Politics latest: Esther Rantzen branded 'distasteful and disrespectful' as MPs debated assisted dying bill
Labour MP fears 'disproportionate impact' of assisted dying bill - and hits out at Rantzen
Labour MP Florence Eshalomi rises next to speak in opposition to the bill, as she did at second reading last year "on the grounds of inadequate safeguard against the coercion of minority communities".
She tells MPs that she has been following the detailed scrutiny of the bill at committee stage in the hopes that her "concerns would be addressed".
"But I am sad to say I'm even more worried now than I was then," she says.
Eshalomi also states that a Private Member's Bill is not "the appropriate mechanism for a national decision of this magnitude to be made", and the government should lead on such a change, rather than an MP "without an elected mandate" (a reference to Kim Leadbeater).
Eshalomi also argues that Leadbeater's amendment to ensure that medical professionals will not face any sanction for refusing to carry out an assisted death is not "comprehensive".
She quotes a palliative care consultant who works predominantly with ethnic minorities who told her, "we are scared".
They fear there will be a "disproportionate impact" on ethnic minority communities.
Eshalomi tells MPs: "Are we really prepared to sideline those unheard voices, and risk embedding further inequalities in healthcare as we legislate?"
She goes on: "If hospices are unable to opt out of providing assisted dying as a collective policy, then the people who already feel ignored by the healthcare systems are more likely to fear accessing the care that they need at the end of their lives."
The Labour MP also takes a swipe at Dame Esther Rantzen for suggesting that "undeclared religious beliefs" were behind some MPs' opposition to the legislation.
She says that is not the reason, but rather because "we recognise that if this bill passes, it may impact everyone, not just those who may wish to die".
Rantzen's statement was "frankly insulting to disabled people, hardworking professionals up and down the country who have raised many valid concerns about this bill to have it dismissed as 'religious beliefs'".
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
35 minutes ago
- BBC News
Gender treatment at Brighton GP practice under investigation
A GP practice is under investigation over concerns it may have prescribed gender-related medication to under-18s outside national clinical Sussex and NHS England is reviewing WellBN, which operates in Brighton and Hove, to assess the care of children and young people who were prescribed or supplied medication for gender Sussex said on Thursday it had launched "a rapid investigation into this activity".WellBN said it had paused all new hormone prescriptions for under-18s but it would "do our best to turn this decision around". The practice added in its statement, issued on its website in May, that it would continue to prescribe to young patients already under its care and the restriction only applies to "the initiation of new prescriptions".It said the NHS was "threatening to close us down altogether if we did not comply" and it "had to consider all 25,000 patients" registered at WellBN. NHS Sussex said the investigation followed "concerns raised about some prescribing for children and young people by WellBN in Brighton and Hove, that may fall outside of national clinical policy and guidance".It said it was working with NHS England "to determine the most appropriate care and treatment for these patients".It said: "The practice is no longer initiating prescribing of hormone medications for children and young people under 18 years for gender dysphoria."The practice will continue to provide general medical care to its patients while the investigation is carried out, and it will continue to provide gender care to adult patients who are aged 18 years and above." The NHS added it had established a helpline for under-18s receiving gender care from WellBN. Process to 'review' notes The cohort of patients whose cases are being reviewed are all aged under 18, and for whom WellBN is prescribing or arranging the supply of medication for gender dysphoria. It is thought that most of these children and young people, but not all of them, live in NHS said there would be a process to "review their notes, and consider next steps in their treatment, in line with national guidance and clinical advice".It said: "As a result of this process, there will likely be different outcomes for different patients."Some children and young people may be recommended for a transfer into specialist NHS commissioned gender services. "Some will be reviewed and supported by local Children and Young People Mental Health Services, and some will need an endocrinology (hormone) review."What happens following that review will differ for each individual and will depend on the outcome of the case note review, the person's age and medication profile." If you are affected by any of these issues, help and support is available via the BBC Action Line here. The BBC has contacted WellBN for May, the practice said: "We are sorry to be passing on this news, but rest assured we will continue to battle against this injustice."We have a strong case to present considering that bodily autonomy is one of the four pillars of modern medical ethics."
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Lord Hermer defended suspected Iraqi bomber
Sir Keir Starmer's law chief represented a suspected Iraqi bomb maker who won more than £33,000 in compensation from the Government. Court documents show that Lord Hermer, the Attorney General, represented Abd Ali Hameed Ali Al-Waheed, who was arrested by British troops after a partly assembled IED (Improvised Explosive Device) and explosives were found at his sister's home in Basra. In the case, Al-Waheed won a total of £33,500 for unlawful detention by the British forces, beating by soldiers and 'inhuman and degrading' treatment after an internal review cleared him of any involvement in the insurgency against the British. It is the latest case highlighted by shadow justice secretary Robert Jenrick, who last week published a video claiming Lord Hermer was unfit to be Attorney General because he had spent his life 'defending Britain's enemies.' The Attorney General has previously defended his record by pointing to the 'cab rank' principle, which requires barristers to accept cases within their area of expertise regardless of the client. Allies also maintain that his extensive previous private practice as a barrister does not impinge upon his current role providing independent legal advice to the Government. However, Mr Jenrick said: 'Even Hermer's colleagues acknowledge he is an activist lawyer that made his career acting against the British Government. He is uniquely ill-suited to being Attorney General. 'But Sir Keir Starmer won't sack him because he's cut from the same cloth as Hermer: his loyalty is to the human rights brigade, not the British people.' List of clients The shadow justice secretary has previously criticised Lord Hermer for acting for Gerry Adams, Shamima Begum and Al-Qaeda chief Rangzieb Ahmed, Osama bin Laden's right-hand man. A professional friend of Lord Hermer last week noted how the 'cab rank' principle did not prevent barristers from picking and choosing cases. Al-Waheed was arrested after soldiers raided his sister's house looking for his brother-in-law, Ali Jaleel, who was suspected of involvement in terrorist activities. Ali Jaleel was out, but a partly assembled IED and a large quantity of explosives were found in the house. Al-Waheed claimed he was 'systematically beaten and tortured' by soldiers on his arrest and subjected to multiple forms of inhuman and degrading treatment during his detention, including sleep deprivation and denied sight and hearing by being hooded. Despite an internal review clearing him of involvement, he claims he was held for 33 days unlawfully in breach of Article 5 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). A spokesman for the Attorney General said: 'Over a 30-year career the Attorney General has represented very many people including victims of the Grenfell Tower fire, military veterans killed and injured in service, victims of rape and serious sexual abuse, victims of human trafficking and modern slavery, the Ukrainian Legal Taskforce as well as thousands of victims of environmental disasters. How barristers work 'It is a feature and cornerstone of our legal system that legal professionals operate the cab rank rule when it comes to clients, and barristers do not associate themselves with their clients' opinions. The Code of Conduct for Barristers prohibits them from refusing instructions on the basis of their views of the character, reputation, cause, conduct, guilt or innocence of the client. Some Conservatives have criticised the attacks on Lord Hermer as unfair. Dr Ben Spencer, a shadow minister, said: 'It's absolutely right to question Lord Hermer's judgement based on his decisions in role. But, even the worst of us must have legal representation.' Former attorney general Dominic Grieve said Mr Jenrick's video was a 'disgraceful' attack on the UK's 'principles of justice and freedoms', which relied on a 'level playing field' for individuals' legal representation under the cab rank rule. Lord Hermer has, however, faced a barrage of criticism in recent days after comparing calls by Tory and Reform politicians to leave the ECHR to the rise of Nazism.
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Ukrainian attack damaged 10% of Russia's strategic bombers, Germany says
BERLIN, June 7 (Reuters) - A Ukrainian drone attack last weekend likely damaged around 10% of Russia's strategic bomber fleet and hit some of the aircraft as they were being prepared for strikes on Ukraine, a senior German military official said. "According to our assessment, more than a dozen aircraft were damaged, TU-95 and TU-22 strategic bombers as well as A-50 surveillance planes," German Major General Christian Freuding said in a YouTube podcast reviewed by Reuters ahead of its publication later on Saturday. The affected A-50s, which function similarly to NATO's AWACS planes by providing aerial situational awareness, were likely non-operational when they were hit, said the general who coordinates Berlin's military aid to Kyiv and is in close touch with the Ukrainian defence ministry. "We believe that they can no longer be used for spare parts. This is a loss, as only a handful of these aircraft exist," he said. "As for the long-range bomber fleet, 10% of it has been damaged in the attack according to our assessment." The United States estimates that Ukraine's audacious drone attack hit as many as 20 Russian warplanes, destroying around 10 of them, two U.S. officials told Reuters, and experts say Moscow will take years to replace the affected planes. Despite the losses, Freuding does not see any immediate reduction of Russian strikes against Ukraine, noting that Moscow still retains 90% of its strategic bombers which can launch ballistic and cruise missiles in addition to dropping bombs. "But there is, of course, an indirect effect as the remaining planes will need to fly more sorties, meaning they will be worn out faster, and, most importantly, there is a huge psychological impact." Freuding said Russia had felt safe in its vast territory, which also explained why there was little protection for the aircraft. "After this successful operation, this no longer holds true. Russia will need to ramp up the security measures." According to Freuding, Ukraine attacked two air fields around 100 kilometres (62 miles) from Moscow, as well as the Olenya air field in the Murmansk region and the Belaya air field, with drones trained with the help of artificial intelligence. A fifth attack on the Ukrainka air field near the Chinese border failed, he said. The bombers that were hit were part of Russia's so-called nuclear triad which enables nuclear weapons deployment by air, sea and ground, he added.
