logo
Doctors are still burned out five years after COVID exposed systemic failures

Doctors are still burned out five years after COVID exposed systemic failures

Axios09-03-2025

Five years after COVID shook the world, doctors and other health providers continue to suffer from burnout that the pandemic highlighted and exacerbated.
Why it matters: Provider burnout — an ongoing state of significant stress — takes a toll on patients, too.
A pre-COVID study found burnout costs the health system about $4.6 billion a year due to physicians leaving the field or cutting back on hours. Another study linked doctor burnout with a doubled risk for patient safety issues.
The big picture: There's been significant progress to reduce the stigma around doctors seeking mental health treatment since the pandemic, but physicians say systemic change to payment and administrative workloads are needed to really improve their wellbeing.
"We need to address the root causes of the problem, all the failures in our health care system right now that are causing challenges for physicians," American Medical Association President Bruce Scott told Axios.
Where it stands: Nearly half of physicians (48%) say they feel burned out, according to the AMA's most recent poll, published in July. Women physicians face higher levels of burnout and risk of suicide than their male counterparts.
The overall burnout rate is down from 2021's high of 63%, when the Delta coronavirusvariant raged.
Still, "the fact that one in two physicians in America are showing signs of burnout is an unacceptable number," Scott told Axios.
Burnout among nurses and other health providers also worsened during the pandemic.
Flashback: Providers' poor mental health and burnout has been a problem for years. The pandemic supercharged it, as doctors, nurses and other medical providers worked long hours with less equipment and often in isolation to save the first COVID-19 patients.
Health providers were lauded as heroes at the start of the pandemic, and some even reported improved wellbeing at work, citing more time spent with patients and less spent on paperwork.
But that didn't last. "Five minutes later, it felt like those same workers were being questioned about the science, getting spit on, threatened," said Corey Feist, CEO of the Dr. Lorna Breen Heroes' Foundation.
Feist started the advocacy group in memory of his sister-in-law, an emergency room physician who took her own life in 2020.
State of play: There's growing awareness of the stresses on health providers.
More than half of states and hundreds of individual hospitals have now changed their licensure requirements to remove questions that ask whether a doctor has received mental health treatment or diagnoses. Those questions have historically deterred doctors from seeking needed help.
The Dr. Lorna Breen Heroes' Foundation coordinates learning collaboratives for hospitals and medical groups to work together on implementing operational changes that support provider wellbeing.
Congress also passed a law in 2022 that opened federal grants for training health providers on strategies to reduce and prevent burnout and other issues. The funding authorizations expired last year, but lawmakers have introduced a bipartisan bill to extend them.
Yes, but: Real improvement requires tackling structural issues, like decreasing Medicare payment rates that make it harder to operate a practice and rising administrative burden associated with insurance claims, doctors and experts say.
Zoom in: The primary driver of health care provider burnout is too much work for too few people, said Srijan Sen, a psychiatrist who researches physician well-being at the University of Michigan.
"Increasing the number of people working, and, even more long term, helping people stay healthier, so less people need health care — those sorts of things will be a big part of the solution," he said.
What to watch: Scores of health tech companies now advertise tools, often driven by artificial intelligence, aimed at cutting down provider workload by automating administrative tasks.
It's not yet clear if they'll deliver, Sen said. The electronic health record once promised to make a physician's job easier, and research now shows it has directly contributed to increased burnout.
Despite the stressors and predicted workforce shortages, health care still is projected to add the most jobs in the U.S. of any sector over the next decade, and medical schools are seeing more interest than ever.
Today's students are more attuned to their mental health than in the past, and they're asking what can be done to make the field one they want to continue working in, said Kelly Holder, chief well-being officer at Brown University's medical school.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Who makes decisions for public health is changing in Hamilton
Who makes decisions for public health is changing in Hamilton

Hamilton Spectator

time3 hours ago

  • Hamilton Spectator

Who makes decisions for public health is changing in Hamilton

Community members are now at Hamilton's public health decision-making table after long-awaited governance reform got the green light from the province. 'I think it's so vitally important to have those voices there,' Coun. Cameron Kroetsch said in an interview with The Spectator. 'I think, also, it just frankly gives the community more confidence that we have both councillors and health experts who can give a balanced perspective.' Public health policy will no longer be decided by the 16 members of Hamilton's city council after legislative changes passed third reading on June 3 and received royal assent on June 5 as part of Bill 11 , More Convenient Care Act. Instead, six appointed community members , with health expertise or lived experience, will work alongside six city councillors and one education representative to oversee public health. Coun. Cameron Kroetsch says it is 'vitally important' to have community voices on the board of health. The Progressive Conservative government made the required amendments to the City of Hamilton Act at council's request. 'The community pushed really hard for this,' Kroetsch said. 'It's been a long journey.' City council will provide one final approval at its meeting on June 18 but the vote is considered a formality. The new board is expected to meet for the first time on July 7 — over four years after calls for change started in March 2021 when COVID-19 brought inequities, related to social determinants of health, to the forefront as some groups fared better than others during the pandemic. Advocates — including doctors, social workers and academics — argued for a board of health that better reflects Hamilton's diversity, including racialized residents and those with disabilities. 'We didn't have that kind of community voice available to respond to issues of public health in our city and so I think this is going to be great,' Kroetsch said. 'Having these key people around the table, we learned during COVID, would have made things so much better … I just can't say enough about how important I think it is for community voices to be at the table.' The changes bring Hamilton more in line with about two-thirds of the province's public health units that are overseen by autonomous boards. Hamilton's board will be semi-autonomous as decisions related to the budget, the annual service plan and the appointment of medical officers of health will still be approved by city council. Toronto and Ottawa also have semi autonomous boards. However, policy decisions would no longer need any further approval so the board's vote would be binding. 'There's not really a way for council to override the board of health,' Kroetsch said. 'We've given over that autonomy.' The governance reform initially had the unanimous support of council in January 2024. While awaiting the legislative changes, a public health subcommittee was created that will now become the board of health. Up until now, its decisions needed to be approved by city councillors. But opposition to the changes flared up in May after a disagreement over how restrictive the city should be about drinking on municipal property revealed a divide between councillors and the subcommittee. The proposed changes to the municipal alcohol policy were passed with almost no discussion by the subcommittee. In stark contrast, councillors voted 13-1 against it after a charged debate and an in-camera session to get legal advice. It raised questions about what would happen in the future when the semi-autonomous board of health no longer needed councillors' approval for such policy decisions. The subsequent vote went from unanimous to passing 9-5 on the makeup of the future board of health. But Kroetsch, who has been chairing the subcommittee, expects the transition will now be smooth. 'It's just going to be a new day for Hamilton in terms of having that expert advice from the community on the board of health to be able to weigh in on matters that are important,' Kroetsch said. 'We're talking about something that has literally a life and death impact for people. Public health is one of those areas of municipal governance that can impact people's day to day lives.' Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .

Top Hamilton headlines this week: 40 hours in St. Joe's emergency department + ‘Rats and cockroaches own that place now'
Top Hamilton headlines this week: 40 hours in St. Joe's emergency department + ‘Rats and cockroaches own that place now'

Hamilton Spectator

time3 hours ago

  • Hamilton Spectator

Top Hamilton headlines this week: 40 hours in St. Joe's emergency department + ‘Rats and cockroaches own that place now'

The weekend is here, but plenty happened in the Hamilton area this week. Don't miss these top stories from Spectator reporters. Take in a Forge FC game, a car show in Burlington or a street party on Concession, and there are plenty more things to do this weekend. Here are some ideas . Saturday is sun day. Environment Canada is forecasting a high of 25 C. Temperatures are expected to peak at 18 C on a cloudy Sunday and there is a chance of showers. Emergency is a three-part series about St. Joseph's Healthcare emergency department in Hamilton's core. Spec reporter Jon Wells spent 40 hours talking to the patients who come to this eye in the storm of the mental health, homelessness and addiction crisis, and those who work there. Part 2: St. Joe's emergency sees upwards of 200 patients in a 24-hour period Part 3: A surge of homeless patients at the busiest emergency department A Burlington lawyer arrested in connection with a suspected multimillion-dollar Ponzi scheme is under investigation by the Law Society of Ontario for allegedly misusing her trust fund. Robert DeRosa feels forgotten as the world increasingly moves on from COVID-19. Life never went back to normal for the 42-year-old former teacher, who went from running marathons nearly five and half years ago to falling so ill from long COVID that he can't work, lives with his dad and barely leaves his Hamilton Mountain home. Hamilton council will not allow a homeowner to keep the contentious poolside oasis he built on city parkland on the Stoney Creek Mountain. Two days after handing over her May rent, Crystal Wicker said she received a letter from the County of Brant informing her the motel she has called home for over two years was unsafe to live in. Before she had time to process the news, the hydro got cut. Subscribe to our newsletters for the latest local content . Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .

Province's former top doc joins Grand Erie health unit amid measles outbreak
Province's former top doc joins Grand Erie health unit amid measles outbreak

Hamilton Spectator

time3 hours ago

  • Hamilton Spectator

Province's former top doc joins Grand Erie health unit amid measles outbreak

As Grand Erie's health unit searches for a new medical officer of health, Ontario's former top doc has stepped in to help the region manage a measles outbreak. Dr. David Williams, who was Ontario's chief medical officer of health from 2015 to 2021, has joined Grand Erie Public Health 'to provide additional temporary support,' the health unit announced in a news release on Thursday. Williams led the province's response to the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic. Since he retired in 2021, he has advised various Ontario health units. His move to Grand Erie comes as Dr. Rebecca Comley returns to the role of acting medical officer of health for GEPH, which covers Haldimand-Norfolk and Brantford-Brant. Comley had been top doc for the former Brant County Health Unit, which merged with Haldimand-Norfolk's health unit in January. She started in the same role with Grand Erie, but went on leave almost immediately after the merger. Comley's replacement, Dr. Malcolm Lock, died suddenly in late February, prompting Waterloo's associate medical officer, Dr. Adelle Chang On, to temporarily transfer to Grand Erie. 'Dr. Comley and Dr. Williams will ensure continuity in coverage during the ongoing recruitment for a permanent medical officer of health,' the release stated. Norfolk Mayor Amy Martin, who chairs Grand Erie's board of health, welcomed Comley's return. 'We're pleased to welcome Dr. Comley back from leave as she resumes the role of acting medical officer of health, supporting continuity while we continue our search for a permanent appointment,' Martin said in the release. 'We expect to share further updates on this recruitment in the near future.' It is unclear whether Comley, who has a master's of public health and spent 10 years in the emergency department at Brantford General Hospital, has applied for the permanent job. According to provincial law, medical officer candidates must have completed at least a year-long postgraduate study in epidemiology, disease prevention and health promotion, while any licensed physician in Ontario can be an acting medical officer of health (MOH). As there is no time limit on how long an acting MOH can stay in the role, Comley could keep the job indefinitely. The health unit is also in search of a new chief executive officer after former CEO Brent Richardson departed the organization without explanation in April. Richardson had been CEO of the Brant County Health Unit and held the same job at Grand Erie after the merger. He did not respond to an interview request at the time of his departure. Comley will have help from Williams in managing an ongoing measles outbreak in Grand Erie. The region — and Norfolk County in particular — has been a hot spot for measles cases during a provincewide outbreak that started last October. As of June 3, Grand Erie has reported 273 measles cases since the end of October, including 25 new cases in the past week, according to Public Health Ontario. That case count is second only to Southwestern Public Health, which borders western Norfolk and has reported 725 total measles cases. The vast majority of cases are in unvaccinated children and youth, the province says. Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store