Way down yonder in southeast Kansas, demonstrators protest to vent frustration and find solace
Debbie Dye (right) braves the stiff south wind as she protests in front of Memorial Hall in Independence, Kansas. (Ron Osborn photo)
Montgomery County in southeast Kansas is an isolated place.
Two-lane, often shoulderless, highways lead into the main towns: Independence, Coffeyville, Cherryvale and Caney. With an ever-declining population of 31,448, most rural residents have no access to high-speed internet unless they want to spring for Elon Musk's Starlink. TV antennas don't really work. Dish and streaming services offer network TV channels out of Oklahoma and Missouri, further isolating residents from Kansas news.
When Kansas went 57.2 percent for Donald Trump in the 2024 election, Montgomery County residents gave him 74.7 percent of their vote. In the heart of this red bastion, a group of protesters persevere. Who are they, and what do they think they can accomplish?
Carol Sanders, chairwoman of the Montgomery County Democratic Party, plays a major role in organizing the rallies, but the system has a grassroots feel. People just invite people and post Facebook calls to anyone feeling the need to make a statement or find community.
Now 72, Sanders doesn't have a long history of protests. Her activism started in 2017 when Trump was first elected.
When asked her motivation, Sanders paused before she sighing and launching into a list of issues: abortion, immigration, Ukraine, economics, LGBTQ+ rights, and the separation of church and state.
'Really, I guess what it comes down to is a threat to our democracy,' she said. 'What is going on is abhorrent to me.'
Sanders continued: 'I was a Republican for years. I voted. I paid attention, to some degree, to the news. I never in a million years thought I would be organizing political protests.'
A retired system analyst for Phillips Petroleum, educated at Kansas State University, Sanders stood in front of Memorial Hall on April 10 in Independence with approximately 35 others. She held a sign saying 'Democracy Is At Risk!!' Other signs supported medical research, Ukraine, human rights and denounced DOGE (unfortunately spelled Dodge).
Debbie Dye stood with Sanders on the steps facing the traffic on Highway 75. Some cars honked, making the protesters cheer. Dye's reasons for braving the 28 mph wind gusts were personal.
'I have three daughters, and one benefited from Kansas University's Cancer Research,' she said. 'Hearing of research cuts for KU broke my heart.'
She also found community: 'Being here makes me feel I'm not alone.'
Dye, 74, has six grandchildren from her three daughters and one great-grandchild. Retired after 25 years as a paraprofessional for the Tri-County Education Co-op, she still volunteers as a tutor. Her activism started when her daughters were in local public schools and Dye became involved in reducing class size.
'I went to PTA meetings. I spoke at board meetings, and I saw the system worked,' she said.
Two high-school aged boys walked along the sidewalk through the protesters. One respectfully asked Dye why she was there.
She explained: 'My mother had better health care options than my granddaughter. I grew up here and I had such a great life. I want that a for you.'
They thanked her and moved off toward the local Sonic.
Ivory Porter, 42, has attended three of the Montgomery County protests and one Labette County town hall meeting.
'It's important to stand up and fight back,' she said. 'Plus, it lets like-minded people know they are not alone.'
Porter received her Anthropology degree from Kansas State University when she was only 20. She works nearly full-time substitute teaching for area schools.
'I just protest because I know it's the right thing to do,' she said.
Dale Belcher, a male-minority member of the group, said he had been a Republican most of his voting years. Now 68, the retired music teacher was motivated to march for many of the same reasons that found him serving in the Peace Corps in Jamaica for two years after college. He wants a better world.
'I don't like controversy,' he said. 'I've never protested before in my life and I'm basically a conflict avoider.'
So why is he standing with a red, white and blue banner waiting for an approving car honk?
'I've done everything right,' Belcher said. 'I voted. I worked election jobs, and now I'm really frustrated. For me it's about respect. … Respect for all people, the economy, immigrants, science.'
None of the protesters appeared to fit Trump's label of 'Radical Left Lunatics,' and none appeared to be 'fighting hard to bring Murderers, Drug Lords, Dangerous Prisoners, the Mentally Insane and well known MS-13 Gang Members and Wife Beaters back into our country,' as a recent Trump social media post warned us.
Turnout fluctuates depending on weather and what community activities lure the faithful away, but Sanders plans more events. So far there have been four protests in Independence and three in Coffeyville. On May 3, protesters gathered at the junction of US 169 and US 166 in Coffeyville . Sanders will call for the first gathering in her home town of Caney ('the reddest town in Montgomery County,' she said) on May 31.
None of the Montgomery County protesters seemed likely to key a Tesla or 'conduct an illegal boycott' to make their points. Teslas in Montgomery County are elusive anyway. Even the protesters seemed unsure just how their actions were going to effect change. Still, they hope their stance will residents consider the costs incurred by the current administration.
As Dye summed it up: 'I just had to do something.'
Marsha Hayes is a retired rural mail carrier, retired community college English teacher and award-winning equine journalist. Through its opinion section, the Kansas Reflector works to amplify the voices of people who are affected by public policies or excluded from public debate. Find information, including how to submit your own commentary, here.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


CNBC
12 minutes ago
- CNBC
PBS, NPR funding on the line as House nears final vote on $9.4 billion in DOGE-backed cuts
The House on Wednesday moved a step closer to approving President Donald Trump's $9.4 billion spending cut package, which would codify some cuts originally proposed by the Department of Government Efficiency. The package would grant permission to the White House not to spend billions of dollars that had already been approved by Congress. The money would be clawed back from specific agencies like the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) and the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, which distributes federally appropriated grants to National Public Radio (NPR) and Public Broadcasting Service (PBS). Although the Wednesday procedural vote passed largely along party lines, a final vote expected Thursday could see some resistance from House Republicans who are uneasy about the popular programs that are being targeted, like PBS and National Public Radio. Given House Speaker Mike Johnson's narrow Republican majority, he can only afford to lose a handful of votes and still push the package over the finish line on a party-line vote. Johnson said earlier this week that he was "working on" getting enough Republicans on board to pass the DOGE package, CNN reported. Wednesday's vote also finalized changes to Republicans' "big, beautiful bill" that were required by the Senate before the measure was allowed to pass with a simple majority, rather than the typical 60-vote Senate threshold. Budget measures like the "big, beautiful bill" can be considered under a special set of rules known as reconciliation. The Senate's parliamentarian, who acts as a sort of referee in disputes over Senate rules, had flagged some provisions in the package earlier that she said were incompatible with the chamber's reconciliation rules.
Yahoo
13 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Thune on protests: LA ‘needed some outside help'
WASHINGTON, DC (KELO) — Senate Majority Leader John Thune is defending President Trump's decision to federalize the National Guard and send in Marines to put a stop to clashes between demonstrators and law enforcement in Los Angeles. Cheyenne River Reservation authorities investigating 2 deaths The South Dakota Republican fielded reporters' questions on a range of topics Wednesday on Capitol Hill, including the ongoing protests over immigration raids. The City of Los Angeles reported fewer clashes overnight as a curfew went into effect. Yet tensions remain high as members of the military are on standby in case of more violence. Thune says the military presence was needed because local officials in California didn't have a handle on the situation. Thune called public safety a 'political imperative' while discussing the protests taking place this week in Los Angeles. 'Because one of the most fundamental questions most people, or most voters ask is my family safe? Is my neighborhood safe? Is my community safe? And when you can't answer that in the affirmative, then you've got a problem and I think that's what they ran into in Los Angeles which is why they needed some outside help,' Thune said. But House Democrats say Los Angeles didn't need outside help from the military to keep the violence in check. 'And state and local law enforcement officials are prepared to do that. At the same time, we respect the right and should embrace the right for any American to peacefully protest,' (D) House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries said. Thune wouldn't directly answer one reporter's question about President Trump's pardons of January 6th rioters. Manu Raju: 'Do you see any inconsistency when a president criticizes and condemns the violent LA protests but then pardons the violent January 6th protestors?' 'I think the issue that's in front of us right now is the chaos in Los Angeles. And clearly, the local officials there, for whatever reason, didn't seem up to the task,' Thune said. Critics say President Trump's deployment of troops to Los Angeles will only provoke more violence. But Thune and other Republicans on Capitol Hill say it was a move that needed to be made. 'At the end of the day, it's about preventing chaos and preserving law and order,' Thune said. A federal judge will hold a hearing Thursday on California Governor Gavin Newsom's request to stop President Trump from using troops in Los Angeles. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
13 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Republicans press Pentagon chief over Trump's plan to end Russia's war against Ukraine, Politico reports
At a Senate budget hearing on June 11, Republican senators fiercely criticized U.S. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth over the Trump administration's effort to end the Ukraine war through negotiations involving Russia. The session revealed deep divisions within the GOP on U.S. foreign policy, as lawmakers clashed over the administration's strategic direction, Politico reports. Leading the pushback was Sen. Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, one of three Republicans who voted against Hegseth's confirmation, who warned, "America's reputation is on the line." McConnell, now chair of the panel overseeing defense funding, issued some of his strongest public criticism yet, questioning whether the United States would continue defending democratic allies against authoritarian threats. He contrasted his stance — rooted in a Reagan-era commitment to global leadership — with Hegseth's "America First" approach favored by many Trump supporters. "We don't want a headline at the end of this conflict that says Russia wins and America loses," McConnell said. When asked who the aggressor in the three-year-old war is, Hegseth responded, "Russia is the aggressor." But he avoided directly stating which side the U.S. wants to see win, instead emphasizing that President Trump is committed to achieving peace. Hegseth shifted blame to the Biden and Obama administrations, arguing that slow responses during their terms allowed Putin to seize Crimea and invade Ukraine. "Vladimir Putin knows that President Trump is strong," he said, suggesting a negotiated peace would bolster America's global position. Sen. Lindsey Graham, a prominent Trump ally, questioned whether Putin would stop his territorial ambitions if he gained ground in Ukraine. Joint Chiefs Chair Gen. Dan Caine said he did not believe Putin would stop. Hegseth, however, responded, "It remains to be seen." Graham rebuked that answer, saying, "This is the '30s all over. It doesn't remain to be seen." Democrats also raised concerns. Sen. Chris Coons of Delaware criticized the administration for omitting Ukraine aid in its 2026 budget request and warned against compromising too much for the sake of peace. 'We cannot abandon Ukraine,' he said. Hegseth defended the administration's strategy, calling a negotiated settlement a show of strength. "The alternative of endless war that is largely funded by the United States and fought by Ukrainians… does not make sense strategically," he said. Read also: America's weak strongman We've been working hard to bring you independent, locally-sourced news from Ukraine. Consider supporting the Kyiv Independent.