logo
Human rights group protests inequities in children getting tried as adults

Human rights group protests inequities in children getting tried as adults

Yahoo13-02-2025

Middlesex and Passaic counties have the highest rates statewide of prosecuting children as adults in New Jersey. (Dana DiFilippo | New Jersey Monitor)
County prosecutors in New Jersey play an outsized role in whether children accused of serious crimes get tried as adults, with juveniles facing potentially vastly different sentences and treatment depending on where they're prosecuted, according to a new report by Human Rights Watch.
Many states, including New Jersey, require a judicial waiver for a child to be tried as an adult, and under that system, judges weigh evidence presented by both sides before deciding whether a case belongs in juvenile or adult court.
But New Jersey's waiver statute 'sidelines judicial oversight' by giving so much discretion and power to prosecutors that they essentially call the shots, according to Amanda Leavell, a Human Rights Watch researcher who authored the report.
That has created a 'justice by geography effect,' Leavell said. Middlesex and Passaic counties have the highest youth waiver rates statewide, with Passaic's rate seven times higher than nearby Union County, Leavell found.
'Your fate is basically completely dependent on how harshly the prosecutor is going to pursue your case,' she said.
Black youth also get disproportionately waived to the adult system, Leavell found, perpetuating racial disparities in a prison system that already has among the highest racial disparities in the nation.
When juveniles get waived to adult court, they move to a system that prioritizes punishment over rehabilitation and into adult prisons where they face higher risks of violence, trauma, and recidivism, causing lifelong harm, Leavell added. She found they also languish in pretrial detention longer because of lengthy hearings and the reset of trial timelines triggered by their transfer to adult court.
New Jersey's waiver statute applies to juveniles aged 15 to 17 who are accused of homicide, sexual assault, certain drug or firearm-related crimes, and several other serious crimes.
Leavell made more than 20 recommendations for changes to legislators, county prosecutors, the Attorney General's Office, the Juvenile Justice Commission, and more.
She urged lawmakers to pass legislation that would reduce and ultimately end the prosecution of children in adult court. Until then, lawmakers should restore and strengthen judicial oversight of waiver motions and pass legislation that would require hearings in which prosecutors who want to try a child in adult court must prove that child could not be rehabilitated in the juvenile system, she recommended.
She also urged the state attorney general to review and assume decision-making authority over waiver requests in counties that send youth into the adult system at significantly higher rates than other counties. She thinks the attorney general should issue statewide guidelines that ensure waiver decisions are uniformly applied across counties and emphasize prosecution in the juvenile justice system as the default approach.
The attorney general and Juvenile Justice Commission should publicly report on juvenile waivers, as they are required by law to do every two years, on a more timely basis and include demographic information, charges, case outcomes, and other details, she added. Those agencies' most recent report — posted online Tuesday, the same day Leavell issued her report — was a half-year late. The data in the biennial reports is also several years old; this week's report examines juvenile waivers in 2020 and 2021.
Tara Oliver, a spokeswoman at the Attorney General's Office, said they will review the report's findings.
'Our office is committed to ensuring public safety while also treating people fairly. This is what we have done for two decades across administrations,' she said in a statement.
Leavell also called on county prosecutors to seek waivers to adult court only as a last resort, considering a youth's developmental capacity, trauma history, disability status, and potential for rehabilitation. Prosecutors and judges should undergo regular training on adolescent brain development and the effects of trauma on youth, she added.
Middlesex County Prosecutor Yolanda Ciccone, who heads the County Prosecutors Association of New Jersey, did not respond to a request for comment.
Former New Jersey Supreme Court Justice Barry Albin applauded the findings, saying uniformity in any system is important.
'It is a basic concept of justice that similarly situated people should be treated the same,' Albin said in a statement. 'One problem with having prosecutors be the primary decision-maker in waiver cases is a lack of uniformity across the state. You have 21 counties and 21 prosecutors, and they may have 21 different philosophies about how to prosecute waiver cases.'
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Officers sue to compel Congress to install a Jan. 6 riot memorial at Capitol

timean hour ago

Officers sue to compel Congress to install a Jan. 6 riot memorial at Capitol

WASHINGTON -- Two of the police officers who defended the U.S. Capitol from a mob of Trump supporters filed a lawsuit on Thursday seeking to compel Congress to follow one of its own laws and install a memorial to the Jan. 6, 2021, attack. The officers claim the failure to install the memorial plaque on the Capitol reflects an effort by President Donald Trump and his congressional allies to rewrite the history of the Jan. 6 riot. 'Even those who recognized the violence of the day eventually partnered with the man who both inspired and minimized it,' the suit says. More than 100 law enforcement officers were injured in the attack. Hundreds of people were convicted of Capitol riot-related crimes, but Trump erased all of the cases in a sweeping act of clemency on his first day back in the White House. In 2022, Congress passed a law directing the Architect of the Capitol to install a memorial honoring the officers who tried to hold off the mob. The deadline for installing it passed over three years ago. In April, Architect of the Capitol Thomas Austin told a House subcommittee that House Speaker Mike Johnson, a Louisiana Republican, had not instructed him to install the plaque. The speaker is responsible for any modifications to the House side of the Capitol, Austin noted. Spokespeople for Austin's office and Johnson didn't immediately respond to emails seeking comment on the lawsuit. The lawsuit's plaintiffs — Metropolitan Police Department officer Daniel Hodges and former Capitol Police officer Harry Dunn — have been outspoken critics of Republicans' revisionist history of Jan. 6. 'Both men live with psychic injuries from that day, compounded by their government's refusal to recognize their service,' the suit says. Hodges was nearly crushed in a door frame during a battle for control of a tunnel entrance. Rioters ripped a gas mask off his face and dislodged his helmet. Dunn left the Capitol police before running an unsuccessful campaign for a House seat in Maryland last year, losing in the Democratic primary. Dunn, who is Black, has said rioters yelled racial slurs at him during the siege. Hodges and Dunn joined Rep. Jamie Raskin in the Maryland Democrat's office on Thursday to discuss the memorial and their lawsuit. Raskin said he placed a poster replica of the plaque outside his office and is encouraging his colleagues to do the same until Johnson complies with the law. Dunn said they tried applying political pressure and 'asking nicely' for the memorial to be installed. 'It didn't work,' he said. 'It's unfortunate that we had to file a lawsuit to compel Congress to follow their own law, but here we are.' Raskin, who led Trump's impeachment over the insurrection, thanked them for taking their campaign to court. 'All you're asking for is the law to be followed,' he said.

Shawn Cranston found guilty of 2024 murder of pregnant Amish woman
Shawn Cranston found guilty of 2024 murder of pregnant Amish woman

Yahoo

time2 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Shawn Cranston found guilty of 2024 murder of pregnant Amish woman

Shawn Cranston, 53, was found guilty on all charges in the February 2024 murder of a pregnant Amish woman in Crawford County, Pennsylvania. Rebecca Byler, 23, was found with multiple slits to her throat and a gunshot wound to the head. Prosecutors said Byler and her unborn child were killed during an attempted burglary at her home on Fish Flats Road. Byler's two small children, ages two and three, were home during the murder, but were not harmed. The children were home alone with their deceased mother for about two hours, until Byler's husband, Andy, returned home from work. Cranston was found guilty of criminal homicide in the first degree, criminal homicide of an unborn child in the second degree, burglary in the first degree and criminal trespass in the first degree. Cranston is set to be sentenced on July 28 at 9:15 a.m. He's facing life in prison. Related Stories:Cranston trial day three — Prison inmate recalls alleged confession Day two of testimony underway for Shawn Cranston murder trial Trial begins for man accused of murdering pregnant Amish woman Trial for man accused of killing pregnant Amish woman pushed to 2025 2024 Amish murder case transferred to Pennsylvania Attorney General's Office New information takes center stage in Rebekah Byler murder trial Daughter of arrested suspect reacts to pregnant Amish woman murder case List of seized items released in pregnant Amish woman homicide case Murdered Amish woman suffered injuries to head, neck: investigators Community remains in shock following Amish woman's death, Corry man's arrest Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Danville man sentenced to 9 years for 2023 armed robbery
Danville man sentenced to 9 years for 2023 armed robbery

Yahoo

time2 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Danville man sentenced to 9 years for 2023 armed robbery

DANVILLE, Ill. (WCIA) — A Danville man has been sentenced to nine years in prison for an armed robbery that happened in October of 2023. Court records show KeShawn Stapleton, 23, was facing five felony counts for crimes including armed robbery and mob action and a misdemeanor count of obstructing identification. On Monday, he reached a plea deal with prosecutors that saw him plead guilty to a Class 1 felony count of armed robbery; the other counts were dismissed. Acquitted, accused again, convicted: Champaign man found guilty of murder Evidence presented in court showed that on Oct. 26, 2023, Stapleton was one of five Black males who approached a person walking to a trash dumpster near Lewis Street. The group held the victim at gunpoint and stole his backpack, which had an Xbox inside, his cell phone and the shoes off the victim's feet. The crime was recorded by a security camera. As detectives were speaking with the victim, Danville Police received a call about robbery suspects running toward Moore Street. When officers responded to the area, they saw several Black males exiting a car on Moore Street. Stapleton was arrested during this police encounter. The State's Attorney's Office said Moore was identified as one of the perpetrators based on his clothes; what he was wearing when he was arrested matched the clothes of the suspect who was recorded on camera taking the robbery victim's shoes from his feet. The shoes and the victim's cell phone were subsequently found inside the vehicle Stapleton exited on Moore Street. Sangamon, Menard Co. Crime Stoppers seeking tips in theft at Springfield church 'I commend the Danville Police Department for quickly identifying and apprehending these violent offenders. We are grateful to the victim for coming forward,' State's Attorney Jacqueline Lacy said in a news release. 'Armed robbery is a dangerous crime that threatens the safety of our entire community. My office remains committed to working with the police to pursue justice and protect victims of violent crime.' Stapleton was given credit for 592 days he's already served in custody, and his sentence will be served at 50%. Once out of prison, he will spend one year on parole. Two other people have been charged in connection to the robbery. Alvin Daniels, charged with the same five felony counts as Stapleton, pleaded guilty in February to one of them and was sentenced to five years in prison. Another person, who is a juvenile, has been charged, but the State's Attorney's Office did not go into further detail. The investigation into the robbery is still ongoing, and people with relevant information are asked to contact law enforcement. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store