Human rights group protests inequities in children getting tried as adults
Middlesex and Passaic counties have the highest rates statewide of prosecuting children as adults in New Jersey. (Dana DiFilippo | New Jersey Monitor)
County prosecutors in New Jersey play an outsized role in whether children accused of serious crimes get tried as adults, with juveniles facing potentially vastly different sentences and treatment depending on where they're prosecuted, according to a new report by Human Rights Watch.
Many states, including New Jersey, require a judicial waiver for a child to be tried as an adult, and under that system, judges weigh evidence presented by both sides before deciding whether a case belongs in juvenile or adult court.
But New Jersey's waiver statute 'sidelines judicial oversight' by giving so much discretion and power to prosecutors that they essentially call the shots, according to Amanda Leavell, a Human Rights Watch researcher who authored the report.
That has created a 'justice by geography effect,' Leavell said. Middlesex and Passaic counties have the highest youth waiver rates statewide, with Passaic's rate seven times higher than nearby Union County, Leavell found.
'Your fate is basically completely dependent on how harshly the prosecutor is going to pursue your case,' she said.
Black youth also get disproportionately waived to the adult system, Leavell found, perpetuating racial disparities in a prison system that already has among the highest racial disparities in the nation.
When juveniles get waived to adult court, they move to a system that prioritizes punishment over rehabilitation and into adult prisons where they face higher risks of violence, trauma, and recidivism, causing lifelong harm, Leavell added. She found they also languish in pretrial detention longer because of lengthy hearings and the reset of trial timelines triggered by their transfer to adult court.
New Jersey's waiver statute applies to juveniles aged 15 to 17 who are accused of homicide, sexual assault, certain drug or firearm-related crimes, and several other serious crimes.
Leavell made more than 20 recommendations for changes to legislators, county prosecutors, the Attorney General's Office, the Juvenile Justice Commission, and more.
She urged lawmakers to pass legislation that would reduce and ultimately end the prosecution of children in adult court. Until then, lawmakers should restore and strengthen judicial oversight of waiver motions and pass legislation that would require hearings in which prosecutors who want to try a child in adult court must prove that child could not be rehabilitated in the juvenile system, she recommended.
She also urged the state attorney general to review and assume decision-making authority over waiver requests in counties that send youth into the adult system at significantly higher rates than other counties. She thinks the attorney general should issue statewide guidelines that ensure waiver decisions are uniformly applied across counties and emphasize prosecution in the juvenile justice system as the default approach.
The attorney general and Juvenile Justice Commission should publicly report on juvenile waivers, as they are required by law to do every two years, on a more timely basis and include demographic information, charges, case outcomes, and other details, she added. Those agencies' most recent report — posted online Tuesday, the same day Leavell issued her report — was a half-year late. The data in the biennial reports is also several years old; this week's report examines juvenile waivers in 2020 and 2021.
Tara Oliver, a spokeswoman at the Attorney General's Office, said they will review the report's findings.
'Our office is committed to ensuring public safety while also treating people fairly. This is what we have done for two decades across administrations,' she said in a statement.
Leavell also called on county prosecutors to seek waivers to adult court only as a last resort, considering a youth's developmental capacity, trauma history, disability status, and potential for rehabilitation. Prosecutors and judges should undergo regular training on adolescent brain development and the effects of trauma on youth, she added.
Middlesex County Prosecutor Yolanda Ciccone, who heads the County Prosecutors Association of New Jersey, did not respond to a request for comment.
Former New Jersey Supreme Court Justice Barry Albin applauded the findings, saying uniformity in any system is important.
'It is a basic concept of justice that similarly situated people should be treated the same,' Albin said in a statement. 'One problem with having prosecutors be the primary decision-maker in waiver cases is a lack of uniformity across the state. You have 21 counties and 21 prosecutors, and they may have 21 different philosophies about how to prosecute waiver cases.'
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
LA protests far different from '92 Rodney King riots
The images of cars set ablaze, protesters tossing rocks at police and officers firing nonlethal rounds and tear gas at protesters hearkens back to the last time a president sent the National Guard to respond to violence on Los Angeles streets. But the unrest during several days of protests over immigration enforcement is far different in scale from the 1992 riots that followed the acquittal of white police officers who were videotaped beating Black motorist Rodney King. President George H.W. Bush used the Insurrection Act to call in the National Guard after requests from Mayor Tom Bradley and Gov. Pete Wilson. After the current protests began Friday over Immigration and Customs Enforcement raids, President Donald Trump ordered the deployment of 4,100 National Guard troops and 700 Marines despite strident opposition from Mayor Karen Bass and Gov. Gavin Newsom. Trump cited a legal provision to mobilize federal service members when there is 'a rebellion or danger of a rebellion against the authority of the Government of the United States.' California Attorney General Rob Bonta filed a lawsuit Monday saying Trump had overstepped his authority. Outrage over the verdicts on April 29, 1992 led to nearly a week of widespread violence that was one of the deadliest riots in American history. Hundreds of businesses were looted. Entire blocks of homes and stores were torched. More than 60 people died in shootings and other violence, mostly in South Los Angeles, an area with a heavily Black population at the time. Unlike the 1992 riots, protests have mainly been peaceful and been confined to a roughly five-block stretch of downtown LA, a tiny patch in the sprawling city of nearly 4 million people. No one has died. There's been vandalism and some cars set on fire but no homes or buildings have burned. At least 50 people have been arrested for everything from failing to follow orders to leave to looting, assault on a police officer and attempted murder for tossing a Molotov cocktail. Several officers have had minor injuries and protesters and some journalists have been struck by some of the more than 600 rubber bullets and other 'less-lethal' munitions fired by police. The 1992 uprising took many by surprise, including the Los Angeles Police Department, but the King verdict was a catalyst for racial tensions that had been building in the city for years. In addition to frustration with their treatment by police, some directed their anger at Korean merchants who owned many of the local stores. Black residents felt the owners treated them more like shoplifters than shoppers. As looting and fires spread toward Koreatown, some merchants protected their stores with shotguns and rifles.

an hour ago
LA protests far different from '92 Rodney King riots
The images of cars set ablaze, protesters tossing rocks at police and officers firing nonlethal rounds and tear gas at protesters hearkens back to the last time a president sent the National Guard to respond to violence on Los Angeles streets. But the unrest during several days of protests over immigration enforcement is far different in scale from the 1992 riots that followed the acquittal of white police officers who were videotaped beating Black motorist Rodney King. President George H.W. Bush used the Insurrection Act to call in the National Guard after requests from Mayor Tom Bradley and Gov. Pete Wilson. After the current protests began Friday over Immigration and Customs Enforcement raids, President Donald Trump ordered the deployment of 4,100 National Guard troops and 700 Marines despite strident opposition from Mayor Karen Bass and Gov. Gavin Newsom. Trump cited a legal provision to mobilize federal service members when there is 'a rebellion or danger of a rebellion against the authority of the Government of the United States.' California Attorney General Rob Bonta filed a lawsuit Monday saying Trump had overstepped his authority. Outrage over the verdicts on April 29, 1992 led to nearly a week of widespread violence that was one of the deadliest riots in American history. Hundreds of businesses were looted. Entire blocks of homes and stores were torched. More than 60 people died in shootings and other violence, mostly in South Los Angeles, an area with a heavily Black population at the time. Unlike the 1992 riots, protests have mainly been peaceful and been confined to a roughly five-block stretch of downtown LA, a tiny patch in the sprawling city of nearly 4 million people. No one has died. There's been vandalism and some cars set on fire but no homes or buildings have burned. At least 50 people have been arrested for everything from failing to follow orders to leave to looting, assault on a police officer and attempted murder for tossing a Molotov cocktail. Several officers have had minor injuries and protesters and some journalists have been struck by some of the more than 600 rubber bullets and other 'less-lethal' munitions fired by police. The 1992 uprising took many by surprise, including the Los Angeles Police Department, but the King verdict was a catalyst for racial tensions that had been building in the city for years. In addition to frustration with their treatment by police, some directed their anger at Korean merchants who owned many of the local stores. Black residents felt the owners treated them more like shoplifters than shoppers. As looting and fires spread toward Koreatown, some merchants protected their stores with shotguns and rifles.


Hamilton Spectator
2 hours ago
- Hamilton Spectator
LA protests far different from ‘92 Rodney King riots
The images of cars set ablaze, protesters tossing rocks at police and officers firing nonlethal rounds and tear gas at protesters hearkens back to the last time a president sent the National Guard to respond to violence on Los Angeles streets. But the unrest during several days of protests over immigration enforcement is far different in scale from the 1992 riots that followed the acquittal of white police officers who were videotaped beating Black motorist Rodney King . President George H.W. Bush used the Insurrection Act to call in the National Guard after requests from Mayor Tom Bradley and Gov. Pete Wilson. After the current protests began Friday over Immigration and Customs Enforcement raids, President Donald Trump ordered the deployment of 4,100 National Guard troops and 700 Marines despite strident opposition from Mayor Karen Bass and Gov. Gavin Newsom. Trump cited a legal provision to mobilize federal service members when there is 'a rebellion or danger of a rebellion against the authority of the Government of the United States.' California Attorney General Rob Bonta filed a lawsuit Monday saying Trump had overstepped his authority. Outrage over the verdicts on April 29, 1992 led to nearly a week of widespread violence that was one of the deadliest riots in American history. Hundreds of businesses were looted. Entire blocks of homes and stores were torched. More than 60 people died in shootings and other violence, mostly in South Los Angeles, an area with a heavily Black population at the time. Unlike the 1992 riots, protests have mainly been peaceful and been confined to a roughly five-block stretch of downtown LA, a tiny patch in the sprawling city of nearly 4 million people. No one has died. There's been vandalism and some cars set on fire but no homes or buildings have burned. At least 50 people have been arrested for everything from failing to follow orders to leave to looting, assault on a police officer and attempted murder for tossing a Molotov cocktail. Several officers have had minor injuries and protesters and some journalists have been struck by some of the more than 600 rubber bullets and other 'less-lethal' munitions fired by police. The 1992 uprising took many by surprise, including the Los Angeles Police Department, but the King verdict was a catalyst for racial tensions that had been building in the city for years. In addition to frustration with their treatment by police, some directed their anger at Korean merchants who owned many of the local stores. Black residents felt the owners treated them more like shoplifters than shoppers. As looting and fires spread toward Koreatown, some merchants protected their stores with shotguns and rifles. Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .