Karen Read trial testimony ends with defense expert dismantling Lexus crash allegation
Karen Read's defense saved her strongest witness for last, experts tell Fox News Digital, bringing in Dr. Andrew Rentschler to try to debunk the prosecution's claims about how her boyfriend, Boston cop John O'Keefe, died.
Jurors have the day off Thursday and will begin deliberations after receiving instructions from the judge and listening to closing arguments Friday.
Read, 45, is accused of hitting O'Keefe, 46, with her 2021 Lexus LX 570 SUV on Jan. 29, 2022, and leaving him to die on the ground with a skull fracture during a blizzard.
Her defense denies that her vehicle ever struck O'Keefe, and Rentschler spent two days on the stand explaining how he came to the conclusion that O'Keefe's injuries were inconsistent with a vehicle strike on a pedestrian.
'I do not believe that injury is consistent with being struck by an SUV at approximately 24 miles an hour,' he testified.
O'Keefe had no broken bones on his right arm, only superficial abrasions, he testified. Based on his testing at ARCCA, a crash reconstruction firm, he said that the arm should have sustained more serious damage.
5 Crash reconstruction expert Dr. Andrew Rentschler served as the last witness for the defense in Karen Read's case.
AP
Rentschler said he did not believe Read's SUV could have struck O'Keefe based on his injuries and ARCCA testing.
But special prosecutor Hank Brennan grilled him on cross-examination, questioning how thorough his testing was and forcing him to concede that he did not take into account shattered pieces of taillight on the ground near O'Keefe and embedded in his clothes.
'The prosecutor will definitely zero-in on this in closing,' said David Gelman, a Philadelphia-area criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor. 'The closings will be key for both parties now. Brennan and [defense attorney Alan] Jackson are both strong personalities, so this is going to be big.'
Brennan also revealed Wednesday afternoon that he will not call a rebuttal witness to the stand before the case goes to jurors.
In what could boil down to a so-called battle of the experts, legal analysts say Rentschler was a solid choice to close out the case.
5 Karen Read talked with her defense team before the start of court on Wednesday.
AP
'He methodically explained why the DA's theory of an SUV-pedestrian strike doesn't hold up,' said Mark Bederow, the New York City-based attorney representing Read ally and Canton blogger Aidan Kearney. 'The lack of arm injuries, the lack of holes in the hoodie, which doesn't come close to corresponding with the amount abrasions, the final location of John O'Keefe not making sense.'
He argued that Rentschler's showing could have prompted Brennan to 'wave the white flag' rather than call Dr. Judson Welcher back to the stand for rebuttal.
Welcher drew the opposite conclusion from Rentschler – testifying that in his opinion, Read's SUV clipped O'Keefe with a glancing blow, knocking him off-balance before he fell and cracked his skull.
5 A still image from an ARCCA reconstruction test showed an SUV taillight shattering during the Karen Read retrial.
AP
5 Dr. Rentschler does not believe that O'Keefe was hit by a car.
AP
'The defense could not have finished the trial any stronger than they did,' Bederow said.
Jack Lu, a retired Massachusetts judge and Boston College law professor, said having Rentschler go last was both a standard strategy and a good one.
'What stood out is that he was steadfast that Dr. Welcher's testimony about simulating the contact was fallacious. Counterpoint: so was Rentschler's,' Lu told Fox News Digital.
5 Dr. Rentschler was cross-examined by special prosecutor Hank Brennan during the Karen Read retrial on Wednesday.
AP
He said both are part of a profit-based consulting industry and at points, their testing came across as absurd.
'You have a disembodied arm hitting a Lexus, versus a grease-painted expert getting hit at low speed by a Lexus,' he said.
Cannone gave jurors the day off Thursday so the sides can hold a charging conference.
The panel returns Friday for jury instructions and closing arguments.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
20 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Karen Read trial nears its finale: What each side is banking on
With closing arguments scheduled for Friday morning, jurors will soon begin deliberating Karen Read's fate after 31 days of testimony in her second trial over the death of Boston cop John O'Keefe, her former boyfriend. Read, 45, is accused of clipping the 46-year-old outside a house party and leaving him to die on the ground during a blizzard on Jan. 29, 2022. Her defense denies that a collision ever happened, suggesting he was attacked by someone at the party and a dog instead. Judge Beverly Cannone denied the defense's second motion for a finding of not guilty Thursday – clearing the way for deliberations to begin. The following includes core evidence presented by both the prosecution and the defense. Karen Read Announces She Will Not Testify In Her Defense As Massachusetts Trial Nears Conclusion Taillight fragments in O'Keefe's clothes Experts say a glancing vehicle strike caused O'Keefe to fall on the back of his head Phone data aligns with prosecution timeline Read's alleged, repeated statements, "I hit him. I hit him. I hit him." Read's many public statements played in court Karen Read Murder Trial Reaches Final Stage With Closing Arguments Set For Friday Read On The Fox News App Former Whitey Bulger defense lawyer turned special prosecutor Hank Brennan, derided as a "mob lawyer" by Read's vocal supporters, came in to take over the case after last year's mistrial. Assistant Norfolk County District Attorneys Adam Lally and Laura McLaughlin returned from the first trial. Central to Brennan's case is that O'Keefe had plastic fragments that matched Read's taillight embedded in his clothes. Dr. Aizik Wolf, a renowned brain surgeon, said O'Keefe's injury is consistent with a "classic" fall backward on frozen ground. And a biomechanist named Dr. Judson Welcher testified that Read likely hit him with a glancing blow to the right arm and sent him stumbling backward before he cracked his head on the lawn at 34 Fairview Road in Canton, where he was found under a pile of snow hours later. Follow The Fox True Crime Team On X Final Defense Witness In Karen Read Trial Pumps Brakes On Lexus Collision Theory And in Read's own alleged words, she repeatedly said, "I hit him. I hit him. I hit him." The timing of Jennifer McCabe's Google search – "hos long to die in cold" – is another key factor, according to Paul Mauro, a retired NYPD inspector who is following the case. "If at 6:23 a.m., it corroborates Jen McCabe's testimony," he told Fox News Digital. "If you believe Jen McCabe, you pretty much have to convict. You could perhaps acquit on the top charge, but certainly you would have to convict on the manslaughter." Read asserts the crash never happened The Bowden defense – investigation was too sloppy to be adequate, and the lead detective got fired Experts say dog bites caused arm injuries, head injury did not happen on lawn and no signs of hypothermia Brennan's reference to holes in O'Keefe's hoodie that were put there by crime lab Sign Up To Get The True Crime Newsletter Read's legal team includes big-city lawyers from three states – Boston's David Yannetti, New York City's Robert Alessi, and Alan Jackson and Elizabeth Little from Los Angeles. In her first trial, Yannetti and Jackson argued that Read had been "framed" by local and state police. This time around, they focused on the theory that Read's 2021 Lexus LX 570 SUV never struck O'Keefe. They also deployed a "Bowden defense" – attempting to show the police investigation was "inadequate." Investigators collected evidence in red Solo cups and shopping bags, used a leaf blower to move snow, mislabeled evidence and did not seek a search warrant for the house at the address where they recovered O'Keefe's remains. Former Massachusetts State Trooper Michael Proctor, a homicide detective on the case, later lost his job for sharing confidential and law enforcement sensitive information on an R-rated text chain that also included lewd remarks about the defendant. GET REAL-TIME UPDATES DIRECTLY ON THE True Crime Hub Defense experts testified that the minor abrasions on O'Keefe's right arm were not caused by contact with Read's broken taillight, but rather by dog or animal bites. Dr. Daniel Wolfe and Dr. Andrew Rentschler disputed Welcher's findings with testing of their own, using a crash dummy arm that they said could not reproduce the same damage to a Lexus taillight. The blow to the back of his head – which fractured his skull – did not come from contact on the frozen lawn, but rather by contact with a ridged, grainy surface, according to Dr. Elizabeth Laposata, a forensic pathologist and clinical professor at Brown University. Laposata also disputed autopsy findings that indicated O'Keefe had hypothermia – testifying that his internal injuries came from resuscitation attempts and not damage from the cold. "The defense case is science, science and then more science," said Mark Bederow, a New York City attorney representing Read ally and Canton blogger Aidan Kearney. "No car accident, then no crime." Read faces 15 years to life in prison if convicted on the top charge. If convicted of drunken driving manslaughter, she would face 5 to article source: Karen Read trial nears its finale: What each side is banking on
Yahoo
35 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Georgia state officer accused of leaking sensitive information in drug investigation
The Brief Kenneth Rankin, a Georgia state community supervision officer, was arrested for leaking sensitive law enforcement information related to a Tennessee drug investigation. Rankin was charged with computer theft and violation of oath of office, following a multi-agency investigation led by the Georgia Bureau of Investigation. The investigation is ongoing, with additional charges anticipated, and will be handed over to the Lookout Mountain Judicial Circuit District Attorney's Office for prosecution. LAFAYETTE, Ga. - A Georgia state community supervision officer has been arrested for allegedly leaking sensitive law enforcement information to a suspect tied to a Tennessee drug investigation, officials said Thursday. What we know The Georgia Bureau of Investigation said Kenneth Rankin, 52, of the Georgia Department of Community Supervision, was arrested June 10 in LaFayette and charged with computer theft and violation of oath of office. He was booked into the Walker County Jail. Authorities said Rankin illegally disseminated official data to a suspect involved in a narcotics investigation that originated in Hamilton County, Tennessee. The GBI launched its probe in May after being contacted by the Soddy Daisy Police Department, which uncovered information suggesting related criminal activity in Georgia. The GBI's West Metro Regional Drug Enforcement Office led the Georgia-based investigation, with support from the agency's Calhoun Regional Investigative Office and the Georgia Department of Community Supervision. The multi-agency investigation also involved the Soddy Daisy Police Department, Tennessee Bureau of Investigation, Hamilton County Sheriff's Office, FBI field offices in Chattanooga and Dalton, and the Lookout Mountain Judicial Circuit District Attorney's Office. What we don't know The GBI said the investigation is ongoing and additional charges are expected. What's next Once the case is complete, it will be turned over to the Lookout Mountain Judicial Circuit District Attorney's Office for prosecution. The Source The Georgia Bureau of Investigation provided the details for this article.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
2 men sentenced for drug trafficking in Monongalia County
MORGANTOWN, (WBOY) — Two men will spend several years behind bars after they were found guilty of their roles in a Morgantown drug operation. According to a release from the U.S. Department of Justice, Jason Davis, 35, of Youngstown, Ohio, will spend 11 years, 3 months in prison after court documents said he and James Peoples II, 28, of Pennsauken Township, New Jersey, worked to distribute drugs in Morgantown. Peoples will serve six years in prison. Former Buckhannon mayor sentenced on child porn charge Both Davis and Peoples were indicted in February 2024 alongside 23 others for their roles in a Philadelphia-based drug ring that operated in Morgantown. The case was investigated by the Mon Metro Drug Task Force, which is made up of members of the FBI; the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives; the Drug Enforcement Administration; the West Virginia State Police; the Monongalia County Sheriff's Office; the Monongalia County Prosecuting Attorney's Office; the Morgantown Police Department; the WVU Police Department; the Granville Police Department; and the Star City Police Department. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
