'Utterly shameful': Irish MEPs slam EU offer to assist Israel in replacing Gaza aid agencies
AN OFFER MADE by the European Union's top diplomat to assist Israel in replacing aid agencies in Gaza has been described as 'utterly shameful' and 'against what we stand for' by two Irish MEPs.
On Wednesday evening, the EU's High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy Kaja Kallas said she had offered Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Saar EU assistance with his government's proposal to take over the distribution of aid in the besieged Palestinian territory, where Israel has imposed a complete blockade since early March.
Since then, no food, water or medical supplies have entered Gaza and Taoiseach Micheál Martin has said the siege is 'clearly a war crime' and that Israel's war 'has lost any moral compass'.
'I offered also help by the European Union to distribute the humanitarian aid if they don't trust the other actors there,' Kallas
told journalists at a meeting
of EU foreign ministers in Warsaw.
Kallas apparently contradicted
her own statement issued on Wednesday
, which raised concerns about the Israeli proposal, saying it 'runs counter to humanitarian principles, as underlined by UN agencies and humanitarian partners'.
The Journal
understands that Kallas made the offer without consulting her colleagues and that her remarks do not reflect the EU's official position.
Irish MEPs spoke to
The Journal
and expressed concern about Kallas' offer of EU assistance.
'Rather than offering to assist in their plan to ethnically cleanse Gaza, the EU should be imposing the most severe sanctions on Israel, and leading calls for a permanent ceasefire,' said Sinn Féin MEP Lynn Boylan.
Fianna Fáil MEP Barry Andrews said: 'Israel's current proposal to bypass and undermine established humanitarian actors and take direct control of aid distribution is deeply alarming.'
Both MEPs said assisting Israel in taking over aid distribution would go against core humanitarian principles and undermine the work of the United Nations.
Kallas made her comments on the same day that UN agencies condemned Israel's plan to take over aid distribution.
Displaced Palestinians by makeshift tents outside an UNRWA-run clinic west of Gaza City
Alamy Stock Photo
Alamy Stock Photo
A spokesperson for the UN's aid coordination office, OCHA, said it 'appears to be a deliberate attempt to weaponise the aid and we have warned against that for a very long time'.
Amnesty International told
The Journal
'the EU must unequivocally reject' the plan and ensure the bloc 'is not complicit in Israel's genocide, whether directly or indirectly'.
There are 15 UN agencies operating in Gaza – including the likes of UNRWA, UNICEF and the World Food Programme – alongside roughly 200 NGOs.
Palestinians struggle to get donated food at a community kitchen in Khan Younis, Gaza Strip
Alamy Stock Photo
Alamy Stock Photo
Advertisement
'Beyond belief'
According to Lynn Boylan, Kallas' offer of EU participation in the Israeli plan undermines the United Nations agencies working in Gaza.
'Kaja Kallas' comments around finding an 'alternative' to UNRWA are utterly shameful and a complete betrayal of international law,' Boylan told
The Journal
.
'Instead of undermining the work of UNRWA, Ms Kallas should focus on who is responsible for blocking humanitarian aid from entering Gaza at every opportunity,' Boylan said.
It is truly beyond belief to make this offer mere days after Israel announced their intention to indefinitely occupy Gaza.
Fianna Fáil MEP Barry Andrews told
The Journal
that the EU has a duty to ensure that aid is delivered 'according to the core humanitarian principles of neutrality, impartiality, independence, and humanity'.
Aligning with Israel's proposed model would not only go against what we stand for, it would also set a dangerous global precedent.
'It is of the utmost importance that aid remains separate from politicisation, militarisation and weaponisation.'
MEPs Lynn Boylan and Barry Andrews
Alamy
Alamy
He also said that normalising 'the politicisation and instrumentalisation' of humanitarian aid would blur the lines between civilian and military roles.
'Fragmenting the humanitarian response system not only risks the lives of those on the ground, but also severely damages the legitimacy and effectiveness of aid delivery.'
Boylan said that Israel has 'forced supplies to rot at the border, attacked aid vessels in international waters and tried to cover up their murder of aid workers'.
'Offering to assist Israel in taking over 'the distribution of aid' in the Gaza Strip is handing them total power to weaponise starvation and deprivation.'
Ireland and a number of other EU member states have consistently voiced support for UN agencies working in Gaza, particularly UNRWA, while the Israeli government has levelled attacks at the UN throughout the conflict.
The Israeli parliament voted to ban UNRWA from operating in Israel in January of this year after accusing the organisation of being staffed by members of Hamas.
Israel's Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu told the General Assembly last year that the UN was an 'antisemitic swamp' while Israeli officials have also taken aim at the UN's International Court of Justice, where the country stands accused of committing genocide against the people of Gaza.
Netanyahu himself is wanted by the International Criminal Court for alleged war crimes, including the use of starvation as a weapon of war.
Earlier this week, a group of more than 20 UN experts said countries were at a moral crossroads over their response to Israel's escalation of hostilities and ongoing siege of Gaza.
States face a choice between acting to halt the violence and looking on at 'the annihilation of the Palestinian population' in the territory, the experts said.
'The decision is stark: remain passive and witness the slaughter of innocents or take part in crafting a just resolution,' they said in a statement, urging the world to avert the 'moral abyss we are descending into'.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
2 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Russia, Ukraine head to Istanbul for fresh peace talks
Russian and Ukrainian officials will meet in Istanbul to exchange their plans for how to end the three-year war, Europe's largest conflict since World War II, after Ukraine says it struck dozens of strategic bombers parked at airbases deep in Russia. Urged on by US President Donald Trump, the countries have opened direct negotiations for the first time since the early weeks of Russia's invasion but have yet to make significant progress towards an elusive agreement. The talks come a day after Ukraine carried out one of its most brazen and successful attacks ever on Russian soil - hitting dozens of strategic bombers parked at airbases thousands of kilometres behind the front line. At the first round of talks in Istanbul last month, they agreed to a large-scale prisoner exchange and to swap notes on what their vision of a peace deal might look like. The second set of negotiations is scheduled to get underway at 11pm Irish time at the Ciragan Palace in Istanbul, an Ottoman imperial house on the banks of the Bosphorus that is now a luxury five-star hotel. Russia says it will present a "memorandum" of its peace terms, having resisted pressure by Ukraine to send its demands in advance. Despite the flurry of diplomacy, the two sides remain far apart over a possible deal - either for a truce or longer-term settlement. Outlining Ukraine's position ahead of the talks, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky refreshed his call for an immediate halt to the fighting. "First - a full and unconditional ceasefire. Second -- the release of prisoners. Third - the return of abducted children," he said in a post on social media. He also called for the sides to discuss a direct meeting with Russian President Vladimir Putin. "The key issues can only be resolved by the leaders," Mr Zelensky said. The Kremlin has repeatedly pushed back on that prospect, saying a Putin-Zelensky meeting could only happen after the negotiating delegations reach wider "agreements". Russia has questioned Mr Zelensky's legitimacy throughout the war and repeatedly called for him to be toppled. Russia has said it wants to address the "root causes" of the conflict - language typically used to refer to a mix of sweeping demands including limiting Ukraine's military, banning the country from joining NATO and massive territorial concessions. Ukraine and the West have rejected those calls and cast Russia's assault as nothing but an imperialist land grab. Tens of thousands have been killed since Russia invaded, with swathes of eastern and southern Ukraine destroyed and millions forced to flee their homes. War rages on Russia's top negotiator in Istanbul will be Vladimir Medinsky, an ideological Putin aide who led failed talks in 2022, has written school textbooks justifying the invasion and questioned Ukraine's right to exist. Ukraine's team will be led by Defence Minister Rustem Umerov, seen as a skilled and pragmatic negotiator, but who has been mired in domestic scandal over alleged abuse of power and a lack of transparency. "Diplomatic advisors" from Germany, France and Britain will be "on the ground... in close coordination with the Ukrainian negotiating team," a German government spokesperson said Sunday. Ukraine said it had damaged some 40 strategic Russian bombers, worth $7 billion, in a major special operation after months of setbacks for the country's military. Ukraine's security service said the plan, 18 months in the making, had involved smuggling drones into Russia which were then launched from near the airbases, thousands of kilometres away from the front lines. Russian troops have meanwhile been advancing on the ground, particularly in the northeastern Sumy region, where Mr Putin ordered his forces to establish a "buffer zone" along the border. Ballistic strikes in the northeastern Kharkiv region yesterday injured at least six people, including a seven-year-old, and damaged a civilian business and a warehouse, Kharkiv Governor Oleg Synegubov said on Monday. Ahead of the talks, Russian officials have called for Ukraine to be cut off from Western military support and cede territory still controlled by its army. Ukraine has pushed Russia to agree to a full, unconditional and immediate ceasefire - saying a pause in the fighting is necessary to then discuss what a long-term settlement could look like. Ukraine has refused to formally give up the one-fifth of its territory controlled by Russia, though it has accepted that it may only be able to get some land back through diplomacy, not fighting. It also wants concrete Western-backed security guarantees - like NATO protections or Western troops on the ground - that have also been ruled out by Russia.
Irish Independent
3 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Letters: US constitution should be used to halt Donald Trump's ban on foreign students
However, the Ivy League university quickly filed a complaint in a federal court in Boston, saying the government's action violated the First Amendment and would have an immediate and devastating effect for Harvard and its valued core of international students. US district judge Allison Burroughs quickly issued a temporary restraining order, freezing the Department of Homeland Security's directive for two weeks. The judge's order prevents Trump from revoking Harvard's certification in the student and exchange visitor programme, which allows the university to enrol international students with visas to study in the US. Harvard enrolled almost 6,800 foreign students in its current school year at its campus in Cambridge, Massachusetts. Most are graduate students, who come from more than 100 countries, including Ireland. It's essential that Trump's attempt to overturn the well-established and lawful practice of American universities welcoming international students is blocked by the federal court. Scholarship and learning are without borders. Ireland and the US have facilitated each other's students for undergraduate, postgraduate, research and cultural exchange for many decades. Indeed, Ireland has a proud record of welcoming foreign students to study in our excellent third-level education system. The same can currently be said about the US. The American constitution must now stand robustly against a president who is determined to damage that record. Billy Ryle, Tralee, Co Kerry The US system is working – checks and balances are stopping president's overreach The crisis of US president Donald Trump's assault on the rule of law is beyond the pale. I say that because nothing like this has ever happened in American history. I believe Trump and his MAGA devotees may need a quick civics lesson about the law. They need to be reminded that courts can overturn unconstitutional laws. I would like to bring to their attention that an executive order isn't law and a president can't make laws without Congress. When judges decide to block Trump, one finds that this is literally how checks and balances work. John O'Brien, Clonmel, Co Tipperary Conflict in Palestine has deep roots, but Benjamin Netanyahu has seized his opportunity Ciaran Masterson asks 'have we forgotten that Hamas started this?' (Sunday Independent, Letters, June 1). I would like to point out the conflict between the state of Israel and the Palestinian people has been ongoing since 1948. I first witnessed the treatment of Palestinian people by Israeli forces of occupation in 1974 when I took up an appointment with United Nations. The Hamas attack on October 7, 2023, was not 'the beginning' of the problem – just the excuse Benjamin Netanyahu needed to pursue his policies of ethnic cleansing. Michael Moriarty, Rochestown, Co Cork We've had two decades of promises on housing, but nobody telling the truth Yet another week of Irish politics and the non-stop saga on provision of housing fills the media. For nigh on two decades, politicians have spouted innumerable promises on housing provision. Were these promises in good faith or merely empty to get a vote? Today, the political parties who have been in power alternatively since 1922 would have the citizenry believe a special 'housing tsar' is the only way to remedy the situation. Definitely not a job for the boys. I am aware of much of the history of the provision of housing throughout the nation from the post Civil War – a disastrous financial era; through the precarious financial years 1939 to 1970. Is there one honest person in politics or the civil service to inform the electorate of Ireland exactly who, or what, the problem is today, when the nation is wealthy and better educated? Declan Foley, Melbourne, Australia Our military capability is weakening as Vladimir Putin's hawkish eyes scan Europe The fact that the Naval Service has had to tie up some of its vessels because of staff shortages is old news. Then during the past week this paper reported that Air Corps flight operations are to move to part-time hours at its headquarters in Baldonnel and may soon have to cease entirely. This military impairment is oceans away from the Naval Service doubling its fleet to 12 vessels, enabling it to possess 'a defensive conventional maritime war-fighting capability' and the Air Corps becoming the Irish Air Force and acquiring a squadron of aircraft 'capable of air combat and interception of airborne threats', as set out in the Commission on the Defence Forces Report (2022). Meanwhile, Vladimir Putin probes our skies and waters which are laden with critical undersea communications infrastructure, undoubtedly observing us as a rudderless, wingless and feckless territory on the edge of a continent he despises. Michael Gannon, St Thomas Square, Kilkenny city I'll raise a glass to Darragh McManus's article on replica jersey obsession Darragh McManus's fine piece on the replica jersey obsession made me pause and take stock of my own wardrobe ('Our children's choice of replica shirts sums up the generation gap to a tee', Irish Independent, May 31). I do have a few Armagh polo shirts (and why wouldn't I, after the year Armagh just had?), but at this very moment I find myself writing to you while wearing a KEO beer T-shirt I picked up in Cyprus. A quick count suggests I own more beer-branded shirts than sports ones. Somewhere along the way, I clearly took a wrong turn – probably at the fridge. Enda Cullen, Tullysaran, Co Armagh My theory on Causeway coins takes one giant leap of the imagination Perhaps the people who placed coins between the rocks at the Giant's Causeway had been advised to put their money 'into bricks and mortar'? Tom Gilsenan, Beaumont, Dublin 9
RTÉ News
4 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Man attacks Colorado crowd with firebombs, 6 people injured
Six people were injured when a 45-year-old man yelled "Free Palestine" and threw incendiary devices into a crowd in Boulder, Colorado where a demonstration to remember the Israeli hostages who remain in Gaza was taking place, US authorities said. FBI special agent in charge of the Denver Field Office Mark Michalek said there were six victims, aged between 67 and 88 years old, who were transported to hospitals. "As a result of these preliminary facts, it is clear that this is a targeted act of violence and the FBI is investigating this as an act of terrorism," he said. Mr Michalek named the suspect as Mohamed Soliman, aged 45, who was hospitalised shortly after the attack FBI Director Kash Patel also described the incident as a"targeted terror attack," and Colorado Attorney General PhilWeiser said it appeared to be "a hate crime given the group that was targeted." We are aware of and fully investigating a targeted terror attack in Boulder, Colorado. Our agents and local law enforcement are on the scene already, and we will share updates as more information becomes available. @FBI — FBI Director Kash Patel (@FBIDirectorKash) June 1, 2025 Boulder Police Chief Stephen Redfearn said he did not believe anyone else was involved. "We're fairly confident we have the lone suspect in custody," he said. "This was a beautiful Sunday afternoon in downtown Boulder onPearl Street and this act was unacceptable," Mr Redfearn said at an earlier press conference. "I ask that you join me in thinking about the victims, the families of those victims, and everyone involved in this tragedy." The incident comes amid heightened tensions in the UnitedStates over Israel's war in Gaza, which has spurred both an increase in antisemitic hate crime as well as moves by conservative supporters of Israel led by President Donald Trumpto brand pro-Palestinian protests as antisemitic. His administration has detained protesters of the war without charge and cut off funding to elite U.S. universities that have permitted such demonstrations. Brooke Coffman, a 19-year-old at the University of Colorado who witnessed the Boulder incident, said she saw four women lying or sitting on the ground with burns on their legs. One of them appeared to have been badly burned on most of her body and had been wrapped in a flag by someone, she said. She described seeing a man whom she presumed to be the attacker standing in the courtyard shirtless, holding a glass bottle of clear liquid and shouting. "Everybody is yelling, 'get water, get water,'" Coffmansaid. Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, a prominent JewishDemocrat, said he was closely monitoring the situation. "This is horrifying, and this cannot continue. We must stand up to antisemitism." The attack follows last month's arrest of a Chicago-born man in the fatal shooting of two Israeli embassy employees in Washington DC. Someone opened fire on a group of people leaving an event hosted by the American Jewish Committee, an advocacy group that fights antisemitism and supports Israel. The shooting fueled polarization in the United States over the war in Gaza between supporters of Israel and pro-Palestiniandemonstrators. Colorado Governor Jared Polis posted on social media that it was "unfathomable that the Jewish community is facing another terror attack here in Boulder."
