logo
Private contracts for Edmonton police rose sharply over last five years: data

Private contracts for Edmonton police rose sharply over last five years: data

CBC06-05-2025

Private policing contracts by the Edmonton Police Service have grown significantly over the last five years, according to new data, with the number of hours and dollars involved more than quadrupling since 2020.
The extra duty detail (EDD) program allows private organizations to contract Edmonton police officers outside of their regular shifts, for duties ranging from traffic control to providing a visible police presence at large events.
CBC News obtained the data through a freedom of information request to EPS.
Temitope Oriola, a professor and criminologist at the University of Alberta, said that while there may be situations where extra duty details make sense, current EPS policies lack clarity on the distinction between public and private policing.
"The line appears to be quite blurred right now," he said. "It's unclear to me where one ends and where the other begins."
Specific criteria must be met
The practice of providing private policing services through paid contracts goes back decades at EPS.
In the past, EPS's private contracts included "weddings, bars and nightclubs, graduations and other questionable events," according to an EDD policy document. Those shifts often "devolved into security work resulting in an unacceptable ownership of liability and careless stewardship of EPS resources."
As a result of a 2013 review, the program today has stricter rules and a client's request must meet certain criteria to be approved.
The policy outlines three categories for EDD requests.
One category is "crime and/or disorder." For these requests, clients must first provide "verifiable information and statistics" to demonstrate that crime or disorder is occurring. A risk analysis of the request must be completed, weighing safety concerns and how the proposed deployment would reflect on EPS.
According to the policy document, these types of requests are rarely granted because it would invite allegations of preferential treatment or two-tier policing. If a client's request highlights a legitimate public safety concern, it may be addressed by deploying regular EPS resources.
Extra duty requests can also address "client risk management," described as cases with the potential for crime, disorder or risks to public safety, such as with large crowds during festivals or sporting events.
The third category, which is rarely used, involves police officers being requested for ceremonial roles.
The EDD rules also allow for the deployment of police to direct traffic during construction or the movement of large equipment. Such "vessel move" jobs are described as an "exceptional" subcategory. However, they account for 32 per cent of the list of clients, although the data does not indicate how many hours or officers that represents.
There are also restrictions around when officers are allowed to accept the voluntary shifts, including requirements to have at least one hour between their regular shift and an EDD shift, and at least eight hours of rest between an EDD shift and their regular shift.
Police not overstretched, says EPS
The EPS data provided to CBC includes monthly totals for the number of hours, number of officers and amount paid to police working extra duty shifts. The hourly rates for extra duty police start at $150 for a constable and $30 for a car, with a minimum charge of three hours.
The data also includes a monthly list of clients. However, no information is included about how many hours or officers each client represents, or even how many days per month a contract might be for.
For example, although Hope City Church appears once per month during the past three years, the church said in a statement that it had hired two officers each Sunday to help with the congested traffic from the 4,000 people who attend its services.
In 2020, the amount paid to police for extra duty shifts was less than $800,000. By 2024, that figure rose to $3.8 million.
Between 2021 and 2024, the number of EDD shifts increased by 215 per cent, while the number of hours rose by 240 per cent.
During that same period, the number of Edmonton's sworn police officers rose from 1,921 to 2,119 — an increase of 10 per cent.
The time frame of the data spans the social restrictions of the pandemic and three Oilers playoff runs past the first round. These events may explain some of the trends but it's not backed up by the data, because of the lack of detailed information around hours or shifts per contract.
In a statement, EPS provided figures of extra duty shifts for 2018 and 2019, saying that the recent increase was simply a return to pre-pandemic levels.
However, the number of EDD shifts last year — 5,471 — still exceeded 2018's total by more than 1,400.
"We must emphasize that these duties are not overstretching police resources," said the EPS statement. Rather, having off-duty officers on-site at large events "ensures public safety needs are met in real time, without drawing from the active operational pool."
In particular, officers on extra duty are able to perform tasks for which private security lacks the legal authority, such as directing traffic or controlling crowds in public spaces.
City expenses unclear
The most frequently occurring client over the five years of data was OEG Inc., which owns the Edmonton Oilers and operates Rogers Place. Including its subsidiaries, the company appeared on the list of clients 99 times.
A spokesperson for OEG said that the Oilers' recent playoff runs have increased the use of extra duty police to augment private security. The team made it to the conference finals in 2022 and the Stanley Cup finals in 2024.
The second-most frequent client in the data was the City of Edmonton.
A statement from the city noted that it co-ordinated civic services for more than 800 events last year. The costs for those services, "including extra duty police, are the responsibility of the event organizer and are mostly recovered by the City."
A civic services subsidy is provided for some local festivals and events to cover certain costs including extra duty detail, said the statement. For city-hosted events, like New Year's Eve and Canada Day festivities, "extra duty policing costs are incurred by the City."
CBC News requested the total amount spent by the city on extra duty police shifts over the past five years. A spokesperson provided expense figures that did not account for any reimbursements by partners. The city was not able to say what its own costs for extra duty police were.
'Their presence is just comforting'
Oriola noted that in the extra duty policies document, EPS referred to the City of Edmonton as a "community partner."
"I think it's important to not simply treat the City of Edmonton as just another community partner. That is your parent organization," said Oriola. "There is no EPS without the City of Edmonton."
As an example of an extra duty contract, the EPS document lists synagogues, mosques or large cultural gatherings for which "intelligence has indicated a heightened threat but without an identified person ... which would otherwise be referred to an investigative area."
That underscored Oriola's concerns around whether the police are billing as private services what they ought to provide as a public service.
"If a mosque, synagogue or church requires a police presence, I don't think that should be construed as private policing," he said. "That's part of what the police do."
Two churches are among the most frequently listed clients in the data, but their extra duty contracts are related to managing traffic congestion on Sundays.
"They're really great," said Jim Somerville, executive pastor at North Pointe Community Church, which has only one entry and exit point for its large parking lot.
"Their presence is just comforting to people so that they know we're doing our best to get traffic in and out because of the volume."
Some tasks 'a routine part of policing'
Oriola agreed that police should be present for large events like festivals or Oilers games, and that it makes sense to recover the costs of those deployments from profit-generating entities like OEG.
But that shouldn't be the approach when it comes to city events, or directing traffic to move heavy equipment for a city project.
"Those, I would humbly submit, ought to be considered a routine part of policing and not private policing," said Oriola.
"It's important that those kinds of duties be seen as, broadly speaking, a part of the service that the EPS provides to the City of Edmonton."

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

NexMetals Commences Trading Under New Symbol "NEXM"
NexMetals Commences Trading Under New Symbol "NEXM"

Globe and Mail

time28 minutes ago

  • Globe and Mail

NexMetals Commences Trading Under New Symbol "NEXM"

Toronto, Ontario--(Newsfile Corp. - June 11, 2025) - NexMetals Mining Corp. (TSXV: NEXM) (OTC Pink: PRMLF) (" NEXM" or the " Company") is pleased to announce that pursuant to its news release dated June 9, 2025, the Company's common shares will commence trading at the market open today on the TSX Venture Exchange under the new symbol " NEXM". NEXM Engages OGIB Corporate Bulletin The Company has entered into a services agreement with OGIB Corporate Bulletin (" OGIB") to provide strategic digital marketing services to the Company including content development and distribution, as well as campaign reporting and optimization, for a term of up to nine months. The Company has agreed to pay OGIB a total cost of CAN $40,000 in advance for these services which will be paid out of the Company's working capital. OGIB is wholly-owned by Keith Schaefer and is based out of Victoria, British Columbia. Both Mr. Schaefer and OGIB are arms length to the Company and, to the Company's knowledge, hold no interest, directly or indirectly, in the securities of the Company or any right or present intention to acquire such an interest. The appointment of OGIB is subject to approval by the TSX Venture Exchange. About NexMetals Mining Corp. NexMetals Mining Corp. is a mineral exploration and development company that is focused on the redevelopment of the previously producing copper, nickel and cobalt resources mines owned by the Company in the Republic of Botswana. NexMetals is committed to governance through transparent accountability and open communication within our team and our stakeholders. NexMetals' team brings extensive experience across the full spectrum of mine discovery and development. Collectively, the team has contributed to dozens of projects, including work on the Company's Selebi and Selkirk mines. Senior team members each have on average, more than 20 years of experience spanning geology, engineering, operations, and project development. For further information about NexMetals Mining Corp., please contact: Morgan Lekstrom CEO and Director morganl@ Jaclyn Ruptash V.P., Communications and Investor Relations jaclyn@

Farmers divided over bill to enshrine Canada's supply management system in law
Farmers divided over bill to enshrine Canada's supply management system in law

Globe and Mail

time28 minutes ago

  • Globe and Mail

Farmers divided over bill to enshrine Canada's supply management system in law

Recently tabled legislation to legally lock in supply management rules on egg, dairy and chicken imports to protect those sectors has reignited friction among Canada's farmers about how it could affect trade negotiations. Imports of poultry, egg and dairy products are limited to certain quotas, before they are subject to steep tariffs. If passed as proposed, the bill would prohibit increasing the quotas or reducing the tariffs imposed by Canada on imports that exceed that quantity. The private member's bill, put forward on May 29 by the Bloc Québécois, is the third such iteration from the party. Supporters of the bill say it would protect local producers in a domestic market that would be overwhelmed if it opened to other markets, particularly the United States. The protectionist measures would also prevent the government from offering foreign access to Canada's supply-managed farm sector in trade negotiations. Alberta farmer's stint in jail highlights controversy over supply management Opinion: If supply management has to be killed, Canada's dairy industry will have to follow New Zealand's lead Michael Harvey, executive director of the Canadian Agri-Food Trade Alliance, warns the proposed law could negatively affect some Canadian exporters at the negotiating table. In particular, Canada's breadbasket and beef exporters could be at greater risk of losing out on stronger agreements in exchange for security for a few sectors. 'If Canada is taking parts of the economy off the table from the beginning, another country is going to take parts of the economy off the table,' Mr. Harvey said, suggesting supply-managed industries can be protected at the bargaining table without legislation. Canada's desire to protect its supply-managed industries is opposed by trade partners and has complicated past international deals, especially with the United States. Ian McCreary owns a 1,200-hectare cattle and grain farm near Bladworth, Sask., located 148 kilometres northwest of Regina. Mr. McCreary says he's not concerned about the bill because he doesn't believe it will harm future trade agreements with countries importing grains and oilseeds. He also doesn't expect the U.S. to stick to its trade agreements when they are made. 'If we didn't have supply management in this circumstance, Canada's milk and egg sector would be at very significant risk of having been pushed down by the U.S. – and then they turn around and change all the rules anyway.' Mr. McCreary acknowledges his opinion may be in the minority of grain and oilseed producers. Andre Harpe farms mostly barley and canola on about 2,000 hectares northwest of Grande Prairie, Alta., and is the chair of Canadian Canola Growers Association. He's concerned about the effect the bill will have on Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement (CUSMA) discussions. The free-trade pact is up for review in 2026. 'It makes it really tough to have a fair and open discussion on what should be traded and what can be traded,' Mr. Harpe said. The majority of Canada's chicken, egg and dairy producers are located in Eastern Canada. Quebec and Ontario were home to about 80 per cent of the country's 9,256 dairy farms in 2024, according to Statistics Canada. Similarly, Ontario and Quebec topped the number of chicken producers. In comparison, Western Canada farms nearly all of the country's canola, spring wheat and barley as well as the vast majority of cattle. Dairy Farmers of Canada has previously expressed support for legislation locking in supply management. In an e-mailed statement, president David Wiens said the organization will work with political leaders as 'they continue to support agriculture and prioritize our national food sovereignty and security.' In past trade agreements, Canada made concessions to allow trade partners more access in supply-managed markets, including in the last agreement with the U.S. and Mexico in 2018. The Bloc's agri-food and supply management critic Yves Perron takes issue with that. 'Giving away 1 per cent, 2 per cent in every negotiation, we are killing the system, but slowly,' Mr. Perron said. Canada later compensated supply-managed sectors for the impact of the CUSMA signing with more than $1.7-billion in direct payments and programs. Bill C-202 mirrors a pair of bills put forward by the Bloc in 2020 and then again in 2023. Its last iteration was passed in the House of Commons with support from all parties two years ago but didn't make it through the Senate before the election was called. Mr. Harvey was disappointed with how quickly the new bill passed its first round of readings – moving through the House in one week. The trade alliance had urged members of Parliament not to allow it to move forward. The bill is now headed to the Senate. 'We were really hoping that the government would take it more seriously this time because we do think it's a terrible piece of trade policy,' Mr. Harvey said. When the new iteration of the bill passed through the House on Thursday, Bloc MP Martin Champoux challenged Prime Minister Mark Carney to support the bill. 'I have been clear about this since January. Supply management will never be on the table in negotiations with the Americans. We will protect supply management,' Mr. Carney responded.

Gen Z is facing the worst youth unemployment rate in decades. Here is how it's different
Gen Z is facing the worst youth unemployment rate in decades. Here is how it's different

CBC

time32 minutes ago

  • CBC

Gen Z is facing the worst youth unemployment rate in decades. Here is how it's different

Graduation cap in hand, Sarah Chung is posing for photos in school regalia ahead of her convocation ceremony. The campus atmosphere is joyful, but what comes next is sobering: this honours student is graduating into one of the worst youth labour markets seen in decades. "It's bleak," said the 23-year-old graduate of the University of Calgary's media and communications program. She hasn't been able to find a job in her field and said she intends to pursue a master's degree. "I believe that it's tough just because of everything that's happening with the economy, with our society and with politics," she said. "There's a whole [lot] of talk about 'there's a recession coming.' I'm not an economist, but I can also see it as well." Chung is part of a generation facing Canada's highest youth unemployment rate in about a quarter-century. Apart from the pandemic, Canadians between the ages of 15 and 24 are facing the highest youth unemployment rate this country has seen since the mid-1990s, according to first quarter data from Statistics Canada. At that time, Jean Chrétien was Canada's prime minister, Gen Z was but a twinkle in their parents' eyes, and the global workforce had yet to be transformed by social media, gig work and artificial intelligence. Fast forward to 2025, and Canada's youngest workers are grappling with a perfect storm of economic conditions: an inflation crisis that came on the heels of a pandemic; a surge in population growth that has outpaced the number of available jobs; and now, a country teetering closer to recession as the U.S. trade war wreaks uncertainty on the economy. One expert says youth unemployment can be a "canary in the coal mine" that foreshadows broader troubles in the labour market. "It's kind of an early warning indicator," said Tricia Williams, director of research at Future Skills Centre, a Toronto Metropolitan University lab dedicated to studying the future of work. "It's not just about getting jobs and skills experience. It's about the larger structural supports and the environment that young people are coming into." Labour market whiplash The Canadian labour market has endured a kind of whiplash in recent years. After pandemic-era restrictions were lifted, companies celebrated with a hiring spree — the economy regained jobs it lost during the crisis and Canadian youth reaped the rewards of a summer job boom. But employers were soon struggling to find workers and fill postings, a result of the workforce having shrunk during the pandemic. The federal government and public policy experts prescribed higher immigration as an antidote to the shortage, which led to a rise in the Gen Z and millennial working population. Hiring sentiment "was really high coming out of the pandemic, which probably was never going to last," said Brendon Bernard, a senior economist at Indeed who closely follows youth labour market trends. As the hiring backlog cleared, other conditions started to slow the economy down, he added. The onset of a fierce inflation episode in mid-2021 triggered a domino effect: consumers pulled back on spending and the Bank of Canada began an aggressive interest rate hike cycle, leading businesses to delay hiring as economic confidence deteriorated. Older workers started working second jobs to pay the bills during the affordability crisis. Some experts suspect that the automation of routine tasks could be leading to fewer entry-level opportunities, but there isn't enough data to say how widespread this is. "As things have turned back and employer appetite has fallen back down to earth, the youth employment situation has weakened," said Bernard. 'It is disheartening' Youth unemployment started ticking back up in the spring of 2024. At the same time, the number of young people not in education, employment or training — an economic measure called the NEET rate — has risen among youth in their early 20s, mainly driven by non-students having trouble finding work. Bernard said there was some cautious optimism at the beginning of this year, when the labour market seemed to be stabilizing. But the Canadian economy has been rocked by U.S. trade war uncertainty since April, potentially stifling the hiring appetite as the overall unemployment rate rises. "It is disheartening," said Thivian Varnacumaaran, an electrical engineering student in his final year at York University who estimates that he's applied for 400 to 500 jobs — with no luck — since he started searching in December. "I wouldn't say I'm pessimistic, but I'm really realistic about the situation," the 25-year-old added. Charles St-Arnaud, chief economist at trade association Alberta Central, says the economy is now "sluggish" even without having breached recession territory. He expects more signs of deterioration in the coming months, and noted that young people will likely bear the brunt of those conditions. "Often businesses do what I would call the 'last in, first out' type of strategy when they reduce headcount," said St-Arnaud. "The younger population that has been just hired are more at risk of being laid off in a downturn." WATCH | How the increase in temporary foreign workers is impacting job seekers: Is our 'addiction' to cheap foreign labour hurting young people? | About That 10 months ago Duration 13:58 The number of temporary foreign workers hired in Canada ballooned over the last two years — particularly in food and retail industries — and the youth unemployment rate has soared alongside it. Andrew Chang explains the government changes that led to the hiring spike, and why economists believe it's having a serious impact on both young job seekers and the broader economy. The scars of unemployment The bleak hiring landscape has some young people taking jobs just to stay ahead of the bills. "I spent two hours sweeping yesterday, and I have a mechanical engineering degree," said 24-year-old Ben Gooch of Dundas, Ont. The McMaster graduate is working part-time at a garden centre to cover some of his living expenses, having applied for upward of 100 jobs since December with only a handful of interviews to show for it. "I feel like I'm just throwing darts out at a wall and hoping to get lucky and hit something." Data shows that it's fairly common for young graduates to work in a job that only requires a high school diploma. But Canadian research has shown that being unemployed at a young age during a recession can lead to a persistent but non-permanent earnings loss for many years after — a well-studied phenomenon known as " wage scarring." Other research also suggests that entering the labour market during a recession can impact a person's health outcomes. "Where it can lead to scarring — I mean, we might think of it as sort of a temporary blemish — but it can have long term implications when the economy goes into a serious recession," said Miles Corak, an Ottawa-based economics professor at the City University of New York's Graduate Centre. "Long-term earnings prospects are dampened for people graduating during the recession — not because they're not getting jobs, but eventually they fall into a part of the labour market that isn't as high-paying, in types of occupations that they didn't anticipate doing," said Corak. The economic downturns seen in Canada during the early 1980s and 1990s show the impact of that scarring. Youth unemployment reached a peak of 18.3 per cent in 1983, and rose again to 17.2 per cent in 1992 and 1993, with real wage declines observed among the 17 to 24 cohort in the years afterward. 'I'm kind of waiting for life to start' The lack of opportunities for young people aren't good for the rest of the country either, said Williams, the researcher. "Young people are a treasure of resource that we need to support and also yield dividends from," she said. Corak offers a different perspective. "I'm not so certain that it impacts the economy [so much] as the nature of our economy gets imprinted more clearly on younger people," he observed. Some young people, he noted, are doing very well and earning more than their parents did, while others are losing ground. "What we're seeing is many young people much more stressed, and running faster on a treadmill to stay still." Lately, Gooch has been reflecting on where his parents were at this stage of their lives. By the time they were in their mid-20s, they were working on their careers, owned real estate and were building a life together, he said. The young engineer hasn't given up on his search — he's applying for jobs across the country and abroad, both in and out of his field. He's accepted that he doesn't know what his circumstances will look like in a year.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store