Triple Lock safeguards 'notional', senator tells cttee
The Defence and National Security Committee is debating legislation that would remove the need for UN approval when deploying more than 12 members of the Defence Forces overseas when they are serving as part of an international force.
The General Scheme of the Defence (Amendment) Bill 2025 aims to reform the so-called Triple Lock.
Opposition parties and a number of independent TDs have vowed to fight the bill.
Independent Senator Tom Clonan questioned the wisdom of the proposal.
"By government majority, any future government can send any number of Irish troops to any conflict anywhere in the world," Senator Clonan said.
Bernie Maguire, Assistant Secretary of the Department of Defence, said that for more than 50 troops, Dáil approval would be needed.
Mr Clonan asked whether only "a simple government majority" would be needed. Ms Maguire agreed.
He added that the Government plans to remove the Triple Lock and be in a position to send troops anywhere for any purpose, whether for "peacekeeping, peace enforcement or full combat operations"
"With safeguards built in," Ms Maguire responded.
Mr Clonan said that any safeguards were "notional" and would not exist "in law".
"When you remove the Triple Lock, there is no safeguard in law," he added.
Committee chairperson, Sinn Féin TD Rose Conway-Walsh, noted that she had allowed Senator Clonan extra time as he had raised important matters.
Ms Maguire said that the power currently lies with the "P5", or five permanent members of the UN Security Council.
This is "why there hasn't been any new peacekeeping missions for the last 11 years," she added.
"There is a fear it won't pass," Ms Maguire said, with at least one the permanent members likely to veto any peacekeeping proposal.
Independent TD Brian Stanley asked if, under the Government's proposals, Ireland would be "taking sides in a conflict without UN sanction".
Ms Maguire accepted that "there wouldn't be a UN mandate" but said this does not mean that UN principles would not apply.
If it was an EU mission, she said, "the EU always adhere to international law and the UN charter".
Mr Stanley dismissed a Double Lock, saying that a Dáil majority would "count for nothing. That's window dressing", as any government would have such a majority.
"The legislation as you framed it completely disregards the will of the Irish people," he added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
24 minutes ago
- Sunday World
Israel and Iran trade strikes for third day as nuclear talks called off
Planned talks on Iran's nuclear programme, which could provide an off-ramp, were called off Israel has unleashed air strikes across Iran for a third day and threatened even greater force as some Iranian missiles evaded Israeli air defences to strike buildings in the heart of the country. Planned talks on Iran's nuclear programme, which could provide an off-ramp, were called off. The region braced for a protracted conflict after Israel's surprise bombardment of Iran's nuclear and military sites on Friday killed several top generals and nuclear scientists, and neither side showed any sign of backing down. Iran said Israel struck two oil refineries, raising the prospect of a broader assault on Iran's heavily sanctioned energy industry that could affect global markets. Israeli first responders work in a residential area near Tel Aviv, Israel, hit by a missile fired from Iran (Ariel Schalit/AP) The Israeli military, in a social media post, warned Iranians to evacuate arms factories, signalling what could be a further widening of the campaign. At around noon local time, explosions were heard again in the Iranian capital Tehran. US president Donald Trump has expressed full support for Israel's actions while warning Iran that it can only avoid further destruction by agreeing to a new nuclear deal. Iranian foreign minister Abbas Araghchi said on Sunday that if the Israeli strikes on Iran stop, then 'our responses will also stop'. He said the United States 'is a partner in these attacks and must take responsibility'. New explosions echoed across Tehran and were reported elsewhere in the country early on Sunday, but there was no update to a death toll put out the day before by Iran's UN ambassador, who said 78 people had been killed and more than 320 wounded. In Israel, at least 10 people were killed in Iranian strikes overnight and into Sunday, according to Israel's Magen David Adom rescue service, bringing the country's total death toll to 13. Israeli security forces inspect destroyed buildings near Tel Aviv that were hit by a missile fired from Iran (Ohad Zwigenberg/AP) The country's main international airport and airspace remained closed for a third day. Israeli strikes targeted Iran's Defence Ministry early on Sunday after hitting air defences, military bases and sites associated with its nuclear programme. The killing of several top generals and nuclear scientists in targeted strikes indicated that Israeli intelligence has penetrated Iran at the highest levels. News in 90 Seconds - 15th June 2025 In Israel, at least six people, including a 10-year-old and a nine-year-old, were killed when a missile hit an apartment building in Bat Yam, near Tel Aviv. Daniel Hadad, a local police commander, said 180 people were wounded and seven are still missing. An Associated Press (AP) reporter saw streets lined with damaged and destroyed buildings, bombed out cars and shards of glass. Responders used a drone at points to look for survivors. Some people could be seen leaving the area with suitcases. The Israeli Iron Dome air defence system fires to intercept missiles over Tel Aviv, Israel (Ohad Zwigenberg/AP) Another four people, including a 13-year-old, were killed and 24 wounded when a missile struck a building in the Arab town of Tamra in northern Israel. A strike on the central city of Rehovot wounded 42. The Weizmann Institute of Science, an important centre for research in Rehovot, said 'there were a number of hits to buildings on the campus'. It said no-one was harmed. Israel has sophisticated multi-tiered air defences that are able to detect and intercept missiles fired at populated areas or key infrastructure, but officials acknowledge it is imperfect. World leaders made urgent calls to de-escalate. The attack on nuclear sites sets a 'dangerous precedent', China's foreign minister said. The region is already on edge as Israel seeks to annihilate Hamas, an Iranian ally, in the Gaza Strip, where the war is still raging after Hamas's October 7 2023 attack. Flames rise from an oil storage facility after it appeared to have been hit by an Israeli strike in Tehran (AP/Vahid Salemi) Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu brushed off such calls, saying Israel's strikes so far are 'nothing compared to what they will feel under the sway of our forces in the coming days'. Israel, the sole though undeclared nuclear-armed state in the Middle East – said it launched the attack to prevent Iran from developing a nuclear weapon. The two countries have been regional adversaries for decades. Iran has always said its nuclear programme was peaceful, and the US and others have assessed it has not pursued a weapon since 2003. But it has enriched ever larger stockpiles of uranium to near weapons-grade levels in recent years and was believed to have been able to develop multiple weapons within months if it chose to do so. The UN's atomic watchdog censured Iran last week for not complying with its obligations. Mr Araghchi said Israel had targeted an oil refinery near Tehran and another in the country's Bushehr province on the Persian Gulf. Smoke rises up from an oil facility after a Saturday explosion in southern Tehran, Iran (Vahid Salemi/AP) He said Iran had also targeted 'economic' sites in Israel, without elaborating. Mr Araghchi was speaking to diplomats in his first public appearance since the initial Israeli strikes. Semi-official Iranian news agencies reported that an Israeli drone strike had caused a 'strong explosion' at an Iranian natural-gas processing plant. Israel's military did not immediately comment. The extent of damage at the South Pars natural gas field was not immediately clear. Such sites have air defence systems around them, which Israel has been targeting. An oil refinery was also damaged in the northern Israeli city of Haifa, according to the firm operating it. Bazan Group said pipelines and transmission lines between facilities were damaged, forcing some downstream facilities to be shut down. It said no-one was wounded. The Arab Gulf country of Oman, which has been mediating indirect talks between the US and Iran over Tehran's nuclear programme, said a sixth round planned for Sunday would not take place. 'We remain committed to talks and hope the Iranians will come to the table soon,' a senior US official said. Mr Araghchi said on Saturday that the nuclear talks were 'unjustifiable' after Israel's strikes, which he said were the 'result of the direct support by Washington'. In a post on his Truth Social account early on Sunday, Mr Trump reiterated that the US was not involved in the attacks on Iran and warned that any retaliation directed against it would bring an American response 'at levels never seen before'. 'However, we can easily get a deal done between Iran and Israel, and end this bloody conflict!!!' he wrote.
Irish Independent
35 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Taoiseach vows new rent controls will be sanctioned by July
Rent controls are being extended to the fifth of tenancies not already covered by Rent Pressure Zone (RPZ) regulations. Under the new regulations, RPZs will change to a nationwide rent control system. RPZs until now only extended to specific areas of high demand where rent increases were capped at a maximum of 2pc per annum. Introduced to tackle spiralling rents amid Ireland's housing shortage, RPZs had been due to expire by December 31. Now, the system will be extended and will effectively operate on a nationwide basis. Taoiseach Micheal Martin said the measures had attracted widespread support. "First of all, the measures have been broadly welcomed by people who are engaged in the housing sector and the housing industry," he said. "I think the Opposition didn't expect the measures we brought in in terms of the protections (offered)." "This measure will come before the Government – it will have to go through the legislature – that depends on the Oireachtas." "But the aim is to have it done before the summer recess and that's just one aspect of what was an important series of reforms which were necessary." ADVERTISEMENT Mr Martin said the measures were being implemented to address issues within the accommodation sector. Under the changes, a further 11 counties will benefit from the controls offered by the RPZ regime. "They had to happen because of the fact we were looking at the expiry deadline for the existing framework at the end of the year and which the Housing Commission and then the Housing Agency – following that the Housing Commission did a review on all of this – both recommended change." "So steady as it goes," he said. Tánaiste Simon Harris said the Coalition was committed to taking "big and bold decisions" on housing in a bid to increase supply and control costs for families. Housing Minister James Browne will introduce the legislation this week. Mr Harris said while it was an interim bill, it could be called emergency legislation. The Tánaiste said the measures underlined just how seriously the Government regarded the issue of housing. Ireland's Economic and Social Research Institute (ESRI) warned that between 35,000 and 53,000 new homes are now required on an annual basis to cope with Ireland's accommodation need. The rent controls measures are being introduced amid fears Ireland will miss its house construction target in 2025.
Extra.ie
2 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Jailing of undocumented migrants ‘will lead to early release of high-risk criminals'
The Department of Justice was warned a crackdown on undocumented immigrants would lead to more serious and high-risk criminals being temporarily released from jail. The head of the Irish Prison Service (IPS) said a garda decision to bring charges against individuals arriving in Ireland without valid documents was contributing to 'unsafe and unmanageable' levels of overcrowding. In a letter to a senior department official obtained under Freedom of Information legislation, IPS Director General Caron McCaffrey noted that in normal circumstances low-risk offenders on short sentences were the first to be offered temporary release. The Department of Justice was warned a crackdown on undocumented immigrants would lead to more serious and high-risk criminals being temporarily released from jail. Pic: Fran Veale She said this would normally include those in custody for immigration offences but that the Department of Justice had made a deliberate policy decision to keep them in jail. Ms McCaffrey said that, while the move was 'understandable', it was adding to the immense pressure on the Irish prison system. She wrote: '[It] will unfortunately necessitate the early release of more serious and high-risk offenders to make space in already overcrowded prisons [instead of] offenders deemed to be low risk from a re-offending and community safety perspective.' Ms McCaffrey also warned the Prison Service was heading into a 'catastrophic period' and that numbers in custody were reaching new highs every day. She said if changes were not made, there was 'real potential to result in violent disorder within our prisons threatening the safety and wellbeing of both our staff and those in our care'. The Director General said the Irish Prison Service had exhausted all options around the temporary release (TR) of low-risk offenders. She said the department needed to look at temporary release for 'medium-risk to high-risk sentenced offenders', which would have to apply to criminals including 'prolific' burglars and individuals who were convicted of assault on gardaí or peace officers. Ms McCaffrey urged the Department to look at options for temporary release of sex offenders, especially those who are at low risk of offending. Under existing rules, sex offenders are ineligible for temporary release and no change has been made to this policy since the letter was sent. As the prisons boss acknowledged to the Department: 'It is recognised that this is a difficult category due to the victim issues and the fact that people convicted of a sex offence pose a low risk of very serious harm while other types of offenders pose a high risk of less-serious harm. 'However, other categories being considered for temporary release as part of crisis measures pose a much greater risk to public safety,' she added. Caron McCaffrey Ms McCaffrey said this was particularly relevant for historic convictions and older sex offenders, some of whom were 'medically dependent' people and actively engaging in rehabilitation. She also called for more flexibility around the use of 'open prisons' for long-serving prisoners. Under existing rules, only those serving sentences of less than eight years could be transferred to an open centre such as Loughan House or Shelton Abbey meaning spaces were not always being used in an optimal way. Ms McCaffrey also called for a reduction in the number of people being remanded to custody rather than granted bail. She said there was a particular need for a bail supervision scheme for female offenders, with the country's two women's prisons in Dublin and Limerick operating above capacity. Ms McCaffrey also asked the Department to press ahead with efforts for reopening of the disused Curragh Prison on Defence Forces land in Co. Kildare. Her letter concluded: 'Overall, we are in an extremely difficult situation that we anticipate will only get worse without urgent decisions being made.' Asked about the correspondence, a spokesman for the Irish Prison Service said they had nothing further to add.
