Human rights group protests inequities in children getting tried as adults
Middlesex and Passaic counties have the highest rates statewide of prosecuting children as adults in New Jersey. (Dana DiFilippo | New Jersey Monitor)
County prosecutors in New Jersey play an outsized role in whether children accused of serious crimes get tried as adults, with juveniles facing potentially vastly different sentences and treatment depending on where they're prosecuted, according to a new report by Human Rights Watch.
Many states, including New Jersey, require a judicial waiver for a child to be tried as an adult, and under that system, judges weigh evidence presented by both sides before deciding whether a case belongs in juvenile or adult court.
But New Jersey's waiver statute 'sidelines judicial oversight' by giving so much discretion and power to prosecutors that they essentially call the shots, according to Amanda Leavell, a Human Rights Watch researcher who authored the report.
That has created a 'justice by geography effect,' Leavell said. Middlesex and Passaic counties have the highest youth waiver rates statewide, with Passaic's rate seven times higher than nearby Union County, Leavell found.
'Your fate is basically completely dependent on how harshly the prosecutor is going to pursue your case,' she said.
Black youth also get disproportionately waived to the adult system, Leavell found, perpetuating racial disparities in a prison system that already has among the highest racial disparities in the nation.
When juveniles get waived to adult court, they move to a system that prioritizes punishment over rehabilitation and into adult prisons where they face higher risks of violence, trauma, and recidivism, causing lifelong harm, Leavell added. She found they also languish in pretrial detention longer because of lengthy hearings and the reset of trial timelines triggered by their transfer to adult court.
New Jersey's waiver statute applies to juveniles aged 15 to 17 who are accused of homicide, sexual assault, certain drug or firearm-related crimes, and several other serious crimes.
Leavell made more than 20 recommendations for changes to legislators, county prosecutors, the Attorney General's Office, the Juvenile Justice Commission, and more.
She urged lawmakers to pass legislation that would reduce and ultimately end the prosecution of children in adult court. Until then, lawmakers should restore and strengthen judicial oversight of waiver motions and pass legislation that would require hearings in which prosecutors who want to try a child in adult court must prove that child could not be rehabilitated in the juvenile system, she recommended.
She also urged the state attorney general to review and assume decision-making authority over waiver requests in counties that send youth into the adult system at significantly higher rates than other counties. She thinks the attorney general should issue statewide guidelines that ensure waiver decisions are uniformly applied across counties and emphasize prosecution in the juvenile justice system as the default approach.
The attorney general and Juvenile Justice Commission should publicly report on juvenile waivers, as they are required by law to do every two years, on a more timely basis and include demographic information, charges, case outcomes, and other details, she added. Those agencies' most recent report — posted online Tuesday, the same day Leavell issued her report — was a half-year late. The data in the biennial reports is also several years old; this week's report examines juvenile waivers in 2020 and 2021.
Tara Oliver, a spokeswoman at the Attorney General's Office, said they will review the report's findings.
'Our office is committed to ensuring public safety while also treating people fairly. This is what we have done for two decades across administrations,' she said in a statement.
Leavell also called on county prosecutors to seek waivers to adult court only as a last resort, considering a youth's developmental capacity, trauma history, disability status, and potential for rehabilitation. Prosecutors and judges should undergo regular training on adolescent brain development and the effects of trauma on youth, she added.
Middlesex County Prosecutor Yolanda Ciccone, who heads the County Prosecutors Association of New Jersey, did not respond to a request for comment.
Former New Jersey Supreme Court Justice Barry Albin applauded the findings, saying uniformity in any system is important.
'It is a basic concept of justice that similarly situated people should be treated the same,' Albin said in a statement. 'One problem with having prosecutors be the primary decision-maker in waiver cases is a lack of uniformity across the state. You have 21 counties and 21 prosecutors, and they may have 21 different philosophies about how to prosecute waiver cases.'
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Construction workers robbed on West Side job sites
CHICAGO — Construction workers were recently robbed on the West Side, according to a Chicago police community alert. The two incidents were part of an alert telling residents about recent armed robberies in Austin and Garfield Park. A timeline of the incidents is below, according to CPD. Thursday, June 5 at 12:25 p.m. — 4300 block of West Washington Boulevard Thursday, June 5 at 4:10 p.m. — 4400 block of West Monroe Thursday, June 5 at 4:11 p.m. — 0-100 block of South Kilbourn Sunday, June 8 at 5:26 p.m. — 4600 block of West Maypole Police did not specify which two incidents were the robberies of construction workers. The suspect is described as a Black male, 16-25, 5'7″-6'1″,140-150 lbs. He was wearing a dark gray hooded sweatshirt with a white design on the back, black pants, white and black gym shoes and a black surgical mask. Anyone with information can leave an anonymous tip at Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
‘I'm not feeling seen': Racist graduation remarks highlight earlier concerns brought to officials
Parents and students in Lynnfield have raised concerns about how the town's schools address race — from the limited portrayal of Black history to reports of racism among students. Now, officials are being forced to confront those concerns after 'inappropriate' remarks were made during a high school graduation livestream. Lynnfield town employees could be heard using 'inappropriate and racist words' during a graduation livestream Friday. The video has since been remove but was seen and heard by people waiting to watch the Lynnfield High School graduation on Friday. The people in the video have been placed on administrative leave during the investigation, town officials said. 'It is especially regrettable that this incident took place on what is and should be a night to celebrate our incredible seniors. Such incidents, however, must be confronted directly and openly and a full investigation and appropriate action will be taken,' a statement by the town read on Facebook. The video was of people setting up chairs on the football field prior to the ceremony. At least two racist words can be heard clearly, Itemlive reported. 'We, as town leaders, stand together in outrage over what has been reported this evening and wish to state emphatically that racist language and behavior has no place in our town and will be dealt with immediately,' the town's statement continued. Select Board member Alexis Leahy spoke out against the comments and thanked the town administration for acting quickly. 'Discrimination not only undermines the values of equity and justice that a community is built upon, but it also divides us at a time when unity and understanding are more important than ever,' she wrote. Jamie Hayman of the school committee also spoke out stating that hundreds of students have now heard these words. 'And just as importantly, they are now watching what we do next. If we treat this only as a personnel issue, we miss a critical opportunity, to lead, to grow, and to teach,' he said. But it isn't the first time this issue has been brought up to the school board committee this year. On June 3, the school committee hearing prior to graduation, a parent, Carl Allien, told the committee that his son was dealing with 'some incidents' as an African-American. The school's principal had called Allien about 'some of the harsh things that my son has been enduring.' Although he did not provide any specifics, he said it wasn't about any specific person and asked for a meeting with the superintendent about these issues. '... it's been challenging for a young African-American kid in the schools,' he said. 'I'm struggling right now.' Two school board members encouraged Allien to leave his contact information with the district secretary for further conversation. In February, Joseph Dixon and his mother, Wendy, went in front of the committee to urge them to have better education and celebration of Black history. 'I'm not feeling seen,' Wendy Dixon said her son told her. Joseph Dixon said during his years at Lynnfield public schools, he has not seen Black history talked about beyond slavery and Martin Luther King Jr. 'We should learn about the many things that black people have contributed to our society and not just the struggle and hurt that they've been through,' he told the committee. He also encouraged education on other cultures too. 'I agree with you that we can do better,' Superintendent Tom Geary said. 'Thank you for being willing to speak. It's something we will talk about administratively on how to move forward with that.' Another school board committee meeting is scheduled for Tuesday. Public comment is available. Ex-con arraigned on home invasion and armed robbery charges Rally to be held in Boston in response to ICE raids in LA 'Devastated' music legend cancels more shows due to health issues Hearing for Newton judge accused of helping man evade ICE begins Monday How a Springfield agency's mission evolved since its founding after the Civil War Read the original article on MassLive.
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Police issue assembly ban for downtown LA after third day of demos
Authorities have declared the entire downtown Los Angeles area an "unlawful assembly" zone after a third consecutive day of clashes between protesters and law enforcement, sparked by the crackdown on immigration ordered by US President Donald Trump. "You are to leave the area immediately," the Los Angeles police department (LAPD) wrote on X in the early hours of Monday. Over the weekend, 56 people were arrested in connection with the ongoing protests, according to police reports. Police chief Jim McDonnell was quoted by US media as announcing that "the number of arrests so far is nothing compared to what is yet to come." On Sunday, tensions spiked dramatically following Trump's order to deploy the National Guard and, controversially, mobilize regular military forces - despite opposition from local officials. Thousands of protesters flooded the streets in response to the unprecedented deployment. Law enforcement responded with tear gas, rubber bullets and flash bangs in an effort to disperse the crowds. However, the rest of the sprawling metropolis continued to function largely as normal, aside from isolated pockets of unrest in the downtown area. An expert cited by The New York Times said this is the first time in 60 years that a president has deployed a state's National Guard without the governor's consent. The last instance was in 1965, when president Lyndon B Johnson used troops to protect predominantly Black demonstrators during the civil rights movement in Alabama The protests began on Friday after Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officers executed search warrants across the city as Trump pushed forward with his goal of mass deportations of undocumented immigrants. California Governor Gavin Newsom has accused the Trump administration of deliberately provoking the escalation and acting unlawfully in an effort to portray the president as a strongman leader. The Democratic governor - considered a potential contender for the 2028 presidential race - announced that the state would file a lawsuit against the federal government. Protests also in San Francisco Protests against the deportation of migrants without residence permits also led to riots in San Francisco. Around 60 people were detained after an initially peaceful demonstration in front of a building belonging to ICE, local station KGO reported. According to the report, hundreds of people protested on Sunday evening against the raids and deportations of migrants without valid residence permits currently taking place in the state of California. The mood turned sour when some demonstrators destroyed property, carried out attacks and caused other damage, according to police, the station reported. In order to break up the demonstration, the authorities declared the protests an "unlawful assembly." Some people nevertheless remained and later damaged buildings and a police car in other streets. Another group refused to disperse. This led to the arrests. According to the report, two officers were injured. A firearm was also seized.