Swinney begs rebels not to oust him
The SNP leader has pleaded with party rebels not to press ahead with a threatened leadership challenge after a shock by-election defeat.
John Swinney, the First Minister, warned it would not be a 'good idea' for disaffected Nationalists to try and oust him at the SNP conference in October.
Mr Swinney said he had helped the SNP 'recover from a very, very difficult situation' following the troubled final months of Nicola Sturgeon 's premiership and Humza Yousaf 's chaotic tenure.
His plea came the day after it was reported that 25 senior SNP figures met on Monday evening to discuss removing Mr Swinney, barely a year after he succeeded Mr Yousaf.
They warned that he risked facing a leadership challenge at the SNP conference in Aberdeen unless he comes up with a new strategy to achieve Scottish independence.
Discontent with his leadership has surfaced after Labour pulled off a surprise victory in last week's Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election, which the SNP had been hot favourites to win.
The defeat followed Labour's rout of the SNP in last year's general election, also under Mr Swinney's leadership.
Alex Neil, a former Cabinet minister in Alex Salmond's and Ms Sturgeon's governments, said that Mr Swinney should be replaced.
Mr Swinney is expected to face robust questions at a meeting of the party's ruling national executive committee on Sunday about his by-election campaign strategy, which focused on the claim that it was a straight fight between the SNP and Reform UK.
The Guardian reported that he faced criticism about the strategy at a 'fractious' MSP group meeting on Tuesday, with one backbencher claiming he had 'panicked' at the rise of Reform, which finished a close third in the contest.
Insiders also expect him to face pressure to come up with much clearer strategy for achieving independence, after he warned that support for separation would have to rise to more than 60 per cent to get another referendum.
Under SNP rules, any member who can secure 100 nominations from 20 different branches ahead of party conference can trigger a leadership vote.
Mr Swinney admitted that he had 'absolutely no idea' about whether he would face a challenge but said: 'I don't think that would be a good idea.'
Speaking after First Minister's Questions at Holyrood, he said: 'I came into office to help the SNP recover from a very, very difficult situation in the spring of 2024, and I'm very focused on making sure that we make that recovery to be ready for the 2026 elections, and that's what's the focus of my thinking and my planning.
'I've obviously taken forward a number of steps over the course of the last 12 months to get the SNP into a better position.'
He insisted that the SNP would not have even been in contention in the by-election before he took over, despite the party winning the seat in the 2021 Holyrood contest by 4,582 votes.
Labour won the contest last week by 602 votes, after the SNP vote in the seat dropped by 17 points compared to 2021.
Swinney worried 'not in the slightest'
However, Mr Swinney said he was 'not in the slightest' worried about the internal briefing against him, and rejected criticism that he was not moving fast enough on independence.
He said he had spent the first year of his leadership 'addressing the issues that people are immediately preoccupied by', such as the cost of living crisis.
Mr Swinney said this was necessary to ensure 'we could get a hearing' from the public, but his 'phase two' plan was to 'open up a conversation about independence' ahead of next year's election.
But Anas Sarwar, the Scottish Labour leader, said: 'Even John Swinney's MSPs are now openly rebelling against him with senior figures saying he has two weeks to come up with a new idea to save his job. John Swinney and the SNP are out of ideas, out of steam and out of time.'
He told First Minister's Questions: 'One SNP MSP said about John Swinney, 'there is no energy, no fire, no boldness, no long-term vision' – they are right.'
It is not thought that an MP or MSP will directly challenge Mr Swinney for the leadership ahead of the May 2026 election, but the rebels said a rank-and-file activist could come forward as a stalking horse.
They warned that any contest would be 'hugely damning and damaging, and make the party look utterly ridiculous'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
33 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
Chaos in UK town see rioters hurl petrol bombs at police amid 'week of shame'
Petrol bombs were thrown at police for a fifth consecutive night in Northern Ireland, in what has been dubbed a "week of shame" for the region. After serious public disorder erupted in Ballymena on Monday, the focus of the violence and unrest has since shifted to Portadown. One officer was directly in the impact of a petrol bomb that landed behind a line of police vehicles during a sustained standoff with those participating in the unrest on Friday. Fireworks, masonry, and bottles were among other items thrown at riot police deployed in the town. Shortly before midnight, the PSNI used a water cannon on the crowd in an effort to disperse those gathered on West Street into other areas. The force used the water cannon again at around 12.30am on Saturday. Elsewhere on Friday, there were reports of disruption and damage to public property as riot police responded to another protest in the Tullyally area of Londonderry. It came after a senior officer said there would be a "scaled-up" policing presence across Northern Ireland in anticipation of further disorder over the weekend. Assistant Chief Constable Ryan Henderson said the mobilisation, which would include officers sent over from Scotland, was "to reassure our communities and protect our streets". Disorder started in Ballymena on Monday after an alleged sexual assault of a girl in the County Antrim town at the weekend, and continued throughout the week. The unrest and riotous behaviour spread to other towns and cities including Larne, Belfast and Coleraine. A number of homes were targeted, and the Northern Ireland Housing Executive has said about 50 households have received assistance across the week, and 14 families have been provided with emergency accommodation. A police representative group said at least 63 police officers have been injured in the five days of disorder, which led political leaders to call for calm during a meeting of the British Irish Council in Newcastle, County Down, on Friday. First Minister Michelle O'Neill said everyone is condemning the disorder and calling for it to stop. She said: "What we have seen over the last four days has been devastation, has been horrific for those people targeted - this is women and children, these are families, at the brunt of racist, violent attacks, and it is wrong on every level. The whole of the Executive is united on that front." Deputy First Minister Emma Little-Pengelly described a "difficult time for Northern Ireland" with "disgraceful scenes of violent disorder", and said her thoughts are with the residents of the areas affected. Additional police officers from Scotland supported the PSNI after a mutual aid request. Scottish First Minister John Swinney said it was an illustration of how cooperation between police forces is "absolutely essential". While disorder in Ballymena raged across Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday night, it appeared to have largely abated in that town by Thursday. However, disorder instead flared in Portadown - although generally at a lower intensity compared to scenes seen earlier in the week. There have also been incidents in other towns, including the burning of Larne Leisure Centre on Wednesday and an arson attack on a house in Coleraine in the early hours of Friday, from which a man and woman, and four young children escaped. It is being treated by police as arson with a racially motivated hate element. The Police Federation, which represents rank and file officers, said that since violence erupted in Ballymena on Monday, 63 officers have been injured. Federation chairman Liam Kelly said it has been "a week of shame with appalling levels of unrest in towns and cities". He said: "Burning people out of their homes, attacking a leisure centre, and the specific targeting of individuals and property fuelled by overt racism and prejudice, is totally deplorable. "Yet again, our overstretched police officers have also been attacked with petrol bombs, bricks and fireworks as they sought to keep people safe and maintain law and order. "They have held the line with great courage and professionalism and are owed a debt of gratitude by this community. They went to the aid of vulnerable people, have prevented further savage attacks and have undoubtedly saved lives." Police Service of Northern Ireland Chief Constable Jon Boutcher warned on Thursday that his officers would be coming after the "bigots and racists" behind the disorder. He also said that the young girl who was the victim of an alleged sexual assault in Ballymena at the weekend had been "further traumatised" by the rioting across the week.
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
Glasgow sidelined by Labour Spending Review, says Aitken
In a letter seen by The Herald, the SNP councillor warned that Ms Reeves's review is a 'retrograde step' for regional devolution in Scotland, and risks 'disempowering' Glasgow. READ MORE: Although the Treasury confirmed a £160 million Investment Zone in the Glasgow City Region and £20 million for Trailblazer Communities, Councillor Aitken said this fell far short of the funding deals being rolled out to five English Mayoral Strategic Authorities. The Spending Review included detailed commitments to expand integrated settlements for English city regions. Rahcel Reeves delivering the spending review (Image: House of Commons/PA Wire) Instead of applying for individual grants through competitive bidding processes, these areas receive a single, flexible pot of long-term funding, allowing Mayors greater autonomy in making their own investment decisions. This integrated funding grants local control over budgets for areas such as housing, skills, and transport. Following the Spending Review, these settlements are being expanded to include London, the North East, West Yorkshire, South Yorkshire, and Liverpool City Region. These will join existing arrangements in Greater Manchester and the West Midlands, meaning nearly 40% of England's population will now have local control over this unified funding for growth and public services. Glasgow will instead be forced to enter what one council source described as a 'beauty contest' and need to bid for cash — similar to the process under the last Tory government, which Labour criticised in opposition. Councillor Aitken told Mr Murray: 'It is clear from the Spending Review that the UK Government recognises the best way to support economic growth of English City Regions is through an integrated settlement, allowing places the ability to make their own investment decisions. 'And yet Glasgow City Region, which is larger in population, size of economy, opportunity and need than most of the Mayoral Combined Authorities, is reduced to simply administering programmes on behalf of UK Government as if it were a small local authority.' She added: 'The empowerment of our comparator city regions in England and the disempowerment of Glasgow City Region threatens all of the progress we have made. We have a shared priority of growing Scotland's economy and ensuring our people reap the benefits of that. 'We cannot grow Scotland's economy without growing Glasgow's economy — and yet yesterday's budget will not contribute to that growth and will cause us to fall behind our English counterparts.' Council insiders told The Herald the lack of progress had come as a surprise, particularly given the constructive tone of recent discussions with the UK Government. Cllr Aitken and Kevin Rush talking to Newsquest's Stewart Paterson in February (Image: Gordon Terris) In February, Councillor Aitken and Glasgow's head of regional economic growth, Kevin Rush, told The Herald the city was 'ready to go' on a bespoke devolution deal. The model would mirror Greater Manchester or the West Midlands — with a 'single pot' of funding and the ability to make investment decisions locally. They said the structures were already in place and that Glasgow was managing numerous major UK Government-backed programmes, including the City Deal, Innovation Accelerator, Investment Zone, Shared Prosperity Fund, 5G Region, and Clyde Mission. The Treasury did reaffirm its commitment to the Glasgow Investment Zone — which it says could unlock £1.7 billion in private investment and create up to 18,000 jobs — and praised the region's potential in advanced manufacturing. READ MORE: But Councillor Aitken said that without control over wider investment decisions, Glasgow's economic future would remain constrained by short-term funding rounds and top-down allocations. She told The Herald: 'If anyone thought locking Glasgow and other Scottish cities out of investment talks last year was a simple oversight, this Spending Review risks creating the impression that the UK Government has now decided it is prepared to let our city regions be left behind. 'That is incredibly frustrating, at a time when we have been working closely with the Secretary of State, Deputy First Minister and officials from governments in Edinburgh and London to develop a positive, deliverable proposition for a devolution deal that would allow us to build on our strong record for innovation, unlock investment opportunities and grow the Scottish economy. 'Despite all of that, it appears the voice of Scotland's cities has not been heard around the Cabinet table." 'We are not asking for anything difficult," she added, "just a level playing field." In her Spending Review, Ms Reeves confirmed that the Scottish Government is set to receive an average of £50.9 billion per year between 2026–27 and 2028–29, representing its largest settlement in real terms since devolution. A UK Government spokesperson said: "Glasgow City Region is at the heart of our Plan for Growth in Scotland. "We are delivering more than £663m funding for the region including an Investment Zone focussed on developing advanced manufacturing and a strategic partnership with the National Wealth Fund. "Further plans will be set out, including the city's important role in the Industrial Strategy. "Devolution within Scotland is a matter for the Scottish Government but, building on the success of city and growth deals, we will work with them to help to ensure places like Glasgow City Region have the tools they need to deliver change and unlock the same levels of growth as their English counterparts like Greater Manchester."
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
Industry leader writes to SNP minister over new nuclear ban
The long term commitment includes a major new plant in the south of England that will create 10,000 jobs, as well as small modular reactors. Louise Gilmour, the GMB Scotland secretary has written to Gillian Martin, MSP and Scottish energy secretary, 'to urge the Scottish Government to review its stance on blocking new nuclear'. She said the new investment 'includes £14.2 billion for an entirely new nuclear site at Sizewell, and also £2.5bn in cutting edge small modular reactor (SMR) technologies'. Louise Gilmour, GMB Scotland secretary. (Image: Andrew Cawley) Ms Gilmour wrote: 'Both of these investments will not just protect our energy security, but create thousands of well-paid, skilled jobs in their construction, and in the long term, hundreds of well-paid jobs in operations and research. 'A total of 10,000 jobs will be created at Sizewell alone. Where in Scotland are jobs being created at such a scale? Scotland's manufacturing base – in construction and energy – is dying.' She continued: 'We have experienced the closure of Grangemouth in Falkirk, of Aggregate Industries in North Lanarkshire, the slashing of jobs at Tarmac in East Lothian, the trickle of job losses from the North Sea, and the yards at Methil and Arnish being brought back from the brink yet again and still there are no major renewable works in those yards 'We are now contending with the planned closure of Alexander Dennis which would be yet another blow to the Falkirk area. This is not sustainable.' READ MORE: 'Amidst broken promises on a green jobs revolution, the Scottish Government cannot afford to scoff at the offering of nuclear energy on the table. An offer that would in large part be funded by the UK Government. The ban against new nuclear – especially SMRs – must be lifted.' Gillian Martin, Scottish energy secretary. (Image: Getty Images) The union said green-lighting new mini reactors in Scotland could create thousands of skilled jobs generating hundreds of millions of pounds for surrounding communities. Rachel Reeves, Chancellor of the Exchequer, said the government is 'investing in Britain's renewal, with the biggest nuclear building programme in a generation ... this landmark decision is our Plan for Change in action', adding: 'We are creating thousands of jobs, kickstarting economic growth and putting more money people's pockets.' The Scottish Government declined to answer in direct response but a spokesperson said to this and earlier questions from The Herald: 'The Scottish Government is focussed on supporting growth and creating jobs by capitalising on Scotland's immense renewable energy capacity rather than expensive new nuclear energy which takes decades to build, creates toxic waste which is difficult and costly to dispose of and does not generate power at a cost that will bring down energy bills.' The union said the nuclear industry supports around 3,700 jobs in Scotland and contributes about £400 million to the Scottish economy.
