Bill Cotterell: Leave Florida's lieutenant governor post alone
There's probably no rule of government cited more often — and ignored so often — than that old line about, 'If it ain't broke, don't fix it.'
Grammar aside, that's a good epigram. Florida lawmakers should heed that advice in deciding whether to try to eliminate the office of lieutenant governor, the subject of a proposed constitutional amendment up for debate in the current lawmaking session. Basically, there's nothing wrong with the office, it just doesn't have enough to do.
So instead of replacing the governor's currently missing understudy with a Cabinet-level Commissioner of Government Efficiency, as HJR 1325 and SJR 1756 propose, legislators ought to give the office some official duties.
Through no fault of the men and women who have held the post, being made fun of comes with the job.
When a budget crisis 30 years ago forced the governor to compose a list of 'non-essential state employees' to be furloughed, some legislators made lapel buttons labeled 'Non-essential Employee of the Year,' with Lt. Gov. Buddy MacKay's picture in the middle.
Lt. Gov. Wayne Mixson used to joke about carrying a little mirror that he said he'd hold under Gov. Bob Graham's nose every morning and, if it fogged, he'd have the day off. MacKay once remarked that if he closed one eye and tilted his head just right, the title on his door said 'Governor.'
Tallahassee once had a restaurant called The Lieutenant Governor's Club, but it didn't last long. It was nice, but the name was just a little dig at the posh Governors Club — a private enclave a block from the Capitol that's so high-class its 'shirts and shoes required' sign is in French.
We got by without a lieutenant governor for about 80 years. When Gov. Dan McCarty died in 1953, Senate President Charley Johns became acting governor for two years, until Gov. LeRoy Collins defeated him.
The office was created by a 1968 constitutional revision, and Gov. Claude Kirk chose a state representative, Ray Osborne, hoping to shore up GOP support for his re-election campaign in the Tampa Bay area, which was troublesome for Kirk at the time.
It didn't help. The Kirk-Osborne ticket survived the 1970 primaries but was soundly defeated by Democrat Reubin Askew and his running mate, Secretary of State Tom Adams, who also provided political ballast that the little-known Askew sorely needed.
The constitution doesn't provide any official duty for the second spot, except to succeed the governor when necessary. That's happened twice — for three days when Graham left to be sworn in as a U.S. senator in 1987 and for 23 days when Gov. Lawton Chiles died in 1998, and MacKay took over.
A running mate's primary job is to help the governor get elected. Some governors appointed their partners to head the old Department of Commerce, and, of course, many lieutenant governors have started working on campaigns for governor — although none has ever made it. There's plenty of other work for them, though.
Lt. Gov. Jeff Kottkamp chaired the board of Space Florida, oversaw the Office of Drug Control and Office of Adoption and Child Protection during the four years he served with Gov. Charlie Crist. Frank Brogan and Toni Jennings, serving with Gov. Jeb Bush, also chaired Space Florida.
Lt. Gov. Bobby Brantley headed the panel that set up the Florida Lottery under Gov. Bob Martinez. Lt. Gov. Jennifer Carroll, who was Gov. Rick Scott's 2010 running mate, said she was able to bring a focus on smaller, rural counties behind the scenes.
Kottkamp noted that linking the two top jobs assures continuity in the executive branch.
'If something happens to the governor, the person that succeeds him or her should be someone from the same political party that will carry out their agenda — the party and agenda the people of Florida voted for,' Kottkamp said. 'If you get rid of the lieutenant governor and make a Cabinet position like attorney general the next in line, you open up the very real possibility of someone from a different party becoming governor. This could be enormously disruptive, and contrary to the will of the people that voted for the governor.'
Five states — Arizona, Maine, New Hampshire, Oregon and Wyoming — don't have lieutenant governors. Some, like neighboring Georgia, have the governor and lieutenant governor run separately. In Florida, governors run alone in the primaries, then pick running mates (and potential lieutenant governors) once they're nominated
Florida has other efficiency officers, auditors and inspectors general. There's no need for a Cabinet-level DOGE czar. Lieutenant governors aren't glamorous, but we don't need them 'til we need them.
Bill Cotterell is a retired Capitol reporter for United Press International and the Tallahassee Democrat. He can be reached at wrcott43@aol.com.
JOIN THE CONVERSATION
Send letters to the editor (up to 200 words) or Your Turn columns (about 500 words) to letters@tallahassee.com. Please include your address for verification purposes only, and if you send a Your Turn, also include a photo and 1-2 line bio of yourself. You can also submit anonymous Zing!s at Tallahassee.com/Zing. Submissions are published on a space-available basis. All submissions may be edited for content, clarity and length, and may also be published by any part of the USA TODAY NETWORK.
This article originally appeared on Tallahassee Democrat: Bill Cotterell: Leave Florida's lieutenant governor post alone
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
9 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Reports: Virginia Democrats outdoing Republicans in raising campaign contributions
Democratic House of Delegates hopeful Kimberly Pope Adams raised the second-highest amount in Virginia of contributions to House campaigns for the latest campaign reporting period, according to the nonpartisan Virginia Public Access Project. Pope Adams, who has already locked up the Democratic nomination in the 82nd House District, reported a total of $262,048 in money raised for the April 1-June 5 window, based on data from the Virginia Department of Elections that was compiled by VPAP. That trailed only House Speaker Don Scott of Portsmouth, who raised just over $344,000 for the period. Political watchers were keeping a close eye on this round of reports, the last before the crucial June 17 party primaries across Virginia. Like Pope Adams, Scott already has the Democratic nod sewn up. He also does not appear to have any GOP opposition this year. The only House primary next week in the Tri-City area is in District 75 where three Democrats are vying to oppose Republican incumbent Carrie Coyner. In that contest, Lindsey Dougherty continues to outdistance Dustin Wade and Stephen Miller-Pitts. For the reporting period, Dougherty raised $171,695, compared to $136,276 for Wade and $4,471 for Miller-Pitts. As of June 5, Wade showed more than $100,000 in cash on hand over Dougherty and five times more than Miller-Pitts. VPAP reported Dougherty raising the sixth-highest amount of contributions for the period, and Wade the 12th. Dougherty and Miller-Pitts ran against Coyner in the 2019 and 2023 elections, respectively. The 75th District covers all of Hopewell and portions of Chesterfield and Prince George counties. More: The primary menu for June 17: Heavy on the state races and a first time for Petersburg In the 82nd District [Petersburg, Surry County, portions of Dinwiddie and Prince George], Pope Adams continues to run away from GOP incumbent Kim Taylor in campaign contributions. For the latest reporting period, Pope Adams' total was more than four times that of Taylor, who listed receiving $64,489 in donations. Her cash-on-hand amount of $289,468 was eight times more than Taylor's $34,502. The race is a rerun of 2023's race, one of the top three most expensive contests in recent Virginia political history. Taylor squeaked out a victory over Pope Adams by only 53 votes following a recount, and Democrats are clocking the 2025 race as pivotal in holding their slim majority in the House for the next two years. Pope Adams' contributions included $25,000 from the Clean Virginia Fund on April 23, $7,500 from the Jane Fonda Climate PAC on May 14, and three $5,000 donations from Elizabeth Simons on May 29, The Next 50 PAC on April 30 and Fund Her PAC on April 29. Taylor's largest contributions for the period were $20,000 from the Dominion Energy PAC on May 8, $10,000 from the Wren Williams for Delegate campaign on April 24, and identical $7,500 amounts from Friends of Scott Wyatt on April 2 and Chris Runion for Delegate on June 5. The reports indicate Taylor getting three donations of $100 or less, and Pope Adams receiving 1,461. More: House GOP incumbent lauds endorsement from local Democratic group. Democrats cry 'foul' In the 75th District primary, Dougherty received two contributions totaling $80,000 from the super PAC Secure Progress and $35,000 from the campaign of Democratic Del. Dan Helmer. Wade's top donations were $5,000 from himself and two donations from Anita Thurston totaling $4,500. Miller-Pitts' sole contribution of over $100 for the period was $250 from Rhonda Clanton-Davis. Coyner, a Republican seeking her fourth term in the House, received $69,056 in contributions over the period. Her largest donations were $10,000 from Carolyn Williams, $7,500 from Strong Start PAC, and three of $5,000 each from Thomas McInerney, Vision Management Services, and Clean Virginia Fund. Records indicate her having $315,350 in cash on hand as of June 5. The district traditionally leans Republican. Coyner has won re-election with as much as 55% of the vote, but Democrats still target her as vulnerable. In Petersburg, history is being made with the first-ever Democratic primary for the constitutional officer Commissioner of the Revenue. Incumbent Brittani Flowers is being challenged by Mary 'Liz Stith' Howard for the right to be the Democrat on the November ballot. Five years ago, the Virginia General Assembly voted to allow any local-office candidate [except School Board] to seek official party backing. The law went into effect last year, as Petersburg Vice Mayor Darrin Hill received the Democratic nomination for his Ward 2 seat by acclimation. The commissioner primary is the first contested one in Petersburg. Campaign records show Flowers receiving just shy of $3,000 in contributions for the reporting period. Her largest donations were $500 from former state Senate candidate Waylin Ross and $300 from Bernard Flowers Jr. Howard did not record any contributions for the reporting period. Petersburg City Councilor Marlow Jones, who is running as an independent for Virginia's lieutenant governor, raised $700 in donations during the latest reporting period. Five hundred dollars came from three contributions of more than $100. The remaining $200 was split among five contributions of less than $100. To see the latest donation data for any race this year, click on the VPAP website. Bill Atkinson (he/him/his) is an award-winning journalist who covers breaking news, government and politics. Reach him at batkinson@ or on X (formerly known as Twitter) at @BAtkinson_PI. This article originally appeared on The Progress-Index: Virginia primary 2025: Campaign finance reports show money pouring in
Yahoo
23 minutes ago
- Yahoo
GOP Sen. Josh Hawley introduces bill to raise federal minimum wage to $15 per hour
WASHINGTON — Sen. Josh Hawley, R-Mo., introduced a bill with Sen. Peter Welch, D-Vt., on Tuesday to raise the federal minimum wage to $15 per hour, making him a rare congressional Republican to endorse the historically liberal cause. The Higher Wages for American Workers Act would set the nationwide minimum wage to $15 on Jan. 1 of the first year after it is enacted, and raise it annually on the basis of inflation. 'This is a populist position,' Hawley told NBC News in the Capitol on Tuesday. 'If we're going to be a working people's party, we have to do something for working people. And working people haven't gotten a raise in years. So they need a raise.' The federal minimum wage is currently $7.25, and hasn't been raised since 2009. Democratic presidents and lawmakers have since attempted to lift it, but each time failed to clear the 60-vote threshold to break a filibuster in the Senate. 'We're in the midst of a severe affordability crisis, with families in red and blue states alike struggling to afford necessities like housing and groceries. A stagnant federal minimum wage only adds fuel to the fire. Every hardworking American deserves a living wage that helps put a roof over their head and food on the table–$7.25 an hour doesn't even come close,' Welch said in a statement. 'Times have changed, and working families deserve a wage that reflects today's financial reality.' Hawley said the current level is 'really, really, really, really low.' 'The truth is — people can't afford to have a family. Families can't support themselves. I mean, if you're pro family, as I am, if you are a populist, if you're pro-worker, you've got to do something for working people,' he said, while noting that various states, including Missouri, have since stepped in to lift it. It represents the latest attempt by Hawley to stake out economic populist ground that has long been associated with liberals. Other recent moves include teaming up with Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., on a bill to cap credit card interest rates at 10%, and voting with Democrats this year on a budget amendment to prohibit tax cuts for the wealthy if Medicaid funding is cut. Still, Hawley admitted he's an outlier in his party, and it's far from clear the wage legislation will reach the Senate floor, let alone find the 60 votes needed to advance in the chamber, where the GOP controls 53 seats. 'I'd love to get a vote on it. I think it's hard to vote against,' he said. 'I say that, but probably most of my Republican colleagues vote against it happily.' Sen. Ron Johnson, R-Wis., said he opposes Hawley's measure, expressing the longstanding GOP stance that minimum wage hikes distort markets and make it harder for employers to hire. 'I wouldn't support it,' Johnson said. 'Because the real minimum wage is $0 when you don't have a job. The minimum wage impacts just a small sliver of people — most people that want entry-level jobs. And so you raise the cost of an entry-level job and you don't have them.' Hawley has another obstacle: President Donald Trump, who has not endorsed any increase in the federal minimum wage. Trump dodged questions about the issue during his 2024 campaign. 'I think he understands the needs of working people really well,' Hawley said. 'I would hope he would support this.' This article was originally published on
Yahoo
23 minutes ago
- Yahoo
St. George school system amendment bill headed to Louisiana Senate
BATON ROUGE, La. (Louisiana First) — A school district is one step closer to becoming a reality in St. George after the Louisiana House of Representatives approved a bill on Monday, June 9. The bill now heads to the Louisiana Senate, where if approved, the public will then have a say during the statewide election on April 18, 2026. SB 25 and SB 234 were both authored by Sen. Rick Edmonds and co-authored by State Representative Emily Chenevert. They aim to create a community school system in St. George, as well as provide details on how it would work. Former Baton Rouge mayor criticizes current administration in social media video Lafayette Regional Airport lockdown lifted, no explosives found House GOP effort to lock in DOGE cuts faces Republican resistance St. George school system amendment bill headed to Louisiana Senate Federal minimum wage would rise to $15 under Sen. Hawley bill California Republican pushes back against Trump immigration enforcement Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
