Motherwell majority shareholder: VAR makes fan experience 'significantly worse', as call made for wider debate on technology
It comes as a majority of fans expressed their frustrations over the technology in a recent survey
Motherwell's majority shareholder has called for a wider discussion over VAR in Scottish football after none of their members backed the technology in its current form during a consultation.
Fans were almost equally split on whether VAR should be scrapped immediately or "fundamentally reformed" but none of the supporters who took part in the Well Society survey felt VAR should remain unchanged. Less than one per cent were "unsure".
A total of 63 per cent of respondents said they did not support VAR in Scottish football while 60 per cent said the use of the video technology had made their experience as a supporter "significantly worse".
A Well Society statement read: "Fans spoke about long delays, a lack of clear communication, inconsistent decisions, and a growing sense of disconnect between those in the stands and those officiating on the pitch.
"Rather than building trust in decisions, many feel VAR has done the opposite, creating more distance between supporters and the game itself.
"Some still see potential for technology to play a role in football, if used in the right way. But the overwhelming feeling from our fan base is that VAR, as it stands in Scotland, is simply not working. A system designed to bring clarity has, for many, only added more confusion."
The use of video technology to aid match officials was brought into the Premiership in October 2022 and a number of managers have expressed their frustration over its implementation since then.
Well Society director David Cullinan added: "As a fan-owned club, we have a duty to listen. This wasn't about grabbing attention. It was about listening to what our supporters really think. And they've made it clear that VAR, as things stand, is letting them down.
"The Society will be taking their views on board and working on a plan of action, which we'll share with members in due course.
"This is just the start of a wider discussion, and we're calling on clubs across Scotland to stand with their supporters and be part of it."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
35 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Motherwell star who downed Rangers turns down new contract at Fir Park
The Steelmen have said farewell to Irish defender Dan Casey Motherwell has announced defender Dan Casey has turned down a new deal at Fir Park and will be pursuing a move down south. The Irishman has spent the past two-and-a-half years with the Steelmen and netted a historic goal for the club last year when they defeated Rangers at Ibrox to claim Motherwell's first win in Govan since 1997. Casey was also part of the Motherwell side that repeated that feat with a win in Glasgow in March this year. The Steelmen are currently on the hunt for a new manager after Michael Wimmer's shock departure last month and Casey won't be hanging around ML1 to see who will replace him. A club statement from Motherwell read: "After offering Casey a contract at Fir Park, the Irish centre-back has decided to pursue options down in England. "Casey arrived in February 2023 on a short-term deal, but after impressing quickly, he signed a two-year deal that summer. "Since then, he has played 85 times for the club, scoring seven times. One of those goals was the winner at Ibrox in 2024, which secured Motherwell's first win in Govan since 1997. "A constant in the side last season, Casey racked up the most minutes played of any player in the squad. "The club would like to thank Dan for his efforts and dedication in his time at Motherwell and wish him nothing but the best for the future."
Daily Record
35 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Celtic book medical for striker as Kyogo set for emotional homecoming
The Scottish champions are beginning to motor ahead with the transfer plans Teenage Fulham striker Callum Osmand could become one of Celtic 's first summer signings. Brendan Rodgers is in the market for attacking reinforcements after losing promising starlet Daniel Cummings to West Ham. The Hoops have also yet to sign a replacement for Japanese goal machine Kyogo, who departed the club for Rennes in January. Now, CeltsAreHere reports that the Scottish champions are on the verge of landing rising Welsh star Osmand from Craven Cottage. It's claimed that a medical has already been booked for the 19-year-old who has caught the eye of Parkhead scouts. Osmand - who netted 10 goals in 17 Premier League 2 appearances last season - is out-of-contract at Fulham, meaning the Double-winners will be able to land him for a modest cross-border compensation fee. Barring any medical hitches, the talented goalscorer is expected to join Celtic's senior squad for pre-season, giving Rodgers a chance to take a closer look. Meanwhile, former Celtic idol Kyogo is back on holiday in his homeland and is set for an emotional return to former club Vissel Kobe. Kyogo has endured a miserable spell in France since his shock £10million winter move to Rennes, failing to score in six appearances. He's found himself bombed out under new boss Habib Beye and has already been deemed surplus to requirements by the Ligue 1 club. That's led to inevitable rumours of a quick-fire return to Glasgow, but it's unlikely Rodgers will sanction a return for the fans' favourite. Bournemouth have also been linked with his services, but for now, Kyogo will make an appearance in familiar territory this weekend. It's been announced that the 30-year-old will be in the stands for Vissel Kobe vs Nagoya Grampus on Sunday and will greet the fans in a special half-time bow at the Noevir Stadium Kobe. Elsewhere, reports in Greece suggest that Greg Taylor's switch to PAOK is far from a done deal. Multiple stories on Monday suggested that Taylor had agreed a two-year deal with the option of an additional 12 months to join the Greek outfit. Taylor is currently a free agent after talks over a new deal at Celtic Park hit the skids. The Scotland international, 27, is holidaying in Dubai with his family and SDNA claims PAOK are no further forward in their pursuit of the left-back, with talks said to be "frozen".
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Lam to be at Bears for 'foreseeable'
Director of rugby Pat Lam will be at Bristol Bears for the "foreseeable" says club chief operating officer Tom Tainton. Lam has been linked with the Wales head coaching role but is under contract at the Premiership club until 2028. Bristol were beaten 34-20 by Bath on Friday night as they fell one match short of reaching their first Premiership final. "I think it's testament to what Pat has achieved here at Bristol Bears that he's in the conversation," Tainton told BBC Radio Bristol."In terms of that Wales role I can say with absolute confidence that Pat Lam is contracted to Bristol Bears and will stay that way. "We know that there is a lot that we have still got to achieve for the remainder of his contract up until 2028."I'm certainly happy to say that Pat is going to be at Bristol Bears for the foreseeable." Lam has been with the Bears since 2017, taking them to promotion from the Championship during his first season in charge. They topped the Premiership table in 2021 and this season is the third time they have reached the play-offs. However, the club are still to reach a Twickenham final or win any silverware. The 56-year-old said following defeat at the Recreation Ground that he was "excited" by the prospect of next season and that he has lost no motivation to continue pushing for a title with added: "[The] ambition is for us to be at the top table of domestic and European rugby and the ambition is for us to win silverware." 'Intentionally gone with smaller squad' Bristol have just 31 players on their books for 2025-26 - a reduction on this season by seven players - and an additional 19 in their senior back Tom Jordan, winger Max Pepper and second row Pedro Rubiolo are the headline signings but Tainton said the club had made a decision to cut back on numbers."At the moment and where we've been over the past 18 months, we think that it's right that we cut our cloth accordingly, we put our focus and our energy and time into young players," Tainton said. "We've intentionally gone with a smaller squad, we've trusted in our academy and those young players."It's really bore fruit for us this year and we want to be a club that gives opportunities to homegrown players."We believe that we have a squad next season that is more than capable of competing for the top four, as this group has done this year." Tainton pointed to the development of homegrown players such as prop George Kloska and second rows Joe Batley and Joe Owen as evidence their strategy was working and helping the club progress."I'm really proud of the brand of rugby that we play, I'm really proud of some of the results that we've had, particularly away from home this season and who can forget the result against Leicester Tigers in December - and I think we can reflect and say there's been genuine progress for Bristol Bears this season."
