Hong Kong appeal court rejects early release for first security law challenger
The first person to mount a legal challenge against Hong Kong's
domestic national security law has lost an appeal to overturn a decision barring his early release from prison.
Advertisement
The Court of Appeal ruled in a judgment delivered on Tuesday that the Correctional Services Department was not obliged to consider granting an early discharge to Adam Ma Chun-man after he was 'lawfully' sentenced to a term of imprisonment for inciting secession.
The three presiding judges stressed that any sentencing reduction was discretionary and that denying a prisoner's early release would not violate his right to liberty.
The court also rejected the appellant's contention that the definition of national security was 'inherently vague' and prone to 'subjective value judgment', saying a broad definition offered 'flexibility' to allow the notion to 'evolve with time and adapt to changing realities'.
'It is broadly framed for good reasons,' Chief Judge of the High Court Jeremy Poon Shiu-chor, the judgment's author, wrote.
Advertisement
'Although it is broadly framed, the definition has a sufficiently and clearly formulated core to enable a person, with advice if necessary, to understand what national security covers and to regulate his conduct accordingly.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
41 minutes ago
- South China Morning Post
Beijing accuses Taiwan's William Lai of inciting cross-strait confrontation in speech
Beijing has lashed out at Taiwan's leader for calling the island a country during a speech that the mainland said contained 'fabricated fallacies'. In a commentary on Tuesday, People's Daily, a mouthpiece of mainland China's ruling Communist Party, said William Lai Ching-te 's speech to a Taiwanese branch of Rotary International on Sunday was 'full of various factual errors and historical fallacies' and was highly provocative and harmful. 'It was a 'Taiwan independence' declaration that blatantly incited cross-strait confrontation, and a hodgepodge of 'Taiwan independence' fallacies and heresies full of errors and omissions,' it said. 'It once again showed Lai Ching-te's ignorance and madness, and once again exposed his stubborn 'Taiwan independence' nature and ugly face, confirming that he is a troublemaker, danger-maker and war-maker. 'No matter how much a fallacy is polished, it is still a fallacy; no matter how much a lie is beautified, it is still a lie.' 05:05 Trump and Xi discuss Taiwan, troubled US-China trade ties in call breaking stand-off Trump and Xi discuss Taiwan, troubled US-China trade ties in call breaking stand-off During his speech on Sunday – the first of 10 in a series called 'Uniting the country' – Lai said Taiwan was 'of course' a country.
RTHK
2 hours ago
- RTHK
Xi urges Singapore PM to join fight against hegemony
Xi urges Singapore PM to join fight against hegemony President Xi Jinping hosts Singapore Prime Minister Lawrence Wong at the Great Hall of the People. Photo: China Daily/Reuters President Xi Jinping called on Singapore's prime minister to join the fight against "hegemony" and protectionism in trade as they met in Beijing on Tuesday. Prime Minister Lawrence Wong's first official visit to China lasts until Thursday. He met Xi on Tuesday morning at Beijing's Great Hall of the People, with the president urging their two countries to work to "stand on the right side of history and on the side of fairness and justice", according to CCTV. Xi told Wong that "the world cannot return to hegemony or be dragged back to the law of the jungle", a veiled swipe at the United States, after President Donald Trump launched a barrage of tariffs this year on countries including China and Singapore. Wong, in turn, told Xi he believed the Singapore-China relationship was "more important than before" in a time of "global turbulence and uncertainty". "We can work together to establish closer ties and... continue to strengthen multilateralism and the rules-based global order for the benefit of all countries," Wong said. Xi also noted that this year marks the 35th anniversary of diplomatic relations between the two countries. He said the two sides have consistently upheld mutual understanding and respect, which has provided a solid foundation for the stable and healthy development of bilateral relations. Cooperation between the two countries has aligned with China's development priorities at various stages, yielding substantial outcomes such as the Suzhou Industrial Park, significantly contributing to each country's modernisation efforts, and also setting a benchmark for cooperation among regional nations, Xi added. Wong, who succeeded Lee Hsien Loong, the son of founding premier Lee Kuan Yew, in 2024, has warned the trade-dependent city-state could be hit hard by Trump's tariffs. Although Trump imposed a baseline 10 percent tariff on Singapore, the country is vulnerable to a global economic slowdown caused by the much higher levies on dozens of other countries because of its heavy reliance on international trade. Following his meetings in Beijing, Wong will head to the northern Tianjin for a meeting of the World Economic Forum. (AFP/Xinhua)
South China Morning Post
2 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Thailand moves to recriminalise cannabis, except for medical use
The Thai government is moving to re-criminalise cannabis – except for medical use – after a pro-weed party quit the coalition, with political turmoil becoming the latest threat to the massive and largely unregulated industry. A new health ministry notification requiring medical prescriptions for cannabis was signed earlier this week and should become effective imminently, Public Health Minister Somsak Thepsutin said on Tuesday. A failure to formulate cannabis regulations following its 2022 decriminalisation has led to the mushrooming of more than 10,000 dispensaries and widespread recreational use, he said. 'It's a festering problem and we have received so many complaints,' Somsak told reporters before a cabinet meeting. 'Today it is classified as a strictly regulated herb for medical uses, but in the future it will be a narcotic.' Re-criminalisation will be a significant move for Thailand , which was the first country in Asia to decriminalise cannabis. With no cannabis law in place, dispensaries have opened nationwide, flourishing in popular tourist areas and even in Bangkok's business districts. There has also been a surge in cannabis smuggling across borders. A vendor tests cannabis aroma for sale at a cannabis shop in Bangkok. Photo: EPA-EFE The threat to put cannabis back on the list of illegal narcotics is nothing new. The issue had long been a flash point between the ruling Pheu Thai Party of Prime Minister Paetongtarn Shinawatra and its then-ally Bhumjathai Party, which spearheaded the decriminalisation policy.
