Hafod landfill campaigner criticises lack of enforcement over smell
Earlier this month councillors told Hafod landfill operator Enovert to 'get it right or shut it' at a meeting of Wrexham's Homes and Environment Scrutiny Committee - but council officers insisted that the environmental permit issued and regulated by Natural Resources Wales held Enovert to account and further enforcement action would not resolve the problem for residents.
Now one campaigner has sent an open letter to the council criticising officers' unwillingness to act over a problem that has blighted the surrounding communities for almost 20 years.
Steve Gittins said the council had a 'moral responsibility' to take action to protect residents and end the odour problem at Hafod.
"Wrexham Council has both the legal authority and the moral responsibility to act," he wrote. "Under the Environmental Protection Act 1990, local authorities have the power to issue abatement notices in cases of statutory nuisance.
"These powers are not contingent upon NRW's actions, nor are they negated by them. In fact, where one regulator is perceived to be failing, it becomes all the more critical that another steps in."
During the committee meeting Ian Jones, Head of Service for Public Protection at Wrexham Council told councillors the NRW environmental permit was designed to regulate Enovert's activity - meaning any statutory notice from the council would effectively be a double-regulation that could lead to a legal challenge.
"We theoretically get into a position where one organisation is being dealt with by two legal processes," he said. "That is not right and the courts wouldn't look favourably on that.
"So the key thing for us - and the advice we get from Welsh Government and UK Government - is to use the permitting process. It is a better and more defined process for enforcement and addressing the matter than statutory nuisance notices."
But in his letter Mr Gittins called the officers' claims into question, citing a specific example where a council in England had recently taken action in similar circumstances.
"The response by Newcastle-under-Lyme Borough Council to the long-running crisis at Walley's Quarry offers a clear and successful precedent," he wrote. "In 2021, the council independently issued an abatement notice despite the Environment Agency's jurisdiction.
"That notice was upheld following mediation and became enforceable in 2023. The Environment Agency then issued a closure notice in 2024. Together, these actions brought tangible relief to the affected community. Wrexham Council should do no less.
"The truth is plainly visible to anyone who chooses to look honestly. Yet those in power seem more intent on preserving illusion than confronting the facts."
Read more:
'Get it right or shut it' - councillors issue ultimatum to Hafod landfill operators
'End nightmare caused by Hafod refuse tip smell'
Frustrated residents turn out in numbers to protest ongoing Hafod landfill issue
In response to the letter Councillor Hugh Jones, Wrexham Council's Lead Member for Strategic Planning and Public Protection, said: 'We are working closely with NRW, site operators and local community councils to monitor and mitigate off-site odour issues for local residents, and we continue to support Natural Resources Wales (NRW) and the measures it has put in place with regards to the Hafod landfill site.
'The council undertook a review of legislative enforcement options towards the end of last year, including the likelihood of the site operator being able to appeal against or defend any legislative action taken by the council – especially given the fact it already faces enforcement action from NRW, and further action by the council might be seen as unnecessary by the courts.
'Legal processes and court actions can be very long, and so we have to consider enforcement action very carefully before going down that route. Our primary focus is to support NRW and Enovert in reducing the odour emission from the site in a timely manner for the benefit of the local community. We are aware there have been cases in other parts of the UK where councils have taken action against landfill site operators – some of the circumstances have been quite different and we recognise the available option should it be required.
'As a result, we'll continue to work closely with NRW, Enovert and other members of the Hafod landfill stakeholder group, with a view to supporting our communities and ensuring continued progress.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Powys County Times
4 hours ago
- Powys County Times
Powys County Council receives grant to tackle child poverty
Over £100,000 has been awarded to Powys County Council to tackle child poverty. The council received a £125,000 grant from the Welsh Government which 'supports bold, collaborative approaches by public and third sector organisations to tackle child poverty and improve outcomes for children and families'. Powys County Council is one of 25 organisations across Wales to receive a share of the £1.495 million awarded through the Welsh Government's Child Poverty Innovation and Supporting Communities Grant Scheme. Last year, the council secured £90,000 through the same grant scheme, enabling the delivery of support and initiatives that supported more than 3,000 people. Cllr Matthew Dorrance, Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for a Fairer Powys, said: 'Securing this Welsh Government funding is a powerful endorsement of our bold and innovative approach to tackling child poverty. 'This investment enables us to take urgent action while laying the foundations for lasting change. By listening to those with lived experience and working closely with our partners and communities, we are not just addressing poverty – we are building a stronger, fairer, greener Powys where every child has the chance to thrive.' This new funding will see the council and its partner Powys Association of Voluntary Organisations (PAVO) continue to work together on initiatives to tackle child poverty in the county. The latest funding will be used to support a new project called 'Speak Truth to Powys' which will be delivered under the umbrella of the Powys Child Poverty Task Force. The project will fund a Young Persons' Engagement Officer, a dedicated officer who will engage directly with children and young people across Powys, both online and in person, to ensure their experiences shape future support. It will also fund a Poverty Truth Commission which will 'bring together people with lived experience of poverty and decision-makers to explore the root causes of poverty in Powys and co-create solutions'. The grant will also fund the 'Essential Support Scheme', a practical support scheme which 'will provide one-off payments to families in urgent need, helping them access essentials such as food, clothing, electricity, and transport'. Help support trusted local news Sign up for a digital subscription now: As a digital subscriber you will get Unlimited access to the County Times website Advert-light access Reader rewards Full access to our app Cllr Joy Jones, Powys County Council's Anti-Poverty Champion, said: 'Behind every statistic is a child, a family, a story. This funding gives us the opportunity to listen more closely, act more compassionately, and respond more effectively to the real challenges people are facing. 'By working together and putting lived experience at the heart of our approach, we can make a meaningful difference in the lives of those who need it most.' Clair Swales, Chief Executive of Powys Association of Voluntary Organisations (PAVO), said: I'm pleased we can continue building on the work we started last year to tackle child poverty in Powys and I look forward to continued collaboration with Powys County Council. 'This funding gives us a valuable opportunity to improve the lives of children and young people experiencing poverty across the county, by listening to their voices and placing them at the heart of our work."
Wales Online
7 hours ago
- Wales Online
Cardiff Capital Region hit with £5.25m Aberthaw power station settlement
Cardiff Capital Region hit with £5.25m Aberthaw power station settlement An independent investigation has been launched how the Cardiff Capital Region handed the process The Aberthaw Power Station pictured before its decommissioning Taxpayers will have to pay £5.25m bill after a regional body responsible for handling the Cardiff City Deal bungled the awarding of a demolition contract for Aberthaw power station. The Cardiff Capital Region, a public body which was set up to invest more than £500m in the south Wales as part of the 2016 City Deal, was taken to court over how it awarded a demolition contract for Aberthaw power station, the disused power station it controversially bought from energy giant RWE. The body, which represents 10 councils, lost a high-court legal challenge brought by a losing bidder, Brown and Mason Group, which concluded in February. Welsh Government has to plunder reserves to fill national insurance blackhole READ MORE: The former coal-powered station was acquired for £8m by the city region in 2022, with contractors Erith beginning demolition work last year. For our free daily briefing on the biggest issues facing the nation, sign up to the Wales Matters newsletter here The region's chair Mary Ann Brocklesby gave an update to the Senedd, telling the economy committee that a settlement of £5.25m had been agreed. Brown and Mason had previously said they were seeking £10m. It has yet to be clarified if the £5.25m includes legal costs. "I'm not able to say much more at this point because we are undergoing an independent review which we commissioned as political leaders to set in train precisely at the point that we knew we were going through a legal process," she said. Article continues below Cllr Brocklesby said: "We had to wait until that legal process was over before that independent review could start. "We are awaiting the findings which – subject to legal caveats – we will be making public." Kellie Beirne, chief executive of the south-east Wales corporate joint committee and Cardiff Capital Region, said: "We're taking this extremely seriously, we recognise the gravity of it and again yes, [it's] something that we don't come and report. "Apologies again for the short notice but we had clearance, we briefed our internal stakeholders and we felt it important to be as transparent as we possibly could by conveying that this morning at this committee." She said a full independent review has been ordered. "When that review concludes and we have findings, we'll be able to be much more open about what happened and take steps to ensure that this can't happen again," she said. Asked whether the court case has impinged on work at the 500-acre site, Cllr Brocklesby insisted: "No, it continues at pace." Conservative MS Andrew RT Davies said: "When you came before this committee in September 2023, Kellie you said that £40m is but a drop in the ocean. "I think the words you used were hundreds of millions of pounds will be required. Obviously, this court case has not helped instil confidence in the private sector in coming on board as partners... so, how are you progressing in that goal?" Cllr Brocklesby replied: "Let's look at the wider ecosystem of CCR: one of the absolute strengths of it is that we have people across the region who are highly valued within their own sectors... who are highly respected not just in Wales but globally." "In terms of the future of Aberthaw, it does actually look very bright and we're not feeling any effects from the impacts of this highly regrettable procurement issue." Article continues below Ms Beirne said Cardiff Capital Region does not have deep enough pockets for what Aberthawr requires following the initial demolition and remediation phase.
Leader Live
14 hours ago
- Leader Live
Delyn MS provides updates from across North East Wales
MS for Delyn It was recess last week in the Senedd, which gave me the chance to get out and about in North East Wales – and it was interesting to see the response from the ban on disposable vapes coming into effect. My first job in government was back in 2017 when, as Minister for the Environment, I kicked off the process to ban single-use plastics in Wales, as part of a wider effort to tackle plastic pollution, reduce litter and landfill and move Wales towards a circular economy – the law finally came into effect in 2023. The recent disposable vapes ban takes that legislation a stage further – littering spoils our communities, introduces harmful substances into soil, rivers and streams and causes harm to biodiversity and many people will have seen discarded vapes lying around, so I wholeheartedly support this ban. Regular readers will know that I've been learning Welsh for some time, so it was good to hear about the boost to the language this week – after a two-year study by the Commission for Welsh Speaking Communities, the Welsh Government has accepted several proposals to protect Welsh as a community language. As the commission says, Welsh is a national language that belongs to us all – whoever we are, wherever we live or however much of the language we speak – so efforts to protect the language for future generations, as well as the target of increasing the number of Welsh speakers to one million by 2050 as laid out in the Cymraeg 2050 action plan, gets my full support. This week is Volunteers Week, an annual campaign to celebrate and recognise the contributions of volunteers in our communities and to highlight the diversity and unity of volunteer work across the UK. Our communities have a real debt to the people who give up their time to volunteer and, along with all the grassroots organisations which rely on volunteers, Volunteers Week is a good time to simply say 'thank you'. I am grateful to all those across our communities who give up their time to help others and our corner of North Wales wouldn't be the same without them. It was recently announced that free period products are now available in even more public spaces across Wales, thanks to the Welsh Government's £3.2m Period Dignity Fund. From schools and colleges to libraries, leisure centres, food banks, sports clubs and youth hubs, essential period products are now freely accessible to thousands. With the aim to eradicate period poverty by 2027, no one should have to miss out on education, work or social life due to a lack of access to period products. Our local authority, Flintshire County Council, has introduced 'reusable period product parties', which have made a practical difference, providing free reusable kits and encouraging open, everyday conversations about menstrual health. These efforts are part of a wider plan to tackle period poverty and improve access to menstrual health support across Wales. More locally, Flintshire Local Voluntary Council (FLVC) has recently opened applications for its Youth Led Grants – if you are aged between 14 and 25 and full of ideas to make a difference in your community, then these grants of £250 to £1,000 are now available to help you kickstart youth-led volunteering projects here in North East Wales. Whether you're passionate about tackling poverty, boosting mental health, protecting the environment or celebrating Welsh culture – FLVC want to hear from you. Funded projects should support one or more of the Well-being of Future Generations Act goals and money can be used for equipment, materials or anything needed to get your idea off the ground – to find out more, call Heather Hicks on 01352 754004 or email or info@ And on the funding theme, congratulations are in order for two local organisations which have secured National Lottery Community Fund grants. Daffodils in Mold, a charity which supports disabled and additional needs children and their families, has secured £20,000 which will help to create a weekly two-hour youth club in Sychdyn, monthly tenpin bowling and swimming sessions at the Jade Jones Pavilion and a festive Christmas party. Also, Cilcain village hall has been awarded a grant to install solar photovoltaic panels on the roof of the village hall – Cilcain is an active and lively village with real community spirit and the village hall is very much the hub of the community. Llongyfarchiadau to both organisations! As always, if you would like advice and/or support, please don't hesitate to get in touch on any of the following contact details – 52 High Street, Mold, Flintshire, on 01352 753464 or by email You can also keep up to date via my Facebook page – Constituents are, of course, welcome to contact my office to arrange an appointment to see me, you don't need to wait for an advice surgery.
