Gerry Thornley: Leinster still most likely disruptors to undisputed era of the French
It has been forecast before, and has proven premature, but this is it then. We're in the very midst of it now. The era of the French. Top 14 clubs are now dominating European rugby like never before and beating them to the trophy has never looked more difficult.
Of course there have always been, and always will be, different cycles. Nothing lasts forever. Northampton's 9-8 win over Munster in 2000 heralded a run of four English winners in a period of five seasons. From 2006 to 2012, there were five Irish champions in seven years. Ah, blissful times! Alas, only one in the last 13 years.
From 2013 to 2015 there was that Toulon three-in-a-row as they hit the tournament like a tornado, before English clubs provided four of the next five champions – three of them by Saracens, who were subsequently derided and relegated for financial doping.
But never before has one country accounted for five
Champions Cup
triumphs in succession. What's more,
Union Bordeaux Bègles
(UBB) became the third different French winner in this era, emulating La Rochelle's maiden win in 2022 over Leinster in Marseille, by beating Northampton in Cardiff last Saturday.
READ MORE
That old chestnut about the French being Eurosceptics, save for Toulouse, has never looked so hoary. In truth, on foot of Toulouse and Brive winning the first two European Cups and Colomiers reaching the final in the fourth season it was always a bit of a myth anyway and perhaps distorted by Castres' seemingly dilettante attitude.
Five different French clubs account for their 13 titles – Toulouse (six), Toulon (three), La Rochelle (two), Brive and UBB one apiece. England's 10 titles have come from six clubs and Ireland's seven trophies have been shared among three of the provinces.
But the French have also provided six other finalists, including Clermont and Racing 92, who have each lost three deciders. That hardly indicates disinterest.
Bordeaux players celebrate in the dressing room after the game. Photograph: Dan Sheridan/Inpho
As well as the 5,000 or more UBB fans who travelled to Cardiff and matched the 20,000 Saints fans for noise and colour, a crowd of 25,000 filled out the fan zone in Bordeaux to watch the match on a giant screen and nearly 40,000 people gathered around the Place des Quinconces on Sunday for the team's civic reception and open top parade.
Pierre Hurmic, the Mayor of Bordeaux, exclaimed: 'We have definitively proven, if it was necessary, that Bordeaux is a great rugby city.'
President Emmanuel Macron posted on X: 'Wine is not the only Bordeaux treasure: the Union Bordeaux Bègles inscribes its name in gold letters in the European legend of rugby! Bravo. With panache and heart, France is proud.'
As well as other Top 14 and ProD2 clubs, the Barcelona and French footballer Jules Koundé congratulated his fellow Girondins, as did PSG ahead of their Champions League final against Inter Milan next Saturday.
UBB's triumph is timely too. The most recent French TV deal in the post-pandemic world of 2022 was reputedly reduced from €30 million to €16 million. Yet, on foot of EPCR botching TNT's offer to renew its €15 million per year contract and having to accept roughly half that from Premier Sports, French television still remains the main broadcasting backer.
Union Bordeaux Bègles' Maxime Lucu celebrates. Photograph: James Crombie/Inpho
True, it's dwarfed by the Canal+ eight-year extension of €696.8m to show all Top 14 rugby until 2032, which is worth €139.4m a season, but EPCR's next four-year deal with beIN Sports and France Télévisions is expected to be confirmed later this week. In addition to beIN Sports again broadcasting every Champions Cup match, as well as some Challenge Cup fixtures, France Télévisions (ever presents since 1995-96) will continue to cover
two
Champions Cup matches, and Challenge Cup fixture, on a free-to-air basis each weekend.
Such is the tournament's reach in France that the Toulon-Toulouse quarter-final drew a record 3.2 million viewers. By contrast, from next season onwards, as part of Premier Sports' contracts with EPCR, the subscription channel will have exclusive coverage of the Champions and Challenge Cups. No matches will be on free-to-air, and that goes for the URC as well, save for TG4.
In so many respects therefore, the French are now the heartbeat of European rugby. Yannick Bru described this as the best of the four Champions Cups he has won as a player, assistant coach and now head coach.
Their president, Laurent Marti, who has masterminded their rise from formation in 2006 through promotion in 2011, couldn't stop grinning when talking to the French media in the Principality Stadium mixed zone.
'I prefer to be champion of France but I discovered the Champions Cup from a different angle,' he admitted. 'I understand better why some people love it. It's magical because it's international, and I think that without Yannick [Bru], we wouldn't have won it.'
UBB benefited from the draw, securing a maximum 20 points in the pool stages with a 66-12 win at home to the Sharks a week after Toulouse failed to earn a bonus point away to the South Africans. This effectively led to UBB having home advantage in the semi-finals against Toulouse. Still, they beat six-time former champions, with 13 titles between them, en route to their first star and scored 54 tries in their eight matches. Leinster fans will forever lament
that
semi-final defeat and wonder what might have been, but Champions Cups usually get the champions it deserves.
What's more, you look at players like Louis Bielle-Biarrey (21), Yoram Moefana (24), Nicolas Depoortère (22) and backrower Marko Gazzotti (21), and UBB look here to stay. Coupled with the arrival of the South African franchises, this tournament has never been harder for an Irish side to win.
Realistically, Leinster remain the most viable contender by a distance. Their playing budget, swelled by 11 central contracts, is probably in the ballpark of €9-9.5 million, with a chunk of that underwritten by the IRFU. But the union recoup all the fees generated by the provinces from the EPCR and URC. They also receive a sizeable amount of money, previously €250,000 to €300,000 from Leinster hiring the Aviva Stadium, and also pocket 50 per cent of Leinster's share of the gate receipts from, say, a Champions Cup home quarter-final, which could be €350,000 to €400,000.
Still, Leinster maximise their socio-economic advantages, akin to Toulouse and UBB, and their playing budget is not a world away from the Top 14 salary cap of €10.5 million. It's also more than the €7.75 million of Premiership clubs such as Northampton.
The playing budgets of Connacht, Munster and Ulster probably range from €4 million to €6 million but like pretty much everyone else belts are being tightened. Money talks, and although they lost a semi-final at home to Northampton, Leinster remain the likeliest threat to this Era of the French.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The 42
2 hours ago
- The 42
Casey emerges as Irish leader in a refreshed summer squad
THE LAST YEAR has been one of highs and lows for Craig Casey with Ireland. Back in July 2024, he was handed the number nine jersey for the first Test against the Springboks in South Africa and made an impressive start before being knocked out in a challenge from RG Snyman. With first-choice scrum-half Jamison Gibson-Park already missing through injury, Casey had to sit out the second Test as a result, watching from the sideline as Andy Farrell's men beat the Boks in Durban. Casey picked up where he left off last November, though, impacting off the bench against Argentina, shining in a try-scoring start versus Fiji, then helping to swing the game in Ireland's favour as a replacement when Joe Schmidt's Australia visited Dublin. Casey looked set for a big 2025 Six Nations with Ireland, only for disaster to strike in December when he injured his knee in a Champions Cup game for Munster against Castres. The Limerick man underwent surgery and was ruled out for four months. It would have been easy for Casey to feel sorry for himself, but he's an upbeat, energetic character. He threw himself into rehabilitation with intent, getting back on the pitch around a month earlier than initially expected. He returned with a superb try-scoring display in Munster's URC win over Connacht in Castlebar and hasn't let up since. Still only 26, Casey has taken his game to a new level despite the injury setbacks over the last year. He has always been a brilliant passer of the ball, but his decision-making is better than ever, he is playing with obvious self-belief, has honed his kicking into a weapon, and defends with an aggression that belies his physical stature. Now, he's the Ireland captain. Craig Casey has always been a leader. Ben Brady / INPHO Ben Brady / INPHO / INPHO Casey was skipper for Ardscoil Rís during his school days. He was captain of the Ireland U18s in 2017 and was a vice-captain for the Ireland U20s. He has been a leader in the Munster squad for a long time. He was only 20 when Johann van Graan added him to the province's leadership group alongside the likes of Peter O'Mahony. Casey hasn't been named as Munster captain for a game yet, but he has been heavily involved in driving the team, even more so as he has emerged as first-choice ahead of Conor Murray in the last two seasons. Indeed, Casey was strongly considered as O'Mahony's successor as Munster skipper when the latter stepped down from that role last season. That role eventually went to Tadhg Beirne but Casey's influence has only continued to grow in the Munster set-up. He made an immediate impression with his professionalism upon joining the senior Ireland set-up in the 2020/21 season, with then captain Johnny Sexton comparing Casey to World Cup-winning England out-half Jonny Wilkinson. Casey captained Ireland A against the All Blacks XV in November 2022 and though he has had plenty of frustration with selection amid the competition with Gibson-Park and Murray, he is clearly still on an upward trajectory. All of this leaves him well-placed to skipper Ireland's tour to Georgia and Portugal. It's a huge honour to become the 112th captain of Ireland since 1875, while this trip also allows him to maintain match sharpness in case an injury call comes from Andy Farrell's Lions. Advertisement Casey is a fitting choice because he still only has 18 caps. He's been around for a while now but he's certainly not one of the old guard. Most of them are on the Lions tour or missing this Irish trip on account of injuries. Casey leads an Irish squad that blends 11 uncapped youngsters with a host of lightly-capped fringe Ireland players, and a few experienced heads. With 15 senior men away on Lions duty, there is a welcome refreshed look to Paul O'Connell's group. Leinster props Thomas Clarkson and Jack Boyle. Billy Stickland / INPHO Billy Stickland / INPHO / INPHO Jack Boyle gets the chance to continue his emergence at loosehead prop, with Michael Milne rewarded for his strong start to life with Munster with a call-up. It's a positive message from the IRFU's point of view that a player who left Leinster to get game time has so quickly been rewarded. The explosive Leinster loosehead Paddy McCarthy, who has had a frustrating season involving just three appearances, completes the loosehead stocks. 51-times capped Finlay Bealham is one of the wise old heads and another who is on the Lions' standby list, while Tom O'Toole seemingly gets the chance to focus solely on tighthead as Thomas Clarkson continues his development. Among those to miss out are Connacht's Jack Aungier, who has trained with the senior squad previously, Ulster's promising Scott Wilson, and the once-capped Oli Jager, whose frustrating season ended in injury. 21-year-old Gus McCarthy is the most experienced hooker going on tour but has already shown his potential, while the return of Tom Stewart is welcome. It's not that long ago that the 24-year-old Ulster man was being heralded as a future star for Ireland along with Dan Sheehan and Rónan Kelleher. Leinster academy hooker Stephen Smyth has yet to start a senior game for his province and has made only four appearances, but he has seemingly done well in Emerging Ireland and Ireland A camps, so the Irish coaches have opted for the 20-year-old's potential ahead of more experienced hookers around the provinces such as Lee Barron. The make-up of the squad suggests that Cormac Izuchukwu, Ryan Baird, and Tom Ahern will feature as second rows, as well as offering dynamism at blindside flanker, and Connacht's gritty, powerful Darragh Murray is the only out-and-out lock in the group. Dynamic Leinster lock Diarmuid Mangan and Munster lineout specialist Evan O'Connell may have been close to making this squad. Munster man Gavin Coombes will be excited about his chance at number eight with Caelan Doris and Jack Conan out of the picture for now, while Cian Prendergast and Max Deegan will be leaders in the group. Nick Timoney and Alex Kendellen complete the back row contingent as the likes of Connacht's Sean Jansen and Munster's John Hodnett miss out. The Irish coaches seemingly rate Kendellen higher than Hodnett, who has been the first-choice openside for Munster ahead of Kendellen. Joining Casey in the scrum-half crop are Connacht's Ben Murphy, another who has thrived this season after leaving Leinster, and Ulsterman Nathan Doak, still only 23 but not far off being a centurion for his province. Ben Murphy was Fans' Player of the Years and Men's Player of the Year in Connacht. James Crombie / INPHO James Crombie / INPHO / INPHO With Gibson-Park away and Murray having retired from Ireland duty, this is a look to the future. Fintan Gunne and Matthew Devine must wait in the wings for now. The out-half trio of Sam Prendergast, Jack Crowley, and Ciarán Frawley is unchanged and it will be fascinating to see how selection for the number 10 shirt goes in these two Tests. Away from the limelight of the Six Nations, this could be an important window for those playmakers. With Robbie Henshaw missing out, Ulster's Stuart McCloskey takes on the role of senior centre and is joined in midfield by exciting Connacht prospect Hugh Gavin and Leinster's Jamie Osborne, who is also a strong option at fullback and can play on the wing too. With Jude Postlethwaite only added as a training panellist, Ireland aren't heavy on centres, but Frawley, Crowley, Tommy O'Brien, Jimmy O'Brien, and Shayne Bolton have some history in the midfield. Many Irish fans were hoping to see Munster's Tom Farrell rewarded for his excellent first season with the southern province, but Ireland have opted against calling the uncapped 31-year-old up. In the end, the Irish coaches have opted for 21-year-old Gavin's potential. Promising Leinster centre Hugh Cooney is another who might have been among those hoping to squeeze in, but just two Tests meant the squad was never likely to be too big. Of course, Leinster man Tommy O'Brien will be hoping to make his impact on the wing, where he has been impressive this season. Connacht's Bolton has also shone out wide when available. Both of them have had more than their fair share of injury travails. Jacob Stockdale, Calvin Nash, and Jimmy O'Brien provide a relative dollop of nous in the back three contingent, with Stockdale's 38 caps making him the most experienced player in the squad behind Bealham. Stockdale has enjoyed a strong season for Ulster and with James Lowe away, will be eyeing the number 11 shirt. Given that four of his five starts for Ireland so far have been at fullback, Osborne appears to be the leading contender in that slot. Stockdale recently switched to the number 15 shirt for Ulster after a long hiatus from that role but he is best on the left wing. Jacob Stockdale has been in flying form. Ben Brady / INPHO Ben Brady / INPHO / INPHO Munster's Diarmuid Kilgallen might have been hoping to make a late dash onto this tour, while Ulster's Zac Ward will join the group in Dublin as a training panellist later this month to continue his development in the 15s game. So there is a nice blend to this Ireland squad and while O'Connell and his makeshift coaching team will be targeting two wins against Georgia and Portugal, they know it is about development too. If they can win while polishing a couple of gems from the group of 11 uncapped players and seeing a couple of fringe players transform into genuine first-team contenders, it will be a worthwhile exercise. Ireland squad: Props: Jack Boyle, Michael Milne, Paddy McCarthy, Finlay Bealham, Tom O'Toole, Thomas Clarkson Hookers: Gus McCarthy, Tom Stewart, Stephen Smyth Second rows: Ryan Baird, Cormac Izuchukwu, Tom Ahern, Darragh Murray Back rows: Gavin Coombes, Max Deegan, Alex Kendellen, Cian Prendergast, Nick Timoney Scrum-halves: Craig Casey (captain), Ben Murphy, Nathan Doak Out-halves: Jack Crowley, Sam Prendergast, Ciarán Frawley Centres: Stuart McCloskey, Hugh Gavin, Jamie Osborne Back threes: Jacob Stockdale, Calvin Nash, Jimmy O'Brien, Shayne Bolton, Tommy O'Brien Training panellists: James McNabney, Jude Postlethwaite, Zac Ward
Irish Examiner
6 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
2023-24 'very positive' financially for Munster but this season 'a lot more challenging'
Munster Rugby reached a break-even cashflow position for 2023-24, provincial branch delegates were told at the Annual General Meeting on Wednesday but the forecast for the season just past is projected to be losses of up to €1 million. The Munster Branch AGM, held at Sunday's Well RFC as Sean Loftus succeeded Brendan Foley as President for 2025-26, had the accounts for 23-24 delivered to them by honorary treasurer Tom Kinirons as the professional team benefitted from finishing first in the URC regular season standings to earn a home draw for the knockout stages. They defeated Ospreys in the quarter-finals at Thomond Park and returned to the Limerick stadium a week later for a semi-final which was lost to eventual champions Glasgow. Chief Operating Officer Philip Quinn told the Irish Examiner that a surplus of €100,000 was achieved largely through increased gates throughout the URC season, a lucrative incoming tour match against Super Rugby champions Crusaders at a sold-out Pairc ui Chaoimh and those two URC knockout games, in addition to ongoing reductions in player costs. Describing the break-even position as 'basically our revenue matching our costs, Quinn said: 'Revenue is up to €20 million from €18m, so a significant jump, but a lot of that would have been relative to URC knockout income. Costs in general rose almost in step with increased revenues in 23-24… from €18.6m up to €20m.' Yet Munster's failure to secure a home draw in either the Champions Cup or URC knockout rounds this season, 2024-25, with the latter campaign concluding last Saturday in South Africa with a goal-kicking shootout defeat at the Sharks, means a very different outlook for the accounts to be delivered in 12 months. Also affecting this season's figures, the COO explained, will be lower than expected revenue shares from both the URC and EPCR, organisers of the European club competitions. 'Overall, 2023-2024 would have been very positive, and then looking at the current year, a lot more challenging,' Quinn said. 'We're going to have a loss this year, We're probably going to be between €0.5m and €1m cashflow loss for the year, and we can't put an exact number on it yet, there's a few still a few things to fall in place. 'Our gate income will drop, which we would have expected, like there is one thing within it around the IRFU funding model where we used to have URC South African TV money, about €0.75m in our other income, that's been built into the IRFU funding now for player costs. 'So our income comes down by €0.75m but are costs come down by €0.75m as well. So now it suddenly looks like we've taken €1.1m off our pro team costs but it's not. €750,000 of that is just an extra credit that we're getting down below. 'But the central distributions from URC and EPCR, we were hopeful that in this new model we would be getting an element of revenue share there but because they haven't hit the targets inside there, the revenue isn't coming in, so that's a hit to us because we would have budgeted that in the new model.' Also impacting the bottom line was switching the annual incoming tour game from Cork GAA's HQ back to Thomond Park, despite Munster playing the All Blacks XV last November in front of a sell-out crowd of 26,267. 'We would have had the All Blacks in Thomond Park versus the Crusaders in Supervalu Pairc ui Chaoimh, so there would be a downturn in revenue there, but it would been offset by costs as well. 'We've been consistent in saying if we were to move Leinster from Thomond Park to Supervalu Pairc ui Chaoimh we wouldn't see a huge uplift in revenue, because the costs of moving into Páirc Uí Chaoimh are significant between the rental cost and the operational costs. It offsets the vast majority of revenue that you're going to generate. 'When we're when we're looking at year on year there and having played Crusaders at Páirc Uí Chaoimh and comparing it with the All Blacks, our revenue will be down but also our costs will be down. 'We do still make a significant profit but not as much as we made for the Crusaders game, although the costs associated with bringing the All Blacks here would have been higher. "And then the URC knockout income. Minimal this year for us, unfortunately, and going to South Africa would cost us money. So when we were at home to Ospreys and Glasgow, you're making money on it, this season we're going to actually lose money from last weekend's game.'
Irish Examiner
6 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
URC chief realistic about Croke Park crowd numbers in event Leinster make final
BKT URC boss Martin Anayi is 'being realistic' about a likely attendance at Croke Park in two weekend's time should Leinster overcome some concerning form and qualify for the league final against one of two South African opponents. The choice of GAA headquarters was made last summer when the URC's teams were asked to pencil in potential dates for the calendar ahead. It appeared at that time as if the Aviva Stadium would not be available for a theoretical decider due to soccer commitments. So it is that Leinster and one of the Sharks or Bulls would compete for the league title on the northside of the Irish capital in the event that Leo Cullen's side makes it that far. And that would create a challenge. Leinster did draw a capacity 80,000-plus crowd to Croke Park for a regular season meeting with Munster back in early October, and for a Champions Cup semi-final against Northampton Saints 13 months ago. More recent crowd figures at the Aviva Stadium give cause for concern while Munster's elimination at the last eight stage last weekend in Durban deprives competition organisers of a potential all-Irish clash that would have generated enormous interest. Timing is another factor with ticket offices and marketing departments having just seven days to drum up sales, and early indications are that it would be a bridge too far to have Croke Park anywhere near half full. 'We've got a really good relationship with the GAA and the leadership there, working very closely with Leinster,' said Anayi. 'There's a lot of tickets to sell in a very short period of time, that one week. 'We're being realistic about what can happen, but it's exciting. We'd love to have that as a spectacle, which is one of the brilliant things that is happening in Ireland, that we're seeing rugby being played in GAA stadiums very successfully.' The first three URC finals have all been played in South Africa with a figure of 31,000 in year one jumping into the fifties for the next two. Over 33,000 tickets have already been sold for the Bulls-Sharks semi-final at Loftus Versfeld. Should Glasgow win this weekend, another final would go down south. Ultimately, there is no sure way of ensuring high crowds given the vagaries across five competing nations and the compacted rugby schedule, but Anayi did confirm that there will be a week off between the final two rounds next year. Now in his tenth year as CEO, the Englishman started off an hour-long media briefing by highlighting the journey taken by a league which has clearly improved from its days as the Celtic League, Magners League and PRO12 or 14. Attendances, he claimed, are up 14% with an average of just under 12,000 per game, and broadcast figures are improving every year since the URC's inception with over 150 million viewers logged since 2021. New TV deals through to 2029 were announced for the various territories earlier this year. Total earnings have supposedly shot up by 33% in the competition's new guise, with another 15-16% bump predicted by 2027. The South African union (SARU) will become a full shareholder in the URC as of this summer, but then change is stitched into the DNA of this tournament and there may be more around the corner given the turbulence in Wales. The Welsh union's contract with the URC commits them to four participating clubs. That is at risk with suggestions that one of the regions may go out of existence, although Anayi said the league would work with the WRU which is, again, one of its shareholders. Whatever about losing a team or two, it doesn't look like the URC will be admitting any more for now regardless of speculation in the last year about the possibility of teams like Georgia's Black Lion or London Irish coming on board. Anayi referenced player welfare, logistics and the league's current competitiveness as potential barriers and remarked that 'the bar is very high' for further expansion. Not that any such concerns stopped the establishment of a World Club Cup. Due to start in 2028, it will replace the knockout stages of the Champions Cup that year, and again in 2032. The URC, as a stakeholder in the EPCR organisation that runs the European competitions, is fully on board. 'We've supported the EPCR and it is very much something that our partners in England and France feel strongly about it. It seems it could be quite intriguing … to see the likes of the Brumbies and Crusaders compete against the best teams in Europe, and South Africa. 'We have a couple of touch points in that, where Crusaders came up and played against Munster in Pairc Ui Chaoimh when Munster had won our league and Crusaders had won Super Rugby Pacific. 'That got a really good attendance, a sellout. That was one little nugget to say, 'okay, there is an interest in that'. That was one of the areas that we focused on.'
