Mariah Carey wins copyright lawsuit over 'All I Want for Christmas Is You'
By Blake Brittain
(Reuters) - Pop singer Mariah Carey defeated a lawsuit claiming she illegally copied elements of her holiday megahit "All I Want for Christmas Is You" from a country song of the same name.
U.S. District Judge Monica Almadani in Los Angeles in a ruling on Wednesday said the writers of Vince Vance and the Valiants' "All I Want for Christmas Is You" failed to show their song was objectively similar enough to Carey's to support their copyright infringement case.
Attorneys for the songwriters, lawyers for Carey and spokespeople for her label, Sony Music, did not immediately respond to requests for comment on the decision on Thursday.
Vince Vance and the Valiants' "All I Want for Christmas Is You" was released in 1989 and reached the Billboard country charts during holiday seasons in the 1990s. Carey's song appeared on her 1994 album "Merry Christmas" and has since become a popular standard, topping the Billboard Hot 100 chart every holiday season since 2019.
Andy Stone, who performs as Vince Vance, and co-writer Troy Powers filed the lawsuit in 2023. They said Carey's song copied their song's "extended comparison between a loved one and trappings of seasonal luxury" and other lyrical and musical elements, requesting at least $20 million in damages.
Carey responded last year that the songs were "completely different" and argued that any similar elements were common to many Christmas songs, such as "snow, mistletoe, presents under Christmas trees, and wanting a loved one for Christmas."
Almadani determined on Wednesday that the songs were not similar enough for a jury to find that Carey had committed copyright infringement, citing differences in their melodies, lyrics and other musical elements.
Almadani also ordered the songwriters to pay part of Carey's attorneys' fees, finding some of their filings contained a "litany of irrelevant and unsupported factual assertions."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fox Sports
3 hours ago
- Fox Sports
Aaron Rodgers confirms he's wearing a wedding ring, but for who?
Aaron Rodgers dropped a bombshell during the first day of the Pittsburgh Steelers' minicamp. While addressing the media for the first time since he signed with the team, one reporter asked him about the ring on his left ring finger. "Is that an aura ring, or anything else… a wedding ring?" Rodgers was asked. The 41-year-old quarterback, who's won a Super Bowl and two MVPs, and played with boundless confidence throughout his 20-year career, seemed caught, uncharacteristically, off guard. But, then he locked back in, embracing the question head on. "Yeah, it's a wedding ring," he said with a smirk. That opened a line of follow-ups. "Congratulations!" one reporter said. "How long has it been?" another asked. "It's been a couple of months," Rodgers replied. And that was that. So, Rodgers, one of the most highly covered athletes in 2025, got married and nobody knew? Seems like it. It seems Rodgers' illustrious and, at times, eccentric career has taught him to keep some parts of his personal life private. However, he chose to address the questions about potential personal drama rather than letting them grow and be up to public opinion. [Related: Aaron Rodgers' most notable accomplishments, moments of NFL career] While no doubt remains about the meaning behind the ring, Rodgers' wife has yet to be confirmed. Rodgers has been linked to celebrities such as Danica Patrick, Shailene Woodley and Olivia Munn in the past, but who is this new life partner? In December, Rodgers casually dropped the name of a girlfriend on the Pat McAfee show when talking about Christmas shopping: "There was one package left for my girlfriend Brittani that hadn't shown up yet," he said. Brittney is a common name, but Brittani, not so much. Many will certainly continue to search for the identity of the mysterious woman that shares Rodgers' wedding ring. And while they do that, he'll be trying to win another on the football field. Want great stories delivered right to your inbox? Create or log in to your FOX Sports account and follow leagues, teams and players to receive a personalized newsletter daily! recommended Get more from National Football League Follow your favorites to get information about games, news and more in this topic
New York Post
4 hours ago
- New York Post
Eminem allegedly wanted rumored ex Mariah Carey to play his mother in ‘8 Mile'
We belong together — as mother and son. Eminem — who starred as aspiring rapper B-Rabbit in '8 Mile,' the 2002 movie based on his own life — reportedly had a certain pop superstar in mind to play the role of his alcoholic mom, who he lives with in a trailer home. And it was none other than Mariah Carey, according to producer Damion 'Damizza' Young, who was working with the legendary singer at the time. 7 After Mariah Carey was reportedly offered the role, Kim Basinger played Eminem's mother in 2002's '8 MIle.' ©Universal/Courtesy Everett Collection 7 Mariah Carey performed her new single 'Type Dangerous' at the BET Awards on Monday night. ©Universal/Courtesy Everett Collection It all began when Eminem requested a meeting with Carey, Damizza said on the 'TFU Podcast.' 'I'm not getting in the middle of that. I know how this ends,' he said. Damizza claimed that Carey initially turned down the meeting before she heard about the movie, alleging she eventually agreed to it. 'The first thing out of [Eminem's] mouth is, 'I want you to play my mother,'' Damizza recalled. But Carey, who at 56 is only four years older than Eminem, was allegedly insulted by the offer. 'Her insecurities kicked in big time,' he said. 7 Eminem performed at the 2024 MTV Video Music Awards at UBS Arena in Elmont, New York Billboard via Getty Images Although Carey never went on to join the cast of '8 Mile' — with the role of Eminem's mom going to Oscar-winning actress Kim Basinger — Damizza alleged that the meeting was the catalyst for the long-rumored romance between the two music icons. 'It was her chasing him, not him chasing her,' he said. 'Next thing I know, we are at Eminem's house … and they disappear. The second they went into his room, literally, I was like, 'I'm going back to LA. There is no point of me being here.' 'It went from business to f—king,' he claimed. 7 Mariah Carey dressed in an Eminem-like disguise as a stalker in her 2009 'Obsessed' video. Billboard via Getty Images 7 Mariah Carey received the Ultimate Icon Award at the 2025 BET Awards. REUTERS While Eminem has also claimed that they dated — he even referenced Carey on the tracks 'Superman' and 'When the Music Stops' from 2002's 'The Eminem Show' — Carey has denied ever having a relationship with him. That led the 'We Be Together' singer to seemingly take aim at Eminem on her 2009 hit 'Obsessed.' 'Telling the world how much you miss me/But we never were, so why you tripping?' sings Carey, who also donned an Eminem-like disguise as a stalker in the music video. 7 Eminem won a Best Original Song Oscar for 'Lose Yourself' from his 2002 film '8 Mile.' REUTERS 7 Eminem and Kim Basinger co-starred as a son and his alcoholic mom living in a trailer home in 2002's '8 Mile.' ©Universal/Courtesy Everett Collection Eminem responded with another track, 'The Warning,' in 2009. 'Wow Mariah, didn't expect you to go balls out/ Bitch, shut the f—k up 'fore I put all them phone calls out,' he rapped. These days, though, Carey has put the Eminem feud far behind her. On Friday, she dropped 'Type Dangerous,' her first proper single since 2018's 'Caution.' She performed the new track on Monday night at the BET Awards, where she received the Ultimate Icon Award. 'This means so much, especially coming from BET,' Carey said. 'This is my first BET Award. I mean, if you're gonna get one, might as well start with the Ultimate Icon Award.' She continued, 'It took me a while, but I finally realized life is far too short to live for anyone else's approval, which is something I always did. So I decided to own who I am—my extra-ness, my fabulousness and, yes, my success and my iconic-ness.'
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
BTS Members RM and V Discharged from Mandatory Korea Military Service Ahead of Band Reunion
BTS members RM and V have completed their mandatory military service in South Korea The K-pop stars were discharged on Tuesday, June 10, and welcomed by fans, some whom flew in internationally to celebrate their service The boy band is expected to reunite in 2025BTS members RM and V are heading home. The K-pop singers completed their mandatory military service in South Korea and were discharged on Tuesday, June 10, per NBC. The 18-month commitment prevented the group from performing and touring since 2023. The K-pop stars were welcomed with a saxophone performance and salutes upon their discharge, per the BBC. RM (whose full name is Kim Namjoon), 30, served as a private in the military band unit. Meanwhile, V (whose full name is Kim Taehyung), 29, served in the special forces unit as a sergeant. Their mandatory service began in December 2023. is now available in the Apple App Store! Download it now for the most binge-worthy celeb content, exclusive video clips, astrology updates and more! Fans gathered at the band's agency Hybe's office in Seoul to welcome them back, with some fans flying in from out of the country to celebrate. "Now, I'm ready to hit the ground running again as RM of BTS. Thank you to everyone who waited and looked after us," RM said to fans upon their return. V said that the obligatory army commitment gave him "time for me to reset both physically and mentally." "I really want to run to ARMY as soon as I can. Thank you for waiting for us during our military service," the singer added. V also asked fans to "wait just a little longer" for the rest of the band members to be discharged for a proper BTS reunion, the BBC reported. In South Korea, it is mandated that all able-bodied men aged 18-28 must serve between 18 and 21 months in the military. Other BTS members J-Hope and Jin wrapped up their military commitment in 2024. Jimin, Suga, and Jung Kook are still completing their mandatory military service but are expected to be released later this month, per the Associated Press. BTS, whose name is Bangtan Sonyeondan (which roughly translated to Bulletproof Boys) formed in 2013 and has been nominated for five Grammy Awards. They've had six No. 1 hits on the Billboard Hot 100 list, including "Butter" and Dynamite," the latter which has spent 32 weeks on the charts. Read the original article on People
