Court grants stay on suspension of TikTok data transfers to China
A High Court judge has granted TikTok a stay on a decision by the Data Protection Commission (DPC) that the social media giant must suspend data transfers to China by November 29th.
Mr Justice Mark Sanfey said the stay would be in place until early October when the court will hear an application by TikTok seeking a longer stay until the court hears the full challenge to the DPC decision which included a €530 million fine on TikTok.
Advertisement
The judge, who heads the Commercial Court, also granted TikTok an application to have the case admitted to the fast track commercial list The court heard there was no objection to entry from the DPC.
The judge was told TikTok are claiming they face billions in losses if the decision stands and if they did not get a stay until the full case is heard.
He said the justice of case required he would grant a stay until October. The court could not hear an application for the stay in July, as TikTok wanted, because the DPC needed time to prepare its case to oppose the stay.
Earlier, Declan McGrath SC, for TikTok, said his client estimates losses post the suspension will run into billions with losses already running at €109 million.
Advertisement
He was very much pressing the case for an interim stay on the suspension decision.
Counsel said the DPC decision is that data transfers from countries in the European Economic Area (EEA) which includes all the EU along with Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway to China must cease.
The data is not in China and is stored outside but Chinese engineers can access it. The DPC order requires that this remote access is to cease and that the processing of the data must brought into compliance which addresses potential issues around storing of data.
The date on which this "corrective order" takes place is six months from 28 days after the order is made which is the period within which an appeal must be brought. That means there must be compliance by November 29th, counsel said.
Advertisement
World
EU accuses TikTok of breaching digital rules with...
Read More
TikTok is also required to show by July that it has taken steps towards compliance, how it is to be implemented and how it will be communicated to service users within the EEA, he said. This was also why there was an urgency to the stay application.
The cost of this to TikTok will include having to relocate engineers and hire new ones in the EEA and other irreversible steps which represent damages that cannot be recouped, he said. It also impacts on taxation and other matters including loss of goodwill.
Kelley Smith SC, for the DPC, said she was not in a position to agree to any of Mr McGrath's application. She said earlier his side needed time to prepare given the volume of paperwork in the case.
Mr Justice Sanfey approved directions for the progress of the stay application in October and said the case could also be mentioned before a vacation sitting of the Commercial Court in September.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
18 minutes ago
- The Independent
Katie Price faces wait over further bankruptcy-related proceedings
Katie Price faces a wait to see whether more of her income will go directly towards paying off money owed under her two bankruptcies. The former glamour model was declared bankrupt in November 2019 and again in March last year, and the bankruptcies have since been discharged. However, Price, who did not attend the hearing and was not represented, still owes money as a result of the bankruptcies, and she had previously reached a voluntary agreement over her debts. On Friday, barrister Darragh Connell, representing trustees, told a specialist court in London she has not paid the £12,500 a month. He asked Insolvency and Companies Court Judge Sebastian Prentis to make an income payments order, which means money would go from any salary towards Price's outstanding debt. The order relates to 10 companies. However, the judge asked for more evidence to be provided to the court about Price's 'reasonable domestic needs'. Last August, a judge ruled that Price's income from social media platform TikTok be suspended as part of efforts to pay off her debts. And in February last year, a judge at a specialist bankruptcy court ordered that she must pay 40% of her monthly income from the adult entertainment website OnlyFans until February 2027. The next hearing will take place later in the year, on a date to be confirmed.
BBC News
44 minutes ago
- BBC News
Katie Price no show at court over bankruptcy-related debts
Katie Price has failed to show up in court to find out if more of her income will go directly towards paying off money owed under her two former glamour model from Sussex was declared bankrupt in November 2019 and again in March last year, and the bankruptcies have since been the mother-of-five, who did not attend the hearing in London on Friday and was not represented, still owes money as a result and had previously reached a voluntary agreement over her August Ms Price was warned by a judge about her non-attendance, after she was arrested for failing to show up for a previous hearing on the matter in July. Barrister Darragh Connell, representing trustees, told the specialist court she has not paid the arranged £12,500 a Connell asked Insolvency and Companies Court Judge Sebastian Prentis to make an income payments order, which means money would go from any salary towards Price's outstanding order relates to 10 the judge asked for more evidence to be provided to the court about Price's "reasonable domestic needs".Last August, a judge ruled that Price's income from social media platform TikTok be suspended as part of efforts to pay off her in February last year, a judge at a specialist bankruptcy court ordered that she must pay 40% of her monthly income from the adult entertainment website OnlyFans until February next hearing will take place later in the year, on a date to be confirmed
BreakingNews.ie
an hour ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Beijing-appointed Panchen Lama holds rare meeting with Chinese leader
The man picked by Beijing as the second highest figure in Tibetan Buddhism pledged adherence to the ruling Communist Party's dictates on Friday during a rare face-to-face meeting with Chinese leader Xi Jinping. Gyaltsen Norbu, who is rarely seen in public, met behind closed doors with Mr Xi in Zhongnanhai, the government compound in the centre of Beijing, about 2,300 miles from his home monastery of Tashilhumpo, high on the Tibetan steppe. Advertisement The 35-year-old said he would 'firmly support the leadership of the Communist Party of China and resolutely safeguard the unity of the motherland and national unity', the Xinhua News Agency reported. The Chinese government appointed him as the Panchen Lama of Tibetan Buddhism in 1995 at age five after followers of the Dalai Lama recognised a different boy, Gedhun Choekyi Nyima, as the Panchen's incarnation. That boy and his family disappeared in 1995 in what the US government has alleged was an abduction by the Chinese government and the Dalai Lama, 89, has refused to recognise the Chinese-appointed Panchen Lama. Chinese President Xi Jinping (centre) receives Gyaltsen Norbu as Wang Huning, chairman of the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference, looks on (Yan Yan/Xinhua via AP/PA) The Chinese government says Gedhun Choekyi Nyima is now a college graduate living a private life and working a stable job, while producing no evidence. Advertisement The Chinese-appointed Panchen Lama was quoted on Friday by Xinhua as saying he would 'contribute to promoting national unity and progress, systematically promote the sinicisation of religion in China, and promote the modernisation of Tibet'. Mr Xi's government uses the term 'sinicisation' to mean that all religions including Christianity and Islam must take their orders from the Communist Party, reduce their non-Chinese aspects and limit their role in society. Mr Xi was quoted as telling the Chinese government's Panchen that he should continue Tibetan Buddhism's 'strong sense of community for the Chinese nation, systematically advancing the sinicisation of religion in China, and promoting the modernisation of Tibet'. Last month, US Secretary of State Marco Rubio issued a statement marking the 30th anniversary of the disappearance of Gedhun Choekyi Nyima, saying he and his family had been abducted by the Chinese government. Advertisement 'Chinese authorities should release Gedhun Choekyi Nyima immediately and stop persecuting Tibetans for their religious beliefs,' Mr Rubio's statement read. The position of Panchen Lama is especially sensitive since he is expected to take part in the recognition of a new Dalai Lama and serve as his tutor, a religious process that the officially atheist Communist Party is determined to control. The meeting on Friday also reflected Mr Xi's focus on economic and political stability within China's borders, where an economic slump has raised concerns of anti-government outbursts and control over minority groups is an overwhelming obsession.
