Brazil Must Abandon 'Marco Temporal' Doctrine Once And For All, Says UN Expert
GENEVA (11 June 2025) – A UN expert today expressed grave concern about Brazil's continued use of the controversial 'Marco Temporal' legal interpretation to revoke the legal foundation for indigenous land demarcation and annul the demarcation of indigenous territories in Santa Catarina.
'This legislative move enforces the discredited 'Marco Temporal' doctrine, which restricts Indigenous land rights to territories physically and permanently occupied as of 5 October 1988, the date of Brazil's current Constitution,' said Albert Kwokwo Barume, Special Rapporteur on the rights of Indigenous Peoples.
Brazil's Senate has approved Legislative Decree No. 717/2024, which seeks to revoke the legal foundation for Indigenous land demarcation and annul the demarcation of the Toldo Imbu and Morro dos Cavalos Indigenous Territories in Santa Catarina. The Bill is now before the Chamber of Deputies.
'This is a deeply regressive step that undermines Indigenous Peoples' rights, environmental protection, and climate action, I urge lawmakers not to approve the Bill,' the expert said.
The Supreme Federal Court of Brazil has already declared the Marco Temporal thesis unconstitutional. Despite this, the proposed decree threatens to hamper the work of the Fundação Nacional dos Povos Indígenas (FUNAI), which plays a vital role in the demarcation of Indigenous lands.
'This is the fourth time in four years that the Special Rapporteur on the rights of Indigenous peoples has raised public alarm over this issue,' Barume said, recalling statements issued in 2021, 2023 and 2024. 'It has also been the subject of formal communications with the Brazilian Government and should be of grave concern to the international community.'
The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights has also issued warnings against the Marco Temporal thesis, which violates international treaties such as ILO Convention 169 and contradicts the jurisprudence of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights.
'Marco Temporal not only undermines legal certainty and Indigenous land rights—it also fuels rural violence and environmental degradation,' Barume said. 'It threatens Indigenous Peoples' security, health and cultural practices, contributing to a slow and painful process that could lead to their extermination.'
'I urge Brazil to abandon the Marco Temporal once and for all. As UN Secretary-General António Guterres has stated, Indigenous Peoples' rights are non-negotiable.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
8 hours ago
- Scoop
DR Congo Crisis: Aid Teams Appeal For Support To Help Displaced Communities Left With Nothing
13 June 2025 Since the beginning of the year, Rwanda-backed M23 fighters have swept across eastern DRC, taking key cities including Goma and Bukavu. The violence has displaced more than one million people in Ituri, North Kivu and South Kivu provinces. Speaking from the village of Sake in North Kivu, UNDP Resident Representative Damien Mama described meeting a woman whose house had been destroyed after she fled the advancing fighters in January. Cut off from livelihoods 'You know, with five children, you can imagine what this represents,' Mr. Mama said. 'She was telling me that [her family] were given food and temporary shelter; but what she needs is to go back to her farm to continue farming, to continue her activities, and also have her home rebuilt.' All those newly displaced by the M23 rebel advance are in addition to the five million people already living in displacement camps in eastern DRC. Health workers have repeatedly warned that the crowded and unsanitary conditions provide ideal conditions for the spread of diseases including mpox, cholera and measles. Given the scale of need it is urgent that small businesses get the help they need to get up and running again 'providing income-generating activities for the women and the youth creating jobs', the UNDP official insisted. 'The economy has suffered a lot,' he explained. ' The banks have closed, businesses have been destroyed, and many are now operating under 30 per cent of their capacity, which is a major blow to their businesses.' Support for women and girls At the same time, the UN agency remains committed to helping the many women and girls impacted by alarming levels of sexual violence. This echoes an alert issued last month by the UN Children's Fund (UNICEF), that during the most intense phase of this year's conflict, a child was raped every half an hour. In the next five months, UNDP intends to support the creation of 1,000 jobs and restore basic infrastructure, benefiting about 15,000 people. To do this, the UN agency will need $25 million. 'We have so far secured $14 million thanks to [South] Korea, Canada, UK as well as Sweden; and our call will be to encourage other countries and donors to provide us with [the] $11 million gap.'
Scoop
8 hours ago
- Scoop
‘The Answer Is Us': Global Indigenous Congress Issues Urgent Call Ahead Of COP30
12 June Indigenous Peoples and Local Communities from the world's major tropical forest regions have released a powerful new declaration from their First Global Congress, held in Brazzaville, Republic of Congo. The declaration outlines urgent demands ahead of COP30 — including land rights, direct climate finance, and protection for environmental defenders — and calls for Indigenous leadership to be centered in global climate and biodiversity solutions. Below are several quotes from the Congress: 'We are tired of false solutions and initiatives disconnected from our ways of life and the realities in our territories,' said Sonia Guajajara, Minister of Indigenous Peoples of Brazil. 'The time has come to invest in innovative mechanisms that treat us as partners, not beneficiaries. The answer is us.' 'Countries must recognize historical injustices; it's important to enshrine this in a legal code,' said Albert K. Barume, United Nations Special Rapporteur on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. 'As an act of recognition and protection, the right to self-determination and traditional authorities must be recognized.' 'This Congress is historic because, for the first time, we have united as Indigenous Peoples and Local Communities from the world's three great forest basins to defend our rights, our territories, our cultures, and our identities,' said Joseph Itongwa, coordinator of the The Network of Indigenous and Local Populations for the Sustainable Management of Forest Ecosystems in Central Africa (REPALEAC). 'Even where laws are weak or unenforced, we see strong local commitment. We urge countries like the Republic of Congo and others in Central Africa that have ratified key conventions to put them into action — our rights must be recognized based on the evidence we have provided. We must continue working every day to secure legal recognition, the demarcation of our lands, and respect for our traditional knowledge, which protects the 50% of biodiversity that still remains intact.' 'This is not just about money; it is about friendship and solidarity. The answer is us. All of us,' said Rukka Sombolinggi, Secretary General of the Indigenous Peoples Alliance of the Archipelago (AMAN) in Indonesia. 'Let's walk together and create a better funding environment for all Indigenous Peoples and Local Communities. We have our mechanisms already, let's test them out!' 'I believe this Congress will contribute to reinforcing the partnership between governments, donors, strategic allies, and the Indigenous People and Local Communities' rights movement,' said Dr. Solange Bandiaky-Badji, Coordinator and President of the Rights and Resources Initiative (RRI). 'We have to work together; we have to work in partnership and to support one another, because ensuring Indigenous Peoples and Local Communities legal recognition will contribute to not just their prosperity but to peace and stability in all countries.'
Scoop
8 hours ago
- Scoop
Number Of People Uprooted By War At Shocking, Decade-High Levels
GENEVA – The number of people displaced by war, violence and persecution worldwide is untenably high, particularly as humanitarian funding evaporates, with the only bright spot being a pickup in returns, notably to Syria, UNHCR, the UN Refugee Agency, said today. According to UNHCR's annual Global Trends Report released today, there were 122.1 million forcibly displaced people by the end of April 2025, up from 120 million at the same time last year, representing around a decade of year-on-year increases in the number of refugees and others forced to flee their homes. The main drivers of displacement remain large conflicts like Sudan, Myanmar and Ukraine and the continued failure to stop the fighting. Filippo Grandi, UN High Commissioner for Refugees, said: 'We are living in a time of intense volatility in international relations, with modern warfare creating a fragile, harrowing landscape marked by acute human suffering. We must redouble our efforts to search for peace and find long-lasting solutions for refugees and others forced to flee their homes.' Forcibly displaced people include people displaced within their own country by conflict, which grew sharply by 6.3 million to 73.5 million at the end of 2024, and refugees fleeing their countries (42.7 million people). Sudan is now the world's largest forced displacement situation with 14.3 million refugees and IDPs, replacing Syria (13.5 million), and followed by Afghanistan (10.3 million) and Ukraine (8.8 million). The report found that, contrary to widespread perceptions in wealthier regions, 67 per cent of refugees stay in neighbouring countries, and with low and middle-income countries host 73 per cent of the world's refugees. Indeed, 60 per cent of people forced to flee never leave their own country. While the number of forcibly displaced people has almost doubled in the last decade, funding for UNHCR now stands at roughly the same level as in 2015 amid brutal and ongoing cuts in humanitarian aid. This situation is untenable, leaving refugees and others fleeing danger even more vulnerable. 'Even amid the devastating cuts, we have seen some rays of hope over the last six months,' Grandi added. 'Nearly two million Syrians have been able to return home after over a decade uprooted. The country remains fragile and people need our help to rebuild their lives again.' In total, 9.8 million forcibly displaced people returned home in 2024, including 1.6 million refugees (the most for more than 2 decades) and 8.2 million IDPs (the second highest ever). Many of these returns, however, happened in an adverse political or security climate. For example, a large number of Afghans were forced to return to Afghanistan in 2024, arriving home in desperate conditions. In countries like the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Myanmar, and South Sudan, there were significant new forced displacements at the same time as the return of refugees and IDPs. The report calls for continuing funding of UNHCR programmes that save lives, assist refugees and IDPs returning home and reinforce basic infrastructure and social services in host communities, as an essential investment to regional and global security.
