Hearts 'cheated' out of penalty shootout by John Beaton as Gary Mackay urges Jambos to demand SFA answers
Beaton showed Cammy Devlin a second yellow card in extra time against Aberdeen after dismissing Michael Steinwender
Gary Mackay claims Hearts were "cheated" out of a penalty shootout with Aberdeen and has urged the club to demand answers form the SFA over John Beaton's performance.
Beaton showed sent Michael Steinwender off two minutes before the break after the Austrian wiped out Topi Keskinen, then flashed a second yellow at Cammy Devlin with just four minutes left of extra-time, after the Aussie caught Dante Polvara when attempting to make a clearance.
And the Dons took advantage to eventually find a way past nine-man Hearts when Oday Dabbagh scored the winner two minutes later to send Jimmy Thelin's side through to the final.
Jambos boss Neil Critchley was fuming with the whistler - who sent off his assistant Mike Garrity after the final whistle - and accused Beaton of lacking respect when he tried to question him.
And Hearts legend Mackay wants the Tynecastle hierarchy to ask the SFA to explain Beaton's display.
He said: 'You want the club to definitely make a stance and get in touch with SFA and demand some kind of explanation.
'If you've had three apologies this season (from the SFA) that could be costly and that's the difference between bottom six and top six.
'It also has a financial cost and the management team are viewed a wee bit less positively.
'I always remember my old Hearts boss Alex MacDonald saying about looking at yourself in the mirror at the end of every game, looking at yourself, your teammates and thinking 'I gave it my best'.
'I'm not sure John Beaton could look himself in the mirror after that on Saturday and I'm sure there's other times and there are things.
'We can't as a football club just bow to this guy, I think the players were cheated out of a penalty shootout opportunity.
'These professionals will maybe never get that opportunity again because of somebody's ineptitude."
Mackay points to the stats of games Beaton has refereed Hearts in and reckons they tell a story compared to other teams.
According to data from transfermarkt.co.uk, Beaton has overseen 58 Hearts games and the Gorgie side have won 19, drawn seven and lost 32.
He has also issued some 151 yellows but compared to Celtic and Aberdeen, who he has refereed 59 and 54 times he has only used 84 and 117 cautions respectively
Club record appearance holder Mackay added: 'From a footballing perspective we need to make it noted.
'You look at the stats for the games John Beaton has refereed, how many we have won, lost and drawn and the amount of bookings and red cards.
"We cannot allow these things to continue to happen and particularly if it's an individual who seems to get a lot of Hearts games.
"It's mind-boggling, 151 yellow cards.
"What Heart of Midlothian Football Club need to do is say to (Scottish FA chief executive) Ian Maxwell, 'are these numbers what you would be expecting from a referee refereeing in these amount of games?'.
'It's the players I feel for because so many players left every single thing on the pitch on Saturday and they could look at themselves in the mirror after the game and say, yep they gave it their best shot.
"But then I look at the referee and as a spectacle for the Hearts fans and players it was ruined by one individual.'
Tune in to Hotline Live every Sunday to Thursday and have your say on the biggest issues in Scottish football and listen to Record Sport's newest podcast, Game On, every Friday for your sporting fix, all in bitesize chunks.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
5 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
George Russell mocks Max Verstappen after beating F1 rival to Canadian GP pole
Max Verstappen was denied pole for the Canadian Grand Prix by George Russell who made it clear he thinks he has an advantage over the Red Bull racer at the first corner on Sunday George Russell secured pole in Montreal for the second successive year with a mighty lap which denied Max Verstappen. And the Brit reacted by cracking a joke at the Dutchman's expense with Verstappen just one penalty point away from a race ban after their collision in Barcelona two weeks ago. Aware of that, Russell said he felt confident about going into the first corner wheel to wheel with the four-time Formula 1 champion tonight. "I've got a few more points on my licence to play with," he smirked, drawing some cheers but also audible boos from fans in the stands at the Circuit Gilles Villeneuve. Verstappen had knocked championship leader Oscar Piastri off the top of the leaderboard but then Russell snatched his sixth career pole. The Brit said: "To be honest that last lap was probably one of the most exhilarating laps of my life. "I got into the last corner and I was six tenths up and I was like, 'This lap is mighty'. Crossing the line and seeing we were P1 was a real surprise, but I was so chuffed with it." Russell had whooped with delight over the radio after his pole was confirmed and shouted: "What a f****** lap!" Speaking on Sky Sports, 2016 World champion with Mercedes Nico Rosberg said: "We just witnessed something very, very special. This is amazing. That car is not supposed to be that far in front. Hats off." Verstappen will have the advantage of starting on the cleaner side of the track but said: "I would always pick P1 because you start a little bit more forward, but it's fine. We'll see what we can do tomorrow. READ MORE: F1 stewards issue statement as Red Bull's Yuki Tsunoda handed massive Canadian GP penalty READ MORE: Nico Rosberg calls out Danica Patrick live on Sky Sports F1 – 'I have to disagree' "I'm already very happy with what we achieved today, to be on the front row and hopefully tomorrow we can have a solid race. I felt quite good all weekend and the car was in a good window. Overall, I'm very happy with qualifying. I think the car was again working quite well." Championship leader Piastri has four poles to his name this year but had to settle for third place on the grid. He was still pleased, though, no doubt made to feel better by the fact team-mate and title rival Lando Norris was way down in seventh having struggled throughout qualifying. The Aussie said: "To be honest, after how practice went I'm really happy with myself at the moment. It was a nice turnaround. I'm pretty happy with third, which is a bit different this year but I'll definitely take it here." But a glum Norris said: "Not ideal! Too many mistakes, and I hit the wall in the last lap. The car felt good today, I just made too many mistakes." Lewis Hamilton matched his best Grand Prix qualifying result of 2025 so far by going fifth fastest for Ferrari, behind rookie Kimi Antonelli. But team-mate Charles Leclerc got stuck in dirty air on his final lap having set the quickest first sector time and had to settle for just eighth.
Scottish Sun
8 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Callum McGregor took fan fireworks fears direct to Celtic chiefs after Rangers clash
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) IAN MAXWELL thinks that footballers in Scotland can help the football association in cracking down on fan behaviour issues. This comes as the chief joined the BBC Sportsound team on Saturday afternoon to address Scottish footballing issues. 2 Celtic fan with homemade rocket launcher at the 2022/23 Viaplay cup final 2 Ian Maxwell revealed that Callum McGregor, pictured here with Celtic chief Michael Nicholson, had spoken direct to the Celtic board over the matter Credit: SNS On the show, Maxwell said: "Rangers played Celtic at Hampden [in 2023] and there was a lot of fireworks. 'There was a video online and a guy had a rocket. They are finding ingenious ways to get these things into grounds. 'I spoke to the Celtic board after it and one of them said Callum McGregor had gone to them and said that was the first time the players had actually talked about something coming onto the pitch. 'At that point you go; 'I think we need to use the players'. 'The players are a fundamental part of trying to impact on that behaviour because with the best will in the world myself or Neil Doncaster or someone else saying 'go and not do that' just makes people want to do it. 'But if players are going to supporters and saying 'you are affecting our performance, you are getting in our heads, I'm worried when I'm taking a corner' then that is a positive message. 'The more we can use that player platform to spread that message and make people aware of the danger then the better. 'It's a player's place of work and it's not right they are taking a corner and there's all sorts raining down beside them.' There has been multiple fan incident's across the season. Most include pyrotechnic use, but we also saw Aberdeen defender Jack MacKenzie struck in the head by a chair from his own fans on the last day of the season. Shock moment Aberdeen star hit with seat thrown from own fans after rivals' pitch invasion Ticket reductions, and the threat of such action, is the route the governing body is taking to try and clamp down on these fan issues. Maxwell added: 'The ticket reduction is the next step. It's a fundamental step. 'We will see how that goes. Hopefully that has the impact. "If it doesn't and we need to look at something else, we will see what the options are at that point.' Keep up to date with ALL the latest news and transfers at the Scottish Sun football page
Daily Record
12 hours ago
- Daily Record
Callum McGregor took fears over yobs directly to Celtic board as SFA chief makes weighty plea to players
The SFA chief admits his voice or Neil Doncaster's won't cut through but Premiership stars sharing their fears holds more power Ian Maxwell has called on the country's top players to help clean up the 'unacceptable' increase in fan misbehaviour across Scottish football. The SFA chief has revealed Callum McGregor had approached the Celtic board with concerns over missiles being thrown onto the park two years ago. And Maxwell reckons more players speaking out directly to the culprits would have a far greater effect than the blazers themselves enforcing the rules. Hampden beaks last week updated their regulations to bring them into line with the SPFL and allow them to fine clubs, reduce ticket allocations or even throw them out the Scottish Cup for disorder in the stands. The past season has seen multiple incidents of pyrotechnics and fireworks, missiles and pitch invasions. The worst case saw former Aberdeen defender Jack MacKenzie struck on the head and injured by a chair thrown by his own fans in the defeat at Dundee United on the last day of the season. And recalling an incident from 2023, Maxwell said: ' Rangers played Celtic at Hampden and there was a lot of fireworks. 'There was a video online and a guy had a rocket. They are finding ingenious ways to get these things into grounds. 'I spoke to the Celtic board after it and one of them said Callum McGregor had gone to them and said that was the first time the players had actually talked about something coming onto the pitch. 'At that point you go.. I think we need to use the players. 'The players are a fundamental part of trying to impact on that behaviour because with the best will in the world myself or Neil Doncaster or someone else saying 'gonna not do that' just makes people want to do it. 'But if players are going to supporters and saying 'you are affecting our performance, you are getting in our heads, I'm worried when I'm taking a corner' then that is na positive message. 'The more we can use that player platform to spread that message and make people aware of the danger then the better. 'It's a player's place of work and it's not right they are taking a corner and there's all sorts raining down beside them.' Both sides of the Old Firm have been hit by ticket reductions from the SPFL for their next League Cup match at Hampden after their fans continually flouted rules over pyrotechnics last season. Motherwell were also hit with a suspended sanction. It comes after the League Cup semi final kick offs were delayed due to smoke billowing round the national stadium. Celtic were also sweating on an away fan ban ahead of their Champions League blockbuster against Bayern Munich in Germany after being hit with a number of fines by UEFA. But there were instances of fan disorder across the country and Maxwell said: 'Towards the end of last season we saw more and more and it's unacceptable. 'We need to eradicate it. 'We approved a rule change at our AGM through the week from a cup competition perspective which brings them more in line with SPFL rules. 'The nuance to this is in a league match the SPFL deal with incidents of crowd behaviour and we deal with on-field stuff. If it's a cup competition it all sits under our jurisdiction. 'So we will deal with incidents of crowd behaviour and it's important that both governing bodies are dealing with those things exactly the same.' But Maxwell believes the country's law makers can do more to help crack down on the hooligans too. He added: 'If someone is going to go into a stadium and throw a seat what can we do about that? It's a criminal act by an absolute idiot. 'The first thing we need to do is identify individuals, that involves police, stewards inside the stadium, then once we've done that are we taking action as the football authority? But there's also the criminal element and they need to go through that. 'The banning order legislation needs to be changed to have some sort of consequence or people will just continue to do what they do. Asked if points deductions would be the next step, Maxwell, speaking on BBC Sportsound, added: 'The ticket reduction is the next step. It's a fundament step. 'We will see how that goes. Hopefully that has the impact. If it doesn't and we need to look at something else, we will see what the options are at that point.'
