Are Cruise Line Private Islands Right For You?
CocoCay, owned and operated by Royal Caribbean, is one of the world's most famous cruise line private islands.
getty
Cruise lines have long promised a taste of paradise, complete with white-sand beaches, turquoise seas and every comfort close at hand. In recent years, that vision has become more literal, as many cruise companies now take passengers to private islands designed exclusively for their guests.
These carefully curated destinations offer a resort-style experience within the comfort blanket of the cruise line. There are no crowds, no taxi negotiations, no unexpected surprises. Just sun loungers, swim-up bars and a schedule of activities tailored to suit every kind of traveler.
But beneath the surface of this polished perfection lies a more complex story. Do cruise line private islands genuinely enhance the vacation experience, or are they simply another way to keep passengers and their credit cards firmly within reach?
While private islands offer undeniable perks, they also raise questions about how much of an "authentic" experience they truly provide.
One of the biggest advantages of visiting a private island is the hassle-free experience, especially for passengers on some of the world's largest cruise ships.
There's no need to battle with thousands of others to deal with local vendors, haggle taxi fares, or cope with crowded public beaches, as everything is conveniently managed by the cruise line.
Safety standards are also high, with these islands being carefully maintained and monitored to minimize risks. Passengers can expect well-maintained beaches and facilities, as cruise lines invest significantly in keeping their islands pristine and clean.
Private chalets and sun loungers on the beach await cruise guests at Royal Caribbean's 'Perfect Day at CocoCay.'
getty
Additionally, the activities and excursions are tailored to the cruise experience, ranging from thrilling water parks to snorkeling excursions, ensuring there's something for everyone. In many cases, onboard beverage packages are valid at island bars.
However, visiting a private island comes with trade-offs. One major downside is the lack of local culture and authenticity, as these islands often feel like an extension of the ship rather than a true destination. Exploration is also limited, as passengers are confined to the island with no opportunity to visit local towns or interact with residents.
Pricing can be another drawback, as while access to the island is included, premium cabanas, excursions, and specialty food and drink often come with hefty price tags.
Finally, despite claims of sustainability, environmental concerns linger. Constructing and maintaining resort-style private islands can have significant ecological consequences.
From the white sands of the Bahamas to the palm-lined shores of the Caribbean, cruise line private islands are marketed as exclusive retreats where passengers can relax without the usual crowds of traditional ports.
While all promise a seamless experience tailored to cruise guests, each island takes a slightly different approach. Some of the most well-known include:
Royal Caribbean's Perfect Day at CocoCay features the tallest water slide in North America and a massive wave pool. On the relaxation side of things, there's overwater cabanas, balloon rides, and an adults-only beach.
Disney Cruise Line's Castaway Cay is designed with families in mind, offering kid-friendly snorkeling lagoons, water play areas, and beachside grills. Disney characters roam the island to entertain younger guests, while adults can retreat to the adult-only space at Serenity Bay.
MSC Cruises' Ocean Cay MSC Marine Reserve is marketed as an eco-conscious retreat, emphasizing marine conservation with coral restoration programs and a stated commitment to sustainable tourism. There's plenty of beach space and other activities such as kayaking available too.
Empty kayaks await guests at Ocean Cay MSC Marine Reserve, a cruise line private island in the Bahamas.
getty
Norwegian Cruise Line's Great Stirrup Cay is a good choice for adrenaline junkies, with activities such as zip-lining over the beach and paddleboarding in crystal-clear waters available. Guests preferring to unwind can choose a private cabana or enjoy freshly grilled seafood at beachside restaurants.
Holland America Line's Half Moon Cay is one of the oldest cruise line private islands. A new pier now allows the latest Carnival cruise ships to also use the beautiful island. Guests can experience horseback riding through the surf, kayaking in a peaceful lagoon, or simply soak up the sun.
While cruise lines pitch private islands as added value for passengers, they're also a lucrative business move.
On a traditional port day, passengers may spend their money at local businesses such as restaurants, markets, and tour operators. But on a private island, every dollar spent stays within the cruise company's ecosystem.
From renting jet skis to booking massages or buying cocktails, everything is designed to encourage additional spending. Cabanas can range from a few hundred to over a thousand dollars for a day.
The impact of this shift is beginning to play out in places like Nassau. After the success of its private island CocoCay, Royal Caribbean is now developing an exclusive $165 million beach club just across the water on Paradise Island.
Though it promises local partnerships and hundreds of jobs, many Bahamians are concerned that such developments divert tourism revenue away from local vendors.
One market vendor told of his fears to the New York Times: 'The tourists will go from cruise ship to the private club back to the ship without spending a dime in the real Nassau.'
With the success of cruise line private islands, investment is on the up. Royal Caribbean is expanding Perfect Day at CocoCay with additional features, while MSC Cruises has positioned Ocean Cay as a multi-day destination on some itineraries.
It's not just Royal Caribbean experimenting with other land-based experiences. Other lines, including Virgin Voyages, are testing exclusive beach club experiences in ports like Bimini.
With sustainability in some popular ports in focus, this raises an interesting question—will cruise line private islands and privately-owned beach clubs eventually replace traditional ports for some itineraries?
Whether or not an island itinerary is worth your time depends on your travel style. If you enjoy a stress-free beach day with all the comforts of the ship, you'll likely love the experience.
But if you prefer cultural immersion, authentic local food, and real exploration, you might find cruise line private islands and beach clubs too sanitized.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Travel Weekly
6 hours ago
- Travel Weekly
Obituary: Rod McLeod, longtime cruise executive and Royal Caribbean founding member
Rod McLeod, the longtime cruise executive and founding member of Royal Caribbean, died on June 3. He was 84. McLeod's long cruise industry career included executive positions at the each of the Big Three cruise companies, beginning in 1972 as Royal Caribbean's first marketing director before being promoted to CMO and executive vice president of sales, marketing and passenger services. Later, he would serve as president and CEO of Norwegian Cruise Line and became Carnival Corp.'s senior vice president of marketing. McLeod was inducted into CLIA's Cruise Industry Hall of Fame in 2015, with the organization saying McLeod was "widely credited with leading an innovative marketing and sales organization that enabled Royal Caribbean to emerge as one of the cruise industry's most powerful and sustainable brands." Cruise industry leaders mourned the loss of McLeod, remembering him as one of cruising's most influential marketing minds. "Rod really was a pioneer in the industry," said Richard Fain, the former chairman and CEO of Royal Caribbean Group. "He was involved in so many defining elements and growth. Beyond that he was a really good person. He formed so many special relationships. And this is an industry that is built on relationships." Fain praised McLeod's marketing prowess at a time "when nobody understood what cruising was." "He was one of the early pioneers to help communicate that cruising was something for everyone and those campaigns were very successful for us," Fain said. "He was instrumental in creating the image of the industry and of Royal Caribbean in people's minds." Former Norwegian Cruise Line CEO Andy Stuart remembered meeting McLeod for the first time. "When I joined the industry in 1988, Rod was already one of the key players - his name was always said with reverence," Stuart said. "It was many years before I met him in person, by which time his reputation had only grown. It was quite intimidating to meet him the first time. He took time to chat with me and was the most humble and charming guy you could ever meet." "He took the time to chat with everyone," Stuart added. "It didn't matter who you were. He impacted the three big industry groups in a significant way and will always be [remembered as] one of the foundations of today's industry. We will miss him. He will always be remembered as one of the good guys." Rick Sasso, chairman of MSC North America and the former Celebrity Cruises president who first met McLeod in the early 1970s, said McLeod "was a classic marketing genius and so well spoken and likable. You were easily attracted to his words and thoughts. He brought incredible attention to our industry and their brands. ... He had a great impact and was one of one of the most talented and well-respected" of the old guard of cruise executives. McLeod was also president of American Classic Voyages for two years and, after retiring from a third Royal Caribbean stint in 2003, cofounded a consulting company, McLeod Applebaum & Partners. His grandson, Matthew Roderick Armstrong, said that McLeod's "proudest achievements were the friendships he built across boardrooms and ports, and the fierce, unwavering love he poured into his family. Whether brainstorming bold new voyages with colleagues or cheering at every grandkid's recital, he measured success by the bonds he forged and the smiles he sparked." Armstong said that while the family has not begun formal planning for McLeod's funeral, "our family intends to honor Rod's wish for an intimate gathering by taking a cruise together that calls at many of the ports he loved most - especially Perfect Day at Coco Cay, the island experience he helped bring to life. Truly, the hardest decision will be choosing which of the cruise lines he shaped that we'll sail with." McLeod is survived by two of his three children, six of his seven grandchildren and two great grandchildren.
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
US changes travel threat level for controversial Caribbean port
US changes travel threat level for controversial Caribbean port originally appeared on Come Cruise With Me. Often, when the U.S. State Department makes a significant change to its travel advisory for a country, it brings a stiffer warning for travelers. This time, however, one of the latest advisory updates will help to ease worries for some travelers considering popular Caribbean cruises that visit the destination on a number of cruise lines including Royal Caribbean, Carnival, Celebrity Cruises, and Disney Cruise revised travel advisory also gives the island's tourism industry reason to breathe a collective sigh of relief. The downgraded travel warning level comes not long after U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio pledged during a tour of the Caribbean that the U.S. would reevaluate its travel advisory to ensure that it reflected the progress the country has recently made in lowering its high violent crime rate. When he met with Rubio, the country's prime minister explained that the island is safer today than at any time in the last two decades. By collaborating with Rubio, he hoped to soon see his country's travel advisory updated to reflect the current state of affairs and help promote travel to the island. And on May 29, his wish came months after the meeting between Rubio and Jamaican Prime Minister Andrew Holness, the State Department has updated its travel advisory for Jamaica, downgrading the warning level from Level 3: Reconsider Travel to Level 2: Exercise Increased Caution. Travelers with upcoming plans to visit Jamaica on a Caribbean cruise or another summer trip should keep in mind that although the advisory has been downgraded, it still recommends that travelers remain extra cautious in Jamaica due to high levels of violent crime. 'While violent crime in Jamaica has decreased since 2024, it remains statistically high throughout the country,' the advisory emphasizes. 'Tourist areas generally see lower rates of violent crime than other parts of the country. The homicide rate reported by the Government of Jamaica is among the highest in the Western Hemisphere. Armed robberies and sexual assaults are common.' The advisory also cautions that the U.S. Embassy receives regular reports of sexual assaults, including from U.S. travelers staying at Jamaican resorts.'U.S. citizens report slow or unsatisfactory response to serious criminal incidents,' the advisory adds. The State Department also wants travelers to be aware that medical services are limited in Jamaica. 'U.S. citizens should not expect the same level of health care available in Jamaica as is available in the United States,' the advisory states. 'This includes slower emergency service response times and less availability of care for illness or injury.' Additionally, the State Department recommends that U.S. citizens purchase travel insurance for Jamaica trips. 'Check with your travel insurance provider about evacuation assistance, medical insurance, and trip cancellation coverage,' the advisory ports in Jamaica include Falmouth, which is visited by cruise lines such as Royal Caribbean, Celebrity Cruises, and Disney Cruise Line, as well as Ocho Rios and Montego Bay, visited by Carnival Cruise Line. Jamaica cruise ports are generally considered safe for tourists, but risks do exist. Cruise passengers visiting Jamaica should make sure to follow the State Department's guidance on ways to stay safe, which include: Avoid public buses. Avoid remote places. Do not physically resist any robbery attempt. Be aware of your surroundings and keep a low profile. Cruise passengers also need to be very careful not to accidentally bring firearms or ammunition, including stray rounds, shells, or empty casings, into Jamaican ports.'The penalties for carrying firearms or ammunition, even by mistake, are severe, and can include long prison sentences,' the State Department warns. For additional safety guidance for cruise ports in Jamaica, make sure to review any port-specific safety information provided by your cruise line and listen for any announcements from your ship's captain. You can also reduce your chances of becoming a target for criminals by booking shore excursions directly through your cruise line. Cruise lines are careful to only partner with trusted tour operators to help ensure a safe and enjoyable port experience for their passengers. (The Arena Group will earn a commission if you book a trip.) , or email Amy Post at or call or text her at 386-383-2472. This story was originally reported by Come Cruise With Me on May 30, 2025, where it first appeared.
Forbes
a day ago
- Forbes
Royal Caribbean Credit Card Review 2025: Sailing Nowhere Fast
The sea may be calling, but the Royal Caribbean Visa Signature Credit Card* is not. Though the card carries so much potential, most cruisers will be disappointed by its low earning rates and distinct lack of benefits while traveling. For a no annual fee card, the welcome bonus delights. You have the opportunity to earn 30,000 bonus points after spending $1,000 and a $50 discount for flights booked with Royal Caribbean's Air2Sea program after spending $3,500, both within the first 90 days of account opening. You can double the value of each point by choosing your reward redemptions carefully. Saving up your points for cabin upgrades, companion fares or cruise vacations can lead to returns of up to 2 cents per point, which is a good return if you're willing to patiently wait for your next reward. Why you can trust Forbes Advisor Our credit card editors are committed to bringing you unbiased ratings and information. Advertisers do not and cannot influence our ratings. We use data-driven methodologies to evaluate financial products and companies, so all are measured equally. You can read more about our editorial guidelines and the credit card methodology for the ratings below. This card could feel like a cruise to nowhere based on how low the earning rates are. There's only one bonus category—charges made with Royal Caribbean or its sister brands—and purchases top out at 2 points per dollar spent. The vast majority of your purchases will only earn a single point per dollar. Airline and hotel credit cards typically lavish cardholders with extras like status boosts, priority boarding or discounts, but the Royal Caribbean Visa doesn't offer a single benefit while cruising. The Royal Caribbean Visa Signature earns MyCruise points at the following rates: Additionally, as a new cardholder, you can earn 30,000 bonus points after spending $1,000 and a $50 discount for flights booked with Royal Caribbean's Air2Sea program after spending $3,500, both within the first 90 days of account opening. Royal Caribbean (and its sister brand, Celebrity Cruises) offer an assortment of redemption options for MyCruise points. Of these, onboard credit, discounts on cruises and charitable donations have the easiest-to-understand values: Your points are worth 1 cent each, meaning 15,000 MyCruise points would buy you $150 in onboard credit or as a discount off your cruise fare. More exciting options—with a higher return per point—include stateroom upgrades, complimentary companion fares or entirely free cruises. The exact value per point on these varies by the precise sailing you're booking, but could increase your point value up to two cents each. For example, the same 15,000 MyCruise points that are worth $150 in onboard credit are also enough to cover the cost of an upgrade on a four to eight-night cruise from an interior to oceanview stateroom valued at up to $300. Free cruises begin at 50,000 MyCruise points for a three or four-night cruise in an oceanview stateroom (valid on cruise fares up to $1,000). Eligible seven night sailings may be redeemed for 125,000 points. This could be a nice incentive for saving your points until you have enough for a larger redemption. Cardholders can also redeem their points for merchandise, though it generally represents poor value. Forbes Advisor uses estimated spending amounts to simulate the number of points you might earn from this card in one year. Based on data from multiple government agencies, our research shows that a household earning in the 70th percentile brings in $127,200 of income and can reasonably charge $40,398 to a credit card across the following categories: Royal Caribbean Visa Signature Credit Card* Rewards Potential The Celebrity Cruises Visa Signature Credit Card* is nearly identical to the Royal Caribbean card—both cards have no annual fee, no foreign transaction fee and earn MyCruise Rewards points at the same rate. For the most part, you'll simply need to choose between the branding that shows on your card name and design. With the Celebrity Cruises Credit Card, you'll still have access to redemptions, including cruise vacations, discounts and onboard credit at the same prices. Currently, there's one slight advantage to choosing the Royal Caribbean version of the card: Only the Royal Caribbean credit card offers new cardholders a small discount on Air2Sea bookings. The Capital One VentureOne Rewards Credit Card is a fantastic, flexible rewards card, especially if you're looking for one without an annual fee (rates & fees). It has no foreign transaction fee and features flexible rewards. While you can't redeem Capital One miles directly for a free cruise, you can reimburse yourself for any travel expenses charged to the card. That's similar to the rate you'd get for onboard credit or fare discounts with the Royal Caribbean card. There are two reasons why the VentureOne could be a better choice for your needs. First, it has a higher base earning rate of 1.25 miles per $1 spent, which means your rewards will add up 25% faster. Additionally, your rewards can be transferred to partnering airlines and hotels. Not only does that add versatility, but it could lead to even greater values. One of the best ways to earn rewards on your cruise fare is with the Chase Sapphire Preferred® Card. If you're willing to reserve your cruise through Chase Travel rather than directly with the cruise line or another agency, you can earn 5 Ultimate Rewards® points per dollar on your fare. Onboard charges earn 2 points per dollar, which is the same multiplier you'd get from the Royal Caribbean card. The Sapphire Preferred has an annual fee, though most cardholders find they get enough value from the card to offset it. You'll get a $50 credit for hotel bookings made with Chase Travel annually, perfect for a night if you arrive at your point of embarkation the night before. The card also includes numerous forms of travel insurance and the ability to transfer points to airlines or hotels for additional redemption options. Additionally, your points are worth 25% more, or 1.25 cents each, when used for travel booked through Chase Travel (including cruises). Unfortunately, the Royal Caribbean Visa Card doesn't quite hit the mark when choosing a travel rewards credit card. We love that it offers no annual fee and no foreign transaction fees, but it lags many other cards in terms of earning rates, redemption versatility and the value per point. Unless you have a massive amount of regular spending with Royal Caribbean, you're likely better off looking for a card with broader options. Forbes Advisor considers a variety of criteria when assigning credit cards a rating. Cards are graded based on numerous factors, including: We give greater weight to the card features we believe cardholders will use most frequently. These factors combine to generate a star rating for each card. To learn more about our rating and review methodology and editorial process, check out our guide on how Forbes Advisor rates credit cards. *The information for the following card(s) has been collected independently by Forbes Advisor: Royal Caribbean Visa Signature Credit Card, Celebrity Cruises Visa Signature Credit Card. The card details on this page have not been reviewed or provided by the card issuer.
