Why Trump's evidence about the killing of South African farmers is inaccurate
Donald Trump put his South African counterpart Cyril Ramaphosa on the spot with a list of claims and video clips when the pair met in the Oval Office on Wednesday.
But multiple pieces of evidence that President Trump used to support his claims are inaccurate.
One video the White House played showed lines of white crosses alongside a road.
Mr Trump told President Ramaphosa that the footage showed burial sites of more than 1,000 white farmers in South Africa.
The clip appears to originate from a YouTube video from 2020 showing crosses lining the P39-1 road near Newcastle in the east of South Africa.
The caption of the video, which was filmed in KwaZulu-Natal province, explains that the crosses are a memorial for murdered farm workers after two farmers Glen and Vida Rafferty had been killed.
There is no indication that the crosses mark where the deceased have been buried or that each cross represents a white farmer.
Satellite map imagery from 2023 shows the crosses are no longer there.
Local reporting at the time quotes attendants of the memorial as saying the crosses are a show of support not specifically for white farmers but for people from all walks of life who were concerned about farm murders.
White crosses have been used as a symbol of commemoration for the murder of farmers in South Africa for years. The Witkruis Monument in the north of the country displays dozens of white crosses as a tribute to farmer workers who have been killed.
Other parts of the evidence presented by Mr Trump were also incorrect.
At one point, while talking about the deaths of white farmers in South Africa, Mr Trump held up a printed-out image of a blog called 'American Thinker'.
The blog picture is taken from a February 2025 YouTube video of Red Cross workers in the Democratic Republic of Congo.
Mr Trump also played videos of people he said were officials promoting the killing of white farmers.
The videos were of rallies or speeches from opponents of Mr Ramaphosa's ANC party, which is currently in power.
Many of these videos show Julius Malema, the leader of the black nationalist and communist Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) party.
1:56
The EFF are not a mainstream party and are not officials as Mr Trump claimed.
Mr Ramaphosa responded to Mr Trump, saying: "Our government policy is completely against what he [Malema] was saying."
He continued that "they [the EFF] are a small minority party, which is allowed to exist according to our constitution".
These claims were made as part of President Trump's allegation that white people in South Africa are facing a high level of race-based violence.
"We have many people that feel they're being persecuted, and they're coming to the United States. So we take from many... locations, if we feel there's persecution or genocide going on," the US president said, referring specifically to white farmers.
5:42
South Africa has rejected the allegation that white people are disproportionately targeted by crime.
South African police data does not give race-based crime statistics. Police data from April 2020 to March 2024 showed 225 people were killed on farms in South Africa.
South Africa crime data suggests 98,115 murders between 2020 and 2024, of which killings on farms are a very small proportion, around 0.2%.
3:41
The accuracy of crime data in South Africa has been questioned by academic experts, as farm murders are not consistently recorded in official data.
In response to a request from Sky News to comment, a White House spokesperson disputed what they called the "characterisation of the president's very real evidence regarding the persecution of Afrikaners as "inaccurate".
Earlier this month, President Trump offered refuge to a small number of white South Africans.
In March, the South African ambassador to the US Ebrahim Rasool was expelled after American secretary of state Marco Rubio him of being a "race-baiting politician" who hates President Trump.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
13 minutes ago
- Reuters
Iran will not compromise on right to enrichment, says official
DUBAI, June 12 (Reuters) - Iran will not abandon its right to uranium enrichment because of mounting frictions in the region, a senior Iranian official told Reuters on Thursday, adding that a "friendly" regional country had alerted Tehran over a potential military strike by Israel. The official said the tensions were intended to "influence Tehran to change its position about its nuclear rights" during talks with the United States on Sunday in Oman. U.S. President Donald Trump said on Wednesday U.S. personnel were being moved out of the Middle East because it could be a "dangerous place", adding that the United States would not allow Iran to have a nuclear weapon. Tehran and Washington will hold a new round of talks in Oman's capital, Muscat, to resolve a decades-long standoff over Iran's nuclear ambitions. After five rounds of discussions between Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araqchi and Trump's Middle East envoy, Steve Witkoff, several obstacles remain. Among them are Iran's rejection of a U.S. demand that it commit to scrapping uranium enrichment.
Reuters
14 minutes ago
- Reuters
Breakdown of U.S. tariffs on China since Trump's first term
BEIJING, June 12 (Reuters) - Billions of dollars of Chinese goods have been impacted by additional U.S. tariffs since 2018, initially under the first Donald Trump presidency and later under the Biden administration. Returning to the White House this year, Trump has imposed even more duties on China. The U.S. tariffs range from those imposed under Section 301 of its trade act due to what Washington claims are unfair Chinese trade practices, to duties under Section 232 levied for national security reasons. This year, Trump has imposed another 20% levies on all Chinese goods, saying Beijing has not done enough to stop the flow of fentanyl into the United States. So-called reciprocal tariffs, under which the U.S. will match duties imposed by other countries, have also been levied in a bid to rebalance trade flows. Below are the U.S. tariffs on China effective as of June 12, 2025: In September 2019, the U.S. imposed 15% tariffs on more than $120 billion of Chinese goods under Section 301, which it then halved to 7.5% less than six months later. The 25% U.S. tariffs on $250 billion of Chinese goods under the earlier List 1-3 remain unchanged. In September 2024, the U.S. Trade Representative under the Biden administration announced additional tariffs of 25-100% on 14 product groups following a four-year review of the Section 301 tariff actions. The levies were imposed on strategic Chinese sectors or sectors where the United States has made significant domestic investments. In addition to the above duties, the first Trump administration in 2018 imposed a range of tariffs under Section 232 aimed at restricting goods deemed a threat to national security, including all aluminium and steel imports, shutting most Chinese suppliers out of the U.S. market.
Reuters
20 minutes ago
- Reuters
China affirms trade deal with US, says it always keeps its word
BEIJING, June 12 (Reuters) - China on Thursday affirmed a trade deal announced by U.S. President Donald Trump, saying both sides needed to abide by the consensus and adding China always kept its word. The deal, reached after Trump and China's President Xi Jinping spoke on the telephone last week, brings a delicate truce in a trade war between the world's two largest economies. "China has always kept its word and delivered results," Lin Jian, a foreign ministry spokesperson, said at a regular news conference. "Now that a consensus has been reached, both sides should abide by it." The Trump-Xi telephone call broke a standoff that had flared just weeks after a preliminary deal was reached in Geneva. The call was quickly followed by more talks in London that Washington said had put "meat on the bones" of the Geneva agreement to ease bilateral retaliatory tariffs. The Geneva deal had faltered over China's continued curbs on minerals exports, prompting the Trump administration to respond with export controls preventing shipments of semiconductor design software, jet engines for Chinese-made planes and other goods to China. Trump on Wednesday said he was very happy with the trade deal. "Our deal with China is done, subject to final approval with President Xi and me," Trump said on Truth Social. "Full magnets, and any necessary rare earths, will be supplied, up front, by China. Likewise, we will provide to China what was agreed to, including Chinese students using our colleges and universities (which has always been good with me!). We are getting a total of 55% tariffs, China is getting 10%." Still, specifics of the latest deal and details on how it will be implemented remain unclear. A White House official said the 55% represents the sum of a baseline 10% "reciprocal" tariff Trump has imposed on goods imported from nearly all U.S. trading partners, 20% on all Chinese imports associated with his accusation that China had not done enough to stem the flow of fentanyl into the U.S., and pre-existing 25% levies on imports from China put in place during Trump's first presidential term.
