Utah Supreme Court orders new trial for man on death row after police misconduct surfaces
The Utah Supreme Court ruled Thursday that 'numerous constitutional violations' during the trial and sentencing of a man who spent decades on death row merit a new trial.
Justices affirmed the ruling of a lower court judge who had ordered a new trial for Douglas Stewart Carter after finding issues with how police and prosecutors handled his case. Carter, 69, was sentenced to death in 1985 after a jury found him guilty of murdering Eva Olesen, the aunt of a former Provo police chief who was found stabbed a dozen times and shot in the head.
While no physical evidence linked him to the crime scene, prosecutors convicted Carter, a Black man, based on a written confession and two witnesses who said he had bragged about killing Olesen, a white woman. Carter has argued his confession was coerced.
In 2019, the Utah Supreme Court sent Carter's case back to a lower court for review after the witnesses — two immigrants without legal status — said police and prosecutors offered to pay their rent, coached them to lie in court and threatened to deport them or their son if they did not implicate Carter.
Judge Derek Pullan ordered a new trial in 2022, saying the witness testimonies and police misconduct prejudiced the original trial. The Utah Attorney General 's office appealed, leading to the high court's decision Thursday.
'There is no question that these numerous constitutional violations — suppressing evidence, suborning perjury, and knowingly failing to correct false testimony — prejudiced Carter at both his trial and sentencing,' Justice Paige Petersen wrote in the high court's opinion.
It's rare, she added, to see a case involving 'multiple instances of intentional misconduct' by two police officers, including the lead investigator, and a prosecutor. Provo Police Lt. George Pierpont had obtained the confession from Carter, and Officer Richard Mack gathered witness statements. The postconviction court also found that prosecutor Wayne Watson was present when police directed a witness to lie, and that he did not correct the false testimony during trial.
Carter remains in prison while he awaits a new trial, said his attorney, Eric Zuckerman.
'Mr. Carter has spent more than forty years behind bars because of an unconstitutional conviction rooted in police and prosecutorial misconduct — including the suborning of perjury before a jury of his peers,' Zuckerman said in a statement. "We are gratified that both the trial court and the Utah Supreme Court have validated Mr. Carter's claims. But no ruling can restore the four decades of freedom the state of Utah unjustly took from him.'
Carter is among several inmates involved in a separate lawsuit challenging Utah's execution methods and protocols.
Olesen's family has repeatedly expressed frustration that the decades-old murder case is ongoing.
'We extend our hearts and sympathies to the family of Eva Olesen, who have sought justice for her murder the last 40 years," said Madison McMicken, a spokesperson for Utah Attorney General Derek Brown. 'We are disappointed the Olesen family does not yet have a resolution in this case.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
21 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Democrat politician and her husband killed in ‘politically motivated assassination'
A Democratic politician and her husband have been shot and killed during a series of 'politically motivated assassination' attempts in Minnesota. Melissa Hortman, the Democratic speaker in Minnesota's House of Representatives, along with her husband, was shot by a gunman in their home in the early hours of Saturday. John Hoffman, a Democratic state senator, and his spouse were also shot multiple times. Both have received surgery and are expected to survive, officials say. Police have issued a shelter order around the Brooklyn Park area of Minnesota as they hunt for a gunman who may be impersonating a police officer. Officers arriving at Ms Hortman's home arrived to find an SUV police equipped with emergency lights. The suspect was wearing a vest, and armed with a taser and other equipment while pretending to be a police officer, said Mark Bruley, the Brooklyn Park police chief. Officers decided to check Ms Hortman's home as a precaution after Mr Hoffman was shot. '[The] Suspect exploited the trust of our uniforms, what our uniforms are meant to represent', said Bob Johnson, a public safety Commissioner. 'That betrayal is deeply disturbing to those of us who wear the badge with honour and responsibility.' After an exchange of gunfire, the suspect fled on foot out of the back of the house. A manhunt is under way to find the gunman. 'It was not a real police officer. This is somebody that clearly had been impersonating a police officer. Again, using the trust of this badge and this uniform to manipulate their way into the home,' Mr Ruth said. A search of the car found a manifesto which included other political targets, he added. An alert warning residents that officers were looking for a suspected gunman was sent at 5.30am by Brooklyn Park Police. 'Police are looking for a suspect in multiple targeted shootings who is armed and dangerous,' the message read. 'Suspect is white male, brown hair, wearing black body armour over a blue shirt and blue pants and may misrepresent himself as law enforcement.' According to Fox 9, one suspect was already in custody. The gunman or men reportedly fled the scene in a car that 'looked like a police car,' a source told the station. The shelter-in-place order is currently being enforced in the three mile radius of Minnesota's Edinburgh Golf Course. Tim Walz, the Minnesota governor, said the killings appeared to be a 'politically motivated assassination.' 'My good friend and colleague, Speaker Melissa Hortman and her husband Mark, were shot and killed early this morning in what appears to be a politically motivated assassination,' Mr Walz said. 'Our state lost a great leader, and I lost a dearest of friends. 'She was a formidable public servant, a fixture and a giant in Minnesota. She woke up every day determined to make this state a better place. 'She is irreplaceable, and we've been missed by so many.' Mr Walz said he had activated a state-emergency-operations centre to deal with the incident. 'I've been briefed this morning on an ongoing situation involving targeted shootings in Champlin and Brooklyn Park,' Mr Waltz wrote on X. 'The Minnesota Department of Public Safety and local law enforcement are on the scene. 'We will share more information soon.' Mr Hoffman, a Democrat, was first elected in 2012. He runs Hoffman Strategic Advisors, a consulting firm. He previously served as vice chair of the Anoka Hennepin School Board, which manages the largest school district in Minnesota. Mr Hoffman is married and has one daughter. Ms Hortman is the top House Democratic leader in the state legislature and a former House speaker. She was first elected in 2004. Ms Hortman, a lawyer, is married and has two children. Both represent districts located north of Minneapolis. Dan Bongino, the deputy director of the FBI, said the bureau is 'fully engaged on the ground in Minnesota and is working in collaboration with our local and state partners'. Pam Bondi, the attorney general, said: 'I am closely monitoring developments in Minnesota after what appears to be a targeted attack against state lawmakers. 'The FBI is on the ground investigating this case alongside state and local partners. This horrific violence will not be tolerated and will be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law.'
Sky News
31 minutes ago
- Sky News
Minnesota politician and husband shot dead in 'politically motivated assassination' - second politician and wife wounded
A manhunt is underway after a US politician and her husband were shot and killed in their home in a "politically motivated assassination", and another politician and his wife were also shot. Minnesota state representative Melissa Hortman and her husband were killed at their homes, Tim Walz, the governor of Minnesota, confirmed. State senator John Hoffman and his wife were also shot in their home but are expected to survive. 1:08 The suspect was reportedly posing as a police officer, and officials said the alleged attacker escaped after an exchange of gunfire. Both politicians are members of the Minnesota Democratic-Farmer-Labor Party. Authorities have since urged residents of the Champlin and Brooklyn Park areas to stay in their homes. In an earlier Facebook post, Mr Walz said: "I've been briefed this morning on an ongoing situation involving targeted shootings in Champlin and Brooklyn Park. "The Minnesota Department of Public Safety and local law enforcement are on the scene. We will share more information soon." At a subsequent press conference, Mr Waltz said: "We must all, in Minnesota and across the country, stand against all forms of political violence. "Those responsible for this will be held accountable." Ms Hortman was first elected in 2004 - and was the top house Democratic leader in the state legislature. She also served as speaker of the Minnesota House of Representatives. Hakeem Jeffries, House Democratic leader, has described the shootings as "deeply disturbing" on X, adding that "violence is never acceptable", and that he is "praying hard" for the victims. Please refresh the page for the latest version.
The Independent
32 minutes ago
- The Independent
Watch: Governor Tim Walz gives update on two lawmakers shot in Minnesota
Watch as Governor of Minnesota Tim Walz confirmed that State Representative Melissa Hortman and her husband, Mark, were shot and killed in what he described as a 'politically motivated assassination.' State Senator John Hoffman and his wife, Yvette, were also shot but are 'out of surgery,' the governor said in a press conference (14 June). 'We are cautiously optimistic they will survive,' he added. The suspect remains at large after exchanging gunfire with police at the Hortmans' home and fleeing the scene. Residents are urged not to approach the suspect and to call 911.
