logo
The Hendler Case: FBAR Penalties Survive Beyond Death

The Hendler Case: FBAR Penalties Survive Beyond Death

Forbes13-04-2025

Death doesn't erase FBAR penalties. Noncompliant taxpayers leave a problem to their estate which ... More may simply inherit the liability. This leaves beneficiaries in a state of peril as well.
A recent decision reminds taxpayers and the tax compliance community of the importance of filing the Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts. The U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York in United States v. Hendler, 23 Civ. 3280 (Sept. 17, 2024) has clarified the enduring nature of penalties tied to FBAR. The court held that FBAR penalties 'accrue' on the date the form is due (but fails to be filed) and not when the IRS assesses the penalties which might be years later and after the taxpayer has died.
The court also determined that an individual's death does not extinguish these obligations or render them excessive under the Eighth Amendment. Adding another layer to the ruling, the court found that the government was not time-barred from assessing these penalties, thanks to the taxpayer's agreement, while still alive, to extend the statute of limitations.
The Hendler case revolves around David Benishai, a U.S. citizen who held financial interests in multiple bank accounts in Israel from 2004 to 2010. Benishai failed to timely file FBARs as required by the Bank Secrecy Act. Mr. Benishai later filed delinquent FBARs and agreed to extend the statute of limitations for the IRS to assess penalties. He passed away a few months before the IRS finalized its assessment.
Benishai's estate, administered by his wife Hanna Hendler, challenged the assessment of 'nonwillful' penalties which IRS had assessed at $10,000 per form per calendar year in line with the U.S. Supreme Court landmark decision. The estate argued that the FBAR penalties could not be enforced after his death, that the statute of limitations had expired, and that they violated constitutional protections. The district court rejected these claims, delivering a ruling with significant implications for taxpayers and their estates.
A key element of the Hendler ruling was the court's determination that FBAR penalties 'accrue' on the date the FBAR form is due. What does this mean in practice? Unlike penalties that might depend on an agency's action such as an assessment, FBAR penalties are tied to the moment of noncompliance. For each year an individual fails to file an FBAR by its due date (now April 15 of the following calendar year, with an automatic six-month extension to October 15), a liability is created. This liability doesn't require the IRS to act immediately; it exists as a latent obligation from that due date onward.
In Benishai's case, his FBARs were due annually between 2005 and 2011 for the calendar years 2004 through 2010. Because he was alive on those due dates and failed to file, the penalties accrued then and not at the later time after his death when the IRS assessed them. The court likened this to tax deficiencies, which arise by operation of law when a return is due but not filed, requiring no formal assessment.
Even though Benishai died in 2021 and the IRS assessed the penalties posthumously, his FBAR liability had already crystallized years earlier while he was alive and failed to file the forms when due. This interpretation means the IRS can pursue these penalties against an estate long after the taxpayer's death, provided it acts within the statutory timeframe. While the IRS may face greater hurdles in FBAR penalty collection, it has various means to ensure payment.
The estate argued that assessing the nonwillful FBAR penalties after Benishai's death extinguished the claim or violated due process and the Eighth Amendment's Excessive Fines Clause. The court disagreed. It found that FBAR penalties are primarily 'remedial', designed to compensate the government for the costs of investigating noncompliance and to enforce tax collection. FBAR penalties are not purely punitive and designed to punish the taxpayer. When a penalty is remedial in nature, the penalty can survive the taxpayer's death. Various precedent was cited by the Hendler court that supported this view, affirming that estates remain on the hook for accrued FBAR violations. As an aside, even 'willful' FBAR penalties have been found to be 'remedial' and survive death, despite the huge penalty amounts involved.
The Eighth Amendment challenge that the penalties were excessive was also unsuccessful. The estate claimed any fine against a deceased person is inherently excessive, but the court found no legal basis for this blanket assertion. The court declined to rule definitively on whether the Excessive Fines Clause applies to FBAR penalties, but it made clear that death alone doesn't render a penalty unconstitutional.
The estate's final defense was that the FBAR six-year statute of limitations barred the IRS' 2021 assessment. This argument was undermined by Benishai's own actions. The Bank Secrecy Act provides the government six years from the due date to assess FBAR penalties, but taxpayers can extend this period by agreement with the IRS. While Benishai was alive, he signed extensions pushing the deadline beyond his death to December 31, 2021. Since the IRS assessed the penalties in April 2021 this assessment was well within the extended window. The estate's argument that such extensions are invalid lacked supporting authority, and prior cases have consistently recognized their legitimacy.
The Hendler decision reminds us that FBAR obligations don't vanish with the taxpayer's death. For individuals with unreported foreign accounts, the accrual of penalties on the due date means liability begins ticking the moment they miss a filing, whether the IRS catches it during their lifetime or not. Estates can inherit these debts, facing enforcement actions years later. If beneficiaries receive assets tied to unreported foreign accounts, they could inadvertently become entangled in ongoing compliance issues or audits, exposing them to further legal and financial risks.
For tax pro's, wealth advisers and estate planners, the Hendler decision is a reminder to investigate potential FBAR liabilities when managing a decedent's affairs. Consider a taxpayer who failed to file an FBAR for a $50,000 Swiss account by April 15, 2018 (for the 2017 tax year), with the automatic extension expiring October 15, 2018. If they died in 2020 without extending the statute of limitations, the IRS could still assess a $10,000 penalty against their estate as late as October 15, 2024, six years from the due date.
FBAR rules can be, and are, enforced beyond the grave. By tying penalty accrual to the FBAR due date and upholding penalty survival post-death, the Hendler court has closed loopholes that might have let estates escape a decedent's FBAR penalties that are not assessed during his lifetime.
Taxpayers who are not compliant leave a problem to their estate which may simply inherit the liability. As foreign account scrutiny intensifies, this decision serves as both a warning and a call to action. There are many avenues to rectify FBAR noncompliance and often, without any penalty being imposed.
Stay on top of tax matters around the globe.
Reach me at vljeker@us-taxes.org
Visit my US tax blog www.us-tax.org It is an invaluable guide in all areas of U.S. international tax. Stay on top of legislative developments and tax reform (including FBAR developments) and keep ahead of U.S. tax changes impacting your life, family or business.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

EHP Inc. Launches National Affiliate Expansion Initiative to Accelerate Employer Healthcare Innovation Under Mardy Gould's Leadership
EHP Inc. Launches National Affiliate Expansion Initiative to Accelerate Employer Healthcare Innovation Under Mardy Gould's Leadership

Business Upturn

time2 hours ago

  • Business Upturn

EHP Inc. Launches National Affiliate Expansion Initiative to Accelerate Employer Healthcare Innovation Under Mardy Gould's Leadership

Jacksonville, FL, June 11, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) — EHP Inc., a leading provider of compliant, tax-efficient employee benefit programs, announced the launch of its 2025 National Affiliate Expansion Initiative, a strategic move aimed at scaling its transformative employer-focused healthcare model across the U.S. The initiative is spearheaded by Co-Founder and Managing Partner Mardy Gould, reaffirming the company's commitment to innovation, compliance, and growth through a robust partner ecosystem. Mardy Gould This newly launched initiative marks a pivotal step in EHP Inc.'s nationwide growth strategy, offering new opportunities for professionals and non-traditional partners to join the company's thriving affiliate network. With over 10,000 affiliates already active, the expansion initiative will provide additional training, real-time tools, and access to EHP's proprietary AI-powered compliance infrastructure, enabling partners to deliver the company's tax-smart, employee-first benefits model with confidence and scale. A Timely Expansion Driven by Founder-Led Vision The launch of the Affiliate Expansion Initiative comes amid increasing demand from mid-sized and large employers seeking effective ways to lower healthcare costs and improve employee engagement without overhauling their existing insurance. EHP Inc.'s structure, based on IRS Sections 125, 105, and 213(d), allows employers to reduce their FICA tax burden by $650 to $750 per employee annually while enhancing preventive healthcare access. 'This expansion initiative reflects our belief that smart growth starts with strong partners,' said Mardy Gould. 'We built EHP Inc. on the principles of compliance, transparency, and impact — and we're inviting professionals across the country to be part of a proven model that actually helps employers solve real problems.' The Employer's Choice for Modern, Tax-Advantaged Healthcare EHP Inc. stands out by offering a fully IRS-compliant model that integrates seamlessly with existing payroll systems and insurance plans. The program requires no out-of-pocket costs from employers and offers employees a suite of wellness services, including virtual primary care, care navigation, and personalized advocacy, services that are delivered in addition to any current benefits. Legal and ERISA-reviewed, the EHP structure helps employers retain talent, improve health outcomes, and achieve cost-efficiency without introducing unnecessary complexity. What Makes the 2025 Expansion Initiative Newsworthy The launch of this initiative represents a major milestone for EHP Inc. It includes: Regional Training Sessions: A calendar of in-person and virtual affiliate training sessions scheduled across major U.S. cities beginning July 2025. A calendar of in-person and virtual affiliate training sessions scheduled across major U.S. cities beginning July 2025. Enhanced Partner Tools: Access to a newly updated Affiliate Portal, with AI-powered proposal generation, real-time commission tracking, and automated compliance updates. Access to a newly updated Affiliate Portal, with AI-powered proposal generation, real-time commission tracking, and automated compliance updates. Tiered Compensation Model: A refined affiliate earnings structure designed to accelerate success for both new and experienced partners. A refined affiliate earnings structure designed to accelerate success for both new and experienced partners. Turnkey Onboarding: Streamlined onboarding powered by smart automation, ensuring that affiliates can activate quickly and compliantly. These enhancements are expected to double the company's affiliate footprint by year's end and strengthen its position as The Employer's Choice in employer-driven healthcare benefits. AI-Driven Compliance and National Infrastructure Central to the success of EHP Inc.'s model is its proprietary compliance automation platform, which governs everything from onboarding and documentation to payroll analysis and partner communications. The platform uses AI to maintain IRS and ERISA compliance while minimizing administrative burden for both employers and affiliates. 'Our infrastructure isn't just scalable; it's protective,' said Gould. 'Every piece of our system is designed to safeguard our clients, our partners, and our mission.' Leadership Continuity Fuels Nationwide Momentum Unlike many rapidly growing companies, EHP Inc. remains founder-led, with its original leadership team still driving strategic direction. Mardy Gould continues to play an active role in expanding partnerships, shaping program design, and advocating for smarter employer benefits at industry forums nationwide. 'We've never lost sight of why we started EHP,' Gould added. 'Our mission was, and still is, to give employers better choices through compliant, tax-savvy solutions. This affiliate expansion is a natural extension of that promise.' About EHP Inc. Headquartered in Jacksonville, Florida, EHP Inc. is a national employer solutions provider offering tax-advantaged, IRS-compliant benefit programs under IRS Sections 125, 105, and 213(d). The company helps businesses lower payroll tax liability and redirect those savings toward meaningful, preventive care for employees. With a strong legal foundation, AI-driven compliance, and a growing network of affiliates, EHP Inc. is redefining how companies manage cost, care, and compliance. To learn more about the 2025 National Affiliate Expansion Initiative or to become an affiliate, visit EHP The Employer's Choice Disclaimer: The above press release comes to you under an arrangement with GlobeNewswire. Business Upturn takes no editorial responsibility for the same.

Fact Check: Clarifying claims Louisiana voted 'to force a 9-year-old girl to deliver her rapist's baby'
Fact Check: Clarifying claims Louisiana voted 'to force a 9-year-old girl to deliver her rapist's baby'

Yahoo

time2 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Fact Check: Clarifying claims Louisiana voted 'to force a 9-year-old girl to deliver her rapist's baby'

Claim: In early June 2025, Louisiana lawmakers voted "to force a 9-year-old girl to deliver her rapist's baby." Rating: What's True: In early June 2025, Louisiana lawmakers rejected a bill that would have added exceptions for rape to the state's abortion ban, specifically allowing young rape victims to terminate their pregnancies. What's False: The proposed bill did not reference or target any specific case of a pregnant 9-year old. What's Undetermined: The claim originated from Louisiana state Rep. Patricia Moore's mention of a pregnant 9-year-old girl in her district. However, she did not provide additional details, and we were unable to independently confirm the existence or circumstances of the case. In early June 2025, a rumor spread that Louisiana lawmakers voted to deny abortion to a 9-year-old rape victim. One X post (archived) on the topic, which as of this writing had over 958,300 views, read, "Louisiana votes to force a 9-year-old girl to deliver her rapist's baby." It also quoted Democratic state Rep. Patricia Moore allegedly saying, "I'm constantly hearing that God would take a bad situation and turn it into good," additionally claiming that Moore spoke out against the bill "even after being made aware of the pregnant 9-year-old girl living in her district." Another Facebook post (archived) making the claim, which amassed over 25,000 reactions, read, "If a 9-year-old walked into an adoption agency with plans to be a mother, they would laugh her out of the room and explain that she's too young to become a mom. But if a 9-year-old is raped, conservatives believe he's the perfect age for motherhood." Similar claims spread on social media platforms including Instagram (archived) and Reddit (archived). In short, the claim was a mixture of true, false and undetermined information. In early June 2025, for the third year in a row, Louisiana lawmakers rejected a bill that would have added exceptions for rape to the state's abortion ban. Namely, the bill would have allowed young rape victims to terminate their pregnancies. However, the proposed legislation did not reference any specific case of a pregnant 9-year-old. The claim stemmed from a statement by Moore, who said she was aware of a 9-year-old girl in her district who had become pregnant. We were unable to independently verify the existence or circumstances of the child mentioned. We reached out to Moore to request more details about the case of the pregnant 9-year-old and will update this story if and when we hear back. Louisiana's abortion ban took effect in 2022 following the U.S. Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade. That decision eliminated federal protections for abortion and allowed individual states to set their own laws. Under the state's law, abortion is banned except in limited cases, such as when the pregnant woman's life is at serious risk, the fetus is "medically futile" or in cases of ectopic pregnancy or miscarriage. There is currently no exception for rape or incest. The in-question legislation was Democratic state Rep. Delisha Boyd's third attempt to create exceptions to Louisiana's abortion law. The proposed bill aimed to allow abortions for victims under 17 who became pregnant as a result of specific offenses such as rape or sexual battery that, if committed against a minor, would make an abortion legal in those cases. The bill said the victim wouldn't need to provide a police report, forensic evidence or proof that someone was being prosecuted for the crime in order to get the abortion. Legislators discussed the bill during a House Committee on Administration of Criminal Justice hearing on June 3, 2025. As shown in the image below, the bill that "provides for exceptions to the abortion laws of this state relative to rape and certain sex offenses" received three votes in favor ("Yea") and nine votes against ("Nay"). Therefore, the law did not proceed to the House floor for further consideration. (Louisiana House of Representatives) You can access the full text of the in-question bill here. A video circulating alongside the claims on Louisiana "denying abortion to 9-year-old rape victim" originated from an April 11, 2025, KLFY News 10 segment that aired before legislators voted on the bill. Moore made the statement about the pregnant 9-year-old during the hearing at 38:57 of the video recording available via the Louisiana House of Representatives' official website. Moore stated that she was "aware of a nine year old, in [her] area, pregnant" and that she was struggling to reconcile her feelings about the case with her religious beliefs. Moore also added that her mother was raped at the age of 13 and had her at 14. "So I do struggle with it. I know we got to protect our children, but this point right now, I cannot vote yes," she said. Boyd, who authored the bill, also mentioned she was aware of a "Louisiana girl who was raped and gave birth at 13 years old and a 9-year-old girl who became pregnant after being sexually assaulted." All in all, while it's true that Louisiana lawmakers rejected a bill that would have allowed abortion in cases of child rape, there was no confirmed evidence that the decision directly affected a specific 9-year-old. Moore mentioned being aware of such a case during the hearing but provided no details, and we were unable to independently verify the claim. As of this writing, Louisiana abortion law does not include an exception for rape or incest. - YouTube. Accessed 11 June 2025. Agenda - Administration of Criminal Justice. Accessed 11 June 2025. HB215. Accessed 11 June 2025. ---. Accessed 11 June 2025. LA House On-Demand Video. Accessed 11 June 2025. Louisiana House of Representatives 24-28. Accessed 11 June 2025. "Louisiana Lawmakers Reject Adding Exceptions for Some Rape Cases to Abortion Ban." AP News, 3 June 2025, Louisiana Laws - Louisiana State Legislature. Accessed 11 June 2025.

EHP Inc. Launches National Affiliate Expansion Initiative to Accelerate Employer Healthcare Innovation Under Mardy Gould's Leadership
EHP Inc. Launches National Affiliate Expansion Initiative to Accelerate Employer Healthcare Innovation Under Mardy Gould's Leadership

Yahoo

time3 hours ago

  • Yahoo

EHP Inc. Launches National Affiliate Expansion Initiative to Accelerate Employer Healthcare Innovation Under Mardy Gould's Leadership

Jacksonville, FL, June 11, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- EHP Inc., a leading provider of compliant, tax-efficient employee benefit programs, announced the launch of its 2025 National Affiliate Expansion Initiative, a strategic move aimed at scaling its transformative employer-focused healthcare model across the U.S. The initiative is spearheaded by Co-Founder and Managing Partner Mardy Gould, reaffirming the company's commitment to innovation, compliance, and growth through a robust partner ecosystem. Mardy Gould This newly launched initiative marks a pivotal step in EHP Inc.'s nationwide growth strategy, offering new opportunities for professionals and non-traditional partners to join the company's thriving affiliate network. With over 10,000 affiliates already active, the expansion initiative will provide additional training, real-time tools, and access to EHP's proprietary AI-powered compliance infrastructure, enabling partners to deliver the company's tax-smart, employee-first benefits model with confidence and scale. A Timely Expansion Driven by Founder-Led Vision The launch of the Affiliate Expansion Initiative comes amid increasing demand from mid-sized and large employers seeking effective ways to lower healthcare costs and improve employee engagement without overhauling their existing insurance. EHP Inc.'s structure, based on IRS Sections 125, 105, and 213(d), allows employers to reduce their FICA tax burden by $650 to $750 per employee annually while enhancing preventive healthcare access. 'This expansion initiative reflects our belief that smart growth starts with strong partners,' said Mardy Gould. 'We built EHP Inc. on the principles of compliance, transparency, and impact — and we're inviting professionals across the country to be part of a proven model that actually helps employers solve real problems.' The Employer's Choice for Modern, Tax-Advantaged Healthcare EHP Inc. stands out by offering a fully IRS-compliant model that integrates seamlessly with existing payroll systems and insurance plans. The program requires no out-of-pocket costs from employers and offers employees a suite of wellness services, including virtual primary care, care navigation, and personalized advocacy, services that are delivered in addition to any current benefits. Legal and ERISA-reviewed, the EHP structure helps employers retain talent, improve health outcomes, and achieve cost-efficiency without introducing unnecessary complexity. What Makes the 2025 Expansion Initiative Newsworthy The launch of this initiative represents a major milestone for EHP Inc. It includes: Regional Training Sessions: A calendar of in-person and virtual affiliate training sessions scheduled across major U.S. cities beginning July 2025. Enhanced Partner Tools: Access to a newly updated Affiliate Portal, with AI-powered proposal generation, real-time commission tracking, and automated compliance updates. Tiered Compensation Model: A refined affiliate earnings structure designed to accelerate success for both new and experienced partners. Turnkey Onboarding: Streamlined onboarding powered by smart automation, ensuring that affiliates can activate quickly and compliantly. These enhancements are expected to double the company's affiliate footprint by year's end and strengthen its position as The Employer's Choice in employer-driven healthcare benefits. AI-Driven Compliance and National Infrastructure Central to the success of EHP Inc.'s model is its proprietary compliance automation platform, which governs everything from onboarding and documentation to payroll analysis and partner communications. The platform uses AI to maintain IRS and ERISA compliance while minimizing administrative burden for both employers and affiliates. 'Our infrastructure isn't just scalable; it's protective,' said Gould. 'Every piece of our system is designed to safeguard our clients, our partners, and our mission.' Leadership Continuity Fuels Nationwide Momentum Unlike many rapidly growing companies, EHP Inc. remains founder-led, with its original leadership team still driving strategic direction. Mardy Gould continues to play an active role in expanding partnerships, shaping program design, and advocating for smarter employer benefits at industry forums nationwide. 'We've never lost sight of why we started EHP,' Gould added. 'Our mission was, and still is, to give employers better choices through compliant, tax-savvy solutions. This affiliate expansion is a natural extension of that promise.' About EHP Inc. Headquartered in Jacksonville, Florida, EHP Inc. is a national employer solutions provider offering tax-advantaged, IRS-compliant benefit programs under IRS Sections 125, 105, and 213(d). The company helps businesses lower payroll tax liability and redirect those savings toward meaningful, preventive care for employees. With a strong legal foundation, AI-driven compliance, and a growing network of affiliates, EHP Inc. is redefining how companies manage cost, care, and compliance. To learn more about the 2025 National Affiliate Expansion Initiative or to become an affiliate, visit EHP The Employer's ChoiceCONTACT: Media Contact: Company Name: EHP Inc. Contact Person: Alex Barret Email: info@ Phone: 904-257-6217 Country: United States Website: in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store