By-election hustings chaos as Labour candidate snub leads to walk out
Campaign group No Cuts Lanarkshire hosted the event at St Peter's chapel hall in Hamilton on Tuesday, inviting all the candidates for the upcoming by-election in Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse on June 5.
The SNP's Katy Loudon, the Scottish Socialist Party's Collette Bradley, and Ann McGuinness from the Scottish Greens turned up.
But both the Labour candidate Davy Russell and Reform UK's Ross Lambie dodged the invite – with Labour instead represented by the Labour leader of South Lanarkshire Council, Joe Fagan.
READ MORE: US considers social media vetting for foreign university students
This led Conservative candidate Richard Nelson to stand up right at the start of the hustings, just as the candidates and Fagan had taken to their seats, and announce he would not be taking part.
It comes amid controversy over Russell repeatedly dodging local hustings, an upcoming STV debate, radio interviews and the media, in general, during the campaign.
A series of heavily edited social media clips have also led to accusations that he is unable to 'string a handful of words together'.
'I don't think it's right that I debate the council leader,' Nelson told the roughly 50-or-so local voters in the audience.
'I would have rather debated with Davy Russell, with the actual candidate. So, I'm going to withdraw from here because I don't think it's fair that the leader of the council comes on his behalf.'
(Image: Richard Nelson)
This led to some claps from the audience. One woman said: 'Absolutely.'
One man in attendance then added, seemingly referring to Nelson's withdrawal: 'Shocking. Absolutely shocking.'
The woman then asked: 'Why is it shocking?'
One of the hosts from No Cuts Lanarkshire then intervened.
He said: 'I'm just going to try to keep this a bit stable. I understand your frustration with Richard withdrawing from the debate and unfortunately it is his decision to make whether we agree with it or not.'
READ MORE: Anas Sarwar slams 'poisonous man' Nigel Farage amid 'racist' Reform UK ad row
The woman then interrupted, adding: 'Can I just ask. This is about candidates. Why is the leader of South Lanarkshire Council sitting at a top table? That shouldn't be happening.'
The host then responded: 'I'm not a member of the Labour Party.'
But the local resident again intervened, saying: 'But he's not a candidate. He shouldn't be here.'
Later on, after each candidate and Fagan made their opening statements, the floor was opened to local residents to quiz them.
The same woman then asked Fagan directly: 'How can you stand and say your speech and say about how Davy Russell is going to lead for the constituency, going to stand in Holyrood and speak for the people of this constituency when he can't turn up to radio interviews, when he can't turn up to hustings, when he can't speak without Anas Sarwar by his side?'
Fagan said: 'Well, right now, he is at an event on the NHS.'
She then responded: 'He's always at an event Joe.'
On Wednesday, Sarwar attempted to defend Russell while being interviewed on BBC Scotland's Good Morning Scotland (GMS) show.
GMS host Gary Robertson quizzed Sarwar about why Russell appears to be avoiding all media outlets during his campaign.
Robertson said: 'We invited the candidates for this upcoming by-election onto the program yesterday, but your candidate didn't come. Why not?'
Sarwar replied: 'That's a matter for the campaign team and the campaign.'
The Scottish Labour leader went on to claim that Russell had done media interviews and that he has more planned in the future.
However, Robertson further called out Sarwar as he asked: 'But you understand what the issue here is, that many of your opponents believe that he is running scared.
'That actually when it comes to appearing on programmes like this, he's just not available.'
Sarwar replied: 'Well, I just don't accept that because Davy Hamilton – Davy Russell, sorry – is the only candidate that lives in Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
5 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Robert Jenrick attacks Attorney General Lord Hermer by parading in front of ten easels showing controversial clients in latest stunt video
Shadow justice secretary Robert Jenrick has attacked the Attorney General by parading in front of easels depicting Lord Hermer's previous clients in his latest stunt video. The former Conservative leadership candidate accused Lord Hermer of choosing to 'defend Britain's enemies', adding: 'Starmer should never have appointed him in the first place'. The video saw Jenrick list a range of controversial figures including Gerry Adams and Shamima Begum, as he hit out at the peer following comments he made in a speech comparing calls to leave the ECHR to Nazi policies. Also mentioned were several Islamist terrorists including a man involved in the 7/7 attacks on London transport who was previously known to be Osama Bin Laden's 'right-hand man'. Lord Hermer has faced calls to resign from his role since making the comments, with Jenrick - who wants the UK to leave the ECHR - the latest to add fuel to the fire. Now Jenrick has accused the Prime Minister of 'sharing [Lord Hermer's] views' as he claimed: 'Britain deserves better than the pair of them.' Posting the clip online, Jenrick wrote: 'Gerry Adams. Shamima Begum. Osama bin Laden's right-hand man. Lord Hermer has spent much of his life defending those who hate Britain. Why on earth did Starmer hand-pick him to be Attorney General?' It comes just days after a video showing Jenrick challenging fare evaders on London transport last week went viral after he attempted to make several people go back and pay their fare. Among the former clients of Lord Hermer listed by Jenrick was former Sinn Fein leader Gerry Adams, who he represented in a damages claim brought by victims of IRA bombings. After Adams won a defamation case against the BBC last week, Lord Hermer was asked about his previous work with the politician but declined to give any details. He also intervened in the case of child ISIS bride Shamima Begum, who was groomed by the terror group along with two schoolfriends before all three travelled from the UK to Syria. A complex legal battle ended with Begum being stripped of her British citizenship after she turned up in a refugee camp appealing to be allowed back to her native UK. Lord Hermer argued she should have been allowed to return to the UK in order to participate in her appeal over the issue. Other cases mentioned by Jenrick included representing asylum seekers, advocating for slavery reparations and his support for giving up the Chagos Islands. This included the case of an Eritrean man who came to Britain claiming to be 16, but who was in fact 26. But the most contentious cases highlighted by Jenrick involved clients linked to Islamist terror groups such as Al-Qaeda. Among these is his work for former Guantanamo Bay detainee Mustafa Al-Hawsawi, who last year pleaded guilty to the murder of 2,900 people in the 9/11 terror attacks. Al-Hawsawi launched a claim against the MoD, MI5 and MI6 which was taken on by Lord Hermer in 2023 over allegations that British spies were complicit in 'torture' and 'degrading' treatment by the CIA. He was involved in a preliminary hearing for the case in May 2023, but stopped working on it when he became Attorney General. Lord Hermer also sought compensation from the British government for an Al-Qaeda chief linked to the 7/7 bombings in London in 2005 over alleged torture he suffered in Pakistan. Rangzieb Ahmed, once known as Osama Bin Laden's right-hand man, made the claim on the basis that UK police and security services should have a 'joint liability' over actions taken by Allies in the war on terror. The case was dismissed. Lord Hermer represented the ringleader of another al-Qaeda plot, Abid Naseer, who headed up a terror cell in the northeast. The Attorney General described MI5's case against Naseer as 'pitiful' after it emerged he was involved in plotting to detonate a bomb at a Manchester shopping centre, and charges were not pressed in the UK. Naseer was later found guilty in a US court of plotting to detonate a car bomb outside the shopping centre and then kill hundreds of Easter shoppers by placing suicide bombers at the exits. And Jenrick drew attention to how Lord Hermer intervened and helped unfreeze assets belonging to Al-Qaeda terror suspect Mohammed al-Ghabra, after he was sanctioned by countries including the UK and USA. Jenrick drew attention to how Lord Hermer intervened and helped unfreeze assets belonging to Al-Qaeda terror suspect Mohammed al-Ghabra - he denies all wrongdoing Al-Ghabra has not been convicted of any offence and has always denied any wrongdoing. The stunt video also saw Jenrick speak to a cabbie, who explained the black cab rule that any customer is always taken by the first taxi in any rank. He argued that as one of the country's most eminent human rights' lawyers, Lord Hermer would have the choice to pick any of his cases, unlike many criminal lawyers, who must take whatever case is first in line. Lord Hermer has faced backlash over his series of controversial clients in recent months, which only increased after his comments on those who wish for the UK to leave the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). In a lecture at the Royal United Services Institute, a defence and security think-tank, he said the Labour Government had a 'policy of progressive realism' that means it will never leave international conventions such as the ECHR. Numerous senior politicians on the Right have called for Britain to leave the convention after it stopped Rwanda deportation flights. Lord Hermer said such 'songs' had been heard before, citing Nazi ideologist Carl Schmitt, who supported Hitler's policies such as the Night of the Long Knives assassinations. The Attorney General said: 'Our approach is a rejection of the siren song that can sadly now be heard in the Palace of Westminster and in some spectrums of the media, that Britain abandons the constraints of international law in favour of raw power. 'This is not a new song. The claim that international law is fine as far as it goes, but can be put aside when conditions change, is a claim that was made in the early 1930s by "realist" jurists in Germany, most notably Carl Schmitt, whose central thesis was in essence the claim that state power is all that counts, not law. 'Because of the experience of what followed in 1933, far-sighted individuals rebuilt and transformed the institutions of international law, as well as internal constitutional law.' Jenrick has quite the opposite view and responded angrily to Lord Hermen's comments. He said: 'The idea you can reform the ECHR is fanciful as it requires unanimity from all 46 signatories. 'It is appalling Hermer would insinuate those who think we should leave the ECHR are like the Nazis. '[Foreign Secretary] David Lammy tried that disgusting smeer with Brexiteers and it didn't work for him. It won't work for Hermer either.'
The National
13 minutes ago
- The National
Reform UK Anas Sarwar advert now seen a million times
The advert – which Reform have spent between £15,000 and £20,000 on – falsely claims Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar would 'prioritise the Pakistani community' and includes selected clips from a video spread by far and alt-right agitators on social media in a bid to claim that Europe was under threat from 'multiculturalism' and mass immigration, specifically of Muslims. The total spend on the advert only last week was listed as between £10,000 and £15,000, and this now appears to have risen several thousand pounds according to statistics. Ross Lambie – who is hoping to claim the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse Scottish Parliament seat for Reform this week – was grilled during an STV hustings by host Colin Mackay and SNP candidate Katy Loudon about the advert. READ MORE: No independence referendum while I am PM, says Keir Starmer He doubled down on defending it insisting the party had not misquoted Sarwar despite telling the BBC last week the claim that Sarwar will 'prioritise' the Pakistani community was 'a quote from us'. He criticised the BBC, suggesting the broadcaster had got facts wrong, and said he 'looked forward to their apology', adding that his party had 'nothing to apologise for'. (Image: STV) Asked by Mackay if he was embarrassed by the advert, Lambie (above) said: 'Anas Sarwar is a man who wants to be the first minister for the whole of Scotland and I think it's quite right the things he says, the speeches he gives, is held up to the highest scrutiny. 'We've done that, we've given our view on it.' Asked if he owed Sarwar an apology for misquoting him, Lambie then said: 'We never misquoted him at all. The title of it was our opinion of it, it was not in quotations.' He was then asked if he believed his party had anything to apologise for to which he said "absolutely not". When it was put to Lambie by both Loudon and Mackay that he had previously said they were not Sarwar's words, Lambie went on: 'We didn't portray them as his words. The BBC were incorrect about the quotations, and we look forward to their apology.' Loudon then asked him to clarify whether they were not Sarwar's words and instead Reform UK's opinion to which Lambie replied: 'Yes, correct.' Last week, Sarwar called Farage a 'pathetic, poisonous little man who wants to use divisive rhetoric to spread fear and division for his own political gain'. READ MORE: Scottish Labour councillor defects to Reform UK The Labour MSP further challenged the Reform UK MP to a debate at 'any time, any place', adding: 'He can challenge me on my views, I'll challenge him on his, and I am confident that the people of Scotland will reject him.' He said the Clacton MP did not know about, or care for, the people in the area, saying Farage "thinks Hamilton is some kind of show on the West End of London". Reform UK are not expected to be able to win the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election, but some pollsters have projected that they could push Labour into third place, which would send shockwaves through Scottish politics. The debate on STV was only attended by two candidates – Lambie and Loudon – despite four others contesting the seat on Thursday having been invited to go on the programme. Scottish Labour's candidate Davy Russell floundered in an accompanying interview after failing to answer a question 11 times. Russell previously said he would not be attending the debate because he would rather be "knocking on doors" – despite the fact that the event is scheduled for 10.40pm. In the individual interview he had with Mackay, he then struggled to answer when asked about the failings of the current Labour Government. Mackay asked Russell a total of 11 times whether the UK Government was right to scrap the Winter Fuel Payment. The Scottish Labour candidate did not answer and instead insisted that he wasn't involved in the decision and that he was running for a Holyrood election rather than Westminster.
Daily Mail
21 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Labour narrows the gap on Reform after PM's full-frontal attack on Nigel Farage - but insurgents still hold six-point poll lead
Labour has narrowed the gap on Reform after Keir Starmer 's extraordinary full-frontal attack. The latest YouGov poll shows the advantage for Nigel Farage 's party trimmed by two points compared to last week. But despite Reform losing a point and Labour gaining one, the lead still stands at six points. Sir Keir summoned a press conference during the Parliamentary recess to condemn Mr Farage's economic plans. He warned voters they cannot trust Reform with their 'future, mortgages or jobs', deriding proposals for huge tax cuts and higher spending. The intervention confirmed a major shift in Labour's tactics, from largely ignoring Reform to targeting their rivals head-on, Mr Farage has sought to woo working class Labour voters by backing an end to the two-child benefit cap and full restoration of winter fuel payments. But he simultaneously insists he can slash taxes, with economists suggesting a commitment to hike the personal allowance alone would cost £60billion to £80billion. Reform argues that would be possible by cutting £350billion-£400billion of spending on quangos, Net Zero and DEI policies - although Mr Farage himself acknowledged the figures could be 'slightly optimistic'. The YouGov research put Reform on 28 per cent, with Labour on 22 per cent, and the Conservatives barely ahead of the Lib Dems on 18 per cent. Panic has grown in Labour circles following the dramatic local election results, when Reform seized 10 councils, two mayoralties and the Parliamentary seat of Runcorn in a by-election. Sir Keir has signalled he will bow to a revolt by MPs over scrapping the winter fuel allowance, as well as easing the two-child benefit cap. But he is under pressure to go further and water down curbs to disability benefits, despite the government desperately struggling to balance the books.
