Patience wears thin as 'Please Call Me' case still awaits a decision
Constitutional Court delays judgment in landmark Nkosana Makate vs Vodacom case
Image: Facebook
Those close to the matter say that their patience is wearing thin as the Constitutional Court has yet to reach a decision on the much anticipated judgment in the historic Nkosana Makate vs Vodacom case.
Six months after the court heard the landmark 'Please Call Me' matter, South Africans are still no closer to knowing when it will finally reach its conclusion raising concerns over judicial efficiency and the impact of such delays on ordinary citizens.
The dispute dates back to 2000 and revolves around Makate's innovative idea of revolutionising mobile communication in South Africa.
As an employee at Vodacom, Makate proposed the 'Please Call Me' service, which allowed users to notify contacts they were calling without incurring charges - a simple yet groundbreaking concept.
This innovation not only transformed the telecom sector but also generated billions of rand in revenue for Vodacom and its parent company, Vodafone.
Makate's quest for fair compensation has dragged on for over two decades despite his contributions.
Multiple court victories - including three rulings from the Supreme Court of Appeal and nine judgments in his favour - have recognised his rights.
Notably, in 2016, the Constitutional Court criticised Vodacom and its executives for unethical conduct, emphasising the importance of acknowledging Makate's contribution. Yet, a final resolution remains elusive.
The latest chapter unfolded in November 2024 when the Constitutional Court heard arguments but has since withheld judgment, leaving Makate and supporters in limbo.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Modise Setoaba, Convener of the #PleaseCallMe Movement (PMC), expressed deep frustration over the prolonged delay.
'The #PleaseCallMe movement has always sought peaceful and lawful means to support Mr Makate. However, it's disheartening to see a case that has been ongoing for 25 years still unresolved,' Setoaba said.
'Justice delayed is justice denied. Makate has waited a quarter of a century for recognition and fair compensation. We trust the Constitutional Court will uphold his rights and deliver justice swiftly.'
Setoaba also called on the Office of the Chief Justice (OCJ) to intervene, citing the emotional toll on Makate, who remains demoralised by the protracted process.
When approached for comment on whether Vodacom was concerned about the delay, a Vodacom spokesperson told IOL: 'The matter is before the Constitutional Court, and we await its ruling.' The company provided no further response.
When asked about the delay, OCJ said that a date for the handing down of judgment in the Constitutional Court matter has yet to be set.
'The matter is currently receiving the attention of the panel of judges who sat, and there is, at this stage, no indication as to when judgment will be delivered.
'The parties will be informed through the relevant formal channels as soon as the judgment is ready for hand-down,' read the response.
Legal experts attribute the delays in delivering judgments to several systemic factors. Lucky Magagula of Magagula Attorneys highlighted resource constraints and high caseloads as primary culprits.
'South African courts are grappling with a surge in cases due to population growth and urbanisation,' Magagula explained.
'For instance, the Gauteng High Court in Pretoria has nearly 40 judges, but only six research staff support them, hampering timely judgments.'
He argued that the number of judges appointed has not grown in proportion to the growth in caseload.
'This increase in caseload may be attributed to population growth, and cities like Johannesburg and Pretoria are economic hubs that have contributed immensely to population growth, which has grown hand in hand with a high-volume caseload.'
He added that complex cases, especially those involving voluminous documentation and novel legal issues like Makatei's, require extensive research and deliberation and often exceed the three-month guideline former Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng set.
The backlog of reserved judgments has become a significant concern, with some exceeding two years.
'Reference can be made to the Gauteng High Court in Johannesburg, where trial dates are scheduled as far out as October 2029, indicating a severe backlog.
'As such, we have seen efforts by Judge President Dustin Mlambo of the court introducing mediation as a primary avenue to be exhausted before matters go to trial,' said Magagula.
The delay in Makate's case is multifaceted. In 2016, the Constitutional Court ordered Vodacom to negotiate a fair fee with Makate.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
40 minutes ago
- IOL News
Point of view: understanding the financial habits of South Africa's youth
Explore how South Africa's youth, aged 18 to 35, are navigating their financial journeys amidst economic pressures, balancing essential expenses with aspirations, and embracing digital financial tools. The financial landscape for young South Africans is rapidly evolving, shaped by economic pressures, shifting priorities, and a growing reliance on digital financial tools. The Youth Barometer, which harnesses data from Standard Bank's Personal and Private Banking and Liberty, offers a revealing snapshot of how South Africans aged 18 to 35 are navigating their financial journeys—balancing essential expenses with discretionary spending, financing their first assets, supporting their families, and planning for their long-term futures. The inaugural Youth Barometer was launched this week in Rosebank. According to the head of youth and mass market segments at Standard Bank, Tshiamo Molanda, these insights are more than data points; they are a call to action. "They challenge us to design solutions that are relevant, inclusive, and forward-looking. Solutions that not only respond to where young South Africans are now but also anticipate where they aspire to go. Because when we understand youth better, we can partner with them more meaningfully, enabling them to grow as we grow," she says. But where are young South Africans today, financially? The Barometer's findings provide answers. Data from three million youth customers reveals a shifting pattern in spending habits. Young South Africans aged 18–24 allocate the highest proportion of their income to essential expenses (58%), followed by those aged 25–29 at 53%. Only the 30–35 group shows an even split between essentials and discretionary spending—a trend mirrored among those over 35, likely due to higher earnings reducing the strain of covering necessities. However, younger generations spend proportionately less than their elders on insurance, loans, transport, and savings, while prioritising categories such as clothing, groceries, dining out, entertainment, digital connectivity, and self-care. Meanwhile, spending on education, healthcare, holidays, utilities, and family support remains fairly consistent across all age groups. The data reveals that while the digital economy is expanding, cash withdrawals remain a common habit for youth aged 18 to 24, making it harder to track their exact spending patterns. Still, the data that remains within banking systems points to top spending categories such as digital connectivity, groceries, and fast food. Interestingly, despite a decline in clothing spending from 2021 to 2024, younger customers still allocate more income to clothing than older youth, frequently shopping at brands like Mr Price, Pep, Ackermans, Sportscene, Pick n Pay Clothing, Shein, H&M, Cotton On, and Markham. Luxury brands also feature strongly, with spending patterns reflecting preferences for Farfetch, Louis Vuitton, Timberland, Steve Madden, Piccadilly, G-Star Raw, and Hugo Boss. 'This tells us that younger age groups have a higher brand affinity to luxury brands, because while we see some of this behaviour among older age bands, more reasonably priced brands feature among older youth,' says Shené Mothilal, solution owner for Digital Money Manager. Young adults aged 18–24 allocate the highest proportion of their income to groceries among under-35s, alongside the highest spend on takeouts—indicating that while older customers increasingly cook at home, younger customers prefer a balance between eating in and dining out. Among 25–29s, spending remains focused on essentials such as groceries, digital connectivity, and clothing. However, insurance and loan repayments begin rising, suggesting that many in this age group are establishing financial stability and working towards formal credit histories. Meanwhile, those aged 30–35 start exhibiting spending behaviours akin to over-35s, allocating more of their income to insurance, loans, and healthcare. With incomes rising due to career advancement, their spending shifts away from essentials such as groceries, clothing, and digital connectivity. This trend is compounded by demographic factors—many are not yet supporting children, with South Africa's median age for first-time mothers now sitting at 28.3 years. In a climate where the cost of living continues to rise and incomes remain under pressure, savings aren't optional—they're essential. To address this, Standard Bank provides tailored guidance for different age groups: 18–24: Start small, but start now. Redirecting just R50 to R100 a month from takeouts, self-care, or entertainment into an emergency fund can create momentum. Using financial tools like Standard Bank's Digital Money Manager to track spending habits can help build consistency before scaling up savings contributions. 25–29: Rebalance discretionary splurges. This group is showing increasing financial maturity through higher contributions toward insurance and loans. However, they still rank second in clothing and takeout spend, suggesting an opportunity to fine-tune their budgets further. 30–35: Leverage career gains to build a cushion. With a more balanced split between essentials and discretionary spending, this group is well-positioned to accelerate their savings toward property, education, and retirement. Redirecting even a small portion of entertainment or takeout spending into interest-bearing financial products could significantly bolster long-term security. The data reveals that despite making up nearly 60% of South Africa's population, those under 35 account for just 17% of the country's outstanding credit value. Their credit portfolios consist largely of unsecured products such as retail accounts, personal loans, and entry-level credit cards, unlike older generations, who have broader access to secured credit lines. Once credit becomes available to them, young South Africans tend to use it extensively. For example, the average credit limit for 18–24-year-olds is approximately R20,000, with utilisation rates above 70%, suggesting many rely on credit for both necessities and lifestyle expenses. Additionally, youth in this age bracket make more credit card payments per month than any other segment, averaging three payments per month. Encouragingly, youth under 35 are showing a strong and growing interest in property ownership, despite broader affordability concerns and rising living costs, the data shows. Approximately 40% of all new home loan enquiries at Standard Bank from January 2023 to April 2025 have come from this demographic, demonstrating a clear ambition to secure long-term financial assets. Similarly, insights from Standard Bank's Vehicle and Asset Finance division indicate that youth aged 18–35 remain a vital segment in the car finance ecosystem, accounting for just under 40% of vehicle finance customers. However, limited incomes shape their decisions—from car brands to deposit sizes and repayment structures. * Maleke is the editor of Personal Finance. PERSONAL FINANCE
The South African
13 hours ago
- The South African
SARS issues warning as 2025 tax season looms
The South African Revenue Service (SARS) has urged taxpayers to verify and update their banking and contact details ahead of the 2025 tax season, warning that incorrect information could delay refunds or result in missed communications. SARS will begin rolling out auto-assessments from Monday, 7 July, meaning taxpayers have until Sunday, 6 July to ensure their details are current for a hassle-free filing experience. The move is part of SARS's continued drive to streamline the tax process, with many individuals expected to receive auto-assessments – pre-completed tax assessments based on data from employers, banks, and medical schemes. When South Africans connect, we don't just network; we build a community. The Lekker Network is a professional network where every conversation starts with, 'How can I help you?' Come join us & be a part of a community of extraordinary Saffas. Taxpayers can check and update their information on by: Logging into their eFiling account Clicking on 'SARS Registered Details' Selecting 'Maintain SARS Registered Details' Choosing which section to update (e.g. bank accounts, email addresses, mobile numbers) Clicking 'Done', then 'Submit' to save changes Failing to submit after updating will result in changes not being registered in the system. No action required if you agree with the auto-assessment. Refunds will be processed automatically if banking details are correct. with the auto-assessment. Refunds will be processed automatically if banking details are correct. Incorrect banking details will result in refund failures. Affected taxpayers will need to manually correct their details and follow up with SARS. will result in refund failures. Affected taxpayers will need to manually correct their details and follow up with SARS. SARS will send notifications via SMS or email to inform taxpayers when their assessments are ready. Taxpayers are advised to wait for this notice before logging into eFiling or the MobiApp. to inform taxpayers when their assessments are ready. Taxpayers are advised to before logging into eFiling or the MobiApp. If a refund is due and banking details are up to date, it will be paid within approximately 72 hours of the assessment. of the assessment. If you disagree with the assessment, you will need to complete and file a tax return manually via eFiling or the MobiApp before the due date indicated. SARS has fully transitioned to digital communication, meaning all critical correspondence will be delivered via email or SMS. This includes: Audit notifications Payment reminders Requests for documentation Dispute outcomes Penalty notices Missing such notices could result in penalties, enforcement actions, or non-compliance flags – which can affect future tax filings and SARS interactions. 'Taxpayers don't need to call or visit our branches. Most issues, including disputes, can be resolved online,' SARS emphasised in a statement. Taxpayers are advised to ensure that they have regular access to their SARS eFiling account or MobiApp and that their registered representative details are also current, particularly for business entities. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
The South African
13 hours ago
- The South African
'Refugee' Errol Langton: 'I AM an Afrikaner, farmer'
IT businessman and now 'refugee' Errol Langton has doubled down on his claims that he is both an Afrikaner and a farmer. He's also shed light on the circumstances that led him to leave South Africa last month. Langton came under fire after his step-daughter branded him an 'opportunist' in a TikTok video. In February, President Donald Trump signed an Executive Order, fast-tracking refugee status to white South Africans – or 'minorities' – over his claims of 'racial discrimination' in SA. Last month, Errol Langton made headlines as one of the 49 white South Africans who arrived in the US as 'Afrikaner refugees'. However, many South Africans – including his stepdaughter – questioned his claims of being a 'farmer' and even an 'Afrikaner'. Some also called him 'opportunistic' for wanting to start again in another country, and in particular, a state – Alabama – where his own relatives immigrated to years ago. While Errol told the New York Times that he was a 'leafy greens' farmer from KwaZulu-Natal, his LinkedIn account lists his experience in the IT sector, where he owned a large business. South African refugee Errol Langton. Images via eNCA/ Facebook Speaking to eNCA's Annika Larson last week, Errol rubbished reports that the group of 'refugees' consisted of white South African farmers. He said: 'That was never the mandate. It was minorities that were suffering persecution'. Of his own identity, he said: 'Yes, I'm an Afrikaner, yes, I'm a farmer. But by everybody else's decision? Maybe not so much' He claims that both being a victim of violent crime and struggling to find work led him to apply for the refugee resettlement programme. 'Being a white South African, BEE laws definitely compounded that issue', he added. During his interview, Errol Langton also claimed that the refugee resettlement programme simply fast-tracked his plans, and he had wanted to leave South Africa in recent years. He continued, 'This was just a much simpler way of going through that process. We ticked all the boxes required for refugee status. I've been looking for opportunities for my kids for a while. It was just the right thing at the right time.' Of the refugees being called 'cowards' by President Cyril Ramaphosa, Errol added: 'If it means that my family is taken care of, I will wear that badge with honour'. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 . Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp , Facebook , X, and Bluesky for the latest news.
