Grandmother of hospitalised baby tells court father faked photographs
The grandmother of a five month old girl who was hospitalised with serious injuries has told a court that the father of the child faked photographs which he alleges show that the infant sustained bruises whilst being minded by her.
A 31 year-old man, who can't be named for legal reasons, is on trial at the Circuit Criminal Court in Cork charged with assaulting his infant daughter. The trial previously heard that the child had bruises on her face, cheek, stomach abdomen and right buttock as well as abrasions on her left temporal area, her cheek and her nose when she was examined by doctors at Cork University Hospital on January 4, 2021. Her parents brought her to hospital as she had been vomiting for eight hours.
The grandmother of the child was cross examined on Friday by defence senior counsel Ray Boland. Two photographs of the infant which were allegedly taken by her father were entered into evidence as defence exhibits.
The father of the child claims that the photographs were taken on occasions after the alleged incidents for which he is on trial and during times when the grandmother was taking care of his daughter.
The photographs entered into the defence exhibit are dated February 15, 2023 and March 1, 2023 respectively. Mr Boland showed the grandmother the first picture which appeared to be of the child at the centre of the case with a small bruise on one of her thighs. The woman said that the photo was fake and that the child never had this bruise.
The second photograph was of the child with a scratch and a bruise on one of her thighs. The grandmother stated that the child did have a scratch but she insisted there was no bruise. She said that the bruise was 'added in' to the photograph. When asked by Mr Boland if she was claiming that the bruising was photoshopped in she agreed that was the case.
Meanwhile, Dr Rosina McGovern, consultant paediatrician, previously told the trial that when the child was admitted to Cork University Hospital (CUH) in January 2021 it was established that she had suffered a subdural haemorrhage, a fractured collar bone, blood on the surface of the brain and tearing of its connective fibres in addition to bruising and abrasions.
Dr McGovern said she believed the injuries constituted serious harm. Prosecution Senior Counsel Jane Hyland said serious harm defined in Irish law is 'an injury that creates a substantial risk of death or causes serious disfigurement or substantial loss or impairment of mobility of the body or function of a bodily member or organ.'
The father of the child has pleaded not guilty to counts of assault causing harm to his infant daughter, assault causing her serious harm and a count of cruelty. The case will continue on Monday of next week in front of a jury of seven women and five men.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
2 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Irish Prison Service warns Department of Justice that prisons are overcrowded
The head of the Irish Prison Service (IPS) wrote to the department saying a garda decision to bring charges against individuals arriving in Ireland without valid passports was contributing to 'unsafe and unmanageable' levels of overcrowding in Irish jails. It is a criminal offence to arrive in this country without a valid travel document, punishable by up to 12 months in prison or a €3,000 fine. That penalty was introduced by the Immigration Act 2004, but it has only been rigorously enforced in recent times, following a crackdown once the numbers of people arriving here without documents began to rise. In a letter to a senior department official, released under the Freedom of Information Act, IPS director general Caron McCaffrey said that, in normal circumstances, low-risk offenders on short sentences were the first to be offered temporary release. She said this would normally include those in custody for immigration offences but the Department of Justice had made a deliberate policy decision to keep them in jail. Her letter stated: 'It will unfortunately necessitate the early release of more serious and high-risk offenders to make space in already overcrowded prisons, instead of offenders deemed to be low risk, from a reoffending and community safety perspective.' She said the IPS was heading into a 'catastrophic period' and numbers in custody were reaching new highs every day. The letter was sent in February 2024 but was withheld by the IPS under Freedom of Information laws until recent weeks. Ms McCaffrey also asked for urgent changes in the operation of temporary release and what type of criminals it could be applied to. She said that if changes were not made, there was the 'real potential to result in violent disorder within our prisons, threatening the safety and well-being of both our staff and those in our care.' She said they had exhausted all options around the temporary release of low-risk offenders and added that the department needed to look at temporary release for 'medium to high-risk sentenced offenders', which would have to apply to criminals including 'prolific' burglars and individuals convicted of assault on gardaí or peace officers. Ms McCaffrey called on the department to look at options for temporary release of sex offenders, especially those at low risk of offending. Under existing rules, sex offenders are ineligible for temporary release and no change has been made to this policy since the letter was sent. 'It is recognised that this is a difficult category due to the victim issues and the fact that people convicted of a sex offence pose a low risk of very serious harm, while other types of offenders pose a high risk of less serious harm,' she said. 'However, other categories being considered for temporary release as part of crisis measures pose a much greater risk to public safety.' She said this was particularly relevant for historic convictions and older sex offenders, some of whom were 'medically dependent' and actively engaging in rehabilitation. She also called for more flexibility around the use of open prisons for long-serving prisoners. Under existing rules, only those serving sentences of less than eight years could be transferred to an open centre such as Loughan House or Shelton Abbey, meaning spaces were not always being used in an optimal way. She called for a reduction in the number of people being remanded in custody, and said there was a particular need for a bail supervision scheme for female offenders, with the country's two women's prisons in Dublin and Limerick operating above capacity. She also asked that the department press ahead with its efforts to reopen the disused Curragh Prison in Co Kildare.
Irish Independent
2 hours ago
- Irish Independent
‘We want mental health care at festivals to be the norm' – charity provides support for music fans this summer
Mick Ledden, a psychotherapist, and his sister Kathryn Ledden, a medical doctor, founded PsyCare Ireland after identifying a lack of mental health services for enthusiasts attending music events. It provides one-to-one peer support, psychological first aid and crisis mental health intervention. Mr Ledden identified the need after volunteering for PsyCare UK, which directly led him to set up the Irish affiliate. The charity has two part-time staff, as well as 20 core 'behind-the-scenes' people and about 180 volunteers. 'What we're trying to do is make mental health supports the norm at festivals. It's the norm in the States, Europe and the UK,' Mr Ledden said. 'The culture of taking care of the mental health of punters at festivals in Ireland isn't taken into account yet. A cultural evolution is needed. We think concerts and festivals can provide life-changing experiences. But it can also be a challenging experience. I've had challenges myself at music festivals in my early 20s.' PsyCare Ireland mainly provides its services at smaller, independent music festivals and concerts, but is trying to expand into some of the bigger and more mainstream festivals too. 'All of our volunteers are highly trained, and a lot of our staff have a background in therapy or are doctors and nurses. We will send people to the medical tents if they are having an adverse reaction to taking drugs or alcohol,' Mr Ledden said. 'Often, the medics are sending people to us after they've been checked. Once it's established that people are medically OK, sometimes they just need a calm and safe space, away from the bright lights of a medical tent, where one of our trained volunteers will sit with them until they get through their psychological distress. 'One person was queuing to get their breakfast at a festival. They got a phone call that one of their best friends at home had taken their own life. ADVERTISEMENT Learn more 'This person was grief-stricken and was unable to process the news. We helped them contact their family and arranged for them to be collected. We have people coming in stone-cold sober who just need to talk. Sometimes they've had a row with their partner or lost their friends. If a person is suicidal, that's a safeguarding red flag and a plan is put in place involving the necessary medics 'We have had people who have taken psychedelic drugs and this can lead them to remember traumatic events. That's where our specialist support hubs come in very useful. We try to refer people on to services afterwards if they need further mental health supports. 'We've also helped people who might be neurodivergent and are overstimulated by the crowds at festivals. And we help those who have become disassociated because of substances and just need to get through it until they recover. 'If a person is suicidal, that's a safeguarding red flag and a plan is put in place involving the necessary medics. We've had cases too, usually with teenagers, who've taken drugs and need their parents to come and take them home.' Data shows that around 1pc of people who attend music events where PsyCare Ireland are working avail of the service. 'That's 50 people out of 5,000 attending in some cases. We are very busy. Our vision is that at every concert in this country there should be one or two people trained in mental health support,' Mr Ledden said.
The Irish Sun
7 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Serial killer ‘fuming' after new light shined on crimes & Irish prison day release denied as behind bars life revealed
SERIAL killer John Shaw is blaming a new podcast for having a recent day release application turned down. The evil rapist and murderer had hoped to get out from Dublin's 5 Elizabeth Plunkett was murdered by Ireland's first serial killers on August 28, 1976 Credit: RTE Press Office Issue 5 John Shaw is said to be annoyed that the series is bringing his crimes to light once more Credit: RTE 5 Stolen Sister centres on his victim Elizabeth Plunkett Credit: RTE Press Office Issue The 78-year-old lifer has been granted permission in the past to leave the prison on temporary day release and walk around And Shaw is blaming a recent He believes Stolen Sister, which centres on his victim And Shaw is said to be annoyed that the series is bringing his The source said: 'Shaw is not a happy camper. He's fuming since he heard that there was a 'Unlike some killers who relish in the spotlight, Shaw wants his evil crimes to be forgotten. 'He is of the belief the recent attention the podcast has been gathering is part of the reason why he is not being granted day release. 'He had been getting out the odd time but that seems to have come to an end. He is really p****d off and blames the recent refusal by the IPS for day release on the podcast and all the newspaper articles it has been generating.' The source said Shaw doesn't do much inside They said. 'He works on the reception in the prison laundry and spends the whole day just sitting there making tea. It's about all he's capable of doing.' IRELANDS FIRST SERIAL KILLERS Shaw, along with accomplice Geoffrey Evans, became known as the country's first The career criminals met in an The pair, from northern England, travelled around Ireland in the Their twisted killing spree ended with the murder of young clerk Elizabeth, 23, in Co The two men were caged for life in February 1978 but shockingly, despite Shaw confessing to the killing of Elizabeth with his now deceased partner-in-crime, the pair were never convicted of the Dublin woman's murder. Ms Plunkett's sisters, Bernie and Kathleen, are now speaking out for the first time in Stolen Sister as they seek justice for Elizabeth. Speaking on the podcast, Bernie said: 'We had tried every avenue, everything. We appealed and appealed and appealed. We went to the DPP, they said no, the Earlier this year, Ms Plunkett's family urged Garda Commissioner 5 Sisters of Elizabeth Plunkett spoke for the first time in nearly 50 years Credit: RTE Press Office Issue 5 Geoffrey Evans murdered two young Irish women in 1976 alongside Shaw Credit: RTE
