‘I used to think Ireland was safe,' says US tourist (81) violently robbed in Kerry
Andrea Bartlett gave a lengthy victim impact statement during the sentencing hearing of Lithuanian man Tomas Starodubcevas
Andrea Bartlett and her husband Bill celebrating their 54th wedding anniversary at Kitty O'Se's in Killarney, shortly before they were attacked on the way to their B&B.
An American tourist, who came to Ireland on a long-planned trip to celebrate her 54th wedding anniversary, has revealed the extent of her injuries and the ordeal she suffered when she was thrown to the ground and robbed while in Kerry.
Andrea Bartlett (81) gave a lengthy victim impact statement via video link from the US this week during the sentencing hearing of Lithuanian man Tomas Starodubcevas (24) who is charged with robbery arising out of the incident at Port Road, Killarney, on April 22, 2024.
Judge Ronan Munro, sitting at Tralee Circuit Criminal Court, said he would like to commiserate with Ms Bartlett as her long-planned trip was 'ruined'.
She told the court she would like to see the defendant, and the camera was adjusted to allow this. Judge Munro said he was sitting in the dock with his hand 'hanging in shame' as he should be.
Ms Bartlett told the court she was 'viciously attacked" on Port Road.
"He threw me to the ground on my left side causing a head injury, and ripped my purse off my right arm causing my humerus [upper right arm] to break in two. I heard the arm break before I hit the ground as it made a loud cracking sound like a branch snapping off a tree. It was so loud I imagine the thief heard it too.'
She said the only question she has had in her mind since then, is 'how could one human being do this to another?'.
She told the court the trip had originally been planned to celebrate the couple's 50th wedding anniversary, but had been postponed due to Covid.
They had also hoped to look up family ancestors while in Ireland, including Sneem, Tahilla and Kenmare in Co Kerry. However, their trip had to be cut short after the ordeal.
On the night of the incident, they had just eaten dinner at a local restaurant where they had a special celebration organised by the B&B owners to mark their anniversary.
She said they were on their way home when the criminal 'brutally attacked'. Gardaí and the emergency services arrived at the scene and Ms Bartlett was transported to University Hospital Kerry. She said when she woke up the next morning, the pain was 'excruciating'.
'Every time I moved I could feel the bones scraping against each other,' she said.
Andrea Bartlett and her husband Bill celebrating their 54th wedding anniversary at Kitty O'Se's in Killarney, shortly before they were attacked on the way to their B&B.
News in 90 Seconds - May 25th 2025
She said such was the movement of the broken bones that it made her feel dizzy and nauseous, and that she also vomited periodically during the first day of her injury, which may have been a result of her head injury.
Ms Bartlett flew home to the US on April 25, three days after the incident occurred, and has endured a 'long and painful recovery' since then.
'I spent two-and-a-half months sitting on my couch day and night. I could not lie down to sleep as it caused too much pain. If I didn't move, I could manage the pain.'
Standing up, walking and travelling in a car also caused her pain. Her husband had to look after her all the time, and she also had to get home help as she could not do anything for herself.
The head injury she suffered also caused difficulties, particularly with her balance, and this remains an issue making it difficult to walk. She is still undergoing physical therapy.
Ms Bartlett said her injuries have left her with several side effects.
My injuries have seriously impacted the quality of life for both my husband and me
She said the attack meant she missed out on many things, including planning to see the towns in Kerry where her ancestors came from.
'My injuries have seriously impacted the quality of life for both my husband and me. We have not been able to visit with family and friends or socialise with them.'
She said she can no longer undertake the activities she enjoyed like playing bridge, gardening and playing bocce.
She has also suffered a significant financial loss as a result of her injuries.
Ms Bartlett said she 'used to think Ireland was a safe place'.
'I am hoping this was an anomaly but, in the future, I plan to be more observant whether I am travelling in Ireland or the US.'
Tomas Starodubcevas of Tudor Lodge, Woodlawn Road, Killarney, was charged with robbing Mrs Bartlett of €325 on April 22.
Listowel District Court, where Starodubcevas was initially charged
Barrister Katie O'Connell, representing Starodubcevas, said her client offered his most sincere apology to Ms Bartlett.
"He is truly ashamed, it has haunted him,' she said.
Ms O'Connell said the defendant had been taking drugs at the time. He owed money and was 'desperate'.
'It may be of little comfort, but it's important you know he is very sorry.'
Ms Bartlett said she was very curious to know why he had done it.
Judge Munro said one of the things he had to consider in sentencing is whether Starodubcevas would re-offend.
The court heard he is currently in jail, after he arrived to court late the previous day, so he is no longer on the streets.
He adjourned the case to July 8 for sentencing to allow a probation report to be carried out, and said Mr Starodubcevas will remain in jail while he is being assessed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
10 hours ago
- Sunday World
Relative of man arrested over Mike Gaine's killing says ‘he's not capable of murder'
Michael Kelley was described as a 'gentle lion' and 'highly intelligent' A family member of a man arrested over the murder of Kerry farmer Mike Gaine has said they cannot conceive that he could be capable of murder. Michael Kelley (53), from Maine in the United States, has told a number of news organisations that he was arrested and questioned as part of the investigation, but said he is being framed by others involved in the killing. A family member of Mr Kelley residing in the US told the Sunday World: 'The Michael I knew was not capable of murder, but we haven't spoken in years.' They described him as a 'gentle lion', and said he is 'highly intelligent' and is 'always generous with people in need'. Separately, court documents obtained by the Sunday World regarding a case in the US several years ago detail how a judge said Mr Kelley has 'questionable ability' to 'determine fact from fiction'. Mr Kelley was arrested on May 18 over the murder of 56-year-old Mr Gaine. He was questioned for 24 hours before being released without charge. In a series of interviews, the American, who says he is a former US soldier, has denied any involvement in the murder of Mr Gaine. Michael Kelley was arrested and released without charge. Photo: Domnick Walsh Mike Gaine: Chief suspect insists he had nothing to do with Kerry farmer's death Until recently, Mr Kelley lived for around three years on Mr Gaine's farm and was employed as a labourer, assisting with physical tasks on the extensive south Kerry farm, which spans about 1,000 acres. It is understood that gardaí are exploring a number of potential theories as they look for a motive in the case. In the early days of the investigation, it is understood that gardaí profiled a number of people who knew Mr Gaine well. A number of individuals were quickly ruled out of the probe. A source said that there have been 'no major developments' in the case in the past week. Mr Kelley is currently free to leave the country, having been released without charge following his arrest on suspicion of murder. However, it's understood that he doesn't have a passport at present. The 53-year-old previously sought asylum in Ireland. In an interview with RTÉ, Mr Kelley spoke of his relationship with Mr Gaine. 'We worked hand and glove. Doing the sheep or whatever, dosing them and stuff. I had already handled animals. I was fixing cars and tractors for him [Gaine],' he said. Mr Kelley said he last saw Mr Gaine at 'around 10am' on March 20 when they met in the farmyard. Michael Kelley was arrested and released without charge. Photo: Domnick Walsh News in 90 seconds - June 2nd He said Mr Gaine had indicated to him that he was planning to meet somebody that day, before giving Mr Kelley a list of chores to complete. Mr Kelley said he then returned to the old farmhouse to make coffee, adding that was the last time he saw Mr Gaine. 'Around 10am. He was as normal as ever. He was doing his chores,' Mr Kelley told RTÉ. 'Redistributing the silage and things. Just ordinary chores. He said 'look after the chores for me. I'm just going to meet a man. I'll be back later'. 'He didn't come back that night. He said he would be back. Then they came looking for him at about 10am the following morning.' Mr Gaine went missing on March 20. His car, which contained a number of personal items, was found on the farm at Carrig East, situated between the town of Kenmare and Moll's Gap. Mike Gaine's remains were found on his farm Mr Kelley told RTÉ: 'I wouldn't describe us as great friends, but we got on. Our relationship was transactional. He gave me accommodation, food and paid me. In return I worked on his farm. 'We had a good working relationship, a civil relationship. We got on and understood one another. 'We are both farmers. We are getting along because we are grown men and we have work to do. 'We were brothers of the land, around the same age, with similar interests, and I liked that sense of brotherhood.' A musician who plays the flute and tin whistle, Mr Kelley was recently seen busking in Tralee, where he has been pictured and has given interviews. In an effort to establish Mr Gaine's whereabouts, an extensive search of his farm, surrounding valleys and lakes was initiated. On April 29, Mr Gaine's disappearance was upgraded by gardaí from a missing person case to a homicide investigation. Human remains were discovered on Mr Gaine's farm on May 16, when one of his nephews and a neighbour were spreading slurry on fields. The farm was immediately sealed off and declared a crime scene. Further human remains are believed to have been found in a slurry spreader and in a slurry tank on the farm in the following days. Gardaí say DNA tests have since confirmed that the remains are those of Mr Gaine. A specialist examination of the slurry tank on Mr Gaine's hillside farmyard days after he disappeared did not uncover his dismembered remains. Questions are now being asked as to how they went undetected by gardaí. However, sources have said that Mr Gaine's remains had been dismembered to such an extent that the small pieces of his body somehow went unnoticed during a specialist search of the slurry tank by gardaí and members of Kerry County Fire Services on March 24.
Sunday World
10 hours ago
- Sunday World
GAA boss Davy Fitzgerald's son spared jail for stealing €35k from former employer
WALKS FREE | Court hears thefts were made to feed a 'serious' gambling addiction Colm Fitzgerald outside Ennis Circuit Criminal Court (Photo: Brendan Gleeson) Colm Fitzgerald, (28), of Castlequinn, Sixmilebridge, Co Clare, stole the money while employed to be in charge of cash at a cash counter, at Bank of Ireland, Shannon Industrial Estate, Shannon, Co Clare, on seven separate dates in 2023, the court heard. Fitzgerald, who immediately resigned after the thefts were discovered during an internal audit, told the bank and gardaí that he stole the cash to sustain a gambling addiction. Fitzgerald's barrister, Kenny Kerins, told Ennis Circuit Criminal Court that 'steeped in GAA' Fitzgerald had paid all of the money back with the support and assistance of his family. Mr Kerins said Fitzgerald was caught in a 'serious' grip of addiction to sports gambling and that he had 'expressed relief' when the thefts were discovered. Fitzgerald admitted stealing the cash in bundles of €5,000 on seven separate dates in 2023. Mr Kerins told the court: 'He was living a life of secrets, he has remorse, he has shame. This young man had everything going well in his life, he was engaged in sport, he had a job, and in seven actions, he absolutely destroys his career'. The barrister told the sentencing hearing last Friday that, prior to the discovery of the cash thefts, Fitzgerald's gambling had become so serious the well-known bookmaker chain Paddy Power banned him from betting with them. 'They were so concerned that they wrote to him and banned him from gambling with them… this was a serious addiction for Mr Fitzgerald,' Mr Kerins said. 'His life was completely out of control, so much so that he sees all this as a positive thing, he sees it as a disengagement from his addiction.' Colm Fitzgerald outside Ennis Circuit Criminal Court (Photo: Brendan Gleeson) News in 90 seconds - June 2nd Mr Kerins said when Bank of Ireland's auditors discovered €35,000 was missing, Fitzgerald prepared a document that would have concealed 'his deceit' but he 'cancelled it almost immediately'. 'He was about to further his criminal endeavour, but he stopped it. He went home and told his grandfather and close family, he knew the jig was up and he came forward, he met with bank officials and made admissions, he resigned and met with gardaí by appointment,' Mr Kerins said. 'That is to his credit, he faced up to it, he is a gentleman.' Mr Kerins said Fitzgerald was 'aware' thefts from his employer were 'unacceptable' but he said Fitzgerald had taken responsibility for his offending as well as measures not to return to gambling. 'He and his family are steeped in GAA, which was perhaps how he became involved in [sports] gambling. Mr Kerins said Fitzgerald had 'engaged with therapeutic services and had worked as a courier' to pay his family back the money they reimbursed to the bank. The barrister said Fitzgerald has, along with his partner, opened a coffee shop in Sixmilebridge, employing four people, and that Fitzgerald had 'taken careful steps' to limit his own 'access to the business's finances and cash, so there is oversight'. Colm Fitzgerald outside Ennis Circuit Criminal Court (Photo: Brendan Gleeson) Detective Garda Paddy Bourke, of Shannon garda station, told the court he believed Fitzgerald had done all he could to co-operate with the garda investigation as well as trying to tackle his addiction and that he hopes to 'to continue to do so'. CCTV footage located at cash counters had expired by the time the bank discovered the thefts and alerted gardaí, and so Fitzgerald's pleas were valuable to the prosecution, the court heard. Mr Kerins said Fitzgerald had 'no previous convictions', had engaged in a residential therapy programme run by the Bushypark Addiction Treatment Centre, and he continues to attend regular Gamblers Anonymous (GA) meetings. 'He's not seeking to blame anyone, he developed a low-level gambling addiction which snowballed and got out-of-control while he was working as an employee of the bank – the court is aware of the compulsive nature of gambling addiction,' Mr Kerins said. Prosecuting barrister Sarah-Jane Comerford said the prosecution 'accepted [Fitzgerald] was suffering from a gambling addiction at the time'. Judge Francis Comerford said Fitzgerald 'took bundles of cash from his employer each worth €5,000' and that he considered a two-year headline sentence to be appropriate. 'It was a significant breach of trust, it was a significant offence, and the aggravating factor is that it was theft by an employee from their employer'. Reducing the sentence to 12 months, the judge said: 'It wasn't a commercial calculated crime, so that tends to put it at a lower level, and it was discovered very quickly.' Judge Comerford suspended the jail term for 18 months, and directed Fitzgerald to continue engaging with gambling support services.
The Irish Sun
11 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Shock moment tourist jumps railing and plunges 18ft into Terracotta Army pit before smashing two priceless statues
THIS is the shocking moment a tourist jumps a railing around the famous Terracotta Army and smashes up two of the priceless statues. The 30-year-old visitor leapt over the guard rail surrounding Advertisement 5 The tourist leapt down into the 18ft-deep pit, landing amongst Terracotta Army warriors Credit: News Flare 5 Two statues can be seen knocked over and damaged Credit: News Flare 5 The man, identified as 30-year-old Sun, is said to suffer from mental health problems Credit: News Flare Footage shows the aftermath of his jump and senseless destruction of the 2000-year-old artefacts. He can be seen lying on his back and rolling around - apparently in pain - at the bottom of an 18ft-deep pit. The alleged vandal is leaning against one of the ancient statues as alarmed onlookers peer down into the pit. Another angle shows the devastating extent of the damage to the statues. Advertisement read more in world news Two have been knocked over and lie in pieces on the floor after the man "pushed and pulled" the clay figures. They can clearly be seen to have crumbled in part - with officials reporting they were damaged to "varying degrees". Security guards for the museum quickly stepped in to grab the intruder before he inflicted more damage. Authorities said the man, identified only by his surname Sun, suffers from mental health problems. Advertisement Most read in The US Sun They also confirmed an investigation has been launched into the circumstances surrounding the incident. Concerns have been raised about how Sun managed to breach the security measures - consisting of a railing protective net - to plunge into the deep pit. Dramatic moment gang blow up museum door & steal 2,500-year-old Golden Helmet in Ocean's 11-style heist before vanishing Despite the intrusion, museum staff confirmed that the Xi'An exhibition remains open to the public. In 2017, an American man admitted to stealing a thumb from one of the terracotta warriors while it was on exhibition in Pennsylvania. Advertisement Michael Rohana, in his early 20s, snapped it off when it was on display at the Franklin Institute museum. In that case, the statue was estimated to be worth $4.5million. 5 The clay figures were discovered buried underground 50 years ago Credit: �2024 Netflix, Inc. 5 The sculptures are based on the army of China's first emperor, Qin Shi Huang Credit: Getty Advertisement By that figure, the damage inflicted by the rogue tourist in Xi'An could amount to a whopping $9million, if the statues are ruined. Rohana was acquitted after his prosecution ended in a mistrial. His lawyer successfully argued that he was wrongly charged under laws that usually apply to major museum thefts. Surveillance footage had captured him "clowning around" with the statues and taking selfies, before appearing to break something from one before leaving. Advertisement Museum staff noticed the missing thumb the following month and contacted the FBI. They later traced the thumb to Rohana, who admitted he had kept the thumb in a desk drawer. What is the Terracotta Army? THE Terracotta Army is a collection of sculptures depicting the army of China's first emperor, Qin Shi Huang. The warriors are made from terracotta, which is a type of reddish-brown clay. The army was crafted for the purpose of being buried alongside Huang when he died around 210 BC. It was believed they would help protect him in the afterlife. The sculptures were first discovered in 1974 by local farmers in Linton County, outside Xi'an. They vary in height according to their rank - with the generals built to be the tallest. Amongst the collection are around 8,000 soldiers, 130 chariots with 520 horses, 150 cavalry horses and a range of other non-military figures. Some of the sculptures have been moved for display, whilst others remain in situ in the pits.
