came up out of his hands and blew him out of the saddle. "There's no one hurting more than Philip about it." All this came as new footage of the fall was shared online. The camera, looking down towards the post from the track, focused in on how Byrnes' feet left their irons. Viewing it on Racing TV on Sunday morning, former jockey Adam McNamara conceded it 'looks really bad'. He said: "I'm going to be pro-jockey by nature and perhaps it's naive of me, but I want to believe it was an unseat. "If it was something more sinister why wait until last to do it? "It looks really bad - I think it's a really bad bit of riding. "The jockey will say he should never have fallen off that." Stewards originally decided on the day that no further action would be taken over the incident. But it was only after a social media outcry that the IHRB confirmed it was being looked into. 1 The new footage from behind focused in how Byrnes' feet left his irons mid-jump FREE BETS - GET THE BEST SIGN UP DEALS AND RACING OFFERS Commercial content notice: Taking one of the offers featured in this article may result in a payment to The Sun. You should be aware brands pay fees to appear in the highest placements on the page. 18+. T&Cs apply. Remember to gamble responsibly A responsible gambler is someone who: Establishes time and monetary limits before playing Only gambles with money they can afford to lose Never chases their losses Doesn't gamble if they're upset, angry or depressed Gamcare – Gamble Aware – Find our detailed guide on responsible gambling practices here.
Daily Mirror
6 days ago
- Daily Mirror
Trainer breaks silence as son's controversial Redwood Queen fall is investigated
Charles and Philip Byrnes were among the winners on Saturday when former Ebor winner and favourite Sonnyboyliston scored at odds of 4-6 in a 2m½f maiden hurdle at Listowel Trainer Charles Byrnes has spoken out about his son's controversial final flight fall from their horse Redwood Queen. The Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board is investigating the incident that saw Philip Byrnes come off the mare in the closing stages of a claiming race at Wexford on Wednesday. A market drifter beforehand, Redwood Queen's departure gifted the race to odds on favourite Beacon Edge from Gordon Elliott's stable. On-course stewards took no action but the IHRB stepped in and said the matter would be looked at again by a senior official. Speaking to the Irish Times, Byrnes senior gave his view on what happened to the six-time winner, who will race on for new connections. "He (Philip) was trying to get the mare to go in and pop it, because obviously she had the race won, and she came up out of his hands and blew him out of the saddle," he said. There's no one hurting more than Philip about it." A head-on replay showed how Cathal Byrnes-owned Redwood Queen picked her feet up and jumped the obstacle high before Philip Byrnes loses his stirrups and exits to the right. The six-time scorer traded at 1.14 in-running, very short odds which summed up the likelihood of winning. Afterwards she was claimed by trainer Cian Collins for €6,000. A summary from the Racing post stated Redwood Queen was "going best 2 out, 2 lengths ahead when jockey unbalanced and unseated last." The Wexford stewards report viewed a recording of the race and took no further action, a decision which frustrated some punters. "We note the position of the raceday stewards following their review of the incident," an IHRB spokesperson said. "We can now confirm the matter is down for review by an IHRB senior racing official." On Saturday trainer and jockey sent their lightly-raced 2021 Ebor winner Sonnyboyliston to the track for his hurdles debut. Making only a third appearance for the stable, the eight-year-old went off at 4-6 after opening up at 6-4 on-course. Philip Byrnes drove him out after Listowel's last jump and the pair reeled in leader Dream Diamond, with Encosta finishing well to split the pair.
Daily Record
6 days ago
- Daily Record
Under fire jockey Philip Byrnes gets first winner since Wexford unseat controversy
Young jockey wins as Sonnyboyliston comes out swinging at Listowel Under-fire jockey Philip Byrnes has returned to the winners enclosure at Listowel after his controversial final-hurdle unseat at Wexford. The young pilot shot to the attention of punters and stewards in midweek after falling off a horse that looked certain to win. Byrnes was leading the Wexford Claiming Hurdle on Redwood Queen, who is trained by his father Charles, heading into the last obstacle before falling off in a fashion which sparked heated social-media and TV debate and has brought a review from Irish racing chiefs. The duo teamed-up, however, with Philip getting a first winner since the incident aboard ex-top Flat horse Sonnyboyliston in Listowel's Supporters Club Maiden Hurdle today. Winner of the 2021 Irish St Leger, the eight-year-old triumphed to please punters having been backed on-course from 6/4 to 4/6 favourite. On the Wednesday incident, the raceday stewards at Wexford felt no further action was required, but the Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board have since said the will review. A IHRB spokesperson said on Thursday: 'We note the position of the raceday stewards following their review of the incident. I can confirm the matter is down for review by an IHRB senior racing official.' The review will take into consideration the incident on the racecourse and other factors, such as betting patterns of the race. Redwood Queen had drifted from 7-2 to 13-2 in the betting odds and traded at 1.14 in running beforehand. The Wexford stewards report said: 'The raceday stewards reviewed the unseating of Philip Byrnes, rider of Redwood Queen, at the last hurdle when leading. Having viewed the recording of the race and considered the matter, the raceday stewards took no further action.' The incident sparked a tasty debate on Saturday morning's ITV Opening Show. Ex-jockey Mick Fitzgerald gave his view on the unseat as footage was shown to viewers and said: 'When you see it on the head-on angle, watch what happens, you'll see his foot come flying out of the stirrup and suddenly his balance has gone to the other side and then he's gone.' But fellow pundit Megan Nicholls, daughter of multiple-times champion trainer Paul, said: 'But Mick, you have to argue that, to watch that, it looks as if he's jumping off before the horse has basically taken off for the hurdle.' Speaking to The Irish Field on Friday, Charles Byrnes said he and Philip would be happy to co-operate with any investigation. Asked to explain what happened in the race, the trainer said: 'The mare was running well, going down to the last. Philip has had a couple of last fence falls recently so he wanted her to go in short, pop it and make doubly sure. But she came up out of his hands, hit him on the backside and he was knocked off balance. 'He is very upset about it and won't look at his phone. I was delighted he was able to go racing in Limerick the next day and he gave our two runners two good rides there. The other jockeys have been very supportive, to be fair to them. 'Philip is only 21 and I hope he can get over this setback. He is a good rider. He doesn't get many outside rides but anyone who has used him has been very happy with him. It's a sad day if the Turf Club has to hold an investigation to please these faceless people on social media. We will answer any questions they have. We have nothing to answer to.'
