California Delta smelt controversy ranges from lawsuits to Trump executive orders
California Delta smelt controversy ranges from lawsuits to Trump executive orders
Show Caption
Hide Caption
Trump administration pulls funding for endangered CA fish
Donald Trump has criticized conservation efforts concerning the delta smelt as hampering California firefighting capabilities.
Fox - Ktvu
For a small fish found only in the San Francisco Estuary, the Delta smelt has caused much controversy over the years, ranging from lawsuits to executive orders.
What is the history of the Delta smelt?
In 1993, the smelt was listed as threatened under the Federal Endangered Species Act and the California Endangered Species Act, according to the California Department of Fish and Wildlife website. The slender fish, which ranges from 2 inches to more than 4 inches long, was upgraded to endangered in 2009.
The smelt used to be the most abundant fish in the estuary and numbered in the millions before state and federal projects began exporting large quantities of Delta water to San Joaquin Valley agribusiness and Southern California water agencies, according to a 2021 Stockton Record article.
The Delta smelt has declined to the point of near-extinction in the wild due to several factors, including big changes to the Delta ecosystem resulting from water exports, the impact of invasive species, and drought, according to the 2021 article.
The fish is also capable of shutting down massively powerful water pumps near Tracy that suck water out of the Delta and into the south San Joaquin Valley and Southern California, according to a 2002 Stockton Record article. The state and federal water-export pumps on the Delta are routinely slowed or stopped when the smelt or adolescent Chinook salmon get near the pumps, which can kill the fish. Lawsuits resulted between water agencies and environmental groups over the shutdowns.
How is Trump getting involved with the smelt?
More recently, President Donald Trump's administration is planning to cut funding for a breeding program created to ensure the fish's survival, according to the San Francisco Chronicle.
Last month, the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation informed UC Davis scientists they would not renew financing to maintain a refuge population of smelt for reintroduction and research in Contra Costa County, according to the publication. The funding is set to end on Feb. 28, but no reason was given.
The news is not unprecedented. On Jan. 20, Trump issued an executive order titled "Putting People Over Fish: Stopping Radical Environmentalism to Provide Water to Southern California."
The order mandated water from Northern California's Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta, one of the state's primary water sources, to be redirected south.
It's seen as an attempt to change the smelt's environmental protections, and it criticizes the state's efforts to battle the raging and deadly wildfires that wreaked havoc across greater Los Angeles.
The executive order comes after Trump initially promised in 2016 to redirect California's water runoff south to help farmers and growers in the Central Valley. In 2020, then-President Trump issued a federal memorandum to redirect millions of gallons of water. However, California Gov. Gavin Newsom successfully sued in federal court to limit the flow from the Delta.
Trump vs Newsom feud
Trump criticized Newsom over the smelt in a Jan. 8 Truth Social post.
"Governor Gavin Newscum refused to sign the water restoration declaration put before him that would have allowed millions of gallons of water, from excess rain and snow melt from the North, to flow daily into many parts of California, including the areas that are currently burning in a virtually apocalyptic way," Trump said. "He wanted to protect an essentially worthless fish called a smelt by giving it less water (it didn't work!), but didn't care about the people of California."
Brian Sobel, a longtime political analyst based in the San Francisco Bay Area, said Trump is using the executive order to argue that California politics, especially around water, is dysfunctional. The debate dates back to when Ronald Reagan was governor before he became president.
Fresno State University Political Science Professor Tom Holyoke, who specializes in western water policy, explained to USA Today last month that scientists believe pumping water out of the Delta is mainly responsible for the smelt's near extinction.
As a result, Holyoke said the Endangered Species Act requires the government to do everything possible to stop the species from going extinct.
Since the Delta smelt, a food source for larger fish including salmon and sea bass as well as sea lions is near extinction, the government has been pumping less water out to save the fish for about 20 years, Holyoke added.
Dan Bacher and Audrey Cooper contributed to this report.
Wes Woods II covers West County for the Ventura County Star. Reach him at wesley.woodsii@vcstar.com, 805-437-0262 or @JournoWes.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
18 hours ago
- Yahoo
President Trump shares birthday with Flag Day. 10 things to know about national holiday
During the Revolutionary War, the infant United States of America flew several different flags. That all changed on June 14, 1777, when Congress passed the Flag Resolution of 1777, establishing the U.S. flag with 13 alternating stripes of red and white, and a union of white stars on a blue field. While the number of stars has changed over the last 248 years, the overall design has not. But it took more than 170 years before Flag Day became a national holiday, celebrated on June 14 every year. "The flag represents a living country and is itself considered a living thing, according to the official Flag Code." 'Flag Day is an honor and tradition that displays the national flag with pride and happiness," said Anniston Army Depot Sgt. Maj. Happiness Brown on "It is an annual observance which reminds us of the dedication and sacrifices made by our military service members. It's also a time to pray for our troops, those at home and abroad." On June 14, 1777, the Continental Congress adopted a resolution on the new country's flag design. "That the flag of the United States shall be of thirteen stripes of alternate red and white, with a union of thirteen stars of white in a blue field, representing the new constellation," the resolution read. A flag of this design was first carried into battle less than three months later, on Sept. 11, 1777, in the Battle of the Brandywine, according to the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. "In the late 1800s, schools all over the United States held Flag Day programs to contribute to the Americanization of immigrant children, and the observance caught on with individual communities," according to the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. In 1916, President Woodrow Wilson issued a presidential proclamation establishing a national Flag Day on June 14, according to the Library of Congress. Both Wilson, in 1916, and President Coolidge, in 1927, issued proclamations asking for June 14 to be observed as National Flag Day. Congressional legislation designating the date as national Flag Day wasn't signed into law until 1949 by President Harry Truman. The legislation also called upon the president to issue a Flag Day proclamation every year. President Trump was born on Flag Day on June 14, 1946. "I am blessed to have shared my birthday with the Star Spangled Banner and the U.S. Army," he said. ➤ US Army's 250th anniversary a celebration that coincides with Trump's birthday. How to attend In 2017, he proclaimed not only Flag Day but Flag Week, saying, "On Flag Day, we honor the symbol that reminds us that we are one Nation under God, united in our pursuit of liberty and justice for all. "By honoring our flag, we pay due respect to the patriots and heroes who have laid down their lives in defense of the liberty it represents. "The Congress also requested, in 1966, that the President annually issue a proclamation designating the week in which June 14 occurs as 'National Flag Week' and call upon citizens of the United States to display the flag during that week." "According to legend, in 1776, George Washington commissioned Philadelphia seamstress Betsy Ross to create a flag for the new nation. "Scholars, however, credit the flag's design to Francis Hopkinson, who also designed the Great Seal and first coin of the United States. Even so, Ross most likely met Washington and certainly sewed early American flags in her family's Philadelphia upholstery shop," according to the Library of Congress. There have been 27 official versions of the flag, but the arrangement of the stars has varied according to the flag-makers' preferences until 1912. That's when President Taft standardized the then-new flag's 48 stars, according to the Library of Congress. That changed when Alaska and Hawaii became states in 1959. The current version of the flag dates to July 4, 1960. The current American flag was designed by Bob G. Heft, a high school student from Lancaster, Ohio, according to the Old Farmer's Almanac. "Even though Bob's history teacher gave him a B- for not knowing how many states the Union had, Bob submitted his design to the White House (unprompted) in anticipation of Hawaii and Alaska joining the Union. To his surprise, President Eisenhower called him! Today, it's Bob Heft's 1958 design — showing 50 stars in a field that included five rows of six stars and four rows of five stars — which is now our 50-star American flag." Heft's teacher changed his grade to an A. The Continental Congress left no record explaining why it chose red, white and blue for the country's new flag. In 1782, the Congress of the Articles of Confederation chose the colors for the Great Seal of the United States with these meanings: white for purity and innocence red for valor and hardiness blue for vigilance, perseverance, and justice The U.S. Flag Code provides guidelines on how to display and care for the U.S. flag. Flags should always hang freely but never with the stars down, except as a distress signal. The U.S. flag flies above any other flag. Never use the flag for decoration. Use bunting with the blue on top, then white, then red. It is the universal custom to display the flag only from sunrise to sunset on buildings and on stationary flagstaffs in the open. However, the flag may be displayed 24 hours a day if properly illuminated at night. When a flag becomes unfit to fly, it should be destroyed with dignity. Do not let the flag touch the ground. Do not fly flag upside down unless there is an emergency. Do not carry the flag flat, or carry things in it. Do not use the flag as clothing. Do not store the flag where it can get dirty. Do not use it as a cover. Do not fasten it or tie it back. Always allow it to fall free. Do not draw on, or otherwise mark the flag. No. The flag should be flown at full-staff, at the top of the pole on Flag Day. No, Flag Day is not a federal holiday, but the president traditionally proclaims its observance every year. The date, June 14, remains the same, no matter which day of the week it falls. Here are 2025 federal holidays: Jan. 1: New Year's Day Jan. 20: Inauguration Day; Martin Luther King Jr. Day Feb. 17: Washington's Birthday. Many state and local governments designation it as Presidents Day. May 26: Memorial Day June 19: Juneteenth July 4: Independence Day Sept. 1: Labor Day Oct. 13: Columbus Day Nov. 11: Veterans Day Nov. 27: Thanksgiving Day Dec. 25: Christmas Day Contributing: Janet Loehrke, USA Today Network This article originally appeared on Florida Times-Union: 10 things to know about Flag Day, President Trump's birthday
Buzz Feed
20 hours ago
- Buzz Feed
Elon Just Couldn't Stop Posting About Trump — And Experts Say It's Very Revealing
Stanford University psychiatrist Dr. Anna Lembke said she doesn't know what is going through Musk's head, but frequent posters in general typically do so out of a desire for social validation, which can be even more potent to receive from people you don't know. Lembke said social validation from millions of strangers online can be 'much more potent and therefore more reinforcing than the social validation we might get from people in our real life, because of the emotional complexity of real-life relationships where there's much more give and take, and we have listen.' 'And that's not necessarily true on social media, where we can just delete or block somebody or go somewhere else to get the reinforcement we're looking for,' she continued. Experts say one other reason for posting so much could be to control narratives against you. A New York Times report alleges that tensions between Trump and Musk had been simmering for months, but the breakup got accelerated after Musk felt ' humiliated ' when Trump got rid of Musk's preferred pick for head of NASA. '[Musk] wants to be validated. This was not the way it was supposed to go. He was supposed to save the country from all kinds of things. And he was the only guy who could do it,' suggested Tracy Ross, a couples therapist, about what Musk might be seeking with his frequent posts. 'Think of the specialness of that, and then to lose that, he's got to feel gutted.' Ross said in her practice it can be typical for couples to engage in a blame game after a breakup. Instead of reflecting on 'How am I responsible for this blow up?' people can discharge those feelings by seeking constant validation online so they 'don't have to feel those things and [they] don't have to look at [their] own contribution' in the breakup, Ross said. And one way to control a narrative about your reputation is to share nonstop posts about it. 'Whoever can post the most and get the most reposts, the most followers and likes, then they at least have the feeling that they're shaping and dominating the historical narrative around what happened,' Lembke said about why people might post so much. To be clear though, posting a lot is not a wholly negative behavior and can sometimes be out of 'a desire for social connection and the possibilities of career enhancement,' Gerrard said. It's also a behavior that social media platforms encourage, Gerrard said. 'X has historically cultivated a following of frequent posters, which isn't an accident as it's precisely what the platform was intended for,' Gerrard said. 'Whereas those posting through it on other platforms may face more criticism. Instagram, for example, is largely viewed as a space for highly curated, aestheticized, and potentially inauthentic content, hence the phrase 'highlight reel.'' But even big-time posters can reach a limit with how much they should share online. Musk appears to have deleted his most inflammatory insults against Trump, including his claims that Trump appears in unreleased files related to the late sex offender Jeffrey Epstein and his support for the president's impeachment. Ross said that deleting certain insults could potentially be an 'admission that maybe he thinks he went too far, and that ... could backfire because Trump is known to be pretty vengeful.'
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Defining symbol of protests, volatile work schedules, healing power of travel: Catch up on the day's stories
👋 Welcome to 5 Things PM! Almost two-thirds of US workers struggle with volatile and inflexible work schedules, according to a new Gallup survey. It's especially common among part-time employees and those without a college degree. Here's what else you might have missed during your busy day: 1️⃣ Defining symbol: Mexico's green, white and red flag has been a common sight at the protests in Los Angeles as demonstrators express solidarity with immigrants and denounce the ICE raids. The brandishing of Latin American flags in the US has a long and complex history. 2️⃣ Dicey outlook: Global economic growth is on track for its weakest decade since the 1960s, according to a new analysis. The World Bank cited US President Donald Trump's trade war as a major factor weighing on economies worldwide. 3️⃣ $1,000 per baby: The so-called 'Trump accounts' would provide parents of newborns with money to invest on behalf of their child's future as part of a five-year pilot program. Here's how it would work and who would benefit the most. 4️⃣ World traveler: Cameron Mofid has struggled with obsessive compulsive disorder since childhood. The California man recently became one of the few people who has visited all 195 UN-recognized countries and territories. He called it 'a form of healing.' 5️⃣ Skygazing: Keep an eye out tonight for June's full strawberry moon as well as the Milky Way and multiple planets. This will be the lowest full moon visible from the Northern Hemisphere in decades due to a phenomenon called a major lunar standstill. 🌊 Undersea wreckage: Researchers from the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution in Massachusetts captured close-up images of a World War I-era submarine that was lost at sea 108 years ago. Take a closer look. • Military mobilization around LA protests will cost roughly $134 million• Gunman opens fire in Austrian school, killing 10 and throwing country into shock• Several dead after wave of explosions hit southwest Colombia, authorities say ✈️ That's how many fewer international travelers are expected to visit New York City this year than in 2024. 🌍 Call for help: Children removing plastic waste from a lake. Tree-covered mountains behind a massive pile of trash. A billboard on parched earth where the seashore used to be. Striking images like these, showing environmental destruction, aim to 'inspire action.' 🛒 Empty shelves: Whole Foods says it's working hard to restock stores with groceries after a cyberattack knocked one of its major suppliers offline. 🚢 Which activist was detained while aboard an aid ship headed for Gaza? A. Ai WeiweiB. Jane FondaC. Greta ThunbergD. Alicia Garza⬇️ Scroll down for the answer. 👨🎨 The real deal: A family displayed a marble sculpture on top of their piano alongside photos. They thought it was 'fake' — a copy of a work of art by renowned sculptor Auguste Rodin. It just sold at auction for nearly $1 million. 👋 We'll see you tomorrow. 🧠 Quiz answer: C. Swedish climate and human rights activist Greta Thunberg departed Israel on a flight to France after being detained by Israeli forces aboard an aid ship bound for Gaza.📧 Check out all of CNN's newsletters. 5 Things PM is produced by CNN's Chris Good, Meghan Pryce, Kimberly Richardson and Morgan Severson.
