Renovation plans for listed Scarborough building rejected
Plans to renovate an historic Grade I listed building in Scarborough's popular South Bay have been rejected.The proposals for the King Richard III bar and restaurant at 23-24 Sandside were blocked by North Yorkshire Council due to concerns they would harm the heritage building and the wider conservation area.The installation of replacement timber windows and doors and the replacement of a section of lead roofing and render repairs had been proposed by the business.Despite concluding that "the harm is classed as less than substantial", officers said the scheme could not be allowed to go ahead
'Historic interest'
Nationally, only 2% of historic buildings are Grade I Listed, and others in the seaside town with the same status include Scarborough Castle and St Mary's Church on Castle Road.According to the Local Democracy Reporting Service, North Yorkshire Council's conservation officer said the proposed changes "fail to conserve the shopfront window and door, fanlight and awning, which are features of architectural and historic significance".The property had the "highest architectural and historic interest", they added."Great weight should be given to the asset's conservation and the more important the asset, the greater the weight should be," the officer said.A planning report stated: "Although the harm is classed as less than substantial, due to the importance of the heritage asset, the loss of historic fabric proposed is assessed to be at the highest end of the 'less-than-substantial' scale."
'No heritage benefit'
In its application, the business said benefits of the proposed scheme included "enhanced security and energy efficiency for the cafe and bar, as well as local employment benefits during works".However, officers said that public benefits would need to outweigh the assessed harm and said they were doubtful about "whether these are genuine public benefits and not private benefits".They added that "no heritage benefit would result from the proposal".North Yorkshire Council rejected the application, saying the applicant "has not provided sufficient evidence to justify the loss of these features on the listed building when appropriate repairs are also a viable option"."Nor have they provided evidence to demonstrate that the public benefits of the proposal would outweigh the level of harm identified", the council said.
Listen to highlights from North Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
a day ago
- BBC News
Uttoxeter Maltings regeneration scheme behind schedule, council says
A major regeneration project in Staffordshire is behind schedule, according to performance targets set by the local authority.A planning application for the redevelopment of The Maltings site in Uttoxeter was due to be submitted in delay was caused by a decision to file separate applications for demolition of the shopping precinct and the regeneration work, bosses council said an application for the demolition was now due to be submitted this month. East Staffordshire Borough Council bought the shopping centre in January, following its purchase of the former Co-op building in 2023 alongside the land that it already council has previously committed to further improvements in the area, including refurbishing toilets on Bradley Street, upgrading connectivity from a bus station and car park to the high street, as well as installing improved lighting and seating, plus a full pedestrianisation of the high addition, 12 new electric vehicle charging stations have been installed in the car park.A consultation on the proposed regeneration work began in May last year and has since ended. This news was gathered by the Local Democracy Reporting Service, which covers councils and other public service organisations. Follow BBC Stoke & Staffordshire on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
BBC News
2 days ago
- BBC News
Major Greater Manchester regeneration plan gets city's backing
Plans to transform two Greater Manchester boroughs have been backed by city Council gave its support to a new development zone that Salford and Trafford along the Manchester Ship Canal. Thousands of jobs could be created as homes and business premises are built, Salford leaders heard. The area is one of six "growth locations" across Greater Manchester boroughs that aim to bring in about £10bn of investment. Salford's mayor, Paul Dennett, said the long-term plan mean "we can secure significant infrastructure investment for this part of the region, while also creating a fairer, greener, healthier and more inclusive city".He added "much-needed homes and high quality jobs that local people deserve" would come from the projects. The Local Democracy Reporting Service reported that the mayoral development zone proposal still needed approval from Trafford Council's executive on 16 June, and from the Greater Manchester Combined Authority on 27 week, Trafford council's executive member for economy and regeneration, Liz Patel, said the development would "see a whole range of opportunities for residents, businesses and visitors, to make the most of our vibrant, well-connected locations and great transport network". Listen to the best of BBC Radio Manchester on Sounds and follow BBC Manchester on Facebook, X, and Instagram. You can also send story ideas via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230.
BBC News
3 days ago
- BBC News
Public toilet restoration approved by Chichester District Council
Eight public toilets in the Chichester district will be refurbished after getting council plans follow the demolition and rebuilding of the old toilet block in Tower new Tower Street toilet, which opened earlier this month, cost more than £200,000 and has been said to be inspiring "envy" in other areas after receiving positive Google reviews. The cost of the latest scheme has not yet been revealed but will be made up of money from the Asset Replacement Fund and from reserves. Chichester District Council does not legally have to provide public toilets, but leader Adrian Moss said they were important to residents, adding that the Tower Street project had been "a triumph".Councillor John Cross added: "There is a bit of toilet envy going on with other district councils because our Tower Street toilets have been given a five-star rating on Google and other district councils want the same!"The toilets set for improvement are in Bracklesham Bay in Bracklesham, Pound Road car park in Petworth, Lifeboat Way in Selsey, Northgate car park in Chichester, Avenue de Chartres car park in Chichester, Hillfield Road in Selsey, Kingfisher Parade in East Wittering and Marine Drive in West council will now look for a contractor to carry out the work, which will be a phased approach over the next two years, said the Local Democracy Reporting Service.
