logo
Ita the Imperious, Australia's media queen, swats aside questions over Lattouf sacking

Ita the Imperious, Australia's media queen, swats aside questions over Lattouf sacking

The Guardian11-02-2025

First the courtiers, then the queen.
After a week of testimony from a stream of ABC managers, it was time for Ita Buttrose, former chair of the ABC to take the stand.
Buttrose – a doyenne of Australian media, a household name, with a voice and face familiar even to those who can name no other ABC chair – is the most-anticipated witness in the unlawful termination case brought by Antoinette Lattouf against the ABC.
Buttrose's words have already featured in this case, which centres around a five-day casual presenting gig that Lattouf was given in December 2023. Lattouf was dismissed three days into the contract after posting on social media about the war in Gaza.
Buttrose's emails to managing director David Anderson about Lattouf, saying she was sick of getting complaints about the journalist, and suggesting Lattouf might 'come down with flu' to get her off air, have been read aloud.
Chris Oliver-Taylor, who gave hours of testimony last Friday, conceded he had felt 'pressure from above' after he started getting complaints about Lattouf forwarded directly to him from Buttrose.
The 83-year-old finally arrived on Tuesday afternoon in a wheelchair and received some help from the court officer in manoeuvring between the enormous lever arch files that contained various documents, affidavits and other evidence. But any sense that the former ABC chair was anything but her pin-sharp self was shortly and witheringly dispatched.
Buttrose swatted away barrister Philip Boncardo's questions of cross-examination as if he were an irritant.
When asked questions, Buttrose often answered Boncardo, not with repeated answers of 'yes' but repeated dismissive answers of 'So?'.
Several times she fixed him with a steely look and answered with an arch 'obviously', several times she talked over the judge, several times she talked over the ABC's own barrister as he rose to object to questions being put to her, at one point causing Ian Neil SC to hold up a hand to silence his own witness, as he sought to have the question she'd been happily answering ruled objectionable.
Neil's objections weren't always needed. Buttrose, unflappable, handled some herself.
'That's a hypothetical question and I can't answer it,' she told Boncardo at one point.
'Do you want to take a stab at it?' Boncardo pressed.
'No,' she said calmly.
At one point, as Boncardo took a minute to get a document from his solicitor, she muttered 'Jesus Christ' with a dramatic eye roll – under her breath, but still clearly audible to the court's microphones.
On the key points, Buttrose said she did not pressure Anderson to take Lattouf off air, nor had she been swayed by the many complaints she had received about Lattouf's presence on ABC Radio Sydney. She had forwarded all the complaints onto Oliver-Taylor at the direction of Anderson (something Anderson disputes in his evidence, saying the direction had come from Buttrose herself), because Anderson wanted Oliver-Taylor 'to learn the folly of not checking the references of someone he hired'.
Buttrose told the court it was 'quite apparent' that Lattouf was 'an activist' and said she thought the presenter should not have been hired. She added that as the complaints started coming in about Lattouf, Buttrose thought 'it looked like [Lattouf] was going to lose her job'. Questioned what made her think that, Buttrose said: 'Because I could see which way the wind was blowing.'
Despite this Buttrose insisted she had, until the moment she heard Lattouf had been let go, expected her to remain on air for the full five days for which she was employed.
'That seemed like a perfect solution to me,' said Buttrose, who said when she heard Lattouf had been let go, she was 'surprised' and not pleased.
Asked if she was happy that Lattouf had been fired, Buttrose replied: 'No one's ever happy with a dismissal of anyone. I don't know why you think that. It's the worst thing that can happen to anybody. And I'm not happy. And I wasn't happy. I didn't wish her to be removed. I didn't put pressure on anybody. It's a fantasy of your own imagination.'
Asked about an email in which she wrote to Anderson: 'Has Antoinette been replaced? I am over getting emails about her', Buttrose told the court: 'I didn't want her replaced. I can't replace anybody, the chair can't do that.' But then went on to quip: 'If I wanted somebody removed I'd be franker than that.'
Buttrose's sharp composure broke – for a giggle – as she addressed questions about the email she sent Anderson asking of Lattouf's employment: 'Why can't she come down with flu or Covid or a stomach upset? We owe her nothing.'
Boncardo began his questioning here by asking: 'Was it your practice in 2023 to wish that ABC employees would come down with respiratory illnesses?'
Buttrose laughed. 'That was just a face-saving idea. I thought it might have been an idea for Antoinette. It's an easy way to save face.'
But the comment elicited a very different reaction from the other side of the room, where there was a shocked gasp from Lattouf and her supporters, who looked at each other wide-eyed and disbelieving.
'David didn't pick up on the suggestion so we didn't go ahead with the idea,' Buttrose shrugged. 'It would give her an easy exit, that's all it was.'
As the case enters its seventh day in the federal court on Wednesday, there are no easy exits in sight.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

BREAKING NEWS Long running ABC program Q+A to be axed after 17 years following a painful decline in ratings
BREAKING NEWS Long running ABC program Q+A to be axed after 17 years following a painful decline in ratings

Daily Mail​

time7 hours ago

  • Daily Mail​

BREAKING NEWS Long running ABC program Q+A to be axed after 17 years following a painful decline in ratings

Q+A, one of the ABC's flagship current affairs and news programs will not return to air, after taking a break in May. It was scheduled to return in August, but those familiar with the matter, who spoke on the condition of anonymity say it won't return. The ABC is set to announce the decision to discontinue the show later this week. The show has come under fire over the last few years, after churning through different hosts following the departure of Tony Jones, who left in 2019. Q+A has seen several changes in its hosting lineup, first with Hamish Macdonald, David Speers, Virginia Trioli, Stan Grant and most recently Patricia Karvelas taking over as host. The number of episodes was also cut by ABC staff in 2024, going from 40 episodes a year to just 24. Q+A also was shifted from its usual slot of Monday night, to Thursday night, a move that was eventually reversed by the ABC. The show also has seen its ratings collapse in the last 5 years. From a peak 600,000 viewers in 2020, the Q+A crashed to a record low of just above 200,000 viewers across the five major capital cities in April 2021. In August 2023, during the show's 'Garma Special', Q+A received its lowest ratings ever, with fewer than 84,000 metro viewers. Daily Mail Australia's Political Editor Peter Van Onselen said the program would not be missed if it didn't return to ABC's roster in 2024. In an opinion piece for The Australian, Van Onselen said Q&A - hosted by Patricia Karvelas - had received 203,000 views nationally. 'With numbers this woeful coupled with how out of touch with mainstream Australia the program has become, it really needs to be put out of its misery,' he wrote. 'There have been enough failed reboots to justify finally axing it.' The commentator said cracks started to appear after Tony Jones stopped hosting after a decade in the role from 2008 to 2019. 'It wasn't all that long ago that the program was vibrant and interesting, with discussions well led by former host Tony Jones,' Van Onselen wrote. 'I remember appearing on it at the time. Ratings regularly hit the one million mark, which precipitated the discussion about changing its time slot.' Van Onselen lashed the show for not being informative enough and hosting discussions that were 'one-sided, uninteresting and rarely funny'. He claimed it was the ABC's 'stubbornness' that was saving the show from being axed for good but that a replacement would be welcomed.

Roseanne Barr reveals who is to blame for her career-ending racist tweet
Roseanne Barr reveals who is to blame for her career-ending racist tweet

Daily Mail​

time15 hours ago

  • Daily Mail​

Roseanne Barr reveals who is to blame for her career-ending racist tweet

Roseanne Barr deflected accountability for her career-ending Tweet in a new interview. In 2018, Barr's, 72, shocking 2am comment about former Barack Obama advisor Valerie Jarrett directly resulted in the cancellation of her 'Roseanne' reboot, with network bosses condemning her Tweet as 'abhorrent' and 'repugnant.' Barr insisted she had no idea about Jarrett's African-American ancestry when suggesting that the political aide looked like the 'Muslim brotherhood and Planet of the Apes had a baby'. Now, Barr reflected on the controversy, sharing in a recent interview with Variety that 'God' told her to write the Tweet. 'The way I feel about it is God told me to do what I did, and it was a nuclear bomb,' the Roseanne alum stated. Barr also called the Tweet a 'perfect caption.' She told the outlet that she was unaware Jarrett, who was involved in Obama 's 2015 Iran nuclear deal, is Black. Roseanne said she was 'having nightmares' about reprising her role on the ABC show until 'God woke [her] up.' 'I had my laptop there in bed, as always, and I opened it, and there was [a post with] a picture of Valerie Jarrett next to Helena Bonham Carter in full makeup as Ari in "Planet of the Apes," and they looked like Xerox copies of each other, so I captioned it.' She also denied that the tweet was racist. '[Other people] were so racist that they thought my tweet said Black people look like monkeys when it was about 'Planet of the Apes,' which is a movie about fascism,' Barr said. '[Screenwriter] Rod Serling himself said it's about the Jews in Germany. It is not a movie about Black people.' The comedian added that 'over 2 million Americans Googled Valerie Jarrett and the Iran deal' afterward. 'That was my intent. So whatever,' she quipped. Barr has previously claimed that she was under the influence of alcohol and Ambien when she posted the controversial tweets, before ultimately leaving the platform. Barr referred to Jarrett as the offspring of the 'muslim brotherhood & planet of the apes' in a tweet from seven years ago Barr quickly apologized for the tweet after it immediately drew backlash. She offered various explanations for the cruel jab at Jarrett, including 'Ambien tweeting', but the damage was done The viral tweet led to the cancellation of her show Roseanne, though it later returned as The Conners, without Barr. Her character was killed off by an opioid overdose. In her latest interview she said the choice to write off her character was 'stupid and shortsighted', adding, 'I felt very pissed off that they stole my rights and killed me.' 'I don't know how they answer to their shareholders for canceling me before even one sponsor pulled out,' she added. Barr also explained that she regrets apologizing for her Tweets. 'I made the mistake of apologizing, and it only got worse after that,' she said. The Conners supplanted Roseanne after Roseanne Barr's May 2018 firing from the show. Sara Gilbert, John Goodman, Laurie Metcalf and Lecy Goranson all continued to appear on the series in their characters. The rebooted show ended with Goodman getting a settlement over his storyline spouse's passing, then visiting her grave with the family. Jarrett in May of 2018 said Disney CEO Bob Iger personally contacted her with an apology over the uncomfortable situation. 'He wanted me to know before he made it public that he was canceling the show,' Jarrett said in an MSNBC townhall called 'Everyday Racism in America' that aired in May of 2018. She added, 'First of all, I think we have to turn it into a teaching moment. I'm fine. I'm worried about all the people out there who don't have a circle of friends and followers coming to their defense.' The original Roseanne show debuted on October 18, 1988, drawing in 21.4 million households to watch the Conners, a working-class American family that resembled many of their own 'The person walking down the street minding their own business and they see someone clinging to their purse or walk across the street... or every Black parent I know who has a boy who has to sit down and have a conversation, the talk as we call it.' Jarrett said that 'those ordinary examples of racism that happen every single day.' Roseanne recently made headlines in declaring that she had been ostracized from President Donald Trump's inner circle despite providing the Commander-in-Chief with decades of loyal support. 'I'm on my own baby, I'm above all that s**t,' she said this past February after Trump shunned her to appoint Jon Voight, Sylvester Stallone and scandal-ridden Mel Gibson in the role of Special Ambassadors to represent Hollywood. She told Variety, 'I'm not a party line person for anyone or anything except myself. The Trump staff or whoever runs it, they're a little afraid of me. I am a loudmouth comedian, so I understand it.'

Moment LA cops shoot reporter on live TV while Brit photographer is hospitalised by rubber bullet during street anarchy
Moment LA cops shoot reporter on live TV while Brit photographer is hospitalised by rubber bullet during street anarchy

Scottish Sun

timea day ago

  • Scottish Sun

Moment LA cops shoot reporter on live TV while Brit photographer is hospitalised by rubber bullet during street anarchy

Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) THIS is the moment a TV journalist was shot live on air as she reported on the violent immigration riots in Los Angeles. Australian reporter Lauren Tomasi was covering the protests for Nine News when she was blasted at close range by a rubber bullet, collapsing in agony mid-broadcast. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 Lauren Tomasi was reporting live from the streets of LA amid the violent protests in the city 2 The Australian reporter was shot with a rubber bullet by riot police live on air Credit: X 'The LAPD are moving in on horseback and firing rubber bullets at protesters,' Tomasi told viewers, as loud bangs echoed across Downtown LA. Suddenly, a police officer swung his weapon towards her, and a cloud of smoke erupted near the correspondent. Caught on camera, Tomasi doubled over in pain, live on air. 'You just f***ing shot a reporter!' a furious protester screamed at police, as others rushed to help the injured Aussie. Despite the shocking moment, Tomasi managed to yell back, 'I'm good, I'm good.' Her network later confirmed she was 'left sore but otherwise unharmed' by the impact — but the image of a journalist being targeted has already sparked outrage. It comes after a British photojournalist was rushed to hospital for emergency surgery when a 'sponge bullet' tore through his thigh during the same night of violence. Nick Stern, 60, from Hertford, said he had made himself clearly visible as a member of the press when he was shot while photographing a standoff between protesters and riot cops. 'I felt this horrific shooting pain impacting my leg. I felt down immediately and felt this large lump … protesters came to help and I was just saying, 'Sit me down, sit me down'… then I blacked out,' he told The Times. More to follow... For the latest news on this story, keep checking back at The U.S. Sun, your go-to destination for the best celebrity news, sports news, real-life stories, jaw-dropping pictures, and must-see videos. Like us on Facebook at TheSunUS and follow us on X at @TheUSSun

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store