UK abandons 'pick-and-mix' approach to international law
The UK has abandoned a 'pick-and-mix' approach to international law and will support a rules-based order, the attorney general has said.
Richard Hermer, the government's chief legal adviser, said that unless Britain fully abides by international law then it will lead to the 'disintegration' of the system.
In the annual security lecture at the Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) defence think tank in London, Mr Hermer explained why the UK was taking the path of 'progressive realism' in its foreign policy.
The approach combines a pragmatic approach to national interest with a principled commitment to a rules-based international order. It was recently outlined by Foreign Secretary David Lammy.
Mr Hermer criticised former prime minister Boris Johnson, who set out to 'deliberately breach international law' concerning the UK's Brexit deal with the EU.
The previous Conservative government's plan to send asylum seekers to Rwanda was deemed to be in danger of breaking international law by the UK's Supreme Court, imperilling the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). Frustration with the convention prompted many Conservatives to call for the UK to leave the treaty it helped to establish more than 70 years ago.
'First, we need to be clear that a selective, or 'pick and mix' approach to international law by the United Kingdom will lead to its disintegration,' Mr Hermer said.
'The international rules-based order soon breaks down when states claim that they can breach international law because it is in their national interests. That is the exceptionalism argument that Russia makes.'
Mr Hermer used his speech to position progressive realism among the competing strands of foreign policy thinking.
On the one hand are 'romantic idealists who say that international law, conceived as the reign of moral principle, provides a complete answer to any question'.
'We should always call out our partners, with different types of governments, regardless of whether or not the criticism works or whether quiet diplomacy might more effectively produce results.'
On the other are what he called 'pseudo realists' in the Conservative party who 'demand that in these volatile times we must abandon our long-standing commitment to international law and to moral principles'.
Mr Hermer said by navigating a course through these two positions in 'good faith' the UK has been able to advance its interest through the mechanisms of international law.
This has included new trade agreements with India, the EU, the US and Japan, and persuading Germany to change its law to stop the shipping of asylum seekers on 'small boats' across continental Europe and the English Channel to the UK.
'By contrast with the inconsistent, flamboyant and on occasion inflammatory rhetoric, this government is clear that the national interest is served by the restoration of our reputation not simply as a nation that respects its international law obligation but as a leader in the rules-based international order,' he said.
Mr Hermer is a lawyer from a human rights and international background. He is close to Labour Prime Minister Keir Starmer, a former human rights lawyer.
Last year, Mr Hermer visited Israel for talks with senior officials to discuss the government's changing policies on the Gaza.
Briefings have emerged in recent weeks that said Mr Hermer is taking a proactive approach to how the government is interpreting the law.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Zawya
39 minutes ago
- Zawya
TishTash announce departure of Managing Director Polly Williams after 10 years & pivotal agency role
TishTash, the award-winning PR and communications agency, and wider TishTash Group, today announce that Polly Williams, Managing Director, will be stepping away after nearly a decade in the business. Having held the position of Managing Director since 2019 and played a key role in the growth and success of the agency Willams will move into the next chapter in her career. Since joining TishTash Communications in 2016 as Group Account Director, Williams has played a pivotal role in the agency's growth, strategic direction, expanded service offering in digital and content, and has helped build a talented and much respected team. Under her guidance, the agency has achieved significant milestones, including: Evolution into a fully integrated communications agency offering traditional PR, creative, events, content, social and digital marketing. Growth from 10 to +70 employees and double-digit growth for the last 5 years. Expansion into KSA and UK markets. Creation of innovative 'Direct to Consumer' division offering brands a way to reach their end customers more efficiently including launch of Raemona Magazine and acquisition of 'That Dubai Girl' online community. Accreditation as a 'Great Place to Work'. Implementation of market first policies including menopause, menstruation and fertility leave. "Polly has been a key driving force behind our growth and success over the last 10 years, and in bringing my vision to life," said Natasha Hatherall, Founder and CEO of TishTash Group. "Her tenacity, determination and commitment have been invaluable to me and the agency as we moved from start-up to the large multi-disciplinary agency we are today. She is a key part of our journey, and her legacy will live on, and while we're all sad to see her go, we're incredibly proud of all she has accomplished and cannot wait to see what she goes on to achieve next.' Reflecting on her time at the agency, Williams said: 'Leading the growth of TishTash has been such a significant and rewarding part of my career. Scaling the business and building a high-performing, multi-disciplinary team of talented women has given me so much to be proud of. I will continue to be in awe of Natasha and TishTash as it goes on to enjoy future successes. I move onto my next adventure knowing that what we have built in TishTash is an agency like no other in the region. As I move into my next chapter, I look forward to applying the experience, insight and momentum gained at TishTash to new opportunities and ventures.' TishTash will continue to build on its strong foundations, reputation and commitment to innovation and doing things a little differently. The agency role will not be replaced at this time, with Senior Business Directors Scarlett Sykes and Katie Watson Grant moving into new roles in support of CEO Natasha Hatherall. Natasha Hatherall and Polly Williams will continue to partner together on a number of new ventures including a book which they are currently co-authoring. For more information visit or keep up to date with the lates news on social media @TishTashTalks About TishTash Group: Formed in February 2025, The TishTash Group is a connected portfolio of companies on a mission to support businesses and individuals to amplify their communications and visibility in the market. Covering PR, marketing, corporate profiling, publishing and direct-to-consumer strategies under one roof, The TishTash Group enables businesses to take a proactive approach to shifting consumer behaviour. Businesses under The Group include: TishTash Communications, Ten by TishTash, TishTash Tots, Raemona Magazine and female-focused digital platform That Dubai Girl. For more information visit For media information, please contact: Israa Aboukoush israa@
The National
an hour ago
- The National
Nationalist Karol Nawrocki is narrow winner in Polish presidential election
Conservative Karol Nawrocki won Poland 's weekend presidential run-off election, according to the final vote count on Monday, in a blow for the country's pro-EU government. Mr Nawrocki, who is 42 and an admirer of US President Donald Trump, won 50.89 per cent of votes in a race against Rafał Trzaskowski, Warsaw's pro-Brussels mayor and ally of the country's centrist government who received 49.11 per cent. "Congratulations to the winner!' outgoing conservative President Andrzej Duda said on X. 'Stay strong Poland!' Mr Nawrocki, a eurosceptic historian who ran a national remembrance institute, campaigned on a promise to ensure economic and social policies favour Poles over other nationalities. The amateur boxer won despite his past dominating debate in the last days of the campaign – from questions about his acquisition of a flat from a pensioner to an admission that he took part in orchestrated gang fights. While Poland's parliament holds most power, the president can veto legislation, and the vote was being watched closely in Ukraine as well as Russia, the US and across the European Union. The victory brings a "fresh victory for (European) patriots', Hungarian Foreign Minister Peter Szijjarto said on his Facebook page on Monday. EU Commission President Ursula von der Leyen on Monday congratulated Mr Nawrocki with his win and said she was convinced the EU could continue its "very good co-operation' with Poland. "We are all stronger together in our community of peace, democracy, and values. So let us work to ensure the security and prosperity of our common home,' Ms von der Leyen said in a post on X. Tight race The race had Poland on edge since a first round of voting two weeks earlier, revealing deep divisions in the country along the eastern flank of Nato and the European Union. About Karol Nawrocki Supports military aid for Ukraine, unlike other eurosceptic leaders, but he will oppose its membership in western alliances. A nationalist, his campaign slogan was Poland First. "Let's help others, but let's take care of our own citizens first," he said on social media in April. Cultivates tough-guy image, posting videos of himself at shooting ranges and in boxing rings. Met Donald Trump at the White House and received his backing. An early exit poll released on Sunday evening suggested that Mr Trzaskowski was heading to victory before polling began to suggest otherwise a couple of hours later. The outcome suggests that Poland can be expected to take a more populist and nationalist path under its new leader. President's role Most day-to-day power in the Polish political system rests with a prime minister chosen by the parliament. However, the president's role is not merely ceremonial – the office holds the power to influence foreign policy and veto legislation. Mr Nawrocki will succeed Mr Duda, a conservative whose second and final term ends on August 6. Under the Polish constitution, the president serves a five-year term and may be re-elected once. Tusk headache Prime Minister Donald Tusk came to power in 2023 with a coalition government that spans a broad ideological divide – so broad that it has not been able to fulfil certain of his electoral promises, such as loosening the restrictive abortion law or passing a civil partnership law for same-sex couples. But Mr Duda's veto power has been another obstacle. It has prevented Mr Tusk from fulfilling promises to reverse laws that politicised the court system in a way that the European Union declared to be undemocratic. Now, it appears Mr Tusk will have no way to fulfil those promises, made to voters and the EU. Some observers in Poland have said the unfulfilled promises could make it more difficult for Mr Tusk to continue his term until the next parliamentary election scheduled for late 2027, particularly if the Law and Justice party dangles the prospect of co-operation with conservatives in his coalition. In the past two weeks, the candidates mostly fought for the support of people who voted for other candidates in the first round, in particular far-right's Slawomir Mentzen, who came third with 15 per cent support. Mr Trzaskowski tried to attract them with promises of deregulation. Mr Nawrocki used his credentials as head of the Institute of National Remembrance (IPN), support for gun ownership, traditional families and Christian values, but also a critical tone on Ukraine, in common with Mr Mentzen. Mr Nawrocki's wife Marta, a civil servant, and three children featured strongly in his campaign. Boxer, historian, politician Mr Nawrocki, a 42-year-old amateur boxer and historian, was chosen by the Law and Justice party as part of its push for a new start. The party governed Poland from 2015 to 2023, when it lost power to a centrist coalition led by Mr Tusk. Mr Nawrocki was chosen as a new face who would not be tainted by the scandals of the party's eight years of rule. However, his candidacy was clouded by allegations of connections to criminal figures and his participation in a violent street brawl. He denies the criminal links but was unapologetic about the street fight, saying he had taken part in 'noble' fights in his life. The revelations did not seem to hurt his support among right-wing voters, many of whom see the allegations as politically motivated. "All my sports activities were based on the strength of my heart, the strength of my muscles, my fists,' Mr Nawrocki told a debate when confronted over reports he had been involved in mass organised fights between football hooligans. "It was a fair competition, regardless of the form.' Mr Nawrocki portrayed the election as a referendum on the government, which he described as a metropolitan elite out of touch with their concerns. "I am simply one of you,' he told voters in the eastern town of Biala Podlaska while on the campaign trail. The Trump factor Mr Trump made it clear he favoured Mr Nawrocki as Poland's president. He welcomed Mr Nawrocki to the White House a month ago. Last week, the conservative group CPAC held its first meeting in Poland to give Mr Nawrocki a boost. Kristi Noem, the US Homeland Security Secretary and a prominent Trump ally, praised Mr Nawrocki and urged Poles to vote for him.
Zawya
3 hours ago
- Zawya
Global economy's 'sugar rush' defies trade drama
FRANKFURT - For all the drama surrounding U.S. President Donald Trump's trade tariffs, the world economy is holding up better than many had expected. The latest data from the United States, China and, to a lesser extent, Europe are showing resilience and the global economy as a whole is still expected to grow modestly this year. This is in part due to U.S. buyers and foreign sellers bringing forward business while many of the import duties unveiled by U.S. President Donald Trump remain suspended. While that effect may prove short-lived, Trump's decision to pause tariffs and some glimpses of progress in trade talks, particularly between the United States and the European Union, have fuelled cautious optimism. "We are seeing a bit of a sugar rush in industry, with manufacturers bringing forward production and trade," said Holger Schmieding, an economist at investment bank Berenberg. "The other thing is that we have evidence that Trump pedalled back on tariffs. The bet in markets and to some extent in the economy is that he barks but doesn't bite." Investment banks and institutions generally expect the United States to avoid a recession this year and the global economy to keep growing. The International Monetary Fund downgraded its global GDP growth forecast by just 0.5 percentage points last month to 2.8%. This is roughly in line with the trend over the past decade and a far cry from the downturns experienced during the COVID-19 pandemic, the 2008 financial crisis or even the turmoil that followed the 9/11 terror attacks in 2001. No one is venturing a prediction on where the trade negotiations will eventually settle, particularly with a U.S. president who sees himself as unstoppable. This week alone, separate U.S. courts first blocked and then reinstated Trump's tariffs - creating a degree of legal uncertainty that will do little to facilitate trade deals between the United States and those threatened with the levies. While the EU celebrated "new impetus" in its trade talks with the United States, negotiations with China were "a bit stalled" according to U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent. Companies are counting the cost of the ongoing impasse. A Reuters analysis of corporate disclosures shows Trump's trade war had cost companies more than $34 billion in lost sales and higher costs, a toll that is expected to rise as ongoing uncertainty over tariffs paralyses decision making at some of the world's largest companies. Car-makers from Japan's Toyota to Germany's Porsche and Mercedes-Benz are bracing for lower, or lower-than-previously expected profits if they have not given up making predictions altogether, like Volvo Cars and Dutch-based Stellantis. This is likely to result in a hit especially for Japan. The United States is Japan's biggest export destination, accounting for 21 trillion yen ($146.16 billion) worth of goods, with automobiles representing roughly 28% of the total. "While the worst shocks may be over, there's still a lot up in the air," Xingchen Yu, a strategist at UBS's Chief Investment Office, said. "We don't really know what a new normal for tariffs would look like, unfortunately." PAYBACK But so far the global economy has held up pretty well. China's output and exports are resilient as its companies re-route trade to the United States via third countries. Even in Europe, manufacturing activity was at a 33-month high in May, rebounding from a slump induced by more expensive fuel following Russia's invasion of Ukraine. Confidence was also buttressed by the prospect of greater fiscal spending in Germany, a missing ingredient for European growth for the past couple of decades. The robustness of the world economy has surprised even professional forecasters. A measure produced by U.S. bank Citi that tracks the degree to which global economic data has surprised to the upside is now at its highest in more than a year. Some of that strength circles back to the tariffs themselves and the attempts by U.S. households and businesses to front-load purchases to beat anticipated price increases later this year. U.S. imports were up around 30% in March from where they were in October. The risk to the upbeat outlook comes from the expected "payback" of those advance purchases, which are unlikely to be repeated and will mean slower activity - in the U.S. and elsewhere - later. Economists still fear a triple whammy in which the front-loaded boost to the goods sector is unwound while U.S. household purchasing power is squeezed by higher prices and companies put off investment and hiring. At the margin, however, this scenario is starting to appear a little less likely after Trump's pause on tariffs. "The balance has slightly shifted towards more optimism, albeit with uncertainty and volatility," ING's global head of macro Carsten Brzeski said. ($1 = 143.6800 yen) (Additional reporting by Dan Burns in Washington, Claire Fu in Singapore, Ellen Zhang in Beijing and Leika Kihara in Tokyo; Editing by Mark John and Jane Merriman)
