
Problems with MCP still linger, a decade after flagging them, says auditor general
Newfoundland and Labrador's auditor general says problems with the province's public medical care plan (MCP) linger on more than a decade after they were first highlighted by her office.
Auditor General Denise Hanrahan's most recent report — which looked at the period between April 2021 to March 31, 2024 — examined if MCP and provincial dental health plan funds were disbursed appropriately.
"Unfortunately, our findings indicate areas of serious concern with the fulfilment of that mandate. What's worse, many of the findings today are the same as our 2014 audit," Hanrahan told reporters on Wednesday.
One of the problems raised to the Department of Health and Community Services included double payments with WorkplaceNL, as well as lingering IT system control problems.
In her report, Hanrahan found a three-year period where physicians and dentists owed the province $2.2 million, and found very little action had been taken to recover it and no recoveries made in 2023.
"I'm not sure that receivable [amount] is an accurate indication of what is owed to the province for the amount of transactions that go through that system," said Hanrahan.
The unpaid money could be due to error or fraud, she said, and the amount is likely higher than what the audit found.
Hanrahan said the frustrating point is that there are tools available that could improve the collection process that are going unused.
"With low productivity and insignificant recoveries, I question the effectiveness of the department's internal audit function as an oversight measure for the MCP program," she said.
Checking in
Hanrahan said she didn't know why the department failed to act on recommendations made a decade ago.
She has made six recommendations in her new report, which touched on addressing an aging technological system, coordinating with WorkplaceNL to prevent double billing, improving money collections and adopting management approvals for adult dental reimbursements.
She also wants the department to ensure its internal audit process is being properly carried out in accordance with legislation, regulations and policy.
As noted in the report, the provincial government has accepted all of Hanrahan's recommendations.
This time around, she signaled she was confident the government would act on those recommendations, saying her office got a good response from the health department and has spoken with the health minister.
"It will cost no money to implement those recommendations. These are about processes, existing staffing, existing systems," she said.
"And my intention in two years is to come back to see where they sit. And in three years I expect 100 per cent implementation."
In a statement Progressive Conservative health critic Barry Petten said it was "unacceptable" that the governing Liberals didn't act on solving the issues over the last 10 years and didn't collect the $2.2 million it was owed.
"We need an updated MCP system, with the proper controls and audits, so that health-care providers can truly focus on providing better health care for all of us," said Petten.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Global News
41 minutes ago
- Global News
Liberals won't split internal trade, major projects bill despite Bloc call
The Liberal government is rejecting a call from the Bloc Québécois to split its marquee legislation in two and allow part of it to speed through the House of Commons this summer. The bill — known as Bill C-5, or the free trade and labour mobility in Canada act —was introduced last Friday. It has two parts. The first portion addresses internal trade barriers the Liberals have promised to tackle by July 1. The second part proposes to make sweeping changes to speed up approvals of major projects. The Bloc argued the internal trade portion of the legislation could be passed relatively quickly with broad support from the House of Commons, but called for a separate study of the changes to major project reviews. 'The bill as it is now would be sent to the transport committee, whereas if it were to be split it could be sent to two different committees, the second one being environment,' Bloc deputy leader Christie Normandin said at a press conference on Monday. Story continues below advertisement Government House leader Steven MacKinnon said Wednesday the Liberals won't split the legislation, even if that would ensure the government meets its self-imposed deadline to tackle interprovincial trade barriers. 'This is a bill that responds to economic conditions caused by the tariff war, among other things, and mobilizes premiers, mobilizes Canadians from coast to coast to coast behind projects of national significance,' MacKinnon said on his way into a Liberal caucus meeting. 1:46 Can the Liberal government's trade bill unify Canada's economy? The legislation would give the federal government sweeping new powers to push forward projects that have been deemed to be in the national interest. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy It sets out five criteria to determine if a project is the national interest, including its likelihood of success, whether it would strengthen the country's resiliency and advance the interests of Indigenous peoples, and whether it would contribute to economic growth in an environmentally responsible way. Story continues below advertisement The government intends to create a list of such projects and then fast-track the approval system with a goal of issuing approvals within two years, instead of the current five-year timeline. The bill would create a new federal office to take the lead on streamlining approvals and task the intergovernmental affairs minister with overseeing the final permitting decision. It's meant to send a signal to build investor confidence, the government said. The proposed legislation has been criticized already by groups like Greenpeace Canada, and some have warned that there are risks in trying to shortcut environmental interests. 4:58 Carney looking to pass legislation 'before summer' to remove trade barriers in Canada The minority Liberal government needs the support of at least four MPs from another party to pass the bill. It does not have a formal or informal agreement with any opposition party to pass legislation, as was the case with the NDP in the last Parliament. Story continues below advertisement Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre has said his party will support legislation that gets new projects built — but he also said he wants the current bill amended to go even further. On Friday, Poilievre said he wanted to meet with his caucus before saying whether Conservative MPs will vote in favour of the legislation. After Wednesday's caucus meeting, his office said there was no update to provide. Prime Minister Mark Carney suggested last week he would consider extending the House sitting into July to get the legislation passed. The House of Commons is scheduled to take a summer break beginning June 21. MacKinnon said Wednesday that he has not tried to get consensus from the other parties to extend the sitting.


Vancouver Sun
2 hours ago
- Vancouver Sun
BC Ferries deal with Chinese shipyard makes waves in Ottawa
OTTAWA — BC Ferries set off a tidal wave of controversy on Tuesday after announcing a major shipbuilding deal with a Chinese state-owned enterprise, with the ripple effects of the decision reaching Ottawa. Vancouver Island Conservative MP Jeff Kibble raised the issue in Wednesday's question period, accusing the Liberal government of rewarding the provincial carrier for selling out Canada's national interest. 'The Liberals are set to hand over $30 million (in federal subsidies) to BC Ferries while BC Ferries hands over critical jobs, investment and industry to China,' said Kibble. Start your day with a roundup of B.C.-focused news and opinion. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder. The next issue of Sunrise will soon be in your inbox. Please try again Interested in more newsletters? Browse here. BC Ferries said in a press release that it had awarded China Merchants Industry Weihai Shipyards (CMI Weihai) a contract to build four new vessels after a 'rigorous' global bidding process. Company CEO Nicolas Jimenez was quoted in the release as saying that CMI Weihai was the 'clear choice' for the contract given, among other factors, its 'proven ability to deliver safe, reliable vessels on dependable timelines.' Kibble blasted BC Ferries in the House of Commons for buying the ships from China instead of a 'proven Canadian shipbuilder' and pressed the Liberal government to tie federal ferry subsidies to buying Canadian-built ships. Liberal Transportation Minister Chrystia Freeland said that she shared Kibble's concerns about procurement 'at all levels of government' but wouldn't comment directly on the BC Ferries contract, calling it a provincial matter. One politician who hasn't hesitated to criticize the deal is the provincial minister responsible for BC Ferries. B.C. Transportation Minister Mike Farnworth was quick to distance himself from the decision, saying he was worried about the message it sends in the midst of Chinese economic aggression. 'I do have concerns around procuring services from any country that is actively harming Canada's economy through unfair tariffs or other protectionist trade practices. I have shared these concerns with BC Ferries,' Farnworth told the media. Yet, despite his reservations, he ruled out blocking the BC Ferries-CMI Weihai deal. 'BC Ferries is an independent company responsible for its own operational decisions,' said Farnworth. He added that he was 'disappointed' that the contract didn't include more involvement from Canadian shipyards. BC Ferries' head of fleet renewal, Ed Hooper, told Postmedia that no Canadian shipbuilders bid on the contract won by CMI Weihai. Liberal Prime Minister Mark Carney promised to ramp up Canadian shipbuilding during this spring's federal election campaign. The federal government previously awarded the Chinese state-owned company a contract to build a new vessel for east coast ferry operator Marine Atlantic, according to a 2023 filing from Transport Canada. The ship began service between Nova Scotia and Newfoundland in July 2024. Federal Procurement Minister Joël Lightbound didn't respond to an inquiry from the National Post about the BC Ferries-CMI Weihai deal, and didn't indicate whether the federal government would continue to take bids from the company. A spokesperson with Public Services and Procurement Canada told the National Post that CMI Weihai does not appear on the agency's database of active bids. National Post rmohamed@ Get more deep-dive National Post political coverage and analysis in your inbox with the Political Hack newsletter, where Ottawa bureau chief Stuart Thomson and political analyst Tasha Kheiriddin get at what's really going on behind the scenes on Parliament Hill every Wednesday and Friday, exclusively for subscribers. Sign up here . Our website is the place for the latest breaking news, exclusive scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark and sign up for our daily newsletter, Posted, here .


Calgary Herald
3 hours ago
- Calgary Herald
AHS lawsuit: Mentzelopoulos seeks expedited ruling on the legality of her firing
The former head of Alberta Health Services (AHS) is seeking to expedite her wrongful dismissal lawsuit by asking a judge to focus on the legality of how she was fired, a move that would keep the case from going to trial if granted. Article content Athana Mentzelopoulos is suing AHS and the provincial government for wrongful dismissal and seeking $1.7 million in damages. Article content Article content On Monday, lawyers for Mentzelopoulos filed an application for summary judgment in Court of King's Bench in Edmonton, alleging that Health Minister Adriana LaGrange orchestrated her Jan. 8 firing by then-deputy minister of health and AHS board member Andre Tremblay, but that both lacked the authority to do so. Article content Article content 'Only the AHS Board or the executive chair (or) chair had the authority to terminate her employment,' the application states, citing Mentzelopoulos' employment agreement with AHS. Article content Article content 'Her employment was improperly terminated by Mr. Tremblay acting without AHS authority and solely on the order of Minister LaGrange.' Article content The application seeks to narrow the focus of the legal proceedings to if the employment agreement was properly followed when Mentzelopoulos was fired, and is next scheduled to be before a judge on July 15. In the court documents, Mentzelopoulos newly alleges she was not invited to a Jan. 7 AHS board meeting organized by LaGrange, and that her exclusion led her to believe the meeting was called to have the board terminate her employment. Article content Mentzelopoulos claims she learned that LaGrange was unable to convince enough board members at that meeting to fire her, and that the minister told the board she would, 'have Andre do it.' Article content Article content 'Having failed in her attempt to cause AHS to terminate Mentzelopoulos, Minister LaGrange took it upon herself to do so, making the unilateral decision to require Mr. Tremblay to purport to terminate Mentzelopoulos, even though both he and she knew that he had no authority to do so,' the application reads. Article content It states at least three board members, including former Progressive Conservative cabinet minister Lyle Oberg, would support Mentzelopoulos's claims. Article content All board members were dismissed on Jan. 31, and Tremblay was announced as the official administrator of AHS. The organization has since seen its scope reduced as part of the government's restructuring of the health care system.