Judgment reserved in Ramaphosa's appeal matter on recognising King Misuzulu as Zulu heir
Nhlanhla Mabaso 29 May 2025 | 16:19 Misuzulu kaZwelithini
Cyril Ramaphosa
Pretoria High Court
President Cyril Ramaphosa meets His Majesty Misuzulu KaZwelithini ahead of the 110th commemoration of King Dinuzulu at KwaNkomonye Royal Palace in KwaZulu Natal on 16 March 2024. Picture: GCIS
BLOEMFONTEIN - Judgment has been reserved in President Cyril Ramaphosa's appeal matter involving the Zulu royal family's identification process.The president seeks to overturn a judgment by the North Gauteng High Court in Pretoria invalidating his recognition of King Misuzulu kaZwekithini as the rightful heir.The appeal was heard for two days in the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA).
With arguments having been concluded, the judges said they would announce the judgment at a later stage.
Ramaphosa's lawyers have argued till the end of these proceedings that his recognition of Amazulu King Misuzulu as monarch was done properly, while the king's lawyers told the five judges that custom dictates that he be on the Zulu throne.
The parties then submitted that the high court order be reversed.
However, Prince Simakde wants the North Gauteng High Court ruling to be adhered to, and that the president appoints an investigative committee to probe the process of identification.
Meanwhile, the king's uncle, Prince Mbonisi Zulu, wants the court to refer the matter of identifying a king back to the Zulu royal family.
Justice Dumisani Zondi reserved the judgment.
ALSO READ: Prince Mbonisi Zulu disputes title of King Misuzulu's mother as 'great wife' of royal family
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
3 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Electronic death registration is a win-win for SA — let's make it happen
Several studies have flagged problems with South Africa's death registration processes. To address it, a critical first step is to replace our paper-based process with an electronic one. A recent report by the South African Medical Research Council (SAMRC) highlights the underreporting of HIV in official mortality statistics. Official cause of death statistics are based on what doctors write on death notification forms. As part of the process of death registration, medical practitioners are required by law to provide information about the medical conditions resulting in each death. Multiple studies have identified concerns about the quality of the information provided by doctors and the Department of Health has been urged in a policy brief to address them as it clearly undermines the quality of data used by our government for health planning and resource allocation. The recently reported study found extensive underreporting of HIV as a cause of death. Only 28% of deaths that occurred in a national sample of public sector hospitals where the medical record had clear clinical indications of HIV, had HIV specified on their death notification form. Aside from ensuring that medical certification of the cause of death is part of the medical training curriculum, and that additional training is provided during internship periods, another key issue to address is that many doctors are reluctant to record HIV/Aids as a cause of death due to concerns about maintaining patient confidentiality. In 2014, a self-sealing section was added to protect information about cause of death on the death notification form, but this has clearly not had the desired effect. Following the deaths of at least 22 children from contaminated food in 2024, President Cyril Ramaphosa announced that the Department of Health would develop an electronic system for recording causes of death as one of several responses to the emergency. The move to an electronic system offers a strategic opportunity to address the challenge around confidentiality and promises a lot more. It allows for secure, institution-based data management that protects confidentiality, encourages accurate reporting and strengthens the integrity of vital statistics. Benefits of this digital transition will include: Improved data quality and confidentiality, encouraging accurate reporting of sensitive conditions like HIV/Aids; Automated validation checks, reducing certification errors at the point of data entry; Real-time access to mortality data, enabling rapid public health responses; and A platform for quality assurance and feedback, currently not possible in the paper-based system. Ultimately, moving away from a paper-based process of death registration will reduce the administrative burden and improve efficiency across the system. This presents a timely and valuable opportunity to collaborate across departments, including health, home affairs and Statistics South Africa, to modernise the country's civil registration and vital statistics system. We are at a pivotal moment for such coordinated policy action. Investing in a robust electronic system for cause-of-death certification will strengthen South Africa's public health planning, improve disease surveillance and increase accountability. The long-term returns – through faster, more reliable data – are substantial for both governance and health outcomes. It is a win-win. DM Dr Pam Groenewald and Professor Debbie Bradshaw are with the South African Medical Research Council's Burden of Disease Research Unit. Note: Spotlight previously reported on the issues discussed in this opinion piece. That reporting included the sentence: 'In the meantime, routine mortality data from Stats SA should clearly be taken with a pinch of salt.' That sentence may have been construed as reflecting Groenewald and the SAMRC's views. Groenewald has asked us to clarify that it does not. She points out that Stats SA is obligated to process the data it receives and the quality issues stem from what doctors report.
The Citizen
6 hours ago
- The Citizen
‘War on Leaks' programme: SIU reveals R2.2bn budget balloons to over R4bn
The SIU has uncovered irregular contract extensions and procurement irregularities in its investigation into the water and sanitation department. The Special Investigating Unit (SIU) has revealed that the budget for the War on Leaks programme has increased to more than double the initial plan, and the number is still rising. The SIU appeared before the Standing Committee on Public Accounts on Wednesday, where it provided an update on its investigations into the Department of Water and Sanitation. According to the SIU, the department is riddled with: Contracts that balloon from the initial budget Irregular appointments of service providers Contractors who fail to perform contractual duties Irregular contract extensions Procurement irregularities Possible fraudulent claims Overpriced goods and services Payment for work never performed Manipulation of the payment system for overpayment and incorrect VAT charges Officials in the water sector who certified and commissioned work that was not performed Irregular expenditure In April last year, President Cyril Ramaphosa signed Proclamation 164 of 2024, authorising the SIU to investigate allegations of serious maladministration in the department and to recover any financial losses suffered by the state or the department. ALSO READ: SIU is not done with NLC yet, as more corruption allegations emerge The scope of the investigation covers any unlawful or improper conduct by department officials or employees, as well as applicable suppliers or service providers, or any other person or entity that has caused or may cause serious harm to the public's interests. 'War on Leaks' The War on Leaks Artisan Training programme was launched by then-president Jacob Zuma in 2015 with the aim of training 15,000 youths to reduce water losses through leaks. The project was signed in 2015 by then Water and Sanitation Minister Nomvula Mokonyane for Rand Water to curb about R7 billion in water leaks across the country. During Phase one of the project, 3 000 pupils were trained during 2015/2016, during Phase two, 5,000 pupils were trained during 2016/2017, while in Phase three, 7,000 pupils were set to be trained during 2017/2018. The second phase of the War on Leaks project was launched by Mokonyane in Durban in February 2017. ALSO READ: SIU authorised to probe water department's 'war on leaks' project The approved budget for the programme was R2.2 billion. However, the SIU identified that R4.7 billion had been paid out so far, the SIU told the committee on Wednesday. The SIU said this number continues to increase due to its forensic account quantification process. Rand Water received R1.7 billion, which includes R40 million in unexplained and unsubstantiated contingency fees. This investigation is ongoing. SIU on Rooiwal Wastewater Treatment Works Rooiwal made headlines in 2023 after a cholera outbreak which killed 23 people at Hammanskraal, with controversial businessman Edwin Sodi's R295-million tender contract to upgrade the plant's infrastructure being scrutinised. At the time, the department found that 'the failure of the Rooiwal Wastewater Treatment Works to meet the desirable final effluent quality for discharge to the Apies River, which in turn flows into the Leeukraal Dam', played a critical role in the Hammanskraal water crisis. ALSO READ: SIU investigates two municipalities for 'serious maladministration' over street light deals The SIU has since been investigating the refurbishment and upgrade project, of which only 60% of the first phase was completed before it was abandoned in 2020. In this project, the SIU identified 65 role players for high-level profiling, including officials, private individuals and entities. Nine officials were flagged for further lifestyle audits due to assets purchased and indications that they were living beyond their means. The SIU said that 27 officials were also flagged for further lifestyle audits due to assets purchased or living beyond their means, as well as suspicious transactions. Since 2012, the department's cash and assets yet to be recovered amount to R264.1 million, while the actual cash or assets recovered amount to R569.1 million. The department's contracts or administrative decisions that were set aside or deemed invalid amount to R1.1 billion. The SIU prevented a potential loss of R717 million. From 2008, the SIU has received 14 proclamations relating to the water and sanitation sector. Investigations into nine of these proclamations have been finalised, while five are active. READ NEXT: Rooiwal tender award: Tshwane officials absolved in Edwin Sodi's company progression
TimesLIVE
9 hours ago
- TimesLIVE
Is Floyd Shivambu a victim of tribalistic machinations in MK Party?
The removal of Floyd Shivambu as secretary-general of the MK Party has sparked a debate about the party's alleged tribalistic behaviour. His removal comes after his controversial visit to fugitive 'prophet' Shepherd Bushiri's church in Malawi over Easter weekend, which the party deemed unauthorised and contrary to its constitution. Critics argue that the MK Party's leadership structure and support base, predominantly Zulu-speaking, give the impression of a 'Zulu party'. The party's dominance in KwaZulu-Natal, where it secured most of the vote in the 2024 elections, has fuelled these perceptions. Additionally, party leader Jacob Zuma's practice of addressing members in Zulu during briefings has been cited as evidence of the party's tribalistic tendencies. Shivambu's time in the party has been marred by controversy, including complaints about his leadership style and a public spat with Zuma's daughter Duduzile Zuma-Sambudla. His removal from the secretary-general position has been met with mixed reactions, with some speculating his differences with Duduzile may have contributed to his departure, while others assumed he was just unfortunate due to not being Zulu. Despite the controversy surrounding his removal, Shivambu accepted the decision and thanked the party leadership for assigning him to an 'important role' in parliament. The party has announced Shivambu will be redeployed to serve in the National Assembly as an MP.
