Sotheby's postpones historical gems auction after India backlash
[HONG KONG] Sotheby's in Hong Kong postponed an auction of gems with ties to early Buddhism on Wednesday (May 7) after opposition from India, which said the jewels were the country's religious and cultural heritage.
The Piprahwa gems, which the auction house said dated back to around 200 BC and were unearthed in 1898 by Englishman William Claxton Peppe in northern India, were scheduled to go under the hammer in Hong Kong on Wednesday.
The Indian Ministry of Culture issued a legal notice on Monday calling the jewels 'inalienable religious and cultural heritage of India and the global Buddhist community' and said the sale violated Indian and international law.
It asked for the auction to be cancelled and the jewels repatriated to India, as well as an apology and full disclosure of provenance documents, according to the notice posted on X.
Sotheby's said on Wednesday morning that the auction has been postponed 'in light of the matters raised by the government of India and with the agreement of the consignors'.
'This will allow for discussions between the parties, and we look forward to sharing any updates as appropriate,' the auction house said.
A NEWSLETTER FOR YOU
Friday, 2 pm Lifestyle
Our picks of the latest dining, travel and leisure options to treat yourself.
Sign Up
Sign Up
Sotheby's said the night before that the auction would 'proceed as planned'.
The Indian Ministry of Culture wrote on X that it was 'pleased to inform' readers that the auction was postponed following its intervention.
The gems in the Hong Kong auction were part of a collection of close to 1,800 gems and precious metal sheets – including amethysts, pearls and gold pieces worked into small beads.
They were excavated at the Piprahwa village near the Buddha's birthplace and have been attributed to a clan linked to the religious figure.
Indian authorities said an inscription on one of the caskets confirms the contents – which include bone fragments – as 'relics of the Buddha, deposited by the Sakya clan'.
In an article written for Sotheby's, Chris Peppe said his ancestor 'gave the gems, the relics and the reliquaries to the Indian government' and that his family kept 'a small portion' of the discovery. AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
8 hours ago
- Straits Times
Top 5 Premier League done deals of the summer's first transfer window
France's Rayan Cherki (25) and Kylian Mbappe (right, 10) in their nations league defeat to Spain. PHOTO: AFP There were some frenzied dealings by English Premier League sides during the 10 days before the special transfer window was slammed shut on June 10. While the move was to allow Manchester City and Chelsea, the two sides in the Club World Cup to strengthen their squads ahead of the month-long tournament in the United States, their EPL rivals were also quick to snap up players. Here are the top five deals done in this period before the transfer window reopens from June 16 to Sept 1. 5. Caoimhin Kelleher (Brentford) Caoimhin Kelleher arrives in Brentford as a Premier League champion. PHOTO: AFP Since their promotion in 2021 , Brentford's shrewd recruitment strategy has been one of the key factors that helped them beat the drop and become Premier League mainstays. And their latest coup is no different. Kelleher arrives in West London as a Premier League champion and one of the division's best shot-stoppers all for a reported cheap price of £12.5 million (S$ 21.7 million). At Liverpool, he stepped in comfortably when Alisson Becker was out injured, however he was never able to hold down the position and as such, was confined to the bench for most of his career on Merseyside. Afte r publicly stating his desire to play regularly in his bid to cement his place as Ireland's first choice goalkeeper, Brentford have granted him that chance following Mark Flekken's departure to Bayer Leverkusen. 4. Jeremie Frimpong (Liverpool) Jeremie Frimpong possesses the ability to play in any right-sided position. PHOTO: AFP Speaking of Leverkusen, the German side have traded their dynamic wing-back Jeremie Frimpong to Liverpool after the Reds triggered his £33.8 million release clause . The Premier League champions are looking to bolster their squad after right-back Trent Alexander-Arnold left for Real Madrid on June 1 and they have moved quickly to sign Frimpong, a member of the invincible Leverkusen team who won the club's first ever Bundesliga title in 2024. While he may not have the same profile as Alexander-Arnold, the 24-year-old Dutchman's pace and ability to get forward have seen him deployed in a more advanced winger role, offering the versatility to play multiple positions. He may not be the last player to leave the BayArena for Liverpool this summer, with a blockbuster move for Florian Wirtz set to be completed soon. 3. Rayan Cherki (Manchester City) Rayan Cherki has scored some high-profile goals last season, including against Manchester United in a Europa League quarter-final. PHOTO: REUTERS City were linked with Wirtz before his expensive price tag forced them to back out of negotiations. Instead, they have opted for a much cheaper option – Lyon's Rayan Cherki. After interest from the likes of Liverpool and Manchester United, City have won the race for the 21-year-old Frenchman, signing him for £34 million on a five-year deal . Primarily a right-winger, Cherki has also featured in an attacking midfield role and Pep Guardiola is hoping that he has found his long-term replacement for Kevin De Bruyne. Cherki's 12 goals and 20 assists in all competitions last season have seen him earn a maiden call- up for France . On June 6, he came off the bench to score one goal and set up another in France's 5-4 loss to Spain in the Nations League semi-finals. 2. Liam Delap (Chelsea) Liam Delap (right) battles with Chelsea's Levi Colwill (left) for the ball. The pair are now teammates together. PHOTO: AFP Part of the criticism about Chelsea's season was their over-reliance on Cole Palmer for goals as well as their lack of an out-and-out striker. The signing of Ipswich Town's Liam Delap looks to plug both those issues. Previously a City academy graduate , Delap scored 12 goals in his first full top-flight campaig n and was one of the shining lights in an otherwise bleak season for Ipswich that ended in relegation. So Chelsea pounced quick, forking up £30 million for the Englishman who will link up once more with Enzo Maresca, who coached him at City's youth level. Delap will don the infamous No. 9 jerse y, worn by flops such as Romelu Lukaku, Alvaro Morata and Fernando Torres, and Chelsea fans will be hoping this transfer will not be another blast from the past. 1. Matheus Cunha (Manchester United) Matheus Cunha has the 7th joint highest league goals last season. PHOTO: AFP Despite their worst Premier League finish since they were relegated in 1974, Manchester United have been able to secure the services of one of the league's most exciting players in Matheus Cunha. Cunha was easily Wolverhampton Wanderers' best player last season, contributing 1 5 goals and six assists in the league. In a summer that is expected to see a lot of chop and change at Old Trafford, Cunha's £62.5 million transfer is currently the most expensive and serves as a statement signing in Ruben Amorim's first full season in charge. United will be hoping the Brazilian can strike up a deadly partnership with captain Bruno Fernandes, and maybe even get out-of-form Rasmus Hojlund firing again. Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Straits Times
13 hours ago
- Straits Times
Polish President on state visit to Singapore from June 11 to 13
Poland's President Andrzej Duda will be making his first visit to Singapore since taking office in 2015. PHOTO: AFP Polish President on state visit to Singapore from June 11 to 13 SINGAPORE – Polish President Andrzej Duda will be making a three-day state visit to Singapore from June 11 to June 13. It will be his first visit to the Republic since taking office in 2015. Mr Duda's second five-year term as President concludes later in 2025 in August. The visit reaffirms the warm and growing relations between Singapore and Poland, said the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MFA) in a statement on June 11. Mr Duda, 53, will receive a ceremonial welcome at Parliament House on June 12. He will make a courtesy call on President Tharman Shanmugaratnam, who will also host a state banquet in his honour in the evening, said MFA. The Polish President, who will be accompanied by Poland's First Lady Agata Kornhauser-Duda and senior government officials, will meet Prime Minister Lawrence Wong on June 13. He will also on June 13 attend the Singapore-Poland Business Forum, jointly organised by the Embassy of the Republic of Poland, the Polish Investment and Trade Agency, and the Singapore Business Federation. His visit is the latest in a series of high-level visits between both countries. In 2017, then President Tony Tan made the first state visit from Singapore to Poland where he met Mr Duda. Poland is Singapore's 13th largest trading partner in the European Union. In 2024, total bilateral goods trade stood at $1.7 billion. There are also approximately 160 Polish companies in Singapore. A new Polish president is set to take office in early August, after historian Karol Nawrocki won the Polish presidential election on June 2. Mr Nawrocki secured 50.89 per cent of the vote. Join ST's WhatsApp Channel and get the latest news and must-reads.
Straits Times
14 hours ago
- Straits Times
Italy forges on with world's largest suspension bridge
The S$19.83 million project would carry trains and six lanes of traffic, allowing cars to cross the Strait of Messina in 15 minutes. PHOTO: AFP ROME - Italy hopes to begin constructing the world's largest suspension bridge connecting Sicily to the Italian mainland this summer, amid widespread scepticism that it will ever be built. The €13.5 billion (S$19.83 million) project would carry trains and six lanes of traffic, allowing cars to cross the Strait of Messina in 15 minutes. Ms Giorgia Meloni's hard-right government hopes to boost the economy of the impoverished region, although critics say there are better ways to do this – and many believe that after decades of false starts, the bridge will never actually happen. The choppy waters between the eastern tip of Sicily and the western edge of the region of Calabria are legendary as the place where monsters Scylla and Charybdis terrified sailors in Homer's epic poem 'The Odyssey'. These days the challenges are more prosaic, from winds of more than 100kmh to the real risk of earthquakes in a region that lies across two tectonic plates. The government says the bridge will be at the cutting edge of engineering, with the section suspended between its two pillars stretching 3.3km, the longest in the world. But critics point to a long history of public works announced, financed and never completed in Italy, whether due to corruption or political instability, resulting in enormous losses for taxpayers. 'The public does not trust this political class and these projects that become endless construction sites,' said Mr Luigi Storniolo, a member of protest group No Ponte (No Bridge). Infrastructure Minister and Deputy Prime Minister Matteo Salvini, one of the main champions of the project, insists it will be a game-changer for the local economy. 'The bridge will be a catalyst for development,' he said on a recent visit to Reggio di Calabria, the city where the bridge will begin. 'A senseless project' The government hopes to boost trade in Sicily, which currently suffers from an 'insularity cost' of around €6.5 billion a year, according to regional authorities. Ms Meloni's ministers are expected to give their final approval to the project – which Rome will fund – later in June, and Mr Salvini insists construction will begin this summer. But work had already been announced for the summer of 2024, before being postponed – a common theme in the history of the bridge, the idea of which dates back to the unification of Italy at the end of the 19th century. The first law for the project was passed in 1971. Since then, successive governments have either revived it or cancelled it. In 2012, the idea appeared to be definitely abandoned amid the eurozone debt crisis, only for Ms Meloni's government, which took office in 2022, to return to it once again. Mr Salvini has repeatedly stated that the bridge would create 120,000 jobs in Calabria and Sicily, which have the fourth and the 13th highest unemployment rates respectively in the EU for young people under 29. However, the left-wing CGIL trade union estimates around 2,300 workers a year will be hired during the project, and critics say the jobs created will be offset by long-term losses from the closure of ferries. Mafia risk The project has sparked local protests, with critics warning of the impact on a protected marine zone and an important bird migratory route. Mr Storniolo told AFP it was a 'senseless project' which used up valuable funds when 'our regions already suffer from many problems... healthcare, schools, and infrastructure.' The Italian Court of Auditors has also criticised the extent of the debt-laden Italian state's investment in this one project in its assessment of the 2024 budget. 'They want to make an entire territory believe that its only hope is this bridge – but then the bridge never arrives,' protester Mr Storniolo added. There is also the question of mafia infiltration. The attorney-general of Messina recently warned of the risk that organised crime would benefit from the project, noting that 'the power of the mafia is hidden... behind public contracts'. The government has proposed placing companies relating to the project under control of an anti-mafia structure reporting to the interior ministry. But Italian President Sergio Mattarella blocked this, saying it should only be used for one-off events such as earthquakes or the Olympics. Mr Salvini argued that the bridge can help tackle the mafia, saying: 'You do not fight the mafia... with conferences and protests, but by creating jobs and giving hope to young people.' AFP Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
