
The French Open is picking humans over technology. Novak Djokovic thinks that's a bad call
For Novak Djokovic, this is a relatively easy call: He, like many players, thinks the French Open is making a mistake by eschewing the electronic line-calling used at most big tennis tournaments and instead remaining old school by letting line judges decide whether serves or other shots land in or out.
Plenty of sports, from soccer and baseball to the NFL, are replacing, or at least helping, officials with some form of high-tech replays or other technology. Tennis, too, is following that trend, except at Roland-Garros, where competition continues through June 8.
Even the longest-running and most tradition-bound of the majors, Wimbledon, is — gasp! — abandoning line judges and moving to an automatic system this year. The WTA and ATP added machine-generated rulings this season for tour events on red clay, the surface at the French Open. But Grand Slam hosts can do what they want, and the French tennis federation is keeping the human element.
The French Open is pushing back against modern technology
Djokovic, the 24-time major champion scheduled to play his first-round match in Paris on Tuesday, understands why folks might prefer the way to keep things the way they were for more than a century in his sport. He gets why there could be an inclination to shy away from too much change in a world now drowning in cell phones and streaming and social media.
'You don't want to give everything away to the technology, right? But if I have to choose between the two, I'm more of a proponent of technology. It's just more accurate, saves time, and ... (means) less people on the court' said Djokovic, 38, who was disqualified from the 2020 U.S. Open for inadvertently hitting an official with a ball hit out of frustration between games.
That edition of the tournament in New York only placed line judges on its two largest courts, while others used an electronic setup, a nod to the COVID-19 pandemic. The Australian Open got rid of all line judges in 2021, a first at a tennis major; the U.S. Open did the same later that year.
The French Open remains a holdout, and that's not likely to change anytime soon.
Don't expect electronic line-calling at Roland Garros in the near future
'Unless the players are unanimous and come to us and say, 'We won't play if there isn't a machine' ... then I think we've got a great future ahead of us to maintain this style of refereeing,' French federation president Gilles Moretton said, while boasting of the quality of his country's officials.
Players don't sound that adamant, although they tend to echo the opinion of 2023 U.S. Open champion Coco Gauff, who is 21: 'I mean, I don't know if it's like the 'Gen Z' in me, but I think if we have the technology, we should use it.'
Still, there is some charm to be found in the choreography of players insisting a call was wrong and chair umpires climbing down for a closer look at a ball mark on the clay. Watch a day of TV coverage from Paris and odds are good that dance will take place — probably more than once.
'That's what makes clay special, in a way — that you can always review the shots. ... Obviously, you can't deny that electronic line-calling is the future, and everything is moving towards AI and artificial intelligence,' said Stefanos Tsitsipas, the runner-up to Djokovic at Roland-Garros four years ago. "But me, personally, I wouldn't mind playing on clay with maybe the judgment of a human instead of a robot.'
Some tennis players resort to taking photos of ball marks
No matter the form of officiating, there invariably are times when athletes — perhaps eyesight or faith strained by heat-of-the-moment tension and an eagerness to be correct — just won't agree with a call.
That, in turn, can lead to extended arguments and sometimes a scene seen recently: A player grabs a cell phone from the sideline to snap a photo of a mark in a bid to prove, and win, a point.
Aryna Sabalenka, a three-time Slam champ and No. 1 women's player, and Alexander Zverev, a three-time major finalist, did just that, although they weren't the first. Back at the 2013 French Open, Sergiy Stakhovsky put down his racket and took a picture of where a ball had landed during a loss to Richard Gasquet; Stakhovsky said then he'd done it before.
'Linespeople mess up sometimes,' said 2023 Australian Open semifinalist Tommy Paul. 'Automatic line-calling is going to mess up probably less.'
___
AP Sports Writer Andrew Dampf in Rome contributed.
___

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Independent
35 minutes ago
- The Independent
Emma Raducanu v Cristina Bucsa live: Tennis scores as British No 2 begins Queen's Club quest
Katie Boulter and Emma Raducanu begin their singles campaigns at Queen's Club today, having triumphed in the first round as a doubles pair on Monday. Boulter and Raducanu made for an impressive duo as they romped to a straight-sets win on Andy Murray Arena, and both face qualifiers in the first round of the singles draw: Boulter first beat Australia's Ajla Tomljanovic in three sets, before Raducanu faced Spaniard Cristina Bucsa. On Court 1, Heather Watson progressed to the second round. The top four seeds – Olympic champion Zheng Qinwen, Americans Madison Keys and Emma Navarro, and 2022 Wimbledon champion Elena Rybakina – have been given byes to the second round at Queen's, while Raducanu could meet seventh seed and reinging Wimbledon champion Barbora Krejciova next if she can first overcome Bucsa. Katie Boulter through to the second round A good win for Boulter, digging deep against an experienced opponent to get her grass-court season up and running. Lawrence Ostlere10 June 2025 15:41 Game, set, match! Boulter 7-6(4), 1-6, 6-4 Tomljanovic Boulter and Tomljanovic exchange holds of serve and now pressure is on the Australian to hold – Boulter races to 15-40 after a lovely passing shot to earn two match points, and a Tomljanovic errs long to cede it! Lawrence Ostlere10 June 2025 15:35 Boulter 7-6(4) 1-6 4-3 Tomljanovic* Tomljanovic breaks! Boulter goes wayward suddenly and the Aussie breaks to 15. Any chance of a hold of serve?! 10 June 2025 15:16 *Boulter 7-6(4) 1-6 4-2 Tomljanovic Boulter breaks! Astonishing. Tomljanovic looks in cruise control at 40-15 but a few whopping Boulter groundstrokes gives her a foothold - and she's back with a break advantage! Which way will this match turn next? 10 June 2025 15:14 Tomljanovic breaks! *Boulter 7-6(4) 1-6 3-2 Tomljanovic Big forehand winner up the line at 15-15 sparks a big 'come on!' in the direction of her player box, which includes fiancee and Australian No 1 Alex de Minaur! Tomljanovic responds with a big forehand winner of her own for 30-30, and then forces Boulter into a wayward forehand for break point! And Boulter goes long! Ah, what a let-off for the Aussie... Back on serve! Kieran Jackson10 June 2025 15:07 Boulter breaks! *Boulter 7-6(4) 1-6 3-1 Tomljanovic What a turnaround here! Boulter is a different player, more authoritative with her shots, and breaks the Aussie again! 10 June 2025 15:03 Kieran Jackson10 June 2025 14:59 Boulter breaks! *Boulter 7-6(4) 1-6 1-1 Tomljanovic Big moment for Boulter in this match! A fortunate net cord at 15-0 sees Tomljanovic get to 30-0, and a cracking inside-out backhand at 30-15 brings up two game points! But Tomljaonic makes two errors for deuce, before another error - and Boulter breaks back with a forehand winner! Back on serve... Kieran Jackson10 June 2025 14:56 Tomljanovic breaks! Boulter 7-6(4) 1-6 0-1 Tomljanovic* A bad start to the game for Boulter with two double faults eventually brings up 15-40 and two break points for the Aussie! She saves the first one with an aggressive first serve and the second as her opponent goes long - a big 'Come on!' from the Brit! Yet a solid volley at the net brings up a third break point and Boulter goes long on the forehand! Boulter down a break in the third... 10 June 2025 14:51 Second set! *Boulter 7-6(4) 1-6 Tomljanovic An ace will do it for Tomljanovic - and she steamrolls to the second set! We go to a decider... Kieran Jackson10 June 2025 14:46


Scottish Sun
40 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Carlos Alcaraz set to lose huge chunk of his £2.1million French Open winnings due to little-known rule
Alcaraz achieved a feat only bettered by two tennis icons NET NEGATIVE Carlos Alcaraz set to lose huge chunk of his £2.1million French Open winnings due to little-known rule Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) CARLOS ALCARAZ is set to lose a huge amount of his £2.1million French Open prize money. The Spaniard beat Jannik Sinner in a thrilling final that lasted five hours and 29 minutes on Sunday. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 1 Carlos Alcaraz won his fifth Grand Slam title at the French Open Credit: Shutterstock Editorial Alcaraz saved three match points in the fourth set as he staged an incredible comeback to seal victory 4-6 6-7 6-4 7-6 7-6. It was his second French Open crown in as many years and his win earned him a sweet £2.13m. Rules state that tax on prize money pocketed must be paid in the country where the tournament is hosted. That means Alcaraz has had to give 30 per cent to the French government as that is the local tax rate on earnings of that size. READ MORE IN TENNIS Not in good Nick Nick Kyrgios 'axed from BBC's Wimbledon coverage' amid row over pundit It sees the 22-year-old cough up a staggering £639,000. However, his cheque will still be worth a whopping £1,491,000. Alcaraz will not have to pay income tax on his Roland Garros cash in Spain. But as he is still registered as a resident in his homeland, any other earnings like sponsorship deals could come within the Spanish government's grasp. BEST FREE BETS AND BETTING SIGN UP OFFERS Alcaraz has a won £35.3m in prize money alone across his career so far. Before the French Open began, he told the Tennis Channel what he spends his cash on, saying: "Not after every big win, but for example at the Grand Slams, if I reach the semi-finals, I like to buy myself a new pair of sneakers. Carlos Alcaraz stuns French Open fans with classy gesture as he wins rally but concedes point due to little-known rule "If I feel like I had a good season, at the end of the year I'll buy myself a nice watch." Alcaraz has now won five Grand Slam titles - with only Bjorn Borg and Rafael Nadal reaching that milestone at a younger age.


The Sun
40 minutes ago
- The Sun
Carlos Alcaraz set to lose huge chunk of his £2.1million French Open winnings due to little-known rule
CARLOS ALCARAZ is set to lose a huge amount of his £2.1million French Open prize money. The Spaniard beat Jannik Sinner in a thrilling final that lasted five hours and 29 minutes on Sunday. 1 Alcaraz saved three match points in the fourth set as he staged an incredible comeback to seal victory 4-6 6-7 6-4 7-6 7-6. It was his second French Open crown in as many years and his win earned him a sweet £2.13m. Rules state that tax on prize money pocketed must be paid in the country where the tournament is hosted. That means Alcaraz has had to give 30 per cent to the French government as that is the local tax rate on earnings of that size. It sees the 22-year-old cough up a staggering £639,000. However, his cheque will still be worth a whopping £1,491,000. Alcaraz will not have to pay income tax on his Roland Garros cash in Spain. But as he is still registered as a resident in his homeland, any other earnings like sponsorship deals could come within the Spanish government's grasp. Alcaraz has a won £35.3m in prize money alone across his career so far. Before the French Open began, he told the Tennis Channel what he spends his cash on, saying: "Not after every big win, but for example at the Grand Slams, if I reach the semi-finals, I like to buy myself a new pair of sneakers. "If I feel like I had a good season, at the end of the year I'll buy myself a nice watch." Alcaraz has now won five Grand Slam titles - with only Bjorn Borg and Rafael Nadal reaching that milestone at a younger age.