State sued over 28 years of racism claim
Queensland Health have been hit with a class action over allegations of racial discrimination that claim Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people received inadequate healthcare spanning three decades.
The class action alleges First Nations people were withheld or denied adequate treatment, had their concerns dismissed and received substandard medical care, which was unlawful and breached the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth).
Litigators JGA Saddler filed the class action on Tuesday on behalf of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people who were subject to discriminatory conduct by the North West and Torres and Cape Hospital and Health Services between 1996 and 2024. JGA Saddler director Rebecca Jancauskas said the state of Queensland needed to be held accountable for systematic racism experienced by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people in the public health system. Photo: Supplied. Credit: Supplied
JGA Saddler director Rebecca Jancauskas said the state needed to be held accountable for systematic practices that resulted in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people who interacted with certain healthcare providers in Queensland receiving a lower standard of healthcare.
'We've heard heartbreaking stories of First Nations patients being ignored, misdiagnosed, or dismissed in ways that would simply not happen to other Australians,' she said.
'This case is about ensuring those voices are heard, and change is made.
'No one should be treated differently in our hospitals because of their race.' Litigators JGA Saddler filed the class action on Tuesday on behalf of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people who were subject to discriminatory conduct by the North West and Torres and Cape Hospital and Health Services between 1996 and 2024. Credit: Supplied
Ms Jancauskas said the claim alleged the State of Queensland failed to take sufficient action to address concerns about systematic racism in hospitals and health services over 30 years despite investigations and inquiries identifying these issues.
She said there were examples of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people who had sought medical care from public hospitals and health services in the North West and Cape regions but been repeatedly dismissed, which the case alleges led to children dying.
'This has sadly been the experience of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people who have sought medical care from public hospitals and health services in these regions,' she said.
'This case goes beyond individual harm. It challenges a pattern of institutional racism that continues to impact the health and lives of First Nations people across Queensland.' The class action alleges the state withheld or denied First Nations people adequate treatment, dismissed patients' concerns and delivered substandard medical care to them breaching the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth). Credit: Supplied
Litigation Lending Services chief executive officer Susan Wynne said they were funding the class action to seek justice on behalf of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people who were failed by Queensland Health.
'Every Australian has the right to access healthcare free from discrimination,' she said.
'For too long, complaints of racism in the public health system have been minimised or ignored.'
Queensland Health declined to comment on the case, as the matter is before the courts.
Health Minister Tim Nicholls has been contacted for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
a day ago
- ABC News
Queensland cosmetic nurses warn storage rules could shut down clinics, push patients underground
Megan McRae took the leap last year to open her small cosmetic injectable clinic in Brisbane after more than three decades as a registered nurse, and seven years as an injector. She sunk her heart, soul and savings into the business to get it off the ground, but within eight months she is already facing the threat of closure — and she's not alone. A recent rule clarification from Queensland Health has left hundreds of cosmetic injectable clinics across the state "scrambling" and Ms McRae said it has forced a dozen to close. The clarification in its guidelines means registered nurses cannot store certain prescription medicines, like botox and injectables, at their clinics without a doctor or nurse practitioner present. Some in the sector have criticised the move, claiming it could harm patient safety and drive them underground for treatments, as dozens plan to rally outside parliament house today. It comes a week after the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency introduced sweeping new industry guidelines for dentists and nurses working with injectables. It included mandating further education and training, minimum periods of experience for nurses, and more restrictions around advertising. Queensland Health doubled down on its guidelines in April, after the industry questioned a fact sheet it released in December stating that registered nurses could not buy or hold stock of S4 class cosmetic injectable medicines at a clinic if they work there. Prior to this, registered nurses believed they were able to stock the prescription medications under strict guidelines. "[We] have scripting companies that look after drug register, live register, checks and balances and logs in place, prescribed by a doctor and stored under lock and key," Ms McRae said. Queensland Health has now confirmed only prescribers of the medicines, like doctors or nurse practitioners could stock them, reaffirming it was not a change of law, but a clarification of the Medicine and Poisons Act 2019. Queensland Health said there has been no change in rules. But registered nurses said up until the point the clarification was issued, they always believed they were operating within the regulations, and have been holding stock of S4 medicines for years. "We thought we were practising safely up until that point … and we've been left scrambling to make ourselves compliant." Ms McRae said two pathways were offered to registered nurses — they could hire a doctor or nurse practitioner to work onsite and take responsibility for the stock, or patients would have to get a script from a doctor and go to a chemist to have the product dispensed, before taking it to the clinics to have it injected. She said these options open dangerous pathways, including a patient potentially misusing the product. "That potentially opens the market up for patients injecting themselves, or selling it on themselves," Ms McRae said. She said it was not logical that a patient could be trusted to collect and handle S4 medicines, but registered nurses could not. "The reason that it should be in the hands of medical professionals is that we have studied, we do know how to administer safely, we do know our anatomy," Ms McRae said. "I've spent thousands on upskilling over many years. "It's a little patronising to not respect the skill set that we have as medical professionals." Ms McRae said even if she could find a doctor to work onsite, it remained unclear how often they would need to be at the clinic, and guaranteed those costs would need to be passed onto the client. She is worried the price hikes could drive customers underground to get their treatments. "We do know there are cowboys out there. We're not against compliance. We just want a pathway that is economically viable that's not going to shut us down." Griffith University school of applied psychology researcher Dr Veya Seekis said she did not think women would turn to the black market for treatment, but it could leave the door open for medications to be misused. "There will always be a small proportion of people who misuse prescription medication, but I think generally women and people who do seek these procedures are more aware of the risk," she said. Dr Seekis said while she was fully in support of more regulation in the industry, in this case, she stood with the registered nurses. "The risks I think outweigh any benefits there," she said. "I do stand with the nurses, who are registered and who do have the additional qualifications and who have done everything right, because they're working and serving the patients. "I feel they should not be penalised simply because there are people out there who are doing the wrong thing." In response to questions from the ABC, Queensland Health said patients deserved to feel informed, safe, and confident in their service provider when receiving treatments and procedures, including cosmetic injectables. "Queensland Health's focus is the safety of Queenslanders and we are committed to ensuring cosmetic injectable providers are aware of their legal obligations and operating legally," a spokesperson said. "In most cases, cosmetic injectable prescription and administration takes place at the same time; we strongly advise against giving cosmetic injectable medicines directly to the client or patient." Ms McRae said more than anything, injectable clinic owners want a "seat at the table" to ensure they can remain complaint.
The Age
a day ago
- The Age
Queensland is tightening Botox and dermal filler laws. Cosmetic nurses are not happy
Nurses who run independent cosmetic clinics fear that 'further clarification' of a Queensland law around the handling of drugs including Botox and dermal fillers will run them out of business. The nurses, who plan to protest outside Queensland Parliament on Tuesday, say the regulations will act as a 'vanity tax', affecting how thousands of women and men across Queensland access cosmetic services. Queensland Health released a new fact sheet in mid-April clarifying the Queensland Medicines and Poisons Act, which stops registered nurses purchasing and storing schedule four (S4) prescription-only medicines, which includes Botox and dermal fillers. 'Registered Nurses (RNs) are not authorised to buy S4 cosmetic injectable medicines,' the fact sheet reads. Lisa Oakman, a registered nurse behind Gordon Park business The Glow Co. Aesthetics, said nurses like her who run their own clinics have medicines sent in bulk and stored in locked drug cupboards on-site. 'Every time my patient comes in, we have a conversation with a doctor [via telehealth to get a prescription] after I've done a full medical assessment,' she said. 'That's a shorter conversation because they [the doctor] trusts that I've got the ability to do the full assessment first.' Under the tightened regulations, a person seeking a cosmetic injection procedure would need to seek out a clinic with an in-house doctor, or consult a GP separately and transport the medication themselves, or have it delivered to the clinic from a pharmacy.
Sydney Morning Herald
a day ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Queensland is tightening Botox and dermal filler laws. Cosmetic nurses are not happy
Nurses who run independent cosmetic clinics fear that 'further clarification' of a Queensland law around the handling of drugs including Botox and dermal fillers will run them out of business. The nurses, who plan to protest outside Queensland Parliament on Tuesday, say the regulations will act as a 'vanity tax', affecting how thousands of women and men across Queensland access cosmetic services. Queensland Health released a new fact sheet in mid-April clarifying the Queensland Medicines and Poisons Act, which stops registered nurses purchasing and storing schedule four (S4) prescription-only medicines, which includes Botox and dermal fillers. 'Registered Nurses (RNs) are not authorised to buy S4 cosmetic injectable medicines,' the fact sheet reads. Lisa Oakman, a registered nurse behind Gordon Park business The Glow Co. Aesthetics, said nurses like her who run their own clinics have medicines sent in bulk and stored in locked drug cupboards on-site. 'Every time my patient comes in, we have a conversation with a doctor [via telehealth to get a prescription] after I've done a full medical assessment,' she said. 'That's a shorter conversation because they [the doctor] trusts that I've got the ability to do the full assessment first.' Under the tightened regulations, a person seeking a cosmetic injection procedure would need to seek out a clinic with an in-house doctor, or consult a GP separately and transport the medication themselves, or have it delivered to the clinic from a pharmacy.
