logo
Ontario's planned crackdown on exclusivity deals could go further, pharmacy regulator says

Ontario's planned crackdown on exclusivity deals could go further, pharmacy regulator says

The board of Ontario's pharmacy regulator said on Monday the province's proposed new restrictions on exclusivity deals between insurers and pharmacies were a good step, but should go further to protect patient safety.
Ontario recently began a second public consultation on preferred provider (or pharmacy) networks (PPNs), a type of deal between pharmacies and insurers that can restrict where patients get medication.
The consultation proposes two options for restricting the deals: 'any able and willing provider' legislation that would allow any pharmacy to join an insurer's network if they met the necessary criteria; and 'standardized and mandatory exemptions' that would allow any patient to go outside a network if they met conditions set by a regulator. The province leaves it open to whether it could pursue either, both or neither option.
The board of the Ontario College of Pharmacists has been discussing a potential crackdown on PPNs since early last year, even passing a motion expressing 'zero tolerance' for closed networks last July.
The board discussed the latest consultation at its meeting Monday. A briefing document prepared and distributed by college staff ahead of time suggested the province's proposals could be 'strengthened' to meet the regulator's goals of guaranteeing patient choice, continuity of care and access to care.
Ontario regulator condemns exclusive deals between pharmacies, insurance companies
Board chair Doug Brown, who owns and runs a pharmacy in the town of Port Perry, said he acknowledged that there was frustration in the community 'over what is perceived to be the lack of progress on this issue.'
However, he said the consultation – which is run by Ontario's Ministry of Finance – crosses multiple industries and needs to be done carefully. He said any new actions undertaken by the college could be undone depending on how the legislation is eventually drafted, and so it would be prudent for the regulator to wait for now.
'But let me be absolutely clear, the college is prepared to move quickly and decisively once the government has confirmed what it will or won't do to address the clear concerns that remained unresolved,' he said.
Most board members expressed support for the province's proposed options.
Elnora Magboo, one of the board's public members, asked during the meeting whether PPNs could provide greater access to medication because of savings negotiated between the agreement's participants.
Ontario considers rule to limit exclusivity deals between insurers and pharmacies
Insurers have argued PPNs are useful tools to keep costs down. They say the deals allow them to negotiate discounts from pharmacies that they pass on to plan sponsors.
But some of the board's independent pharmacists, who are often kept out of these networks in favour of large chain pharmacies, pushed back on the idea that there are cost savings, and raised other concerns with the deals.
Siva Sivapalan, a community pharmacist in Beamsville, raised a witness the board heard from last July, whose medication was delivered by a network pharmacy to a non-refrigerated area at the back of a craft store.
That witness – a teacher from Waterloo named Amy Miller – lodged a complaint with the network pharmacy last summer. In the months since, she has expressed frustration at the slow pace of the college's investigation and the difficulty in obtaining her medication from her preferred source.
'Every month that passes without a decision makes my access to care more uncertain,' Ms. Miller wrote in a letter sent to the board in May, which she shared with The Globe and Mail. 'Every delay deepens the harm. And every public statement you make about protecting patients becomes more hollow.'
College spokesperson Dave Bourne said the regulator could not share details about Ms. Miller's case, but continues to investigate concerns about PPNs. Speaking generally, he said some complaints are complex and time-consuming to investigate.
'We understand Ms. Miller's frustration with the time being taken to address her complaint, and we empathize with her situation,' he said in an e-mail.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Kids with diabetes show off their devices at Canadian fashion shows
Kids with diabetes show off their devices at Canadian fashion shows

CBC

time27 minutes ago

  • CBC

Kids with diabetes show off their devices at Canadian fashion shows

⭐️HERE'S WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW⭐️ The Pump Couture fashion shows took place in six cities across Canada this spring. The shows are an opportunity for people with diabetes to show off their devices. Diabetes Canada organized the events to raise money for the organization's camps for kids with diabetes. Read on to find out what it was like for kids who participated. ⬇️⬇️⬇️ When you hear 'pumps' and fashion, you might be thinking about high-heeled shoes. But at the Pump Couture fashion shows, the pumps in question are a piece of medical tech. That's because the shows, put on by Diabetes Canada, feature kids and adults living with diabetes who use devices like insulin pumps and continuous glucose monitors (CGMs) to help manage their condition. The events took place in six Canadian cities over the spring. CBC Kids News spoke to four kids who said it was a good experience to meet other kids with diabetes and feel more confident. 'It's probably one of the biggest things I look forward to every year now,' said Mathew Voss, 17, who took part in Regina, Saskatchewan, for a second year. He said he hopes the fashion shows encourage people 'to wear their devices out in public and be more proud of who they are and what their condition is instead of hiding.' Show features kids with Type 1 diabetes This year's Pump Couture shows took place in: Halifax, Nova Scotia, on April 4. Vancouver, British Columbia, on April 16. Calgary, Alberta, on May 1. Regina, Saskatchewan, on May 16. Winnipeg, Manitoba, on May 23. Toronto, Ontario, on June 10. Each model has diabetes and uses devices to manage it. The kid models we spoke to got to wear two outfits: a casual one and a fancy one. There are two types of diabetes: Type 1 and Type 2. The kids we spoke to all have Type 1 diabetes, meaning their pancreas doesn't make a hormone called insulin. Insulin controls how much sugar is in your blood. Without insulin, too much sugar builds up in the blood and that can cause serious health complications and sometimes death. Chantelle Valley, left, shows off her insulin pump while trying on dresses for the Toronto, Ontario, fashion show. Mathew Voss, right, walks the runway in Regina, Saskatchewan, with his CGM (continuous glucose monitor) displayed on his arm. (Images submitted by Pierre Valley and Cindy Voss) To help track and manage their blood sugar, some people with Type 1 diabetes use devices like the CGM and insulin pump. The CGM is a circular sensor that sticks into the body and communicates with a phone or other device to help people with diabetes track their sugars. The insulin pump gives people with diabetes the insulin they need to stay healthy. Both these devices are worn on the body and need to be incorporated into outfits. If the device can't be clipped on the clothes or put in a pocket, Chantelle Valley, 10, who took part in Toronto, Ontario, said she uses a special bag that holds her pump. Amannat Dhaliwal, 14, who took part in the Vancouver, B.C., fashion show, said sometimes the pump gets in the way but overall she is grateful for it. 'It helps out a lot throughout every day.' An opportunity to show devices Amannat said the Pump Couture shows helped her to feel more confident and gave her an opportunity to show off her devices. 'I normally try to hide mine as much as I can.' Each model got to wear two outfits. One of the outfits Amannat Dhaliwal wore was an Indian sari, right, that let her show off her culture at the show in Vancouver, British Columbia. (Images submitted by Sherry Dhaliwal) She said it gets 'tiring' having to explain it to people who don't know what the pump is for. But at the fashion shows, everyone already knows and is supportive. At school, Silvie Mahoney, 11, who walked in the Halifax, Nova Scotia, show, said she is often asked about her devices. 'It kind of makes me feel sad because some people say: 'Oh, are you a robot?'' Silvie said the shows helped her not feel embarrassed to wear her pump in an obvious place. 'You just can show it off and be like, I'm a diabetic and I'm proud.' Raising money for D-Camp The fashion shows help raise money for D-Camp, which is run by Diabetes Canada for kids with Type 1 diabetes. The kids we spoke to have all been to a D-Camp in their region. Chantelle said she likes going to D-Camp because she can meet other kids who have to monitor their insulin, unlike at school where she is the only one living with diabetes. Mathew said monitoring sugar levels and making sure you're taking the right amount of insulin can require a lot of planning and supporting. 'Diabetes it's a very hard condition sometimes,' he said. 'With D-camps, you have that extra safety seatbelt of other people you can rely on so that you can have more fun.'

Udo Haan back in St. Thomas hospital after harassment complaint
Udo Haan back in St. Thomas hospital after harassment complaint

CTV News

time35 minutes ago

  • CTV News

Udo Haan back in St. Thomas hospital after harassment complaint

Udo Haan, the Kitchener, Ont. man who was found not criminally responsible for killing his wife and causing an explosion that destroyed the couple's home in 2018, has been readmitted to the Southwest Centre for Forensic Mental Health Care in St. Thomas. The 65-year-old was brought back to the hospital on April 18 after a woman accused him of harassment. Haan's history Haan was sent to the facility at the conclusion of his criminal case. Since then, his care has been under the purview of the Ontario Review Board. They monitor the progress of his treatment and decide when, and for how long, he can leave the centre. Haan had been suffering from delusions when his killed his wife Edra and blew up their home on Sprucedale Cresent in August 2018. He was diagnosed with an unspecified bipolar disorder and has been taking lithium as part of his treatment plan. The board gave Haan permission to move out of the hospital in September 2024. In the months since, he had been living independently in an apartment near the hospital. He was still required to attend meetings with his medical team and submit to regular testing to make sure he was taking his medication. The Ontario Review Board noted in a recent hearing that Haan wanted to pursue romantic relationships. They ultimately decided he had to report any relationships to his medical team due to 'grave intimate partner violence' in the past and his 'lack of insight into his illness.' Haan was also told he had to abstain from drugs and alcohol. The board, while allowing Haan more freedoms, felt he still represented a 'significant threat to the safety of the public.' New developments On April 18, police went to Haan's apartment after a woman complained he had been harassing her. 'When police arrived at his apartment, they found him drinking beer and smoking joints of cannabis,' a hospital report said. Haan claimed he had received a death threat on social media and that was one of the reasons he had used drugs and alcohol. The hospital's outreach team said they are investigating that allegation. Haan also said he hired a private investigator to follow the woman who filed the complaint in order to discount her story. Members of his medical team noted he had previously hired a private investigator to follow his wife before he caused her death. Haan's actions resulted in criminal charges, and he was taken back to the Southwest Centre for Forensic Mental Health Care. Within days, his medical team said he was experiencing 'an acute decompensation of his unspecified bipolar and related disorder, which was likely primarily triggered by sub-optimal treatment and driven by cannabis and alcohol use, along with stressors he was experiencing around the alleged death threat he received.' A doctor at the facility also determined Haan was incapable of making treatment decisions for his bipolar condition. Since Haan has launched a court appeal, the hospital noted that has limited his treatment options. That, in turn, means his hospital stay will likely be extended. At a hearing on Tuesday, both the hospital's lawyer and Haan's lawyer agreed the restrictions on his liberty were warranted.

Government watchdog gives Manitoba minister title of ‘worst finance minister in the country': report
Government watchdog gives Manitoba minister title of ‘worst finance minister in the country': report

CTV News

time35 minutes ago

  • CTV News

Government watchdog gives Manitoba minister title of ‘worst finance minister in the country': report

Manitoba Finance Minister Adrien Sala has received an overall F grade from the Canadian Taxpayers Federation on provincial spending, debt, debt interest and tax relief. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/John Woods) The Canadian Taxpayers Federation (CTF) has given Manitoba's finance minister the title of 'worst finance minister in the country,' according to a report on provincial government spending. The organization that is 'dedicated to lower taxes, less waste and accountable government' released its 2025 Finance Minister Report Card—ranking ministers based on provincial spending, debt, debt interest, and tax relief. The report compared provincial budgets from last year to this year and took into consideration other provincial fiscal announcements. Manitoba Finance Minister Adrien Sala received the lowest grade according to the report, an overall F, which he shares with Newfoundland and Labrador's Finance Minister Siobhan Coady. The report indicates that Coady also received the title of 'worst finance minister in the country.' Lowest grade for tax relief among provinces: report 'Unfortunately, Manitoba is not performing well financially compared to other finance ministers in the country,' said Gage Haubrich, CTF prairie director. 'Manitoba was one of the only provinces this year to actually hike taxes in its provincial budget, and it did in a sneaky, underhanded way, known as bracket creep,' he said. Haubrich said that Manitoba's government has stopped linking income tax brackets to inflation, which will cost Manitoba taxpayers $82 million this year, per the report. Manitoba received the lowest grade for tax relief among the provinces. 'So that means just by getting a cost-of-living raise, not actually making any more money, you can get bumped up into a higher tax bracket, and that increases your taxes,' said Haubrich. Gage Haubrich Canadian Taxpayers Federation prairie director Gage Haubrich said that the provincial government's decision to stop linking income tax brackets to inflation is 'a very sneaky tax hike.' (Zoom) He said the longer bracket creep sticks around, the more money taxpayers are going to pay from compounding inflation. 'It's a very sneaky tax hike,' Haubrich said. He added the last time Manitoba got rid of bracket creep was in 2017. The report says that the government 'introduced a small cut to the province's payroll tax and an increase to the homeowner's affordability tax credit' but adds that the cuts save taxpayers less than what the bracket creep will cost them. F grade for debt interest payments: report Manitoba also received an F grade for debt interest payments, along with Quebec and Newfoundland and Labrador. The report says that the Manitoba debt interest payment will be $2.3 billion this year, working out to be $1,554 per person, only behind Newfoundland and Labrador at $2,088 per person. The province also received a D grade for a spending increase, listed at approximately 7.1 per cent, and the same grade for debt, which is planned to increase to $1 billion compared to last year's budget, per the report. 'Manitoba is on solid financial footing,' says Sala In an emailed statement from Sala, he said, 'Our plan was recently given an A+ by S&P Global Ratings, which means independent experts believe Manitoba is managing its finances responsibly.' 'This lowers borrowing costs and creates more stability for Manitobans in uncertain times, with a greater capacity to invest in the things that matter, like health care, affordability and public safety.' Sala added that 'Manitoba is on solid financial footing.' The report says that Saskatchewan's finance minister is 'performing the best,' with an overall B+ grade. 'No finance minister in the country earned an A grade for their budget, because all finance ministers are continuing or planning to rack up debt and waste millions of taxpayer dollars on debt interest payments,' says the report.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store